Yahoo Sports NFL
usageShould the Eagles want Shane Steichen back?
GOODTaylor benefited from Steichen's creative run-game design in the 2025 Chargers game; the source highlights a play where a fake shovel pass to Tyler Warren created hesitation for defenders while the ball went to Taylor, demonstrating how Steichen's scheme uses motion and deceptive actions to create running lanes without requiring spectacular individual plays.
Yahoo Sports NFL
matchup5 Things I Think I Think About the Miami Dolphins After Week 10
GOODJonathan Taylor found consistent running lanes against Miami's depleted defensive line, finishing with 172 rushing yards for Indianapolis; the Colts' run game benefited from the Dolphins' lack of healthy defensive tackles.
Yahoo Sports NFL
rolePotential landing spots for Daniel Jones after $50 million Colts disaster
NEUTRALTaylor, an All-Pro running back, was one of two key figures subject to trade deadline speculation as the Colts begin their latest rebuilding process alongside Daniel Jones.
Yahoo Sports NFL
usageNow what? Colts should have traded Daniel Jones when they had the chance
BADTaylor had 11 carries for 21 yards and four catches for six yards in Thursday's blowout loss to the Texans. The Colts sunk major money into Taylor this offseason but have little to show for it, and the team listened to trade offers for him before the deadline but ultimately kept him.
Yahoo Sports NFL
roleIndianapolis Colts release QB Daniel Jones
GOODTaylor was one of the key offensive weapons Jones initially took advantage of in the Colts' play-action and RPO-heavy offense during the early part of the 2025 season.
Yahoo Sports NFL
roleColts release Daniel Jones as QB's Indy era ends with a thud
NEUTRALThe Colts opted to keep Jonathan Taylor ahead of the trade deadline despite parting ways with notable names like Quenton Nelson, DeForest Buckner, and Josh Downs during their roster remodel.
Yahoo Fantasy Football
roleFantasy Football: These NFL teams are dead in the water — but can we still trust their stars in our lineups?
GOODTaylor's workhorse status has eroded significantly since the Colts' mid-season trades. His snap rate dropped from 80% (before Nelson trade) to 67% (since trades), rush share fell from 74% to 51%, and goal-line share declined from 87% to 60%. Seth McGowan has emerged as a consistent threat: in Week 11 TNF, McGowan took 27.6% of snaps with four touches to Taylor's 10, nearly split targets (2 to 1), and both were on the field for half of the Colts' red-zone plays. McGowan took a high-value TD touch against Miami, and it wasn't his first time cutting into Taylor's workload. While Taylor was ninth in explosive run rate and had a double-digit target rate through Week 6 (suggesting he could overcome poor environments), the Colts appear to be either preserving him for an offseason trade market or evaluating the rest of the roster. The source recommends moving on from Taylor.
FantasyPros Articles
projectionFantasy Football Week 11 Player Grades & Start/Sit Advice (2026)
NEUTRALAssigned a B+ grade for Week 11 start/sit advice, ranked fifteenth among running backs, indicating moderate projected performance against Houston.
Yahoo Sports NFL
roleValue of Things: In the rearview mirror
NEUTRALThe source references Jonathan Taylor in the context of Daniel Jones' performance, noting that when Taylor is bottled up, Jones gets really exposed. This suggests Taylor's role and effectiveness are critical to the Colts' offensive function and Jones' ability to perform.
Hogs Haven
projectionCommanders news: Dexter Lawrence brings huge test for Commanders OL
BADColts RB had an equally horrendous game in 26-3 loss to Texans; Taylor averaged 1.9 yards per carry on 11 attempts for a total of 21 yards. The source notes Taylor is 'the most positive face of the franchise' but had a dismal performance, and while comparing QB to RB play is imperfect, both are working with the same complement of talent around them.
Yahoo Sports NFL
projectionCutting pressure in half and beating Cover-0: Washington’s OL is finding answers at the right time - Daily Slop
BADColts running back Jonathan Taylor had an equally horrendous game in Thursday's 26-3 loss to Houston, averaging 1.9 yards per carry on 11 attempts for a grand total of 21 yards; the source notes that while he is the most positive face of the franchise, he is working with the same complement of talent around him as Jones.
Yahoo Sports NFL
usageChiefs News: Former Chiefs safety Justin Reid hits waivers
BADTaylor, whom the Colts retained amid trade rumors, finished with just 21 rushing yards on 11 carries in the loss to the Texans, averaging 1.9 yards per carry.
Arrowhead Pride
usageChiefs News: Former Chiefs safety Justin Reid hits waivers
BADColts RB Jonathan Taylor, retained by the team amid trade rumors, produced just 21 rushing yards on 11 carries against the Texans, averaging 1.9 yards per carry. The poor performance underscores the Colts' offensive struggles as the team has lost six of their last seven games following the firing of GM Chris Ballard and deadline trades.
Yahoo Sports NFL
usageWinners, losers as Texans rout Colts 26-3 on Thursday Night Football
BADTaylor rushed 11 times for just 21 yards against Houston's capable defense, continuing a disappointing season. As the Colts' only consistent offensive talent post-trade deadline, his inability to produce highlights the team's offensive limitations and another lost season for his career.
Yahoo Sports NFL
usageColts surrender 26 unanswered points as Daniel Jones benched in blowout road loss to Texans
BADTaylor was patient enough to move the chains on one early run but the Colts' rushing attack could never get into any rhythm, held to just 38 rushing yards on 17 attempts for the entire game. A dropped pass by Taylor also stalled a drive in the first half.
Stampede Blue
usageColts surrender 26 unanswered points as Daniel Jones benched in blowout road loss to Texans
NEUTRALTaylor was patient enough to let a hole develop and surge forward to move the chains on one carry, but the Colts' rushing attack was held to just 38 rushing yards on 17 attempts overall. Taylor also dropped a pass during the game.
Reddit /r/fantasyfootball
bustQB Daniel Jones threw his NFL-leading 13th interception and kicker Spencer Shrader missed two field goals as the Indianapolis Colts fall to the Houston Texans
BADNot traded at deadline despite Colts' fire sale; now stuck on gutted roster. 'waste of talent' and 'trapped.' Colts sold off other stars for picks but kept Taylor, described as 'selling the farm but keeping the cow.' Snap share declining; DJ Giddens getting carries. One comment notes Taylor got only 1 carry then pulled for 7th-round rookie to get 2nd carry—'braindead team management.' Drafted 5th overall by many; now benched or dropped by owners. Some suggest he's only playable vs bad defenses; others say drop him entirely. Repeated theme: could have gotten 2nd-round pick at deadline but now worth much less.
Yahoo Sports NFL
usageC.J. Stroud, Texans take care of business vs. cratering Colts: TNF winners, losers
BADTaylor had a dismal performance, rushing 11 times for only 21 yards (1.9 yards per carry) in the Colts' 26-3 loss. The source lists him as a loser, noting 'So sorry you fellas are consigned to Indy for two more months,' suggesting his situation with the struggling Colts is a negative for fantasy purposes.
Yahoo Sports NFL
usageThursday Night Football: Texans beat up on Colts, 26-3
BADTaylor rushed for only 21 yards on 11 carries in the Colts' 26-3 loss to Houston, continuing a pattern of limited production.