From the episode
Basically, anytime he's been healthy, he's no worse than wide receiver six in a full season aside from last year. And the peripherals from last season are still very, very strong, nearly a 29% target share. The touchdowns were lacking. He scored two touchdowns all season, despite 18 red zone targets... when Carson Wentz was on our center, five games, Justin Jefferson was posting nearly a hundred receiving yards per game at 95.
STACKED’s take
Erickson sees WR6 bounce-back; Brown sees WR12 due to QB risk and declining route metrics.
Andrew Erickson ranks Jefferson WR6, arguing his body of work shows he finishes no worse than WR6 in full seasons when healthy (aside from 2025). Despite 2025's poor performance, peripherals remain strong: 29% target share, 18 red zone targets but only 2 touchdowns (major regression). Erickson attributes the down year to terrible quarterback play in Minnesota; when Carson Wentz started (5 games in 2025), Jefferson posted 95 receiving yards per game. He projects Jefferson will return to top-five conversation with improved QB play (Kyler Murray or improved JJ McCarthy). Derek Brown counters with WR12 ranking, citing 2025 performance: Jefferson finished WR14 in expected fantasy points per game with 36th-ranked separation and 38th-ranked route win rate among 109 WRs—not elite for a top-six receiver. Brown's core concern is the Minnesota QB situation: if JJ McCarthy doesn't improve or if Kyler Murray underperforms (as documented in recent seasons), Jefferson will suffer. Murray has documented inability to throw over the middle of the field, problematic because 32.2% of Jefferson's target volume over the last two seasons came in the middle of the field (0–19 yards from line of scrimmage). 68% of chat voted to draft Jefferson, with Erickson going 2-for-2 in securing 'draft him' verdicts.
Justin JeffersonCLEPlayer page — value, ADP, projections, and every insight