Feel It or F--k It 5.18.26: An RSP Podcast with Bob Harris and Matt Waldman

Finished QB18 last year and is currently being drafted outside QB2 territory. With Mike McCarthy in 2026, Bob Harris projects him as a viable fantasy option, particularly in two-QB leagues. Rodgers is now three years past his Achilles tear, suggesting recovery trajectory supports QB evaluation. He has receiver fits in DK Metcalf and Michael Pittman Jr. who adjust well to zone coverage.

Serves as a baseline comparison for the type of receiver Aaron Rodgers prefers; DK Metcalf and Michael Pittman Jr. are characterized as plus or plus-plus-plus versions of Lazard. Lazard may show up at some point in the Steelers' receiver rotation, though his role is uncertain.

Bob Harris flags stride and footwork concerns in Jeanty, noting he has issues with how he sets his feet similar to Denzel Boston, suggesting potential injury risk. However, Harris expects Jeanty to improve in 2026 now that Chip Kelly has fixed his stance and stride; the Raiders' offensive line couldn't be much worse than last year, so improvement there should help Jeanty's production going forward.

Bob Harris is 'feeling it' on Breece Hall for a career year in 2026 and top-10 RB territory. Geno Smith is a much better signal caller and diagnostician than Justin Fields or Zach Wilson, offering defenses more to honor and translating to bigger plays and better matchups for Hall. If Hall gains an extra 20–30 yards per game in rushing and/or receiving compared to 2025, he reaches top-10 territory. Hall was RB2 two years ago with 288 points; that same production the following year would have ranked RB7, indicating the low scoring environment. The Jets' running game will remain the main focus with more 12 personnel usage, and GM Brick Johnson's roster construction around Hall is expected to serve him well. Hall might have the best offensive line he's played with, at least on paper.

Bob Harris expresses lack of trust in Bucky Irving's recovery from shoulder surgery; Irving is 195 pounds (undersized for the position) and did not work out at OTAs, raising durability concerns that make him a risky bet for consistent playing time in Tampa Bay's backfield. The combination of recent injury and lack of ideal size creates draft trust issues.

Christian Kirk is a good player who, when healthy, can play multiple spots—a trait coveted by Kyle Shanahan. He presents a formidable challenge to Deebo Samuel as a route runner with reliable hands and after-the-catch ability; his different but dependable style makes him a significant competitor for targets in San Francisco's offense.

Deebo Samuel's fantasy value is limited by his role in Kyle Shanahan's offense. While his speed, size, and blocking ability are frequently discussed, his fantasy production may be capped if the 49ers use him more in 11-personnel packages to block and play tight end—a role that doesn't generate fantasy points. Christian Kirk's presence as a reliable route runner and receiver presents meaningful competition for targets.

Movement coaches have identified concerning stride mechanics in Boston's footwork at the line of scrimmage; his feet are splayed outward in a way that puts stress on the knee, ankle, and leg, creating inefficient and injury-prone movement patterns. Bob Harris compares this to stride issues seen in Kenneth Walker and Christian McCaffrey, both of whom have dealt with recurring injuries throughout their careers despite performing well when healthy.

Bob Harris is confident Watson will be the Browns' starter and projects low-end QB2 value. Watson is a full year removed from ACL injury and appears healthier; Todd Monken's offensive scheme is designed to leverage Watson's strengths from his Houston tenure, with glowing reports from offseason workouts in Florida. Harris acknowledges Watson's days as a top-five fantasy asset are behind him but frames his outlook as stable given health recovery and offensive fit.

George Kittle's readiness upon return from his Achilles injury is uncertain and may affect the 49ers' personnel usage. If Kittle is not ready for primetime, the team may rely more on Deebo Samuel in 11-personnel blocking roles, which would impact Samuel's receiving opportunities and overall offensive balance.

Bob Harris evaluates Jayden Daniels as one of two strong draft picks (alongside Mason Taylor) that may generate debate about their success in the coming year. Harris expresses confidence in the pick, noting it has worked out well for him.

One of two Steelers running backs (alongside Rico Dowdle) supporting the offense under McCarthy. His passing game usage may increase if Pittman's health becomes a concern, as the Steelers lack receiving core depth.

