Source + player page
Yahoo Sports NFL fantasy football takes on Jonathan Taylor
Every source-backed article insight STACKED has extracted from Yahoo Sports NFL about Jonathan Taylor.
80
Insights
21
Positive
30
Negative
Insight ledger
All Yahoo Sports NFL insights about Jonathan Taylor
PositiveUsageNov 21, 2026
Taylor benefited from Steichen's creative run-game design in the 2025 Chargers game; the source highlights a play where a fake shovel pass to Tyler Warren created hesitation for defenders while the ball went to Taylor, demonstrating how Steichen's scheme uses motion and deceptive actions to create running lanes without requiring spectacular individual plays.PositiveMatchupNov 21, 2026
Jonathan Taylor found consistent running lanes against Miami's depleted defensive line, finishing with 172 rushing yards for Indianapolis; the Colts' run game benefited from the Dolphins' lack of healthy defensive tackles.NegativeRoleNov 20, 2026
Taylor, an All-Pro running back, was one of two key figures subject to trade deadline speculation as the Colts begin their latest rebuilding process alongside Daniel Jones.NegativeUsageNov 20, 2026
Taylor had 11 carries for 21 yards and four catches for six yards in Thursday's blowout loss to the Texans. The Colts sunk major money into Taylor this offseason but have little to show for it, and the team listened to trade offers for him before the deadline but ultimately kept him.PositiveRoleNov 20, 2026
Taylor was one of the key offensive weapons Jones initially took advantage of in the Colts' play-action and RPO-heavy offense during the early part of the 2025 season.NegativeRoleNov 20, 2026
The Colts opted to keep Jonathan Taylor ahead of the trade deadline despite parting ways with notable names like Quenton Nelson, DeForest Buckner, and Josh Downs during their roster remodel.NegativeRoleNov 20, 2026
The source references Jonathan Taylor in the context of Daniel Jones' performance, noting that when Taylor is bottled up, Jones gets really exposed. This suggests Taylor's role and effectiveness are critical to the Colts' offensive function and Jones' ability to perform.NegativeProjectionNov 20, 2026
Colts running back Jonathan Taylor had an equally horrendous game in Thursday's 26-3 loss to Houston, averaging 1.9 yards per carry on 11 attempts for a grand total of 21 yards; the source notes that while he is the most positive face of the franchise, he is working with the same complement of talent around him as Jones.NegativeUsageNov 20, 2026
Taylor, whom the Colts retained amid trade rumors, finished with just 21 rushing yards on 11 carries in the loss to the Texans, averaging 1.9 yards per carry.NegativeUsageNov 20, 2026
Taylor rushed 11 times for just 21 yards against Houston's capable defense, continuing a disappointing season. As the Colts' only consistent offensive talent post-trade deadline, his inability to produce highlights the team's offensive limitations and another lost season for his career.NegativeUsageNov 20, 2026
Taylor was patient enough to move the chains on one early run but the Colts' rushing attack could never get into any rhythm, held to just 38 rushing yards on 17 attempts for the entire game. A dropped pass by Taylor also stalled a drive in the first half.NegativeUsageNov 20, 2026
Taylor had a dismal performance, rushing 11 times for only 21 yards (1.9 yards per carry) in the Colts' 26-3 loss. The source lists him as a loser, noting 'So sorry you fellas are consigned to Indy for two more months,' suggesting his situation with the struggling Colts is a negative for fantasy purposes.NegativeUsageNov 20, 2026
Taylor rushed for only 21 yards on 11 carries in the Colts' 26-3 loss to Houston, continuing a pattern of limited production.NegativeUsageNov 20, 2026
Taylor has eight carries for 17 yards in the first half, averaging just 2.1 yards per carry against the Texans defense.NegativeUsageNov 19, 2026
Taylor managed only 21 yards on 11 carries against the Texans' defense, a poor rushing performance that put additional pressure on the Colts' passing game and contributed to Indianapolis's offensive struggles in the 26-3 loss.NegativeUsageNov 19, 2026
