Matt Waldman artwork

QB & WR Development, Saints Offense, & Rookies: Going Deep with Brandon Angelo & Matt Waldman

STACKED extracted the fantasy-relevant player signal from this video and kept the full transcript here for context.

1 hr 7 min
Duration
Estimated from transcript
No date
Published
26
Player insights
26
Players mentioned
Topics
A.J. BrownAlvin KamaraBaker MayfieldDemario DouglasDevaughn VeleDrew LockE.J. ManuelJ.J. McCarthyJameis WinstonJames CookJordan TravisKenneth GainwellLuther BurdenMalik Nabers
Player analysis

Player insights

26

A.J. Brown

PositiveUsage10:12

Case Keenum suggests that the Patriots' roster strategy should have centered around acquiring high-end talent like AJ Brown to support their quarterback, noting that when Brown is available, he is a focal point worth investing in.

Insight page

Alvin Kamara

PositiveUsage50:02

Alvin Kamara is a key playmaker who helps the offense effectively utilize 13 and 12 personnel, which maintains quarterback stability. As long as he remains healthy, he is expected to be a reliable contributor as both a receiver and a runner.

Insight page

Baker Mayfield

NegativeProjection70:31

Baker Mayfield is viewed as a middle-tier quarterback who remains a viable long-term starter; he is athletic and tough, and while he plays with risk, he has successfully reigned in his style to remain effective for stretches of time.

Insight page

Demario Douglas

NegativeRole20:44

Case Keenum evaluates DeMario Douglas as the Patriots' best receiver pound-for-pound, but notes that his utility is strictly limited to the slot due to his small stature.

Insight page

Devaughn Vele

NegativeUsage50:56

Devaughn Vele is involved in the passing game but has struggled with safety positioning on in-breaking routes, which has nearly resulted in interceptions in multiple games against the Raiders and Ravens.

Insight page

Drew Lock

NegativeBust57:08

Drew Lock is cited as an example of a quarterback who fits the "robo quarterback" prototype but fails to develop into a successful long-term NFL starter.

Insight page

E.J. Manuel

NegativeBust65:56

EJ Manuel is categorized as a 'robo quarterback' who failed to sustain a starting role; despite possessing the prototypical physical build and technical specifications favored by assembly-line scouting, he lacked the intuitive play and productive creativity necessary for long-term NFL success.

Insight page

J.J. McCarthy

NegativeDepth Chart21:53

The team acquired JJ McCarthy not because they view him as superior to Jackson Dart, but as an insurance policy. This move provides the organization with a longer runway to ensure Dart is 100% healthy before playing and offers a secondary option if Dart continues to falter.

Insight page

Jameis Winston

NegativeRole22:30

Jameis Winston is viewed as a veteran presence who is best suited for an emergency quarterback role rather than a starter, as the team is not expected to be competitive this season.

Insight page

James Cook

PositiveUsage8:50

James Cook is a high-end running back who possesses the necessary lower limb dexterity to navigate wide zone schemes effectively, a trait that is essential for success in that specific run style.

Insight page

Jordan Travis

PositiveDepth Chart54:09

Jordan Travis is expected to serve as an additional playmaker for the offense upon his return from injury, which is projected to simplify the quarterback's decision-making process.

Insight page

Kenneth Gainwell

PositiveUsage83:35

Kenneth Gainwell is identified as a phenomenal route runner out of the backfield who is currently being underutilized by his team.

Insight page

Luther Burden

PositiveValue20:05

Case Keenum highlights Luther Burden as a superior draft prospect compared to the players the Patriots actually selected, noting his ability to operate across three levels of the field and extend the run game.

Insight page

Malik Nabers

NegativeUsage22:54

Malik Nabers is struggling significantly, appearing as a shell of his former self. Matt Waldman suggests that if Nabers does not show progress in the first half of the season, the team might choose to bench him for an extended period to ensure he is fully healthy for the following year.

Insight page

Mitchell Trubisky

NegativeBust57:10

Mitchell Trubisky is categorized as a quarterback who looks the part of a prototypical prospect but ultimately fails to sustain success as a long-term NFL starter.

Insight page

N'Keal Harry

NegativeBust21:57

Case Keenum cites N'Keal Harry as a prime example of a failed first-round draft pick for the Patriots who did not pan out as expected.

Insight page

Noah Fant

NegativeUsage50:31

Noah Fant is identified as the cause of two of the quarterback's three interceptions due to poor route running, specifically failing to settle in his spot and running routes that led to miscommunications.

