Source + player page
Windy City Gridiron fantasy football takes on Justin Herbert
Every source-backed article insight STACKED has extracted from Windy City Gridiron about Justin Herbert.
15
Insights
1
Positive
12
Negative
Insight ledger
All Windy City Gridiron insights about Justin Herbert
NegativeProjectionOct 27, 2026
Herbert receives an F grade; despite some valid offensive line excuses under Jim Harbaugh, he has been notably poor in late-game situations and has more interceptions than touchdowns, which the source calls unacceptable for a veteran quarterback and a significant departure from preseason MVP expectations.NegativeBustOct 27, 2026
Herbert received an F grade; while some excuses are valid (offensive line has been a disaster since Jim Harbaugh's first year), it's impossible to ignore how bad he's been late in games. Things can change from preseason expectations, but this was a front-runner for MVP consideration and has underperformed significantly.NegativeBustOct 20, 2026
Herbert has experienced a significant performance decline that the source describes as one of the hardest fall-offs they've seen from a player. The source explicitly notes Herbert was not always bad, but nothing approaching the current level of decline, suggesting a dramatic regression from his earlier career performance.NegativeProjectionOct 15, 2026
Herbert drops from 6th to 8th; he's playing like one of the five worst QBs in the NFL, but the source resists a steep drop due to his previous years of success. If struggles continue, he could fall out of the top 10 or even top 20, but the source wants to see more games before declaring him outside the elite tier.NegativeProjectionOct 13, 2026
Quarterback Justin Herbert has looked worse than at any point in his career this season for the 0-5 Chargers; the source cites this performance decline as a major concern and suggests the team should consider selling at the deadline.NegativeProjectionOct 6, 2026
Chargers QB is underperforming significantly; Justin Fields states 'Justin Herbert stinks right now,' attributing it to possible growing pains under Mike McDaniel, the inevitable Jim Harbaugh clock (who has never lasted more than four seasons as an NFL head coach), or Herbert's true level being closer to this breakdown. This version of Herbert is not getting the Chargers anywhere but last place in the division and potential coaching termination.NegativeProjectionOct 6, 2026
Herbert is having the worst season of his professional career following the hiring of Mike McDaniel as offensive coordinator. Despite being a front-runner for MVP in the offseason, four games into the season he has collapsed, with McDaniel unable to get the running game going and the defense declining without Jesse Minter.NegativeProjectionSep 29, 2026
Justin Herbert's performance under Mike McDaniel has been shocking and unacceptable for a seventh-year quarterback of his caliber. The source criticizes his 3-4 touchdown-to-interception ratio and sub-60% completion rate, noting that while the Chargers' 0-3 start is surprising, Herbert and the offense struggling to score and move the ball is simply shocking. The source dismisses common excuses made for Herbert.NegativeProjectionSep 23, 2026
Has 'put himself on fraud watch this year,' indicating a significant decline in performance or perception; the source expresses regret at having to write this assessment, suggesting Herbert's fall from expectations is notable.NegativeProjectionSep 22, 2026
The source describes Chargers QB Justin Herbert and offensive coordinator Mike McDaniel as 'complete disasters together,' citing seriously concerning signs after two games and suggesting the team faces calls for changes heading into the offseason without a complete 180.NegativeProjectionSep 11, 2026
Ranked #6 overall; characterized as a regular season warrior and postseason dud; needs postseason success to change his image and perception.NegativeMatchupSep 8, 2026
Quarterback for Los Angeles Chargers; Joe Alt's performance in protecting him is projected to contribute to both individual and team success in 2026.NegativeDepth ChartSep 3, 2026
Justin Herbert was selected #6 overall by the Los Angeles Chargers under Tom Telesco, one of four top-11 picks made by Telesco during his tenure.NegativeInjuryJul 27, 2026
Herbert has a concerning injury history despite not missing extensive time. He has fractured his left hand/wrist three times and injured his throwing shoulder three times. These recurring injuries to critical areas create backup QB concerns for the Chargers and position them as a potential trade destination for Bagent.PositiveValueJul 26, 2026
Part of an elite QB duo in dynasty; Anderson rates the QB room as "great" with Herbert and Nix forming two QB1s, though he notes a desire for a third QB option.