From the episode
justin herbert like how many more excuses can we give this guy like he's had everything he's got coaching changes he's had weapons he's had running backs he's had line like when is it just justin herbert's not good
STACKED’s take
Herbert remains a disappointment despite tools and weapons; currently QB25 and droppable in redraft.
Quarterback has become a consistent disappointment despite having all the tools and weapons. Herbert has cycled through coaching changes, running backs, offensive line investments, and skill-position talent (Ladd McConkey, Trey Harris, Quinton Johnson) yet continues to underperform. Currently QB25 on the year with limited weapons—McConkey is not a true WR1, and Harris and Johnson appear to be WR3-caliber at best. The pattern of excuses has exhausted itself; at some point, the issue is Herbert's play itself. In redraft, he is droppable; in dynasty, he may be acquirable cheaply in superflex leagues but consistency and reliability remain major concerns.
Justin HerbertQB · LACPlayer page — value, ADP, projections, and every insight