Insight page

Roman Wilson

PositiveUsage75:30

Roman Wilson is currently struggling with drops and mistakes, resulting in a loss of snaps to Jeremy Bernard; he is not viewed as a player capable of handling a high-volume target share at this stage.

Insight page

Romeo Doubs

NegativeUsage15:11

Romeo Doubs is contrasted with elite receivers, as he requires perfect ball placement to make catches, particularly on back-shoulder throws.

Insight page

Saquon Barkley

NegativeRole10:03

Saquon Barkley is used as an example of a running back who, despite his talent, lacks the specific lower limb dexterity required to excel in wide zone movement.

Insight page

Travis Etienne

NegativeInjury54:16

Travis Etienne is currently dealing with hamstring issues, which has limited his consistency and health, negatively impacting the team's run game efficiency.

Insight page

TreVeyon Henderson

NegativeBust20:05

Case Keenum expresses disappointment in TreVeyon Henderson's performance, noting that he has been merely 'okay' and has not lived up to the expectations of a high draft pick.

Insight page

Trevor Lawrence

PositiveProjection23:36

Trevor Lawrence is cited as a prime example of the benefits of coaching continuity. In his second year within the same system, Lawrence has shown measurable improvement in handling the blitz. While his early career was hindered by a dysfunctional supporting cast, he was "resuscitated" by Liam Coen, who provided the necessary intermediate infrastructure to allow Lawrence to play winning football.

Insight page

Tyler Huntley

PositiveProjection48:47

Tyler Huntley is viewed as a viable fantasy starter with a trajectory toward being a top-12 quarterback this season. While he has only played 14 games, his decision-making and the Kellen Moore scheme provide confidence, though managers should monitor his performance against zone-heavy defenses and potential tight end coverage adjustments.

Insight page

Will Levis

NegativeBust57:18

Will Levis is struggling to maintain his standing in the NFL; despite a strong initial performance that created high expectations, he has since regressed and is currently fighting to secure a backup role.

Insight page

Zach Wilson

NegativeBust57:05

Zach Wilson is cited as a primary example of a quarterback who possesses the physical "robo" traits GMs look for but fails to develop into a successful long-term NFL starter.

