PlayerProfiler Fantasy Football Podcast Network artwork

Davis Mattek - Grinding the Variance: Week 9 Gillcast - NFL DFS Recap

STACKED extracted the fantasy-relevant player signal from this podcast and kept the full transcript here for context.

42 min
Duration
Estimated from transcript
Nov 9, 2026
Published
Mon, November 9, 2026
52
Player insights
28
Players mentioned
Topics
Antonio WilliamsPatrick MahomesRyan FlournoyTravis KelceAdonai MitchellCeeDee LambChristian McCaffreyDevin SingletaryGeorge KittleJake FergusonJonah ColemanPuka NacuaAlvin KamaraDavid Njoku
Player analysis

Player insights

52

Adonai Mitchell

NegativeBust0:33

Mitchell posted one of the most tilting DFS performances of the week: 14.4 expected fantasy points (seventh-most air yards in the NFL), three targets with his feet in the end zone, but zero actual DraftKings points. He was 100% owned in high-stakes contests by sharp players (Nate Knolling, Whirling Dervish) but only 20% owned in the $25 double-up, and ultimately delivered nothing despite the setup suggesting he should have scored.

Insight page
NegativeProjection3:48

Mitchell received seven targets with 17.5 expected DraftKings points but scored zero actual points; the source notes this was the most likely outcome and expresses frustration that the projection was visible beforehand, highlighting the gap between expected and actual fantasy production.

Insight page
PositiveValue5:34

Mitchell was the preferred DFS play over Ryan Flournoy in Week 9, and the source believes this decision would hold even with advance knowledge of Flournoy's coverage situation.

Insight page

Alvin Kamara

NegativeProjection39:00

Kamara appeared in a DFS lineup that the source later realized was a parsing error or accidental swap; when confirmed to be in the lineup, the source called it 'dusty' and criticized the running back pairing of Kamara and Singletary as 'combined 60 years old,' indicating both are considered poor fantasy options.

Insight page

Antonio Williams

PositiveUsage0:00

Williams was part of the optimal/run-solver DFS lineup that won the massive $25 double-up contest in Week 9. The source notes there will be discussion about the vagaries of Williams' performance, but he ultimately delivered in the winning lineup.

Insight page
NegativeUsage3:50

Williams recorded three receptions for 25 yards in a game where his team was throwing heavily; the source defends the play as reasonable despite the low output, noting that getting the decision right or wrong is often a matter of variance rather than poor analysis.

Insight page
PositiveRole11:36

Antonio Williams is a standard fourth-round receiver archetype with limited upside; he will get around six targets with low average depth of target and has no shot at a 100-yard game. The source argues Williams is not a good play compared to Furnoy in this game environment, despite having twice the targets per outing as Furnoy. Williams is described as the Furnoy play on a worse team with worse matchup context.

Insight page
NegativeUsage26:42

Williams was mentioned as a factor limiting Flournoy's target share in Week 9; he was also included in successful DFS lineups, suggesting he had some value but competed with other receivers for targets.

Insight page

CeeDee Lamb

PositiveUsage0:53

Lamb was part of the optimal/run-solver DFS lineup that won the massive $25 double-up contest in Week 9.

Insight page
NegativeRole5:58

Lamb's role involves moving across the formation and running screens from the backfield, which makes it harder for opposing corners to maintain consistent coverage; the Colts' decision to assign Sauce Gardner to Ryan Flournoy was partly justified by this dynamic.

Insight page
PositiveProjection23:02

Lamb finished just 1.75 points behind Puka Nakua in Week 9 DFS scoring; the source acknowledges Lamb is 'very good and obviously he's smashed' and notes that having both Puka and CeeDee was the sharpest way to build lineups, as CD is 'the only one who has close to Puka's upside.'

Insight page

Christian McCaffrey

PositiveUsage0:53

McCaffrey was part of the optimal/run-solver DFS lineup that won the massive $25 double-up contest in Week 9.

Insight page
NegativeUsage7:00

McCaffrey was part of the shared DFS lineup for Week 9, selected as a running back option.

Insight page
PositiveProjection34:00

McCaffrey scored 22 points in Week 9 and was part of a winning DFS lineup; the source notes that swapping McCaffrey in over Walker simmed 'so much better,' which was counterintuitive but proved correct in tournament play.

Insight page

David Njoku

PositiveProjection39:00

Njoku (referred to as 'Dolsic' in the transcript) was part of a successful DFS lineup that won the Sklansky buck challenge for the Gillcast in Week 9, indicating he was a sharp play with good value.

Insight page

Devin Singletary

PositiveUsage0:53

Singletary was part of the optimal/run-solver DFS lineup that won the massive $25 double-up contest in Week 9.

Insight page
NegativeUsage7:00

Singletary was part of the shared DFS lineup for Week 9, selected as a running back option.

Insight page
NegativeProjection36:00

Singletary was heavily owned at 36% in tournaments but the source considers him 'dust' and 'terrible'; he was faded in favor of Ollie Gordon, who the source believes is 'way, way, way better' with more talent, a better matchup, and lower ownership. The source notes that Singletary is an example of a player who projects well but 'mostly sucks,' making him a poor fantasy option despite expected workload.

Insight page

Drew Lock

NegativeMatchup8:54

Locke faced a favorable matchup and had JSN available, but the source was wary of playing him due to an elbow injury he was carrying into the week.

Insight page

Garrett Wilson

PositiveInjury11:22

Garrett Wilson is out, which opens target upside for A.D. Mitchell and other receivers in the Jets' target hierarchy.

Insight page

George Kittle

PositiveUsage0:53

Kittle was part of the optimal/run-solver DFS lineup that won the massive $25 double-up contest in Week 9.

Insight page
NegativeUsage7:00

Kittle was part of the shared DFS lineup for Week 9, selected as the tight end option.

Insight page

George Pickens

NegativeInjury0:54

Pickens was ruled out before Week 9, which the source identifies as a critical late-week lineup decision that destroyed DFS outcomes for those who had built around him.

Insight page

Jake Ferguson

NegativeRole10:54

Ferguson's presence in the offense was initially considered as a reason Flournoy would not get targeted, but the source caught himself before fully developing this argument.

Insight page
PositiveRole10:59

Ferguson is unable to earn targets, making him a poor reference point for evaluating Furnoy's target upside. The source explicitly states it's actively better for Furnoy that Ferguson is playing because Ferguson cannot secure targets.

