From the episode

50 point game as a rookie set an unreasonable level of expectations. He isn't scoring much differently than in his previous years... Completion percentage over expectation is a 776 percent difference. It's 11.5 to negative 1.7... The fantasy points per game follow suit. It's a full touchdown... plus higher with Nico Collins in the lineup.

STACKED’s take

NeutralProjection

Collins' rookie hype inflated expectations; he's a 20-point average QB enabler.

Nico Collins' 50-point rookie game set unreasonable expectations; he is not scoring much differently than in previous years and is not putting the ball in harm's way with zero percent turnover-worthy throw percentage. Defensive regression and lack of run game have left fewer opportunities for him to be targeted, but the Nico Collins corollary is very real: with Collins on the field in 2026, CJ Stroud's completion percentage over expectation is 11.5 versus -1.7 without him (7.76 percent difference), deep ball is down, wide receiver targets up 18 percent, EPA per drop back increases massively, and fantasy points per game are nearly a full touchdown higher. The question becomes whether you are paying for CJ Stroud or secretly paying for Nico Collins.

Nico Collins headshotNico CollinsWR · HOUPlayer page — value, ADP, projections, and every insight