Insight page
Full transcript

Episode Transcript

598
0:00All right, we're going to go deep into the quarterback roller coaster. Which rookie is going to break out soon?
0:05Matthew Golden, is he making progress?
0:08The Saints offense, are they making progress? And is Dvat Smith really a legit wide receiver one? I think most people are going to say yes, except you
0:16don't think so, probably. Well, we're going to find out. Um, Brandon, it's always a pleasure for us to be able to
0:23do this. So, anything new going on that we want to share with anybody?
0:27>> Oh gosh, no. It's it's one of those times of year where you're just trying to gather information on what to expect
0:33in the future. I think that's the biggest thing, right? Of >> Yeah.
0:36>> You know, this off seasonason, what are we expecting in the quarterback carousel? You know, what are we looking at in terms of potential, you know,
0:43draft capital for some of these college guys, right? opposite trend with the the quarterback class kind of being shaken up with Arch not playing super well and
0:51you have Darian Mensah playing out of his mind. Trinidad Shameless is playing good ball and also you have Dante Moore who might have a season ending injury
1:00right with the with the pretty nasty concussion he took um the hit he took against USC. So it's an interesting time
1:05of year you're kind of just sitting back and gathering information but uh nothing really new on my end just watching my
1:12Bears go with Case Keenum and maybe Tyson Beant this week. So that's right.
1:16>> Be a fun one.
1:17>> Well, yeah. Well, Tyson's daddy, maybe we can get him out there and let him Martin wrestle some.
1:22>> Oh, yeah. First, have to have to.
1:24>> Exactly. But, um, yeah. So, let's start with the quarterback roller coaster. You know, we you you mentioned the injuries.
1:33You mentioned, you know, what that might mean for the draft, but we also had the trade with JJ McCarthy >> to um to the Giants. Baker Mayfield is
1:42out. Now, we got Jaylen Daniels. And yeah, >> um, you know, he understands thermostat versus thermometer. So, [laughter] >> so I got quite a few I got quite a few
1:54people adding me on X about that because I've I've written about that a lot with quarterbacks. Um, so it was kind of
2:01funny. Um, but you know, we got that going on. Another bad week for Justin Herbert. Another bad week for Drake May.
2:09Um, Michael Pedix comes in and, you know, a nice debut for, you know, for him against the Packers. Um, so where do you
2:20want to start with this carousel?
2:22>> Gosh. Or roller coaster.
2:24>> I don't know. I think the most interesting points are probably the Drake May, Justin Herbert conundrum.
2:29We've talked about this in the past because they have pretty similar problems. are just, you know, Justin Herbert's had the problem for a lot
2:36longer than Drake May has, but Justin Herbert keeps being laed this lauded as this top five quarterback, which he very well isn't. He's not a very good
2:45quarterback. Uh, he's a good thrower ball, but he's not good at playing quarterback. And that's the issue too with Drake May is he's really struggling
2:54because he can't play quarterback and no one's taught him how. He's just, you know, he beat he beat up on really bad
3:02defenses last year. He had a really difficult time in the playoffs. And when coverages essentially get muddy, right? And when
3:11defensive coordinators can disguise different elements and make them look the same to May, he has no idea what's going on. Like he is
3:22ve he's flustered. He's unsure. he's not confident in, you know, in the timing.
3:29But also too, it's a difficult part where you have a play caller that's not really catering to his strengths very well, but also to you don't have a deep
3:41enough receiver room to where you can, you know, you have a guy that can bail you out. Like even when AJ Brown comes
3:50back, you're trusting a 30-year-old coming off a high ankle, right? who's a myra of have knee issues. So, that's going to be really interesting to see if
3:58they add anybody else because obviously the Romeo Dobs that's not working out, right? You know, you have Kyle Williams who denies peace, but they don't trust
4:06him. Your best option is literally M.
4:09Holland. Like, it's difficult for any young quarterback to deal with, but um the best friend of a quarterback's a run game. They don't have one of those
4:18either. So, it's a really interesting conundrum in that capacity. And then you go to Herbert, it's kind of similar to where he's not a processor and he
4:28doesn't see things well enough to make better decisions. And that hurts when you have three very capable receivers,
4:39you know, and Maki, Harris, and Johnston. and you have a Mike McDaniel there who should have improved that run
4:50game, but it's it's no better than it was a year ago. Might be even worse because you're trying to fit the Omar
4:55and Hampton peg in a different hole. And that's a difficult one when you can't runs you can't run wide zone with
5:02Hampton. He's just it's just not the type of player he is. But you keep trying it and he he's going to continue
5:07to struggle because that's just not the type of back that he he is and can be.
5:12So >> talking about that since spring.
5:15>> We we've Matt, you and I have talked about that since the draft with Hampton coming out of UNC. I mean that's the
5:20thing is like he just doesn't have he does not have the ability and dexterity from a lower limb perspective. And you
5:30talk about this with James Cook, which I I love that post because it's so true.
5:34just the lower limb dexterity to Have you ever seen like the meme of the motorcycle kind of going like >> I used it with James Wilder like way
5:44back in the day.
5:45>> It It's the truth. Like that's like the really high-end backs, but we love these super mass driven like heavy dudes. They
5:53can't do that. Like they they can't ride that wave. And especially when you're talking about a wide zone centric league that wants to do all this stuff and
6:03stretch the field in in that sense east to west. You can't have even a Saquon Barkley, you can't have
6:14your Derrick Henry do that. You can't have your Marian Hampton do that as well because they don't have that skill set.
