Windy City Gridiron on Caleb Williams
From the article
Caleb Williams has a Ferrari, and they still insist on evaluating the throws he makes by the scale applied to other arms. There are moves he can make, decisions he can access, that simply are not reasonable considerations even for the majority of professional athletes.
STACKED’s take
Elite arm talent enables decision-making PFF's system fails to properly evaluate.
Caleb Williams delivered an elite performance that Pro Football Focus graded as average, exemplifying a fundamental flaw in PFF's quarterback evaluation methodology. The source argues that Williams possesses elite arm talent (a 'Ferrari' arm) that enables decision-making and throw options unavailable to most professional athletes, yet PFF evaluates his throws by the same scale applied to average arms. This mismatch between his exceptional capability and PFF's standardized grading system results in undervaluation of his actual performance. The source further contends that PFF's per-play grading ignores how football develops and exploits tendencies across 60 minutes, and that aggressive play from elite quarterbacks can force defensive reactions even when individual throws don't produce immediate results—a strategic dimension PFF's process fails to capture.
Caleb WilliamsQB · CHIPlayer page — value, ADP, projections, and every insight