Source + player page

Mattek Fantasy Football fantasy football takes on Tyler Warren

Every source-backed video insight STACKED has extracted from Mattek Fantasy Football about Tyler Warren.

28
Insights
12
Positive
9
Negative
Insight ledger

All Mattek Fantasy Football insights about Tyler Warren

NegativeProjectionNov 13, 2026
Drake May ranks Tyler Warren at six, "much lower than average consensus" and below prop market expectations. With the removal of Keenan Allen and Josh Downs, prop lines suggest Warren should be "one of the best plays you've ever seen" based on expected receptions and yards. However, May tempers expectations due to the Colts' overall weakness: they are a bad team with poor receivers (Laquan Treadwell, Deion Burks, Anthony Gold, Ashton Doulan) and Daniel Jones as a "pre-season caliber quarterback." While Warren will likely be started and could have a strong game, May's expectations are lower than the market because the Colts "are not going to play very well." The floor is "so low in these situations."
PositiveProjectionOct 16, 2026
Ranked tight end six against the Tennessee Titans. Mattek Fantasy Football has been going back and forth on ranking Colts pass catchers all week. While Josh Downs has a 95% route share but is below career average in targets per route run and yards per route run, Tyler Warren has not been particularly efficient in yards but has been very efficient scoring touchdowns. The tight end position is mostly defined by touchdowns, and Warren has been the most consistent and dependable part of the Colts offense. Playing the Titans, Warren is going to have a good game.
NegativeProjectionOct 15, 2026
Ranked 45th in Week 6 FLEX rankings. Scored a rushing touchdown last week. Fantasy value is heavily dependent on touchdown scoring; the source was not optimistic about Warren pre-season but emphasizes that targets are the most important thing in fantasy football. Players without targets or unable to score touchdowns struggle to reach high performance ceilings. For Warren, touchdowns are critical to reaching high fantasy ceilings given his target involvement.
NegativeValueSep 11, 2026
Tyler Warren represents mega value at his current draft position, going 20 picks after Brock Bowers (who is not even going to play), suggesting exceptional value relative to market expectations. However, the source is lower than the market on Warren because Keenan Allen and Josh Downs' presence is not particularly good for Warren personally, limiting his target opportunities and role in the offense. The source credits Warren with underrated value tied to offensive scheme, noting that Daniel Jones' protection needs could elevate Warren's role in the Giants' offense: 'I've not historically given Tyler Warren enough credit for this, but he they could they could want to protect Mr. Dimes a little bit. And if they want to protect Mr. dimes a little bit. Uh, that could be quite good.' However, the source also notes Warren is not a primary target, saying 'I don't think Tyler Warren's a boss. He's just not a guy that I'm really really targeting, but I think it would have been reasonable for us to take him there.' In FFPC format (full PPR with tight ends at 1.5 points per reception instead of 1.0), Tyler Warren went early on source's team due to the enhanced tight end scoring.
NegativeProjectionNo date
Ranked 61st overall by Fernando Mendoza, expecting him to be lower than consensus. Over the last two weeks Warren posted 4 for 44 and 4 for 18 on 10 targets, and Mendoza compares him unfavorably to Dallas Goedert, suggesting Warren is not living up to expectations despite earlier season production (7 for 83). Mendoza includes Warren in his broader negative outlook for the entire Indianapolis Colts offense against Miami, expecting the team to underperform with a 20.5-point implied team total and Kyle McCord at quarterback playing slow.