6:21The absence of mass is what helps that, right? It's, you know, it's the motorcycle versus the drag racer. Both are fast.
6:32One's fast in a curve linear sense. The other is useless. So, that's kind of where that comes into play. But, yeah, I
6:39think, you know, to get back on track with the quarterbacks, the most concerning one might be CJ Stra. Like, what do you do if you're Houston? Like,
6:48he's not playing well. Um but the offensive line isn't it's a joke.
6:54>> Get better. Yeah.
6:55>> And that was the thing in the offseason like we're going to get better on the you know get on the offensive line and
7:01they traded away their best players on the O line. So it's difficult to get better when those guys are shipped out.
7:08So it's just kind of a mess with Stra because he's he's similar in a way to the other guys who I talked about. You
7:16know May and Herbert.
7:18It's they're not high-end processors.
7:21Stout is not a high-end processor. When the picture's clean, he's good. And third ball of anticipation, multiple quadrant thrower, we don't question
7:31that.
7:32But when things are disguised, the pockets collapsing don't know what to do. [clears throat] Like it's like, you know, we we talked
7:44about this last time. I think it's like the the Simpsons episode when Homer has the monkey with, you know, with the symbols banging in
7:54his head. That's kind of what happens to those guys is they just have no answer.
7:58And I don't think any of their coordinators are helping them find that answer. And that's another issue with McDaniel McDaniels and then Nick Kaye
8:09who's terrible. Oh my gosh. Um, Bobby Sloic was bad and got worse. Um, but yeah, it's definitely it's definitely
8:19interesting to see and gonna be interesting to see as well what happens with those guys and if they can progress, if Shaw can get back on track,
8:26same with same with Herbert. What are you what are you seeing with with some of these guys and any others that I
8:31didn't mention?
8:32>> Sure. I mean, I think with May the problem is is with all these guys is that it's a combination of things. I mean, I think
8:40you hit the nail on the head when you're talking about whether the scheme's helping them, whether they can process the information well. But sometimes you
8:48can be in a situation where you don't process so well, but if you have the arm talent, you have the athletic talent,
8:55and you have surrounding talent that can kind of ease your burden. You don't have to be perfect with your throws. If you
9:03can make the good enough read and the balls in the general vicinity, well, Stefon Diggs or AJ Brown or Kahan Bouty
9:11are going to be able to do that. But if you're throwing to Romeo Dubs, you've got to throw that back shoulder perfect
9:19or else he's not going to catch it. And that's what happened last week. He's, you know, you're going to find Deario
9:26Douglas in working across field to the flat on a scramble drill, but if he's too short for you to put that thing up
9:34there the way that you did, and he's not going to catch the ball.
9:38>> So, you can look at these and say, well, they should have made those plays and maybe some of those plays would have
9:44been different or one of those outcomes would have been different. And that's possible. And you so if you have three good receivers, generally one may
9:53actually break the coverage that the scheme is um demanding um you to win and you may not make the right decision, but
10:04the receiver still breaks the coverage and that helps you um in ways that maybe um conceptually you're not quite as good
10:12at. And Drake May doesn't have that kind of player playing right now. And if he only has one when AJ Brown comes back
10:21when he could have had three um you know that's that's a that's a disaster. And I think that that's the problem with the Patriots organization
10:31is that they are um I would say they had their window and they got cheap. Um and they they could have said, you know
10:40what, how do we go all in on offense?
10:43Because let's be real with ourselves.
10:44Drake had a great year, but everybody's giving him flowers. He quite doesn't deserve. Um, maybe we continue to prop his ass up because we can get AJ. We can
10:55get all these guys. And if I'm a smart GM, I would think let's get these guys.
11:00Let's pay them. Drake wins a Super Bowl, maybe, maybe gets us deep into the playoffs, and then the contract time comes, we say, "Nah, we trade him the
11:09year before." Um, let somebody else think they got a finished product. Um, and we'll draft and we'll have Cap clean by that point anyway because all these
11:19guys that we paid, they're going to be old enough to be gone. Maybe we keep Bouty, maybe we don't, but you know, a
11:26year or two of Stefon Diggs, he'll be gone. AJ's going to be gone, you know, and we went all in and maybe we won one
11:33with him. But yeah, you know, instead of going we've got the hubris to think that May is Tom Brady part two and suddenly
11:42realizing that yeah pro we were probably a little too we were miss remiss with that. So you've got Yeah. Go ahead.
11:49>> Yeah. And you had Grank and Yeah. I mean with Tom Brady Grank and Welker and Edelman and Randy Moss, right? You had
11:57>> high-end talent. Yeah. You know, now we you have nobody because you put your chips in the AJ Brown basket, right? But
12:05it's >> I remember on draft night they they took Trayvon Henderson over Luther Burton.
12:11>> Yeah.
12:11>> Right. Yeah.
12:12>> It's like if you had Luther Burton right now, >> it would look a lot different.
12:16>> Yeah.
12:17>> You'd have someone who can extend your run game, can operate on three levels, and you can grow with, but now you don't
12:23have that guy, right? You thought you had him in Trayvon, you know, we thought we had him in Trayvon Henderson. He's
12:28been okay. hasn't been great. We had Baker last year, right? He's out of the league.
12:34>> Yep.
12:35>> Right. You know, Pulk out of the league.
12:38>> Yeah.
12:38>> You can't develop these guys. Kyle Williams is your fourth string receiver.
12:43>> Yeah.
12:44>> Like Effan Chisum is okay. Like your best receiver pound-for-pound is probably Deari Douglas. Yeah.
