PlayerProfiler Fantasy Football Podcast Network on Justin Herbert

PodcastTop 24 Quarterback Rankings For Week 5 | Fantasy Football 2026October 8, 2026

From the episode

Justin Herbert belongs in the F tier... I think, is probably cuttable at this point in one quarterback leagues, especially ones that are a bit shallower.

Mentioned at 23:34 – 25:12

STACKED’s take

Negative signalBust

Herbert is a bust and likely cuttable in shallow leagues.

Justin Herbert is a major disappointment and is likely cuttable in shallower 10-team leagues. He is a desperate start only in Superflex formats.

Justin HerbertQB · LACPlayer page — value, ADP, projections, and every insight

Justin HerbertNegativeBust

Herbert is at his worst and lacks clear path to improvement

Fantasy Football with Ian Hartitz

Justin HerbertPositiveDepth Chart

KEEP/TRADE/CUT: Sam Darnold Justin Herbert Jalen Hurts

SleeperNFL

Justin HerbertPositiveBreakout

Source expects Herbert and Chargers to improve; too much talent to stay this bad.

Fantasy Life Articles

Justin HerbertNegativeProjection

Herbert unplayable in 1QB; source prefers Jameis Winston over him.

Fantasy Life Articles

Justin HerbertNegativeMatchup

Peterson predicts Chiefs win 24-9 with Herbert turning it over more than he scores TDs.

Yahoo Sports NFL

Justin HerbertNegativeProjection

Herbert's 59.4% completion, 5 TDs, 7 INTs reflect historic sack rate and scheme mismatch.

Yahoo Sports NFL

From the episode

STACKED’s take

More on Justin Herbert and from PlayerProfiler Fantasy Football Podcast Network