Insight page

Javonte Williams

NegativeRole7:30

Williams remained healthy in Week 9, which was cited as a reason why Ryan Flournoy's target share would be limited despite his projection.

Insight page

Jonah Coleman

PositiveUsage0:53

Coleman was part of the optimal/run-solver DFS lineup that won the massive $25 double-up contest in Week 9.

Insight page
NegativeUsage7:00

Coleman was part of the shared DFS lineup for Week 9, selected as a running back option.

Insight page

Kenneth Walker III

NegativeProjection34:00

Walker was initially included in DFS builds but was swapped out for McCaffrey, which simmed 'so much better' despite being counterintuitive; the source wanted to play Walker but ultimately found better value elsewhere in Week 9 tournaments.

Insight page

Kyle Juszczyk

PositiveUsage5:28

Juszczyk's target share exceeded Ryan Flournoy's despite Flournoy being played at wide receiver in DFS, highlighting Juszczyk's elevated role in the offense.

Insight page

Malik Willis

NegativeProjection23:22

Willis was expected to run more but didn't run at all in Week 9; the source notes he was 'most certainly not fine' despite getting close to the end zone a couple times, and was the most owned quarterback in tournaments despite underperforming expectations.

Insight page

Michael Wilson

NegativeRole6:13

The source views Wilson as a good player but not elite; no NFL team is offering him a massive free-agent contract, suggesting he is a solid mid-tier receiver without superstar upside.

Insight page

Ollie Gordon II

PositiveProjection36:00

Gordon was preferred over Singletary in Week 9 DFS; the source believes Gordon is 'way, way, way better' with more talent, a better matchup against the Lions (who are missing defensive captain and best player), and came in at significantly lower ownership, making him a sharper play despite Singletary's higher expected workload.

Insight page

Omar Cooper Jr.

PositiveValue34:00

Cooper was described as 'mega sharp' and 'extremely good' by the source; he was included in a successful DFS lineup and the source thought he was 'a great pivot,' suggesting he was undervalued and represented strong value in Week 9 tournaments.

Insight page

Patrick Mahomes

PositiveUsage0:53

Mahomes was part of the optimal/run-solver DFS lineup that won the massive $25 double-up contest in Week 9.

Insight page
NegativeUsage7:00

Mahomes was part of the DFS lineup used in Week 9, selected as the quarterback for the slate.

Insight page
PositiveProjection8:57

Mahomes paired with Adonai Mitchell ended up outscoring the Drew Locke and Rashi Rice stack, making it the winning DFS pairing for the week.

Insight page
NegativeProjection31:00

Mahomes came in under-owned in tournaments and was considered a good bet to score around 24 points; however, the source believes he will 'never' get 36 points again (350+ passing yards and 4 TDs) and thus can't generate enough points at his salary to consistently win tournaments, though he still has upside that hasn't been fully realized this season.

Insight page

Puka Nacua

NegativeUsage7:00

Nakua was part of the shared DFS lineup for Week 9, selected as a wide receiver option.

Insight page
PositiveProjection23:22

Puka was an absolute smash in Week 9, accumulating 119 of 136 Stafford passing yards; he scored 30+ points without a touchdown and is described as 'inevitable'—he 'never fails,' 'never gets shut out,' and 'is always omnipresent.' The source emphasizes you 'have to play Puka' and that fading him was a mistake; his target share and route rate are so dominant that he constantly accumulates points regardless of game script or variance.

Insight page

Rashee Rice

PositiveProjection31:00

Rice came in at 9.4% ownership and was part of a Mahomes stack that the source thought was 'so, so pure'; the source notes 'the Rice scam is like fully back,' suggesting Rice is undervalued and represents a sharp play when paired with Mahomes.

Insight page

Rhamondre Stevenson

NegativeProjection24:00

Stevenson scored only 15 points in Week 9, significantly underperforming compared to Bowers (26) and McCaffrey (22); he was considered in DFS swaps but ultimately was a poor fantasy option for the week.

Insight page

Ryan Flournoy

PositiveUsage0:08

The source and co-host both committed to playing Flournoy in Week 9 DFS, viewing him as essential to their lineup construction despite the Cowboys' overall offensive struggles.

Insight page
PositiveUsage5:20

Flournoy received only three targets and a nine percent target share despite projecting for 13+ points across multiple optimal models (Cardi, Run the Sims, ETR); the Colts' decision to assign Sauce Gardner to cover him limited his production significantly.

Insight page
NegativeUsage5:23

Flournoy recorded a five-target game with 0.07% targets per route run, gaining DFS value purely on efficiency with no additional volume; the source characterizes him as a fine NFL player but neither elite nor poor.

Insight page
PositiveUsage26:42

Flournoy ran 38 routes (100% of team routes) but earned only 3 targets for a 0.0789 targets-per-route rate and 0.273 target share; despite high route participation, he couldn't earn targets and was covered by Sauce Gardner, limiting his fantasy upside despite full-time field presence.

Insight page

Travis Kelce

NegativeProjection0:18

Kelce's touchdown was recorded as a rushing touchdown rather than a receiving touchdown on DraftKings in Week 9, affecting DFS scoring and lineup outcomes.

Insight page
PositiveProjection10:00

Kelce scored a rushing touchdown in Week 9, contributing to the Mahomes stack's success.

Insight page
PositiveProjection24:00

Kelce scored only 9 points in Week 9 and came in at just 3.3% ownership in DFS tournaments; the source notes this was 'crazy' low ownership for a player of his caliber, suggesting he was undervalued despite poor production.

Insight page
PositiveValue31:00

Kelce came in at just 3.3% ownership in DFS tournaments despite being a premium player, which the source found surprising and considered a potential edge; when paired with Mahomes, the stack was considered undervalued and likely to 'rate well in any post-lock sim just because of how under-owned they were.'

Insight page

Trey McBride

NegativeRole6:43

The source expresses frustration about McBride's situation with the Arizona Cardinals, noting that Gardner Minshew's arrival has negatively impacted his career trajectory; the source indicates they are holding losing positions on McBride.

Insight page

Tyler Warren

NegativeProjection29:00

Warren was included in a DFS lineup that the source felt good about, suggesting he had some value in Week 9 tournaments, though no specific performance or role details are provided.

