Source + player page

Windy City Gridiron fantasy football takes on Tyson Bagent

Every source-backed article insight STACKED has extracted from Windy City Gridiron about Tyson Bagent.

80
Insights
22
Positive
35
Negative
Insight ledger

All Windy City Gridiron insights about Tyson Bagent

NegativeRoleOct 15, 2026
Bagent struggled to diagnose coverages and became increasingly skittish in the pocket despite 24.0% pressure rate and time to throw north of three seconds; accuracy and processing issues persisted even when Green Bay wasn't immediately disrupting the pocket. The film breakdown reveals systematic missed open receivers across nine play examples, including Luther Burden III with no defender within 5 yards, Kalif Raymond breaking open, and multiple checkdown hesitations that led to sacks and turnovers.
PositiveUsageOct 15, 2026
Bagent's processing and accuracy metrics collapsed Week 5. His on-target throw rate fell from 83.3% season average to 60.0%; his completion percentage over expected (CPOE) dropped nearly 20 percentage points from +8.0% to -10.9%; his success rate fell from 61.1% in Week 4 to 40.0% against Green Bay. He attempted just five passes more than 10 yards downfield, completing one while two were intercepted. His EPA per dropback fell from +0.22 (11th) to -0.41 (26th of 30 qualifiers).
NegativeProjectionOct 15, 2026
Bagent's Week 5 performance against Green Bay was a dramatic reversal from Week 4 optimism. After completing 21 of 23 passes from a clean pocket for 202 yards against New York, he collapsed at Lambeau with 12 of 21 completions for 87 yards, zero touchdowns, and two interceptions, finishing with a 27.4 passer rating before being benched in the third quarter. His yards per attempt cratered from 7.9 to 4.1; the source notes this was the lowest adjusted game grade ever handed out in this film-breakdown series.
NegativeRoleOct 13, 2026
Windy City Gridiron critiques Tyson Bagent as a backup quarterback who is not NFL-starter caliber, despite his two-year, $10 million contract. Caleb Williams Windy City dismisses speculation that Bagent could be a starting QB for the Bears or trade asset, noting "four years of data suggesting Bagent might not even be a roster-worthy quarterback, let alone a guy worth $10 million or an NFL starter." Bagent's poor performance against Green Bay—including missed open receivers and interceptions—exemplifies the gap between backup-level play and winning quarterback play. The piece concludes that Bagent's performance proves there are "levels to this NFL stuff, and there's a difference between competing and winning."
NegativeProjectionOct 12, 2026
Tyson Bagent finished 12-for-21 (57.1%) with 87 passing yards, zero touchdowns, and two interceptions against Green Bay. The source states he made several throws into tight coverage or double-team situations and made baffling decisions. The analysis concludes: 'He's not one of the best 32 quarterbacks in the NFL. He is not a starting-caliber player.' In four years in the NFL, Bagent has three passing touchdowns and nine interceptions. While still a solid backup, Sunday's performance showed his actual level.
NegativeBustOct 11, 2026
Bagent delivered a poor performance throughout the game, looking bad from the start and worsening as the game progressed. He fell down on his own on third down, symbolizing the entire game's dysfunction. He threw three interceptions, including one into double coverage in the second quarter to Xavier McKinney, and another late in the game that essentially iced the contest. The source notes Bagent has a pattern of throwing late over the middle and giving up stupid interceptions when on the field, and starting him over Case Keenum seems hard to justify given his poor play last week as well.
NegativeRoleOct 10, 2026
Tyson Bagent is the primary starting QB candidate for the Bears vs Packers after taking the majority of first-team reps in practice, though head coach Ben Johnson's unpredictability creates uncertainty. Last week vs the Jets, Bagent was expected to start after prominent NFL insiders reported he took most first-team reps, but Johnson deployed Case Keenum to take the opening snap to obscure the plan after reports leaked. Johnson explained: 'Well, I got all these memos saying that Tyson was starting before I ever made an announcement, so I wanted to get Case out there. It was like his ceremonial first pitch out there. Handing off the torch.' Johnson said earlier in the week that Bagent would start against Green Bay, and he still may, but Caleb Williams' return to practice creates a competing scenario.
NegativeMatchupOct 8, 2026
Bears backup QB faces a critical matchup against Packers safety Xavier McKinney, a ballhawking defender with 20 career interceptions who roams over the middle. The source warns Bagent must approach this game very carefully with his downfield passing; against the Jets, he went 7/10 on deep passes (10+ yards) but threw behind Colston Loveland on a crosser, gifting Minkah Fitzpatrick an interception. McKinney presents a similar threat to Fitzpatrick and has already recorded a comparable interception this season, making Bagent's deep ball placement and decision-making critical to avoiding turnovers.
PositiveRoleOct 8, 2026
Bagent has been named 'the guy' by offensive coordinator Ben Johnson for Week 5 against the Packers, earning a second consecutive start and a full week of preparation knowing the offense is his. This is a significant opportunity: neither Case Keenum nor Bagent had received consecutive starts or full-week preparation in the previous two weeks. The source notes this will make next week's evaluation 'particularly interesting' as Bagent enters a divisional matchup where the Bears likely cannot afford three turnover-worthy throws in a half.
NegativeProjectionOct 8, 2026
