Source + player page

Yahoo Sports NFL fantasy football takes on Jonathan Taylor

Every source-backed article insight STACKED has extracted from Yahoo Sports NFL about Jonathan Taylor.

80
Insights
21
Positive
30
Negative
Insight ledger

All Yahoo Sports NFL insights about Jonathan Taylor

NegativeProjectionNov 18, 2026
Taylor projects for 76.5 total yards in Week 11 at HOU. He's no longer a fantasy RB1; over the past month with Seth McGowan earning more change-of-pace work, Taylor has dropped to RB16 in usage at 12.9 expected half PPR points per game. Historical splits show when the Colts finish with under 21 points, Taylor is largely a fantasy RB2. Last week McGowan converted a goal-line score on a drive Taylor was playing on, and Taylor was stuffed on another goal-line attempt—no longer true bell-cow usage. The Colts ruled out both starting OTs and traded away star LG Quenton Nelson, creating major OL concerns on a short week against Houston's DL. Indy has a 16.0-point team total as 12.5-point dogs. In Week 3 with a healthy OL, Taylor had 68 scoreless yards against Houston; in Week 18 with a backup QB, he had 39 scoreless yards.
PositiveUsageNov 17, 2026
The source argues that Taylor isn't receiving the workload he believes he deserves. The Colts have 2 productive running backs, and the source advocates putting Taylor and McGowan on the field together, using more 2- and 3-tight-end formations to create additional opportunities while incorporating direct snaps, screens and designed runs that force defenses to account for different possibilities. The source suggests running the ball 40 times could be part of a solution to the Colts' offensive struggles.
PositiveUsageNov 17, 2026
Taylor rushed for 83 yards on 16 carries (5.2 yards per attempt) against Miami but received only 57 percent of carries between the two running backs despite being vastly more accomplished than Seth McGowan. The source argues Taylor should be receiving the overwhelming majority of opportunities and should play well above 80 percent of offensive snaps when healthy; the Colts retained him at the trade deadline despite reportedly receiving second-round offers, indicating they value him as a first-round asset, yet he is not being treated as the centerpiece of the offense.
NegativeUsageNov 16, 2026
Taylor received only 60% of Colts RB touches on Sunday, lower than his recent average and well below the expected 85%+ workload now that Indianapolis has no reason to tank. He was vulture-picked in the red zone and posted modest fantasy performance against a favorable opponent. While talented enough to overcome low volume or a weak offense individually, Taylor cannot do both; a road matchup versus Houston's run defense on Thursday Night Football will be more difficult.
NegativeRoleNov 16, 2026
With the Colts playing out the string, there's no reason for them to push Taylor. Seth McGowan has taken advantage of opportunities, averaging 4.8 yards per carry on the season and vulturing a score from Taylor in each of the last two weeks. The source believes Taylor's RB1 upside is a fading dream and characterizes him as a steady contributor profile with no more potential to threaten overall RB1 ranks, likely having had his last hurrah against the Falcons in Europe roughly a year ago.
NegativeRoleNov 11, 2026
The Colts traded away LG Quenton Nelson, DT DeForest Buckner, WR Josh Downs, and WR Keenan Allen, making the team significantly worse. Taylor's fantasy production is heavily dependent on team scoring: when the Colts score 0-17 points, he averages 11.3 half PPR (RB18); 18-24 points yields 14.9 (RB15); 25-30 yields 19.7 (RB3); 31+ yields 29.5 (RB1). The Dolphins are equally bad with Malik Willis headed to IR. Indianapolis is a 3.5-point home favorite with a 21-point implied total (19th).