Taylor's workload has declined noticeably since Week 7 as the Colts (3-7) manage his touches during a lost season. He has averaged 17.1 touches per game and played no more than 69% of offensive snaps since Week 7, down from 22.8 touches per game and a minimum 71% snap share in the first six games. Against Miami, Taylor saw 18 touches while backup Seth McGowan had 12, suggesting a 60-40 workload split may become the norm.PositiveProjectionNov 19, 2026
Taylor is pacing for his fourth season with at least 1,500 scrimmage yards in 2026, continuing a pattern of elite production across his seven seasons with the Colts. He has twice led the NFL in total touchdowns during his career and earned an All-Pro first-team nod in 2021.PositiveRoleNov 19, 2026
Colts coach Shane Steichen expressed strong confidence in Taylor's future with the franchise, calling him "one of the best running backs in the league" and stating the organization is committed to keeping him as a core piece during their rebuild. Taylor is under contract through 2028 with $39 million guaranteed on a two-year, $44 million extension, ranking third among NFL running backs in AAV at $22 million.NegativeRoleNov 19, 2026
Indianapolis held on to star running back Jonathan Taylor ahead of the trade deadline despite a reported fire sale, suggesting the Colts view him as central to their future despite the team's disappointing 3-7 record.NegativeUsageNov 19, 2026
Jonathan Taylor's snap share remains a concern in Week 11, with the source questioning whether he will ever again play 70 percent of the Colts' snaps, indicating ongoing role uncertainty and limited usage despite his talent.NegativeProjectionNov 19, 2026
Jonathan Taylor remained south of 70 percent of the Colts' snaps following the trade deadline, but only just. Indy ratcheted up the running against the Dolphins and will have to make it a trend even as matchups turn unfavorable, including Thursday's date with the Texans (Indy is a massive Week 11 underdog after being favored in Week 10). Taylor is a floor-based RB2 with little shot at one of his patented ceiling efforts.NegativeUsageNov 19, 2026
The Colts did not trade Jonathan Taylor despite reported strong offers including a second-round pick and more, then continued using him in a committee with rookie Seth McGowan; Taylor has had a slight edge in carries the past few weeks, with 16 carries to McGowan's 12 last week, which is odd given the Colts' lost season and long rebuild ahead.NegativeRoleNov 19, 2026
Stampede Blue notes the Colts are putting significant stock in a 27-year-old (soon to be 28) running back having a down year for him; Taylor is being eaten into by seventh-round pick Seth McGowan, who has been an absolute steal and is taking carries away from Taylor.PositiveUsageNov 19, 2026
Jonathan Taylor combined with Seth McGowan for 160 rushing yards on only 28 carries (5.7 yards per carry average), demonstrating productive ground game efficiency despite limited offensive opportunities overall; the source notes the Colts' most productive players receive limited opportunities under the current game plan.PositiveRoleNov 19, 2026
Jonathan Taylor remains on the Colts offense after Indianapolis executed a fire sale around the NFL trade deadline; the team compiled a season-best 172 rushing yards in a win over Miami last week, suggesting Taylor is a key component of their offensive approach heading into Week 11.NegativeProjectionNov 18, 2026
Taylor projects for 76.5 total yards in Week 11 at HOU. He's no longer a fantasy RB1; over the past month with Seth McGowan earning more change-of-pace work, Taylor has dropped to RB16 in usage at 12.9 expected half PPR points per game. Historical splits show when the Colts finish with under 21 points, Taylor is largely a fantasy RB2. Last week McGowan converted a goal-line score on a drive Taylor was playing on, and Taylor was stuffed on another goal-line attempt—no longer true bell-cow usage. The Colts ruled out both starting OTs and traded away star LG Quenton Nelson, creating major OL concerns on a short week against Houston's DL. Indy has a 16.0-point team total as 12.5-point dogs. In Week 3 with a healthy OL, Taylor had 68 scoreless yards against Houston; in Week 18 with a backup QB, he had 39 scoreless yards.NegativeRoleNov 17, 2026
