From the episode

The only two times he's been an elite quarterback in fantasy. His first two seasons in the NFL, he averaged more than 26 fantasy points per game. And he threw 39, he threw more than 39 passes per game, both years.

STACKED’s take

Negative signalProjection

Herbert's elite seasons (26+ PPG) required 39+ pass attempts; lacks yards-per-attempt upside.

Justin Herbert has been elite in fantasy only twice in his NFL career—his first two seasons—when he averaged more than 26 fantasy points per game and threw more than 39 passes per game both years. He has never been a yards-per-attempt standout, suggesting limited upside for sustained elite production.

Justin Herbert headshotJustin HerbertQB · LACPlayer page — value, ADP, projections, and every insight