Source + player page
Mattek Fantasy Football fantasy football takes on Tyler Warren
Every source-backed video insight STACKED has extracted from Mattek Fantasy Football about Tyler Warren.
28
Insights
12
Positive
9
Negative
Insight ledger
All Mattek Fantasy Football insights about Tyler Warren
NegativeProjectionNov 13, 2026
Drake May ranks Tyler Warren at six, "much lower than average consensus" and below prop market expectations. With the removal of Keenan Allen and Josh Downs, prop lines suggest Warren should be "one of the best plays you've ever seen" based on expected receptions and yards. However, May tempers expectations due to the Colts' overall weakness: they are a bad team with poor receivers (Laquan Treadwell, Deion Burks, Anthony Gold, Ashton Doulan) and Daniel Jones as a "pre-season caliber quarterback." While Warren will likely be started and could have a strong game, May's expectations are lower than the market because the Colts "are not going to play very well." The floor is "so low in these situations."PositiveRoleNov 2, 2026
Warren returned to a featured role in the Giants offense with 10 targets on 37 dropbacks in Week 8 vs. Jacksonville. The source characterizes the Giants offense as 'absolutely terrible and about to get worse,' and Daniel Jones (42 PFF grade, 19-of-28 for 144 yards, 1 TD, 2 INTs) is a poor quarterback limiting Warren's ceiling despite high target volume.NegativeInjuryOct 29, 2026
George Kd doesn't think Tyler Warren will play this week. If confirmation comes that Warren is 100% playing, George Kd will move him back up into the B tier. Additionally, there are overall concerns about the Indianapolis Colts organization actively trading away good players and giving up on the season, which creates a weird environment for any Colts player.NegativeProjectionOct 21, 2026
Ranked at 69 in rest-of-season rankings; the source describes him as 'fine' with no major concerns or upside.PositiveInjuryOct 17, 2026
Suffered a groin injury in practice on Friday. Bejian Robinson believes Warren will likely miss Week 6, which would significantly boost target volume for Josh Downs and potentially Keenan Allen in the Colts passing game.PositiveProjectionOct 16, 2026
Ranked tight end six against the Tennessee Titans. Mattek Fantasy Football has been going back and forth on ranking Colts pass catchers all week. While Josh Downs has a 95% route share but is below career average in targets per route run and yards per route run, Tyler Warren has not been particularly efficient in yards but has been very efficient scoring touchdowns. The tight end position is mostly defined by touchdowns, and Warren has been the most consistent and dependable part of the Colts offense. Playing the Titans, Warren is going to have a good game.NegativeProjectionOct 15, 2026
Ranked 45th in Week 6 FLEX rankings. Scored a rushing touchdown last week. Fantasy value is heavily dependent on touchdown scoring; the source was not optimistic about Warren pre-season but emphasizes that targets are the most important thing in fantasy football. Players without targets or unable to score touchdowns struggle to reach high performance ceilings. For Warren, touchdowns are critical to reaching high fantasy ceilings given his target involvement.NegativeProjectionOct 13, 2026
Ranked 64th in rest-of-season rankings. Warren has been very touchdown dependent in a way that is not expected to continue, making him a little pricey for fantasy at current ADP/ranking.NegativeRoleOct 9, 2026
Mattek is lower on Warren than the market, citing efficiency concerns, but acknowledges his high floor due to his role as an every-snap player for the Colts. Mattek believes Josh Downs is a better player and Keenan Allen will likely be a better target earner when healthy, though Warren's touchdown potential remains undeniable.NegativeValueSep 30, 2026
Tyler Warren is identified as a primary trade chip to move in order to acquire running back help. Tyson Beant suggests packaging him with Roma Dunes to upgrade the running back room, indicating Warren should be traded away despite his value.NegativeRoleSep 26, 2026
Tyler Warren has accumulated fewer than 40 receiving yards through three games despite scoring a touchdown in each game. Mattek Fantasy Football predicted in the offseason that Josh Downs becoming a full-time player would be bad for Warren's volume, as Downs is significantly better at earning volume than previous full-time tight ends. However, Warren is at 80% route share and scores touchdowns, making him a must-start despite volume concerns.PositiveValueSep 23, 2026