Rookie RB Seth McGowan is getting more work than expected, and the Indianapolis offense lacks buoyancy due to poor QB Daniel Jones play. Although the Colts kept Taylor at the trade deadline, he is no longer the earth-moving pick he appeared to be in August.NegativeDepth ChartNov 17, 2026
Jonathan Taylor remained with the Colts past the trade deadline, keeping his role as the primary back; the source notes that managers who dropped Seth McGowan when Taylor stayed were second-guessing their decision after McGowan's strong Week 10 performance.NegativeUsageNov 17, 2026
Taylor finished with 16 carries for 83 yards in the Colts' win over Miami, but was not the offensive highlight; teammate Seth McGowan led the backfield in efficiency and was described as the offensive highlight.NegativeUsageNov 17, 2026
Finished with 16 carries for 83 yards in Colts' win over Dolphins; contributed to Indianapolis' ground game despite terrible quarterback play.NegativeRoleNov 17, 2026
Taylor didn't get traded, which is why Seth McGowan may have been dropped by speculators but should remain rostered.PositiveUsageNov 17, 2026
Taylor is one of two Colts running backs capable of producing significant yardage but isn't receiving the workload the source believes he deserves; the source argues that Steichen should make Taylor an unquestioned focal point of the offense and potentially run the ball 40 times to improve offensive production.PositiveUsageNov 17, 2026
The source argues that Taylor isn't receiving the workload he believes he deserves. The Colts have 2 productive running backs, and the source advocates putting Taylor and McGowan on the field together, using more 2- and 3-tight-end formations to create additional opportunities while incorporating direct snaps, screens and designed runs that force defenses to account for different possibilities. The source suggests running the ball 40 times could be part of a solution to the Colts' offensive struggles.PositiveUsageNov 17, 2026
Taylor rushed for 83 yards on 16 carries (5.2 yards per attempt) against Miami but received only 57 percent of carries between the two running backs despite being vastly more accomplished than Seth McGowan. The source argues Taylor should be receiving the overwhelming majority of opportunities and should play well above 80 percent of offensive snaps when healthy; the Colts retained him at the trade deadline despite reportedly receiving second-round offers, indicating they value him as a first-round asset, yet he is not being treated as the centerpiece of the offense.NegativeRoleNov 17, 2026
Indianapolis Colts RB Jonathan Taylor discussed in panic meter segment; specific role or performance concern addressed in Week 10 context.NegativeRoleNov 16, 2026
The star workhorse running back has been the subject of recent trade talks, and the Colts have shifted him into a time-share and running back platoon with rookie Seth McGowan. This appears to be a strategy to keep Taylor fresher and reduce his mileage in what is a lost season for Indianapolis.NegativeRoleNov 16, 2026
Jonathan Taylor still leads the backfield tandem with Seth McGowan as a complementary piece; Taylor was the main name in headlines before the trade deadline, but the front office decided it was best to keep their star captain around for the rebuild.NegativeUsageNov 16, 2026
Taylor handled 67.8 percent of snaps in Week 10, well off his early-season bell-cow usage; this marks the fourth consecutive week of reduced snap share. The source attributes this to the Colts' reluctance to risk injury ahead of potential trade talks, both before and after the trade deadline. Combined with the deteriorated offensive environment, Taylor is now viewed as an unreliable RB2 rather than a locked-in RB1 for the fantasy season's stretch run.NegativeUsageNov 16, 2026
Taylor received only 60% of Colts RB touches on Sunday, lower than his recent average and well below the expected 85%+ workload now that Indianapolis has no reason to tank. He was vulture-picked in the red zone and posted modest fantasy performance against a favorable opponent. While talented enough to overcome low volume or a weak offense individually, Taylor cannot do both; a road matchup versus Houston's run defense on Thursday Night Football will be more difficult.PositiveUsageNov 16, 2026
