From the video
Justin Herbert has been what he is... He's a great thrower. He's an average to below average starter as a quarterback and that involves the decision-making part.
STACKED’s take
Herbert is an average starter hampered by poor decision-making and forced mechanics.
Bob Harris and Matt Waldman express significant skepticism regarding Justin Herbert's performance, with Harris questioning if the team's attempts to alter his footwork and accelerate his release are counterproductive. Waldman characterizes Herbert as an average to below-average starter who, despite elite physical arm talent and movement skills, suffers from persistent decision-making flaws and mechanical issues dating back to his time at Oregon. Waldman argues that Mike McDaniel's efforts to force mechanical adjustments in the shotgun are a misguided attempt to fit the player into a system rather than addressing inherent blind spots and inaccuracies in Herbert's game.
Justin HerbertQB · LACPlayer page — value, ADP, projections, and every insight