Tyler Warren is preferred over Tucker Kraft for fantasy rosters, though Josh Downs is expected to out-target him for the remainder of the season. Warren remains a viable depth option, but his usage is secondary to the primary pass-catchers in his respective offense.PositiveProjectionSep 21, 2026
Running a high volume of routes and receiving multiple targets in week 2. Has scored touchdowns in both games despite accumulating only 32 receiving yards through two games, indicating positive trajectory as volume continues.PositiveRoleSep 17, 2026
Ranked 63 overall. The source is concerned about route overlap with Keenan Allen and Stefon Diggs, which mirrors the target-distribution challenges that played out in Allen's first game with the Bills. This positioning could limit Warren's ceiling in the Bills' passing game.PositiveRoleSep 16, 2026
While acknowledging Tyler Warren's talent and ability to earn targets, the source warns that he faces significant target competition from Keenan Allen and Josh Downs, who are better route runners and target earners, likely limiting his ceiling. However, the source notes he has the potential to score a significant number of touchdowns in Shane Steichen's RPO-heavy scheme.NegativeValueSep 11, 2026
Tyler Warren represents mega value at his current draft position, going 20 picks after Brock Bowers (who is not even going to play), suggesting exceptional value relative to market expectations. However, the source is lower than the market on Warren because Keenan Allen and Josh Downs' presence is not particularly good for Warren personally, limiting his target opportunities and role in the offense. The source credits Warren with underrated value tied to offensive scheme, noting that Daniel Jones' protection needs could elevate Warren's role in the Giants' offense: 'I've not historically given Tyler Warren enough credit for this, but he they could they could want to protect Mr. Dimes a little bit. And if they want to protect Mr. dimes a little bit. Uh, that could be quite good.' However, the source also notes Warren is not a primary target, saying 'I don't think Tyler Warren's a boss. He's just not a guy that I'm really really targeting, but I think it would have been reasonable for us to take him there.' In FFPC format (full PPR with tight ends at 1.5 points per reception instead of 1.0), Tyler Warren went early on source's team due to the enhanced tight end scoring.NegativeProjectionSep 9, 2026
Ranked 59th in week one FLEX rankings.PositiveSleeperAug 18, 2026
Tyler Warren is a popular late-round tight end target among NFFC drafters this year, though the source notes he may be getting drafted a little early.PositiveRoleJul 13, 2026
Josh Downs will have to beat Tyler Warren in targets per route run for Downs to reach his projection ceiling.NegativeValueJun 24, 2026
Analyst prefers the combination of Jalen Hurts and Kyle Pitts over Tyler Warren and Jackson Dart, indicating less confidence in Warren.NegativeValueJun 24, 2026
Author does not recommend taking Tyler Warren at the tight end position, stating he is not a mega jam and prefers to wait on wide receivers instead.NegativeValueJun 23, 2026
Tyler Warren goes very early in drafts, suggesting he may be overvalued.NegativeProjectionNo date
Ranked 61st overall by Fernando Mendoza, expecting him to be lower than consensus. Over the last two weeks Warren posted 4 for 44 and 4 for 18 on 10 targets, and Mendoza compares him unfavorably to Dallas Goedert, suggesting Warren is not living up to expectations despite earlier season production (7 for 83). Mendoza includes Warren in his broader negative outlook for the entire Indianapolis Colts offense against Miami, expecting the team to underperform with a 20.5-point implied team total and Kyle McCord at quarterback playing slow.NegativeProjectionNo date
Ranked in the F tier. Keenan Allen is playing this week, but Tyler Warren has a 1.66 aDOT (not great) but does have greater propensity to score touchdowns than the average tight end.PositiveRoleNo date
Tyler Warren is a primary red-zone target for the Colts alongside Jonathan Taylor, limiting Josh Downs' touchdown opportunities in the end zone.PositiveProjectionNo date
Gino Smith feels significantly better about Tyler Warren's fantasy prospects due to the team's injury situation.PositiveSleeperNo date
Warren is a high-upside tight end with a target share exceeding 20%. While he faces competition from Josh Downs and Keenan Allen, he is expected to lead the team in red-zone targets and potential touchdown production.NegativeUsageNo date
Will share the field with Josh Davis and Keenan Allen. The speaker expects both Davis and Allen to beat Warren in terms of targets per route run, limiting his receiving volume and fantasy upside.