Jonathan Taylor was a key part of Indianapolis's dominant rushing attack in Week 10, as the Colts ran the football 34 times for 172 yards (5.1 yards per carry average). The Colts' offense consistently handed the ball to Taylor and Seth McGowan, finding room to operate and putting Miami's defense on their heels throughout the afternoon without needing elaborate offensive schemes or trick plays.PositiveUsageNov 16, 2026
Taylor led the Colts' ground attack against Miami's defense, which struggled to stop the run; Taylor and Seth McGowan combined to lead Indianapolis to over 170 yards on the ground.NegativeRoleNov 16, 2026
The source reports league sources aren't confident a second and fifth-round pick trade package will be available for Taylor in March, suggesting the Colts may have overvalued him in recent weeks. By keeping Taylor rather than trading him, the Colts have maintained optionality for the next GM.NegativeRoleNov 16, 2026
With the Colts playing out the string, there's no reason for them to push Taylor. Seth McGowan has taken advantage of opportunities, averaging 4.8 yards per carry on the season and vulturing a score from Taylor in each of the last two weeks. The source believes Taylor's RB1 upside is a fading dream and characterizes him as a steady contributor profile with no more potential to threaten overall RB1 ranks, likely having had his last hurrah against the Falcons in Europe roughly a year ago.NegativeUsageNov 16, 2026
Jonathan Taylor had 5.2 yards per carry on 16 carries and two receptions in Week 10, underperforming McGowan's 6.4 yards per carry despite receiving more touches. This suggests McGowan may be gaining ground in the Colts' backfield hierarchy following the trade deadline receiver moves.NegativeUsageNov 16, 2026
RB Jonathan Taylor had 18 touches in Sunday's 24-22 win over Miami, his third straight game with fewer than 20 touches; this marks a notable decline from his first seven games when he had at least 20 touches in six of them, suggesting the Colts are managing his workload despite being headed into a rebuild with Taylor under contract through 2028.NegativeRoleNov 16, 2026
The Colts did not trade Taylor at the deadline despite speculation, apparently not receiving the Godfather offer they wanted with Round 2 draft pick compensation deemed insufficient; the Colts continue to manage his touches as they head into rebuild mode with the 28-year-old bell cow under contract through 2028.NegativeProjectionNov 15, 2026
Taylor is no longer a certified RB1 for fantasy and has been downgraded to RB2/3 status. While he should maintain around 10-20 touches per game due to his salary and the Colts' need to run the ball, his ceiling is significantly diminished in an offense that lacks a passing game after trading away Keenan Allen and Josh Downs.NegativeRoleNov 15, 2026
Taylor is now in a timeshare with rookie Seth McGowan after the Colts held him past the trade deadline. This marks the fourth straight game Taylor failed to reach 20+ fantasy points (his historical barometer), and McGowan leeched plenty of carries while finding the end zone, though Taylor still nearly reached 20 touches.PositiveUsageNov 15, 2026
Taylor led the Colts' punishing backfield tandem with 83 rushing yards on 16 carries; he danced in the backfield patiently waiting for holes to open, converted first downs on runs, and matched McGowan with tough gains to move Indianapolis into scoring range in a physical possession-based offense.NegativeUsageNov 15, 2026
Rushed for 83 yards on 16 carries in the Colts' 24-22 win over Miami; averaged 5.2 yards per carry in the victory that ended Indianapolis's five-game losing streak.NegativeUsageNov 15, 2026
9 carries for 48 yards at halftime; receiving limited touches compared to Seth McGowan in the Colts backfield.NegativeUsageNov 15, 2026
The source notes that defenses are keying hard on the run game when Jonathan Taylor is in the game because they know the Colts receivers cannot get open against even bad NFL cornerbacks; this defensive focus has made moving the ball down the field dependent on luck and defensive pass interference calls rather than scheme.PositiveProjectionNov 15, 2026
