From the episode
Fitzy loves Bucky Irving and Tara says Bucky Irving is the final draft trap...I was a pioneer in the fade Bucky movement this off season...his ranking has dropped all the way to RB20...the real problem here, aside from the injury trust issues, is the backfield mates...the Bucks organization specifically saying like, hey, these two players, Bucky Irving and Kenneth Gainwell, they mirror each other. This was a 1A, 1B situation...Everything about this situation, him, his injury, the Bucks, the offense, everything, the players, it screams that they are shifting more towards a committee.
STACKED’s take
Irving's RB20 ranking masks a low-floor committee role with Gainwell and Robinson.
The source identifies Bucky Irving as a draft trap despite his ranking dropping to RB20 (which the source credits to their earlier fade campaign). The core issue is a low-floor, committee-bound situation masked by perceived safety. Irving faces multiple compounding concerns: (1) lingering injury-recovery trust issues from last season; (2) Kenneth Gainwell as a 1A/1B backfield mate (per Bucks organization language) who will chip away at receiving work and touches; (3) Sean Tucker already sniping goal-line carries; (4) new offensive coordinator Zach Robinson, who gave Tyler Algier goal-line carries over Bijon Robinson last season, suggesting Irving won't be guaranteed goal-line work; (5) Irving already had an extremely low red-zone and inside-the-10 touch share compared to other RB1s. The source concludes everything about this situation—injury, backfield mates, offensive coordinator—screams committee, not a safe RB1 workload. While Irving won't fade away, the risk-reward is poor; riskier players drafted around him offer higher ceilings.
Bucky IrvingRB · TBPlayer page — value, ADP, projections, and every insight