Insight page
Full transcript

Episode Transcript

475
0:00You guys waited literally all year for this to happen.
0:04It finally happened. There's going to be coping, there's going to be seething, there's going to be name calling, people are going
0:11to be talking about the vagaries of Antonio Williams, they're going to wonder why we didn't just play Drew Locke.
0:18There's going to be, from my end, there's going to be a little bit of swearing that Travis Kelsey's touchdown was recorded
0:26as a rushing touchdown because at the end of the day, we end up all winning.
0:32If indeed Travis Kelsey's touchdown was recorded and Sammy, it was a it was a crazy, crazy train week this week on DraftKings.
0:40If you go look at the massive $25 double up you see there there is just I mean, there's a train at 161.3.
0:48There's a giant train at 134. There are 139 137.98 an absolutely massive massive train that killed us.
0:54God, George Pickens being ruled out Sammy ruined everything George Pickens being ruled out killed this late for me.
1:01It just absolutely killed me. It destroyed it. We had it.
1:04We had it. We literally had it easy. It's just yeah.
1:08I think I think it was very clear the right thing before we got Ryan Flournoy.
1:14And me and you were both like, brother, I'm not going to going to war today without Ryan Flournoy.
1:21Like no way. No how. I mean, the guys, the guy's a good player.
1:25It just turns out the Cowboys suck. But man, man, it would have been great if George Pickens was a real man
1:33or or dare I say it if Adonai Mitchell was a real man.
1:38Because what we found out is that Adonai Mitchell is a true beta.
1:42He is he needs the alpha there. And it's when when it's his turn to be the alpha, he can't do it.
1:50So that that ruined us pretty good because I mean, I got honestly, like, do I want to tilt Adonai Mitchell not being able to catch the ball?
2:00Yeah, I mean, I absolutely am going to be tilting Adonai Mitchell not being able to catch the ball.
2:06He had 14.4 expected fantasy points today. He had the seventh most.
2:11He had the seventh most air yards in the entire NFL today.
2:15He was targeted three times with his feet literally in the end zone, like truly one of the most tilting performances I
2:23can remember because to take people inside baseball myself, Nate Knolling and whirling Dervish all played Adonai Mitchell 100% owned.
2:30He was only 20% owned in the massive $25 double up, which is now basically the biggest one that gives you a
2:37a good sample size of what to do. And he did absolutely nothing.
2:42And in the end, Sammy, our entire day was decided.
2:45If you if you look at the if you if you go look at the massive $25 double up our entire day.
2:53So the big train team, if you played this was, I believe the established the run solver, optimal, Patrick Mahomes, Jonah Coleman,
3:01Devin Singletary, CD lamb, Ryan Flournoy, Antonio Williams, George Kittle, Chris McCaffrey and the Giants defense.
3:06The entire day, the entire day Nate Knolling was decided by the fact that Adonai Mitchell just could not catch a pass.
3:14It was truly one of the most. And you know what?
3:18I got on the ship cast to go, you know, right after lock.
3:22And I go on and I say, guys, you know what?
3:26I'm gonna lose today because I knew I knew when I made the decision to one V one Adonai Mitchell versus Antonio Williams.
3:34There's there's no way it was going to work out.
3:38It was never going to work out. And guess what, Nate?
3:42It didn't work out. The amount of expected draft Kings points that Adonai Mitchell left on the field.
3:48But it it hurts because like we saw it coming before it happened, like you knew it was going to happen.
3:55This was the most likely outcome that he was going to get seven targets, 17 and a half expected draft Kings points
4:03and zero actual drafting points and zero actual dollars in our bank accounts.
4:08Well, literally, I'd love to see his career. I want to see a career expected fantasy points versus a career scored for Adonai.
4:16I mean, he had seven. It's not I'd like this is this is the thing that's going to tilt me is everyone
4:23is going to be like, dude, you're so stupid.
4:27How did you play Adonai Mitchell? Dude, you're so bad.
4:30You're so bad, bro. Antonio Williams, who beat us, had three for 25 in a game.
4:36His team was throwing the whole game. Like I thought Antonio Williams was fine.
4:41I'm not castigating you. If you got that decision right, more power to you.
4:45But the idea that 80 because because this is always what happens is is and I'm guilty of this, too.
4:52But you get you get the wrong side of the two V two and you're the dumbest person who's ever lived.
5:00How could you possibly play Adonai Mitchell? If Adonai Mitchell catches his first target in this game, which was like a 42 yard touchdown, you're all just bowing.
5:10You're all just saying, Davis, how did you know?
5:13So, Davis, how did you how did you know to play 80 Mitchell?
5:17How did you know, brother? How did you know?
5:20I'm so I'm so annoyed, dude. And the reason why it is extra, extra annoying is because, Nate, we just knew this shit was happening, bro.
5:30We knew we knew it was happening. I'm so tilted.
5:33I mean, I I did play Antonio Williams, but the Ryan Flournoy crap as well.
5:38I mean, he literally got there with like a five target game.
5:43I mean, it was like he had like a point zero seven percent targets per route run.
5:48No extra volume whatsoever. And gets there purely on efficiency while 80 Mitchell just does what 80 Mitchell does, which is like forget how to play football.
5:58He just runs routes and gets open and just.
6:01Well, I mean, I am like Ryan Flournoy is good at football and 80 Mitchell is not.
6:07So that's no right. Ryan Flournoy is also not good.
6:11Ryan Flournoy is is at he's fine. Like Ryan Flournoy is is a very fine National Football League player.
6:17He he's not he is neither a goat nor a woat.
6:21He's he's kind of just like, you know, who Ryan, you know, honestly, Ryan Flournoy is.
6:27He's kind of like Michael Wilson, actually. Where he's like, yeah, it's like I think Michael Wilson's pretty good.
6:33I don't think Michael Wilson's like some great, you know, like no team is giving Michael Wilson.
6:39Ninety seven million dollars in in free agency or whatever.
6:43Instead, they're going to send Jacoby Brissett over to the over to the Ravens and then have Gardner Minshew destroy Trey McBride's career.
6:51I literally don't even get me started in this Arizona Cardinals crap.
6:55I am. My Trey McBride bags are. All right.
6:58Well, well, I guess let's talk about what happens this morning.
