Fantasy Football Happy Hour with Matthew Berry on Jameis Winston

PodcastMNF Recap + Week 3 Waiver WireSeptember 22, 2026

From the episode

I think it's a downgrade for sure. Now I can't take much away from what we saw from Winston yesterday. He clearly was not good at all.

Mentioned at 6:35 – 7:43

STACKED’s take

Negative signalProjection

Jameis Winston is a downgrade from Dart for the Giants offense

Jameis Winston is considered a downgrade from Jackson Dart for the Giants offense. His performance was poor in his initial appearance, partly due to a lack of reps with new receivers like Malik Nabers, leading to timing issues and miscommunications.

Jameis WinstonQB · NYGPlayer page — value, ADP, projections, and every insight

Jameis WinstonNeutralRole

Winston kept Giants afloat as backup; fine for short-term role.

Yahoo Sports NFL

Jameis WinstonNeutralRole

Winston went 2-1-1 in four starts, meeting backup QB expectations to keep team afloat.

Big Blue View

Jameis WinstonPositiveNews

Jeffrey Simmons almost gets a TFL but Jameis Winston beats him to it

Ted Nguyen

Jameis WinstonPositiveRole

Winston's Ravens tenure gave Likely 30% target share; McCarthy reduced it to 16%.

Fantasy Life Articles

Jameis WinstonNegativeRole

Winston was inept in Week 2 replacement role; later benched for McCarthy.

Turf Show Times

Jameis WinstonNeutralRole

Winston relegated to backup role; used as QB-sneak specialist with 4 rushes, 1 TD in Week 7.

Yahoo Sports NFL

From the episode

STACKED’s take

More on Jameis Winston and from Fantasy Football Happy Hour with Matthew Berry