Taylor ranks 3rd all-time in rushing touchdowns among players who only played for one team with 77 career rushing TDs for the Colts; he appeared to be moving at the trade deadline but has remained with Indianapolis throughout his career.NegativeProjectionNov 15, 2026
Jonathan Taylor is included in the source's three-leg parlay pick, projected to score a touchdown in Week 10.NegativeMatchupNov 15, 2026
Multiple fans identify shutting down Taylor as the key to a Dolphins victory; one fan projects Taylor will be held to less than 70 rushing yards, while another emphasizes the Dolphins defense must shut down Taylor and force Daniels into throwing interceptions.NegativeDepth ChartNov 14, 2026
Both the Packers and Broncos had been linked to Colts running back Jonathan Taylor; the Colts created the impression Taylor would be traded but ultimately opted to take the best offer they could get, keeping him on the roster.NegativeMatchupNov 14, 2026
Taylor's memory of the Giants' refusal to trade a first-round pick to acquire him adds narrative context to the upcoming Colts matchup, where the Giants are positioned as heavy favorites against a tanking defense.NegativeMatchupNov 13, 2026
Taylor had his least productive season of his career in 2023 when Freeland played extensively for the Colts, with only one 100-yard game which came on a day Freeland didn't play, suggesting Freeland's run blocking struggles may have impacted the running back's performance.PositiveMatchupNov 13, 2026
Despite a brief decline in playing time the last couple of weeks amid trade rumors, Taylor remained with Indy. With the Colts being favored by 4.5 points, the source expects to see his touches rise against the Dolphins. Miami is allowing the eighth-most fantasy points to RBs, including double-digit fantasy points to at least one running back each week.PositiveMatchupNov 13, 2026
Despite a brief decline in playing time the last couple of weeks amid trade rumors, Taylor remained with Indianapolis. With the Colts being favored by four points, the source expects his touches to rise against the Dolphins. Miami is allowing the eighth-most fantasy points to RBs, including double-digit fantasy points to at least one running back each week.PositiveRoleNov 13, 2026
Jonathan Taylor is identified as one of the few bright spots for the 2026 Colts, alongside a stockpile of draft picks. The source notes that Taylor and the draft capital are 'about all there is to be excited for' on a team that otherwise lacks direction, hope, or a clear future path.NegativeUsageNov 12, 2026
Jonathan Taylor owns 63% of the Colts' rushing yards heading into Week 10 vs. Miami, highlighting his central role in the Colts' ground game.NegativeMatchupNov 12, 2026
Miami's run defense ranks 16th league-wide, allowing opposing offenses an average of 111.8 rushing yards per game, making them an average run-stopping unit for Taylor's upcoming matchup.NegativeProjectionNov 12, 2026
Through 9 starts in 2026, Taylor has 161 carries for 656 rushing yards (4.1 yards per carry average) and 8 rushing touchdowns; he remains an elite Top 5 running back despite the Colts' rebuild. However, at 27 years old heading into 28 in January, questions linger about whether he has sufficient prime career longevity to outlast an Indianapolis rebuild projected to take 2-3 years.NegativeRoleNov 12, 2026
Taylor remained with the Colts despite trade speculation and the franchise's fire sale; consensus reporting suggested he would only be traded for a Christian McCaffrey-esque package or a first-round pick. When asked if he wanted to be traded after All-Pro teammates Quenton Nelson and DeForest Buckner were moved, Taylor was vague, stating he was focused on preparing for Miami rather than addressing his future.NegativeRoleNov 12, 2026
The source questions why Jonathan Taylor is still on the Colts' roster midseason, implying he is underperforming or not being utilized effectively.PositiveMatchupNov 12, 2026