7:02So the lineup that we all we all had the exact same lineup this morning, which was Patrick Mahomes, Jonah Coleman, Devin
7:10Singletary, Puka Nakua, Adonai Mitchell, Antonio Williams, George Kittle, Christian McCaffrey and the Eagles defense.
7:15We all had this lineup right here. So Nate ends up not swapping this lineup at all.
7:21He just plays the same line of doesn't adjust the late news at all, which I may.
7:27I think this line. We should have we should have punished him.
7:31Should have should have gotten punished for no touchdown.
7:34And this is this is what I get. This is what actually this is what actually happened in the game, which is that sauce Gardner.
7:43The Colts made the genius decision to stick sauce Gardner on Ryan for no because I actually I wanted to hate on
7:51it, but it actually makes a little bit of sense.
7:54If you think about it, if you just erase for no way.
7:58And then because Lamb is going to be moving across the formation, he's going to be running screens.
8:05He's going to be in the backfield. It's harder to keep your corner lined up in that scenario.
8:11So it's kind of fine to just use your best corner to go erase this idiot.
8:17And it almost kind of worked like they did.
8:20They literally did. He only got three targets. It wasn't even five targets.
8:24It was three targets. He had a nine percent target share.
8:28Literally, there are running back. Kyle Juszczyk has a higher target share than freaking Ryan Flournoy.
8:34And you played him at wide receiver over Adonai Mitchell, who I mean, people got away with like this Flournoy thing.
8:41We all went nuts. Well, I did. I did not play him over Adonai Mitchell.
8:46So we can get into what I did here in a second.
8:51So the big decision today before the Flournoy stuff was it was Drew Locke and a 6K receiver.
8:57So Rashi Rice, someone like that. That was the OG optimal.
9:01It was Drew Locke, Rashi Rice versus Patrick Mahomes, Adonai Mitchell.
9:05And I actually kind of wanted to play the Drew Locke side.
9:09And I assume the Drew Locke side ends up winning in the end on that.
9:14How many points did Drew Locke through two touchdowns?
9:17How many points did Drew Locke get in the end?
9:21He threw one touchdown. I don't know. Did the second Barner one not stand?
9:26No. The Barner had a rest. So the second Barner one does not stand.
9:31So actually that side gets punished. I mean, Drew Locke.
9:34So the reason why I was pretty weary of doing the Drew Locke thing was it is a really good matchup and he gets to throw to JSN.
9:44But he himself was coming in with this elbow injury.
9:47He was not even the backup quarterback last week.
9:51It was Milrow because Milrow. Oh, you know what?
9:54I'm getting these things mixed up. Barner got a tush push.
9:58The second receiving touchdown for Barner did stand. That's what I'm saying, brother.
10:02Him and Travis Kelsey rushing touchdowns. Yes. Yeah. Sorry.
10:05I got confused. So actually the Mahomes side does end up winning that.
10:10But Nate, there was just... I got to say, man, not playing Flournoy is pretty fucking crazy in this spot.
10:17He projected insane. He projected insane. Everyone, everyone had him for like 13 or more points.
10:22He was in the Cardi optimal. He was in the Run the Sims optimal.
10:27He was in the ETR optimal. He was in all the optimals.
10:31I think not playing him here is crazy. I think that if all week we knew this news, I still think A.D.
10:39Mitchell and Antonio Williams were the play. I think that late news almost makes you biased towards the most recent thing and
10:47it makes it seem shinier than it really is.
10:50Javante Williams is still healthy. C.D. Lamb is still healthy.
10:54Jake Ferguson. Like, there wasn't as many reasons that Furnoy was going to get targets.
10:59Bro was literally about to use Jake Ferguson as a reason that Ryan Furnoy would not get targeted.
11:05Bro, he was seriously... He was about to do it and he caught himself and he was like, you know what?
11:12That's actually so bad. That's actually too terrible. I can't reference Jake Ferguson.
11:17It's literally actively better for Furnoy that Ferguson's playing because Ferguson can't earn a target.
11:22Okay. Literally, though, A.D. Mitchell is out there, out targeting...
11:26He's out earning Garrett Wilson when Garrett Wilson is healthy.
11:29Now Garrett Wilson's out. A.D. Mitchell only has potential upside with his targets and he's already out earning.
11:36And then Antonio Williams has been earning more target and McLaurin's...
11:39I mean, there's so much more reason that I thought Williams and Mitchell were in better...
11:45Antonio Williams is literally the Furnoy play on a worse team and a worse mashup.
11:50Like, it's... No! C.D. Lamb is on the Cowboys.
11:53Who's C.D. Lamb of the Washington... Stephon Diggs is on the Commanders.
11:58Oh my... The fact that you are comparing C.D.
12:01Lamb and his 50% target share compared to Stephon Diggs, the ghost of Stephon Diggs, he is not the target magnet that C.D.
12:09Lamb is. And Antonio Williams is... And the dropbacks for the Commanders are way less.
12:14That's obvious. Like, most obvious thing of all time.
12:17Like, I would bet over the course of the season, the Commanders average 10 fewer dropbacks per game than the Cowboys.
12:25And I might even be low. The Cowboys might have legitimately like 12 more dropbacks.
12:30I mean, I can look right now. And I'm almost certainly going to be right.
12:35And Nate is going to have to say... No, Antonio Williams has twice the targets per outrun that Ryan Flournoy has.
12:42Because he's got way better... Yeah, because he hasn't been a full-time player until last week.
12:48He's got way better... He's not a way better talent.
12:52This is where you want someone like that. Not a third-year, fourth-year player who's already been proven to not have a legitimate upside on the field.
13:01Antonio Williams... The Dallas Cowboys, this is actually insane.
13:04Before this game, or Dak had whatever infinity dropbacks he had.
13:08Before this game, the Dallas Football Cowboys had 72 more pass attempts than the Commanders.
13:13It's not even... Nate, this is... To say that Flournoy is a bad play, I will not accept.
13:19If you want to say him and Antonio Williams are similar, fine.
13:23But to say that Flournoy is a bad play is...
13:27Fine. Flournoy is not a bad play. But considering that we had Williams and Mitchell, I didn't think Flournoy was a must.
13:35I thought too many people moved on to him last minute and moved off of values that we had looked at all week and we were sure of.
13:44And I think sometimes late news moves you and biases you in the wrong direction.
13:50And I think in this move, it was... Here's the thing.
