Big Cat Country on J.J. McCarthy

ArticleJaguars vs. Giants: Staff roundtable and game picks for Week 11
Read the full article

From the article

The key is to end this fairy tale that J.J. McCarthy is in right now. After a brutal short career in Minnesota, McCarthy got dealt to the Giants this season and, to his credit, has played well in place of injured Jaxson Dart... McCarthy is 22nd in the league in on-target throws (per SIS), right below Kyler Murray... J.J. McCarthy doesn't move me whatsoever.
Captured by STACKED 2 hr after posting

STACKED’s take

Positive signalProjection

McCarthy's 'fairy tale' faces reality check; 22nd in on-target throws despite volume.

Giants starting QB with recent strong play but facing significant scrutiny heading into Week 11. Dillon Appleman frames McCarthy's success as a 'fairy tale' and calls for Jacksonville defense to 'bring the McCarthy narrative down to earth,' noting he has faced nobody of substance since assuming the starting role. Travis Holmes provides detailed efficiency concerns: McCarthy ranks 22nd in on-target throws (per SIS), right below Kyler Murray, despite leading the league in air yards per attempt in his four games played. Henry Zimmer notes McCarthy has thrown a ton of balls but only has 2 passing touchdowns, suggesting limited efficiency. Gus Logue dismisses McCarthy entirely: 'J.J. McCarthy doesn't move me whatsoever.'

J.J. McCarthy headshotJ.J. McCarthyQB · NYGPlayer page — value, ADP, projections, and every insight