Daily Norseman on J.J. McCarthy
From the article
I still believe there's a solid starter in there. Or at the very least, I still believe we have no idea what his trajectory looks like.
STACKED’s take
Expert consensus split: upside exists but development trajectory remains highly uncertain
Expert opinions on McCarthy's future as an NFL starter are mixed. Brandon Warne believes there is 'a solid starter in there' but acknowledges uncertainty given McCarthy has played just over 500 snaps with all coming under 'functionally a rookie' conditions. Craig Williams notes he is 'one hit away from starting again' and could develop like Sam Darnold. Warren Ludford is pessimistic, citing unfavorable odds and historical precedent for players in McCarthy's situation. Dave Stefano expects McCarthy to develop into a starting QB with proper coaching and surroundings. Sam Buegler sees potential for a solid starter or good backup role but believes media attention and pressure have rattled him.
J.J. McCarthyQB · MINPlayer page — value, ADP, projections, and every insight