13:54Here's the thing. Flournoy has succeeded when other Dallas receivers have gone out.
13:58Like, he had a pretty good run when CeeDee Lamb was hurt last year, I believe.
14:04It was a way better game environment for him.
14:07Antonio Williams is like your standard 4K receiver who it's like, okay, he's going to get like six targets.
14:14They're all going to be low ADOT. He's not going to zero.
14:18But he has like no shot at like a 100-yard game.
14:22And I think in this game environment, Flournoy had the upside.
14:25So he beat him in kind of your median, depending on what you're looking at.
14:31But their median's were pretty similar. I think that Flournoy has way more upside in this spot.
14:37I did not think Antonio Williams was that good of a play.
14:41You guys are completely missing the talent side of this equation.
14:45Antonio Williams as a rookie has flashed upside. He legitimately has...
14:49Like, he is an unknown at the NFL level with potential upside.
14:53The risk is towards the upside for him. Where Ryan Flournoy has had opportunities and has not proven in breaking out in
15:00three plus years in the NFL level. This is not going to be a sudden fourth-year breakout for him.
15:07Where Antonio Williams, if he continues to ascend the way that he has, this is exactly the type of place where he would hit.
15:16A rookie who's showing potential, who now has volume.
15:19That's where you take bets. That's where you take bets.
15:22Jaden Daniels is getting healthier. There's so many things that are on this rookie side that is not in Flournoy's favor.
15:30And like, talent has to matter. This is the same Braylon take that we had a couple weeks ago where you guys
15:37were fading Braylon until he smacked you in the face.
15:41I was not a Braylon fader. You are misnomering me, brother.
15:45I'm a Braylon apologist. Well, I don't want to...
15:48I mean, this one... Yeah. But I do think Flournoy is like a known NFL thing.
15:53Where I think when you have a rookie, there is unknown upside.
15:58And I think that has to be taken into account.
16:01So basically, I decided to go down the path less trodden because I'm a free thinker.
16:07You guys might notice my name at the top of the three-man Galecast standings.
16:12I'm just kind of curious if you guys noticed that.
16:15I am indeed at the top because I'm a free thinker.
16:19I'm willing to break free. And I said, you know what?
16:23I said, you know what? Why do I have to accept the false dichotomy of Aidy Mitchell or Ryan Flournoy?
16:30I said, nay. I will actually play both of these young gentlemen.
16:34So I played CeeDee Lamb instead of Puka. I played Flournoy instead of Anthony Williams.
16:39And I said, hey, I got to find some salary.
16:43How can I get there? I played the Green Bay Packers who are facing the sandwich artist known as Drake May at $2,400 DraftKings.
16:51I think actually in the end, the Saints did end up getting one more point.
16:56Or not the Saints. The Giants, which was a big shock defense, ends up getting one more point.
17:03I do think it is – you guys are going to chuckle and laugh at me.
17:08But I think I actually learned the right lesson from the Buccaneers-Dolphins week, which is – that has got to just be
17:16by far the easiest way to create a little bit of positive or negative variance in cash games.
17:22Like, I think it's one thing if it's like the chalk defense is a $2,800 defense against Nathan Peterman at home in the rain, you know?
17:31But, like, the Giants can lose this game. I mean, like, you know, the Saints almost did lose this game, you know,
17:39and they got, like, 13 or whatever. But, I mean, even the Saints getting 13, and that was the top projected defense.
17:47Like, that was, like, the number one defense in all this same stuff.
17:51They sacked Shadur, what, like six times? And they scored one more – they scored one more point than the Packers.
17:59It's – if you don't get a defensive – if you don't get a defensive touchdown, these defenses are all the same.
18:06They're going to get between 8 and 15. And sure, that can lose you a slate.
18:12But if I – my prior – funny enough, I just spent 10 minutes arguing against Nate.
18:18And I ultimately agree with him, which is that there was no way I wasn't playing A.D.
18:24Mitchell with no Garrett Wilson. I thought A.D. Mitchell was a must, basically.
18:29And fading Antonio Williams to me is like, whatever.
18:32He's fine. A.D. Mitchell has shown star-level ability in the NFL.
18:36Like, he's not a star because he's not focused and he's not consistent and he can't lock in.
18:42But he's on A.D.H.D. medication. I don't think you guys were – like, enough of the field was not factoring in that he's finally got his medication.
18:51If he legitimately was on A.D. medication, he should have been, like, a fourth-round pick in basketball.
18:57Like, seriously, he – I know everyone, like, memes this stuff.
19:01He really is that good. But, like, he – I mean, the fact that he was so bad in this game and
19:09they kept throwing him the ball, I think, like, should be clear evidence.
19:13He was second on the team in targets, dude.
19:17He got zero points. He was second on the team in targets.
19:21It really is all-time run bad. We should – When's the last time you saw a seven-target shutout game?
19:27Like, when have we seen that? I mean, here, let me – I want to score a Gami for box scores.
19:35All right, player, I'm going to run a game finder.
19:38Single games matching criteria will go 2026, 2025, so most recent two years.
19:43I will run this filter. I want to turn it over to you guys while I run this filter on Singletary.
19:50Do you guys feel any regrets on Singletary or Coleman?
19:54Or basically, not getting Ken Walker, not trying to find a way to get Lamb and Puka in together?
20:00Because I saw some people did get Lamb and Puka in together.
20:04I never seriously considered Walker – I honestly never seriously considered not playing Singletary.
20:09He got – Speaking of score Gami box scores, I did see someone tweet this.
20:15It was first time in five years that a player generated 20 or more touches and got 40 or fewer scrimmage yards, which is pretty insane.
20:24Yeah, I mean, I knew – I think we all knew deep down in our heart and souls that Devin Singletary would not score any fantasy points today.
20:34For sure. Like, we all knew it. Yeah, yeah.
20:37Yeah, 100%. And when we turn over our cards for GPP lineups, I guarantee that none of us had Devin Singletary in those goddamn lineups.
20:45No, no, no, no. Sadly. Oh, my God. Well, then you're a stone fish.
20:50Whoever had Devin Singletary in a GPP is a stone-ass fish.