Taylor was the centerpiece of Frank Reich's offensive attack against Buffalo when Reich was head coach of the Colts. In the November 2021 matchup, Taylor rushed for 185 yards and four touchdowns, caught another touchdown pass, and accounted for five of Indianapolis' six trips to the end zone in the Colts' 41-15 victory over Buffalo. Reich's offenses scored a combined 102 points across three meetings with Buffalo.NegativeRoleNov 12, 2026
Jonathan Taylor navigates uncertainty following the trade deadline, with the source noting he is trying to move beyond the stress of the deadline period.PositiveRoleNov 12, 2026
Jonathan Taylor was retained by the Colts at the trade deadline and 'should continue to be the focal point of the Colts' offense,' per the source. With the wide receiver group decimated by trades, Taylor remains Jones' biggest playmaker and the team's primary offensive weapon going forward.NegativeMatchupNov 12, 2026
Taylor entered the game against Dallas as Indianapolis' biggest offensive weapon but was held to just 46 rushing yards. The source describes this as one of the Cowboys' best run-defense performances of the season, suggesting Dallas has shown it can stop a high-level running back from controlling a game.NegativeRoleNov 12, 2026
Taylor was kept by the Colts despite the team's reboot and lost-cause season; keeping him was an odd move for a franchise that no longer looks positioned to capitalize on his prime, suggesting a disconnect in the team's rebuild strategy.NegativeDepth ChartNov 12, 2026
Jonathan Taylor was retained by the Colts despite being pursued hard by multiple teams before the trade deadline; the source notes the Colts chose to keep him as they rebuild, though the team's overall situation is uncertain.NegativeDepth ChartNov 12, 2026
Taylor was retained by the Colts at the trade deadline despite weeks of speculation that he could be traded away as one of the prizes of the deadline. The source notes he is a 'star running back,' indicating the team chose to keep him despite the broader sell-off.NegativeRoleNov 12, 2026
Jonathan Taylor was weirdly retained by the Colts despite the team trading several key pieces and firing general manager Chris Ballard during their 2-7 collapse.NegativeUsageNov 11, 2026
Taylor is the RB19 on RB13 usage this month. The key watch is whether Taylor is a 70% or 90% player with Seth McGowan flashing potential as his backup; McGowan has mixed in before garbage time over the past month, which wasn't the case at Taylor's peak fantasy value. Last week's goal-line touchdown was due to Taylor losing his shoe.NegativeRoleNov 11, 2026
The Colts traded away LG Quenton Nelson, DT DeForest Buckner, WR Josh Downs, and WR Keenan Allen, making the team significantly worse. Taylor's fantasy production is heavily dependent on team scoring: when the Colts score 0-17 points, he averages 11.3 half PPR (RB18); 18-24 points yields 14.9 (RB15); 25-30 yields 19.7 (RB3); 31+ yields 29.5 (RB1). The Dolphins are equally bad with Malik Willis headed to IR. Indianapolis is a 3.5-point home favorite with a 21-point implied total (19th).NegativeProjectionNov 11, 2026
Taylor is projected for 85.5 total yards in Week 10 vs. Miami. The trade deadline was not kind to Taylor. The Colts kept him, possibly with the idea being that they can trade him in the offseason and save some face as the rest of this season winds down. However, they also traded away superstar LG Quenton Nelson, star DT DeForest Buckner, WR Josh Downs, and WR Keenan Allen. This team is simply way worse now.PositiveUsageNov 11, 2026
Running back Jonathan Taylor owns 63% of the Colts' rushing yards, indicating heavy reliance on his production in the ground game.NegativeRoleNov 11, 2026
The Giants made a trade offer to the Indianapolis Colts for Jonathan Taylor that was eventually taken off the table, as part of their aggressive pursuit of running back upgrades.PositiveProjectionNov 11, 2026
After finishing as RB39 and RB31 the last two weeks amid trade speculation, Jonathan Taylor is positioned to return to form. The Colts kept Taylor while trading away their two starting wide receivers, leaving him as the primary offensive weapon. Against the Dolphins' 29th-ranked run defense (0.013 Rush EPA over last four weeks), Taylor is projected for 20 touches and 100+ yards.