Bagent finished Week 4 with a game grade of -1.85, landing in the lower half of the 'Average' range; he ranked 5th of 5 quarterbacks graded in Week 4. The performance was a tale of two halves: all three turnover-worthy plays and the majority of negatively graded throws came before halftime (-2.35 first-half grade), while the second half was much cleaner with a positive 0.50 grade and no turnover-worthy, Poor, or Bad graded plays. The source notes legitimate signs of growth compared to 2023—Bagent operated the offense more comfortably, generally kept Chicago on schedule, and avoided compounding mistakes in the second half—but also highlights persistent limitations when pressure forced him off schedule.
NegativeRoleOct 8, 2026
The source identified at least 6 plays where Bagent moved off deeper concepts too quickly, overlooking open receivers downfield and dumping the ball underneath instead. One example showed Bagent and Luther Burden's body language reflecting this premature concept abandonment, with Bagent acknowledging the mistake shortly after. This pattern illustrates a limitation in Bagent's decision-making when given time to let plays develop, though the source notes this is correctable and that Ben Johnson and Bagent watch the same tape.
NegativeProjectionOct 8, 2026
Bagent completed 25 of 34 attempts (73.5%) for 268 yards, 0 TDs, 1 INT, and an 84.0 passer rating in Week 4 against the Jets. The source notes he looked noticeably more comfortable operating the Bears offense than in 2023, with improved confidence in reading concepts and getting the ball out quickly. From a clean pocket, he completed 21 of 23 passes (91.3%) for 202 yards, performing 17.3 percentage points above expectation; under pressure, he was 4 of 11 for 66 yards with the interception. His True Passer Rating of 102.5 hovered around league average, his PFN Impact Score of 80.8 ranked 7th of 32 qualifying QBs, and his EPA per dropback of +0.22 ranked 11th—better than Case Keenum's Week 3 mark by 0.04 despite zero TDs. The source credits Ben Johnson's play-calling for keeping Bagent in favorable situations, allowing him to run the offense, stay on schedule, and avoid sacks while letting talent around him take over.
PositiveUsageOct 8, 2026
Offensive coordinator Ben Johnson identified specific areas for improvement: Bagent needs to be more aggressive on second-level throws that were available but not taken, and should trust his pass catchers more to give them opportunities to make plays on the ball. Johnson stated, 'I have a lot of confidence in how our pass catchers are playing right now,' and encouraged Bagent to 'get the green light' to be more aggressive downfield. The focus heading into the Packers game is carrying over what worked against the Jets while making necessary adjustments.
NegativeProjectionOct 7, 2026
Tyson Bagent averaged 5.8 air yards per attempt vs. Jets in Week 4, lower than Case Keenum's 6.4 against the Eagles and significantly lower than Caleb Williams' 10.4 in Week 1, reflecting head coach Ben Johnson's conservative play-calling despite dialing up a few more longer-developing plays than in Week 3. Johnson praised Bagent's operation control, tempo, and efficiency but noted he put the ball in jeopardy too much with turnovers and red zone struggles.
PositiveProjectionOct 7, 2026
The source evaluates quarterback Tyson Bagent's performance as 'excellent,' noting that while he threw one interception and was 'bailed out on another by penalty,' he 'played on time and threw catchable passes.' The source contextualizes Bagent's capability: with the Bears' offensive infrastructure, he is 'good enough to beat bad teams and keep the Bears competitive against mediocre ones,' but the source is uncertain whether he can beat good teams, with the upcoming Packers matchup as a test case.
PositiveRoleOct 7, 2026
Backup QB delivered a strong performance in the Bears' dominant 23-17 win over the Jets, where the Bears dominated on both sides of the ball and had more first downs than the Jets ran plays. The source credits Bagent's play alongside elite playcalling and an elite offensive line as key factors in the offensive dominance, though emphasizes that Ben Johnson's playcalling is doing this 'with a backup quarterback,' suggesting the offense's success is scheme-driven rather than QB-dependent.
NegativeProjectionOct 5, 2026
Backup quarterback finished 25-of-34 (73.5%) for 268 passing yards, 7.9 yards-per-attempt, and one interception against the Jets. However, the source emphasizes that box-score numbers mask significant concerns. Bagent's lack of arm strength creates a thin margin for error; he had three interceptions wiped out by penalties (one on a free play) and several other close throws that could have gone the other way. On the positive side, when accurate and on time, Bagent was responsible for multiple big plays downfield; his protection was fantastic and his footwork and mechanics looked good. The source notes that Bagent and Case Keenum play similarly—both require good protection, on-time play, and above-average accuracy due to limited arm strength. Ben Johnson is 2-0 in games started with backups, but the source questions whether veteran Keenum might give the Bears a better chance in a big road game against Green Bay.
NegativeProjectionOct 5, 2026
Bagent's first start in over a thousand days (fifth career start) showed mixed decision-making: he was lucky not to throw multiple interceptions, with two could-have-been picks negated by defensive penalties and one actual interception on a late/behind throw. However, he demonstrated positive moments including nice progressions on the seam throw to Rome Odunze before halftime, a veteran free-play deep shot, solid cadence work, and good timing on screens. The source frames this as a learning experience for both Bagent and the Bears.
PositiveRoleOct 3, 2026
Tyson Bagent took the majority of first-team reps at practice this week and is expected to start for the Chicago Bears against the New York Jets on Sunday, per Ian Rapoport. While Ben Johnson has not officially named a starter, all signs point to Bagent getting the start. The source notes Bagent plays with the poise of a much more experienced player despite only 4 NFL starts, and the Bears gave him a contract extension, indicating Ben Johnson's confidence in him.