20:54But I will say this. I did think it was interesting that we all started off with the same lineup.
21:01We got the Flournoy news. And we all handled it a different way.
21:06Nate stuck. You decided not to play Puka, and you went down to CeeDee Lamb, and that allowed you to get up from Antonio Williams to Flournoy.
21:15I handled it a third different way, which I'm not quite sure how I feel about it.
21:21But I got off of Patrick Mahomes, and I played Malik no-touchdown Willis in a pretty good matchup.
21:27And that allowed me to play Aidy Mitchell and Flournoy together with the Saints defense.
21:33And I felt pretty good about that. I did not necessarily think this was a big smash spot for Mahomes.
21:40He doesn't run that much anymore. So, really, he needs to throw three touchdowns or get 300 yards to really make a difference these days.
21:49And I just thought, you know, it's not that likely that he does that.
21:53He hasn't done it consistently this year at all.
21:57It turns out he didn't. The flaw in this logic is that Aidy Mitchell A sucks and Malik Willis.
22:03Malik Willis is god-awful. And so are the Dolphins.
22:06They're just a shitty coach team. Every time they get some momentum, I finally watched them for the first time because I had Willis.
22:15And they're just like holding penalties, false start. Sammy, this decision-making is preposterous, dude.
22:20Sammy, I told you two weeks ago we got to get you back to square one.
22:25And you're showing up with Malik Willis? With Malik Willis in cash.
22:29With Malik Willis? What's wrong with that, Malik Willis?
22:33Wait, hold on. He's got fantasy points. He runs.
22:36Wait. Hold on. Actually, Sammy, I need to commend you just while we're making fun of you.
22:42I actually do want to commend you because I almost made this swap.
22:46This actually was a very good swap. The swap was sharp.
22:50This is a really good swap you made. This was a really, really good swap.
22:55Swapping Kittle and McCaffrey to Ramondre and Bowers is just like a truly, truly good swap.
23:01All right. All right. You guys can eat my ass with the swap thing, okay?
23:06Malik Willis was facing the league's worst defense, Sands Jack Campbell.
23:10And getting into the weeds a little bit, they've been playing close to 50% man coverage the last couple weeks.
23:17They really shifted their defensive identity. Man coverage historically much better for rushing quarterbacks.
23:22Man coverage creates lanes, you know, people with their backs on the line.
23:27Malik Willis, I don't know why he stopped running, but he didn't even run at all.
23:32And they got close to the end zone a couple times.
23:36I think Malik Willis was fine. I think he was fine.
23:40He was most certainly not fine. Also, I do just need to bring this up that, Nate, if basically I got fucked
23:48by Lamb having that one last catch because I had the Bowers-Ramondre swap in.
23:52And you would have done it. And I would have done it, but I got that one last Lamb catch.
23:59And I was like, okay, because I think, what?
24:03Lamb got to, what did he get to? Okay.
24:06So he lost to Puka by literally like two points, like 1.75.
24:10By his fumble. By his fumble. Yes. And so Bowers scored 26.
24:14McCaffrey scores 22. But Kittle scores, or Ramondre scores 15.
24:18Kittle scores 9. So, yeah. Yes. That, that I, well.
24:21Look, look, look, look. Look, let me, let me just stop right here.
24:26I'm never going to hate on like CeeDee Lamb because he's very good and obviously he's smashed.
24:32But not playing Puka Nakua is way worse than playing, not playing Patrick Mahomes.
24:37Puka Nakua at one point had like 119 of the 136 Stafford yards.
24:41His whopper is so bulbous. It is out of control.
24:45He never fails. He never gets shut out. He is always omnipresent.
24:49It is crazy that you got bailed out, frankly, in this spot.
24:53I mean, wow. I can't believe you didn't play fucking Puka Nakua, man, and live to tell about it.
25:00Uh, honestly, I got to say. Nate, back me up here.
25:04Nate, back me up. Sammy's right. Sammy's right. Sammy's right.
25:07Sammy's right. Puka legitimately in this spot was an absolute smash.
25:11Puka, if he needed any volume, the fact that he can legitimately get 30 points without touchdowns, like he got to 30
25:19points, I think, without a touchdown today before his touchdown came.
25:23And it was like, I mean, any, any week here, he's going to get some efficiency that goes his way, some variance,
25:30and it's going to be an explosion game. He just constantly accumulates and there's nothing you can do about it.
25:37And so it's one of those things where it's like, he's just inevitable.
25:42That's the word that keeps coming to mind. Puka is inevitable.
25:46You have to play Puka. The only mistake I made was not finding a way to get Puka and CD.
25:53I think that that was the sharpest way to play.
25:56I think that's what I should have done when I heard the Pickens news is just said, these are the two.
26:03I'm going to do anything I can get those guys.
26:07I think that was the right way to build.
26:10I think the floor and away stuff was a mistake.
26:14I think the fading Puka was a mistake. But if you got both Puka and CD, I think that was the right way to play.
26:22Because CD, I mean, CD is the only one who has close to Puka's upside.
26:28But Puka, I think you can't not play Puka.
26:31Okay, I want to know this. I want to know this and I want to put it to bed.
26:37I want to put it to bed. Did Flournoy run more routes than usual?
26:42Was he on the field more than usual? Like, did he see an uptick in time on the field than routes run?
26:50Let's see. Flournoy ran 38 routes, three targets for a total of .0789 targets per route run.
26:56His Whopper was .233. Or no, .273. So, he was out there for every route.
27:01He ran 100% of the routes. Yeah, he literally, like, Flournoy was in the way.
27:07But he can't earn targets. That wasn't even, first off, that's not even really true.
27:12Second off, it was just a thing. It's just a thing that happened in game, dude.
27:17They fucking put Sauce Gardner on him. Also, you know, hold on.
27:22He's going to get a 50% tax here. I do need to make one point here, which we gave you a hard
27:29time on the show, but we actually didn't give you a hard enough fucking time on the show last week for playing St.
27:37Brown over McCaffrey. I mean, truly. Not to relitigate it in the past.
27:42You're not going back to last week. You guys, this is ridiculous.
27:46That shit was hilarious, Nate. Well, you know, look.
27:49We did it, guys. We got one. You guys got one slate of the whole year.
27:55It really does not happen that often. This is what everybody wants.