Bob Harris projects Herbert to finish around QB8 ADP despite current expectations, citing significant fantasy headwinds: third offense in three years (two in NFL), lost Wan'Dale Robinson from receiving corps, ranked as worst QB against pressure last year, and teams now have a full offseason book on his weaknesses. The combination of offensive instability, defensive game-planning, and depleted receiving options makes him a fade at current ADP.

Bob Harris recommends Ka'Tron Allen as an RB3 late-round flyer in Washington for contingent upside, with the caveat that he could be a late-round target if he proves surprisingly good.

Bob Harris projects rookie receiver Malachi Fields for 800–900 yards, framing him as a good fit for the Giants' offensive scheme. Fields can work the middle of the field, win contested catches, and generate yards after catch—all three skills the Giants need post-Wan'Dale Robinson loss. Upside depends on Jackson Dart's development and ability to support the passing game.

Bob Harris is skeptical of Malik Davis being elevated to running back two; Davis was always the second banana to Rico Dowdle for years and Harris questions how much better he's really gotten, suggesting the Cowboys' interest in Davis signals that Blue and Moffa aren't ready or performing to expectation.

Suffered an ACL tear requiring cleanup surgery and will not be fully healthy until 2027. While he will play this season, he is projected to be only 70% of his rookie-year production. Bob Harris rates his WR8 ADP (19th pick) as not worth the investment.

Bob Harris evaluates Mason Taylor as one of two strong draft picks (alongside Jayden Daniels) that may generate debate about their success in the coming year, though he expresses confidence in both selections.

Under McCarthy's Steelers offense, Pittman is part of the receiving core alongside McKinnon and two running backs (Jaylen Warren and Rico Dowdle). Health of Pittman's back is a key variable for running back passing game usage, as the Steelers lack depth at receiver if Pittman is unavailable.

UDFA running back signed by Patriots with the most lucrative contract of all their UDFA signings; Bob Harris grades him as a top-five running back pre-draft and highlights him as the best blocker and pass protector in the class. Montgomery chose the Patriots because he liked their coaching philosophy and competitive environment. Beat writers already expect him to be the RB3 over Terrell Jennings, making him one injury away from playing time. Harris recommends him as an end-of-draft option in dynasty leagues, noting the Patriots' reputation for letting players compete.

Bob Harris recommends Nicholas Singleton as an RB3 late-round flyer to monitor in Tennessee, suggesting he warrants late-round draft consideration with contingent upside.

Rashod Bateman will never return first-round value to the Ravens because Baltimore's offensive scheme doesn't suit his strengths. Bateman excels at winning contested catches on the outside—something he did extraordinarily well at Minnesota—but the Ravens run routes in the middle of the field and don't allow him to go up and win contested catches on the outside. The scheme mismatch limits his fantasy ceiling in Baltimore.

Bob Harris rejects the premise that Treyveon Henderson will take over as Patriots RB1 by year's end, citing Stevenson's superior pass protection, receiving ability, and route-running skills as well as his power and short-yardage dominance inside the five-yard line. Stevenson would need to 'fall off a cliff as a player' for Henderson to take over; currently being drafted as RB29 (up from RB43 last year), suggesting market undervaluation relative to his role security.

Ricky Pearsall retains a meaningful role in San Francisco's receiver room. The speaker explicitly rejects the notion that Deebo Samuel will beat out Pearsall for the number two receiver spot, affirming Pearsall's depth chart standing.

One of two Steelers running backs (alongside Jaylen Warren) supporting the offense under McCarthy. His passing game usage may increase if Pittman's health becomes a concern, as the Steelers lack receiving core depth.

Bob Harris recommends Sean Tucker as a late-round draft target with strong waiver wire upside. Tucker can be drafted as a disposable piece early in the draft and dropped if the team's backfield stays healthy, but should be prioritized high on waiver wire lists to capitalize on instant starter potential if an injury occurs. Harris values late-round RBs (picks 15-20) as rotational roster pieces with injury-contingent upside, and Tucker fits that profile with a different skill set than the team's other backs.

Despite elite speed and three monster games last year (28+ points each, including a 32-pointer), Henderson's role is limited by his incomplete skill set: he only runs gap concepts well and lacks Stevenson's pass protection and receiving refinement. In 14 other games, he averaged just 8 points per game; two of his three huge games came with Stevenson sidelined, indicating contingent rather than primary upside. Currently drafted as RB19, suggesting overvaluation relative to his actual role and consistency.