Big Blue View on J.J. McCarthy

ArticleNY Giants news: Dennard Wilson on Tae Banks, Arvell Reese named Rookie of the W...October 9, 2026

Read the full article

From the article

Matt Nagy says that J.J. McCarthy has been an "A+" when it comes to learning the Giants' offense

Captured by STACKED 2 hr after posting

STACKED’s take

Positive signalRole

McCarthy earns A+ from Nagy for learning Giants offense amid Dart's injury.

Giants backup QB receives high marks from head coach Matt Nagy for offensive learning, earning an "A+" grade. This context is relevant as McCarthy is positioned as a contingency option given starting QB Jaxson Dart's season-ending knee injury, with the team's ceiling in 2026 "greatly reduced" with McCarthy or Jameis Winston compared to Dart.

J.J. McCarthyQB · NYGPlayer page — value, ADP, projections, and every insight

J.J. McCarthyPositiveRole

McCarthy's development could create premium trade capital via a young QB surplus.

Big Blue View

J.J. McCarthyPositiveProjection

McCarthy's first Giants start was dominant; demolished Texans defense after Minnesota demotion.

Battle Red Blog

J.J. McCarthyPositiveNews

• Will Jonathan Taylor be moved before the deadline? • J.J. McCarthy leads NYG to an upset over HOU • Omar Cooper Jr. continues to breakout Everythin...

Pat Thorman

J.J. McCarthyNegativeValue

J.J. McCarthy has 0 trade value, minimal asset status.

Yahoo Sports NFL

J.J. McCarthyNegativeProjection

McCarthy's 10.1 YPA is likely unsustainable; expect regression in yards per attempt.

NBC Sports Rotoworld

J.J. McCarthyPositiveProjection

McCarthy's 9 YPA and elite accuracy metrics make him a clear upgrade over Winston.

NBC Sports Rotoworld