27:59But all three of us finished below. So, the cash line in the massive $25 double up was 134.24 points.
28:06My lineup, which was best. Just to state that again.
28:10I had the best lineup in the three-man. Davis, I'm actually – I do need to give you props.
28:16This is the first week I think you've beat me, and all it took for you was sunrunning with the Packers defense
28:24getting four sacks, three interceptions, and a defensive fumble.
28:27If that's what it takes to beat me every week.
28:31First off, I beat you last week, and I'm pretty certain I beat you the week before as well.
28:37I don't think so. Well, actually, wait. Hold on.
28:40Can we get the – Yes. What do you need, Sammy?
28:44Can we get the champagne popping medal and the, you know, medal over the head and then, you know, eighth on the podium?
28:52Yes. Yes, we can. Can you transpose that over you?
28:56Which is valid. Thank you. We need it. People need it.
29:00Now, as you might guess by my fascination with Ryan Flannoy, not a banner day for me in guaranteed prize pool contests on DraftKings.
29:08So I want to pull up the big spy.
29:11I played two spy teams, and I had big dreams for one of them.
29:16I think this is my really bad one. 64% sim ROI.
29:20Actual ROI, negative 100,000%. So I played – And I'm actually kind of curious if any of you guys did this with your teams.
29:28Because I tried to get Gibbs in, thinking Gibbs would be a little bit lighter owned.
29:34It didn't actually end up really happening. But my big spy team was Mahomes, Gibbs, Singletary, Rasheed, Ryan Flannoy, Aidy Mitchell, Tyler Warren, Gentie in the Saints defense.
29:44The independent field ROI, negative 28%. What is that?
29:47Well, my big thing today – Ashton Gentie? The Raiders back and running back?
29:52No, I mean, because I was dead-ass right that he was going to be a full-ass starter, which he was.
29:59Mike Washington barely played today. So Gentie was like – $5,900 Gentie compared to Singletary, compared to Coleman, compared to Hubbard, compared
30:07to Ramondre, compared to the Jets guys. I felt pretty, pretty good about Gentie.
30:11And, I mean, it is one of those sick things where, like, I end up being 100% correct about it.
30:18It just ends up not mattering at all because Gentie had a pretty bad game.
30:24And, I mean, not that it would have really mattered anyway.
30:28But the ownership on Gentie, 3.6%. Rice with Mahomes at 9.4%.
30:31Flannoy – honestly, Flannoy came in way less owned than I thought he would be because of Antonio Williams and because of Omar Kuber Jr.
30:40as well. Frankly, this is a team that I – I actually would just run this back.
30:46I actually – I think this team is – I think this team is pretty good.
30:52I – what is score 70, 74 points or whatever.
30:55Nate's going to say the same thing – Nate's going to say the same thing that I am going to say about it.
31:03And I'm mad that I didn't do this. But just have Walker as part of the – the Chief.
31:10So, I did – I did do that. Like, playing Gibbs – playing Gibbs here, not great, I don't think.
31:17So, this is the – this is the other spy.
31:20So, there was – they did a – they did two spies today.
31:25This was the 50-k to first spy. So, this team is Mahomes, Gibbs, Walker, Flannoy, Mitchell, Antonio Williams, Kelsey, 3.3%.
31:32Kelsey, 3.3%. And then Singletary in the Cardinals defense.
31:35I honestly – like – good. Good. Frankly, I think the – I think the issue actually with these teams is Mahomes
31:43is pretty good – pretty good bet to get 24 points, which he would have gotten today if that Kelsey pass was ruled a forward pass.
31:52I think he's probably, like, just never getting 36 points in the game ever again.
31:57Like, ever. Like, just – like, that's it. He'll just – he'll – he just – he will never have 350 passing
32:05yards and four passing touchdowns in the game ever again.
32:08And so, I think these teams can sim okay or whatever.
32:12But I just don't – like, I just – I don't think he can get enough points at his salary.
32:19I don't know. What do you think, Nate? Yeah, I liked Mahomes.
32:23I thought Mahomes was going to come in under-owned.
32:27He did. Yeah, I mean, I like Mahomes. I think when you can say that the cash quarterback for the week for
32:34most people is going to come in this under-owned in cash – or in tournaments, like, I think there's an edge to be had there.
32:43And I do think Mahomes still has upside that we haven't seen yet this year.
32:48And so, getting him at this ownership, especially with Rice coming in single digits or Kelsey coming in as low as he
32:56did, I think that stack is going to be – that's going to rate well in any post-lock sim just because of how under-owned they were.
33:05But, yeah. So, I actually – I think those builds were fine.
33:09I just – like, I knew I really wanted to play Walker.
33:14I mean, obviously the 80 stuff sucks. Kelsey at 3% is crazy.
33:18I – 36% Devin Singletary, that probably, like, pushes on the side of being bad, honestly, of, like, it's just too much.
33:25He'd probably have to score twice. I don't know.
33:29That does not feel great. 36% Devin Singletary feels pretty bad.
33:32Pushes on the side? No, it's awful. It's awful.
33:36Yeah, well, you know what? You know what, Sammy?
33:39That's fair. That's fair. All right, Sammy, that team you sent in our group chat, which contest is that in?
33:46Big Spy. Big Spy. All right. Big Spy. Yeah.
33:49Whirling – Whirling Dervish got you for – plus 166% SimROI, sir.
33:53Wow. Respect my goal. This team was a – this team was a goddamn scratch.
33:58So, originally this team had Walker in it. And as I fiddled around with things, it just – it was just simming
34:06so much better with CMC, which was counterintuitive to me.
34:10But that's, you know, that's what I did. It was just – this was a team that, like, I felt so good
34:17about because I, you know, fucking built it sitting on the potty.
34:22And I was just like, yeah, you know, shitting, you know, doing it.
34:26And I'm like, oh, wow, this is going to be great.
34:30And then, you know, I finish up and I go sim it.
34:34And it just simmed like a motherfucker. Made a couple tweaks and I was like, yeah, this is it.
34:41This is it right here. You know. What was Cooper owned?
34:45Really? Like, not very much. I don't know. I don't think it shows on those green.
34:50I just thought that was mega sharp. I think Omar Cooper is, like, extremely good.
34:56Yeah. The Omar Cooper play was interesting. I just thought it was a great pivot.
35:01Oh, never mind. Sorry. Cooper. Cooper was pretty owned.
35:04Kittle on this lineup. So, Kittle and McCaffrey, no Purdy.
35:07Mahomes, I mean, Mahomes and Rice, I thought, was so, so pure.
