FantasyPros - Fantasy Football Podcast on Caleb Williams

PodcastNFL Trade RUMORS, JJ McCarthy Returns & Vikings Stay Perfect: Week 7 Reactions...October 28, 2026

From the episode

People don't do that for Caleb Williams. Hell, he was on the middle, on the front of a freaking Madden cover and he had a worse catchable throw rate.

Mentioned at 33:00 – 34:00

STACKED’s take

NeutralProjection

Williams had worse catchable throw rate than McCarthy but faced less criticism.

Debro compares J.J. McCarthy's early-season criticism to Caleb Williams' treatment, noting that Williams had a worse catchable throw rate than McCarthy but did not face the same level of scrutiny. Debro argues the inconsistency in how the two quarterbacks were evaluated highlights media bias against McCarthy.