Windy City Gridiron on J.J. McCarthy

ArticleWeek 8 NFL Power Rankings: Grading Each Team’s Quarterback SituationOctober 27, 2026

Read the full article

From the article

McCarthy has looked like a new quarterback during his two games so far in New York

Captured by STACKED 35 min after posting

STACKED’s take

Positive signalProjection

McCarthy's B+ grade reflects new-look performance in two Giants starts.

McCarthy received a B+ grade and has looked like a new quarterback during his two games with the Giants. Despite major adversity from quarterback injuries, all three Giants quarterbacks have flashed impressively, and McCarthy's performance has been a bright spot in New York's prime position to win the NFC East.

J.J. McCarthyQB · NYGPlayer page — value, ADP, projections, and every insight

J.J. McCarthyPositiveProjection

McCarthy's first Giants start was dominant; demolished Texans defense after Minnesota demotion.

Battle Red Blog

J.J. McCarthyNegativeProjection

McCarthy's 10.1 YPA is likely unsustainable; expect regression in yards per attempt.

NBC Sports Rotoworld

J.J. McCarthyPositiveProjection

McCarthy's 9 YPA and elite accuracy metrics make him a clear upgrade over Winston.

NBC Sports Rotoworld

J.J. McCarthyPositiveProjection

McCarthy's 9-yard average depth of target drives Giants' elite air yards volume

NBC Sports Rotoworld

J.J. McCarthyPositiveProjection

McCarthy's 9-yard average depth of target fuels Giants' air yards despite run-heavy approach.

Yahoo Sports NFL

J.J. McCarthyPositiveNews

• Will Jonathan Taylor be moved before the deadline? • J.J. McCarthy leads NYG to an upset over HOU • Omar Cooper Jr. continues to breakout Everythin...

Pat Thorman