35:12I was just like, dude, the Rice scam is like fully back.
35:16The issue was, so the issue with teams against the Jets is the Jets make first halves incredibly short because in the
35:24first half, before they're behind by too much, they're just run, run, run, four yards, run, run.
35:29Like, they burnt up. The Jets, I think, won the time of possession in the first half, I believe, against the Chiefs.
35:37And then by the time it's over in the second half, it's just over because they have no ability to hang with you.
35:45Like, it's just, I don't know. The Jets are a very weird fantasy opponent.
35:50Ollie Gordon, I think, is terrible, actually. It's just like, just play.
35:54Just play. Oh, no. I like the Ollie Gordon.
35:57Just play Singletary. No, no. What do you have on it?
36:01Gordon's way better than Singletary. And he was coming in at way less ownership.
36:06Clearly, I was wrong. I thought, look, this is a really good spot to attack the Lions where they're missing their defensive
36:14captain and maybe the best player on their defense.
36:17And they're on the road, out of the dome.
36:20I think Miami can actually do something. Clearly, I had Malik Willis in cash.
36:25Didn't happen. I had Ollie Gordon here. Clearly, it didn't happen.
36:29But Ollie Gordon is way, way, way better than Devin Singletary, mate.
36:33Like, you can't get that one past me. He's more talented, better matchup.
36:38Just all the above. I mean, I'd way rather.
36:41And way less ownership. So, I thought, I like the play.
36:45Yeah. Yeah, I'm actually okay with that play. I do think, Sammy, you are undervaluing a little bit just how much expected workload Singletary was going to have.
36:55But Singletary is dust. I get it. Yeah, he's terrible.
36:58But, yeah, I do think Ollie has more upside.
37:01And I think at lower ownership, that play kind of does make sense.
37:06But you're hating on Singletary a little too much there.
37:09You know he wasn't going to score any points.
37:12You know. Look deep in your soul, Nate. You knew he was not going to score fantasy points.
37:19Be honest with you. I mean, I did think he was the one I wanted to try to get off of.
37:26But at the same point, like, fading that over the long haul, I don't think is sharp.
37:32It's just like, yes, I can. So, like, Sammy, this is honestly one of the things that to me that I think
37:40is so hard about DFS these days is that most of the value is found in these guys who mostly suck.
37:47Like, they project very well, but no one wants to play them.
37:51Like, no one really wanted to play. To your point, Sammy, no one really wanted to play Devin Singletary.
37:58If Devin Singletary's name was Blaze McKinnon and he was a fifth-round rookie out of SMU who, like, had, like, the same
38:06stats that Singletary had this year up until this point and he was starting, instead of being 36% owned, he would have been 51% owned.
38:14Because we just all, like, know. Yeah, well, we just know Devin Singletary sucks.
38:19Like, we just, you know. But, I mean, Nate, this is the point you were making on the show last week.
38:27Like, the issue with my one team that cashed this by was, like, actually it had too many good players.
38:34Too many good players kept it from being able to get first because all the plays were good.
38:40You gotta have some pukers in there, dude. Well, I mean, dude, look at the Sklansky bucks that this team won.
38:47I mean, it is, I win the Sklansky buck challenge for the Gilcaste this week.
38:53Well, I don't know. We gotta check. Nathan, which big spy, big red zone.
38:5875k red zone. Which of these? You can pull up any of them.
39:02Maybe the big spy. I mean, I didn't play well in tournaments.
39:06I had a lot of Malik. My Wildcat team, I was probably the one I spent the most time on.
39:13You fucking fraud, Nate! You fraud! You had a lot of Malik!
39:17I had a lot of Malik. I did not know Malik was gonna pull in.
39:23Nate, why? Why? Why am I seeing Alvin Kamara on my screen right now?
39:28What do you mean? Why am I seeing Alvin Kamara?
39:31I think that might be a parsing error. I don't think I played Kamara.
39:36Let me check. No, I think you might have a parsing error.
39:40I don't think I played Kamara. Nate! I didn't.
39:43It was Malik Willis, Devin Singletary, Kenneth Walker, Antonio Williams, Puka, Flournoy, Dolsic.
39:48Let me refresh. Maybe something went wrong here. I don't want to cast aspersions against NateN.
39:54NateN user. I believe you, but something is confusing.
39:57It must be literally there's multiple NateNs. That literally has to be in.
40:01No way. I mean, Nate, we know for a fact that there actually are many, many, many NateNs on DraftKings because you
40:09have to send us the DraftKings three-man every single week because we can't find you.
40:14Let me pull it up on the actual website to make sure I didn't have a weird swap.
40:21You definitely did. Nate has a proclivity, a multi-year run of uploading the wrong CSV, and that's probably what happened.
40:28No, I did run a swap on a bunch of lineups because I was dead.
40:33So it's possible, but I... No. Yeah, this lineup in this...
40:37Or that's the Wildcat. What's the spy? What's the ID?
40:40Give me one second. I played... Anyway, I did play a lot of Malik Willis.
40:45I thought Malik Willis was going to be more under-owned.
40:49I did not expect him to be like the most owned quarterback in tournaments.
40:54If I did, I would not have played him.
40:57Wait, Malik Willis was the most owned quarterback in tournaments and I didn't win today?
41:02Okay, so my 40... Okay, in the 400K spy, what I played was...
41:07Oh, it did swap to Kamara. Fucking checkmate, brother.
41:10This team. Davis, you got to clip that shit, dude.
41:13It's going on tomorrow. No way! There's no way!
41:17There's no way! This team is trying to... There's no way.
41:20Yeah, I have Mahomes, Kamara, Singletary, Puka, AD, and Tony Williams.
41:24And I did a swap to Bowers and Stevenson.
41:27I don't think that was my... Real American dollars on a lineup that has Singletary and Kamara in it.
41:34Just like so fucking dusty, bro. Your running backs are combined 60 years old.
41:39That is brutal. I thought, Nate, I thought there was no way that our contest scraper would hallucinate a lineup.
41:46I... Yeah. Oh my god. Brother, that is brutal.
41:49Let me just tell you. We need to sign off on that.
41:53Yeah, you know what? We need to sign off on that.
41:57That's as good as it gets. We're not beating that.
42:01We're not beating that. Like the video. Subscribe to the channel.
42:05I'll be back with you guys tomorrow.

More episodes from PlayerProfiler Fantasy Football Podcast Network

6