12:50>> But you can only operate him in the slot. He's too small to play anywhere else.
12:54>> But they're good at picking slot receivers. And so that's like, yeah, that's like [laughter] it's it's crazy because if you if you
13:02kind of look back at it, >> who has been a receiver that they've actually developed from the ground up, not named Julian Edelman?
13:10>> Yeah.
13:11>> Like who like >> Deion Branch maybe? And he wasn't unbelievable.
13:17>> Remember they drafted Remember Nikil Harrow as a first round pick.
13:19>> Yep. Yep.
13:21>> And he didn't he didn't pan out.
13:22>> So was Chad Jackson.
13:24>> Yeah.
13:24>> You know, way back then. Yeah.
13:25>> Yeah. So, it's it's a definite conundrum because if you don't, you know, if you don't build the infrastructure with guys
13:32that can make plays, you you put a big burden on the quarterback of, you know, I got to do it all.
13:39>> Here's an example of that. I had this conversation with um with the saxophone for the band Los. I don't know if you
13:47know the band Los, but they they used to play in the 1980s and they were like a >> they're a regional band and they also
13:54had like a hit um >> back in the 1980s. But I was I was at a film festival with a friend of mine
14:01who's a composer and he introduced me to this guy at Los Lobos and we were both we were all talking and they were big
14:08football fans and I'm a big music fan.
14:10So, we joked around that we were going to get a chess clock and we were going to hit the clock and then basically um
14:17they would ask me football questions and I would ask them music questions and we were taking turns and at the time Brock
14:23Perie was like his second year in the league and and you know I was we were talking about and we ended up
14:30intersecting at this point which is like whether you're a quarterback with a really good supporting cast or whether you're a new guy who's like an upand
14:39cominging musician playing with a band with great musicians around you. It's the same thing. Like Trent Williams is like having like an unbelievable basist
14:49who, you know, directs everything that's going on or having Jason Kelsey as your center. You know what I mean? And then
14:56like the other players are all like like the drummers like a great wide receiver and the the you know and the piano
15:03players, you know, a great running back.
15:06And so if you're the, you know, if you're playing and you're like a quarterback in that situation, it's kind of like everything's happening the way
15:14it's supposed to happen. The running back's getting you into second and short or getting you into third and one. The playbook's wide open. The receivers's
15:24running his route exactly where he needed to and adjusting it to where it is. Um, you're getting the protection that you need so that you can make your
15:33drops and do everything that you're supposed to do. And when you do that, your game elevates because you don't have to think about anything else but
15:41your own stuff. But when you get put into a situation where like the band, the drummer is dragging, the bass player
15:49is rushing, the you know, time's all over the place, the piano player's getting lost and in the form of the music, and you're supposed to be playing
15:59a solo over all that. Um, and you don't even know what the time field feels like. Well, and you don't know whether
16:05the piano player is playing the harmony, right? Cuz he's missing the, you know, he's he doesn't know where he is. It's
16:12going to sound awful because now you're and then you're thinking about what everybody else is supposed to be doing rather than you just trying to go with
16:18the flow of what happens. That was Caleb Williams first season. That was Trevor Lawrence's first season. You know, that's what happens with quarterbacks
16:27who get wind up in disasters. But if you're Brock Perie, you came in with a with a Grammy band with Grammy
16:35award-winning musicians and and you basically could just focus on what you do well. And what he does well is process information. So when he was up
16:45and down, it was against the likes of Joe Burrow. It was in good games where he made a mistake or two and it ended
16:52the game for them. But it was like he was playing high-end football and missing on high-end things. Um whereas you look at Drake May, it was like
17:04it's not like that. It's like they took away the one or two good musicians that he had and now he's forced to lead it
17:12and he doesn't know where to start. And so it's it's that small of a margin when we're looking at that. It's why with
17:20Justin Herbert it's the same thing. It's like it's great that you want to change his footwork and work at that, but I
17:31think Mike McDaniels took a look at what you know, he was in the same boat as Liam Cohen last year. Liam Cohen's like,
17:38"We're going to throw the ball downfield. We're going to be the Tampa Bay Bucks. We're going to go vertical."
17:43Oh, wait a minute. Trevor can't do that.
17:45That was M. Jones doing that. Okay. So, as you to your point last year about that, they, you know, we had to switch
17:52that up. We traded for tough guys who run good routes and get open and if they don't, they can still make the play.
17:59They're not the fragile, finesse, fast, you know, receivers. They're the guys that go, "Okay, we can do the dirty work and make Trevor look good when
18:10maybe it's not perfect." or Trevor makes it perfect, but you got to make it a really good play like the >> like the Parker Washington touchdown
18:18this past week where it was perfectly thrown, but he had to like really get >> it was two in a row. The first one was
18:26uh it it was it was called back because of penalty. He scored and the next play >> Yeah. Yeah.
18:33>> scored again. It was it was absurd.
18:35>> Yeah. So, I mean, he they got Jacobe and they've got Parker now doing that thing.
18:41But, see, McDaniel, who was known as the guy that when they did the the the kind of the conferences and all the
18:48coordinators talking about stuff, he was the one that disagreed with everyone saying, "Oh, well, no scheme, you know, look, I'm not, you know, these guys got
18:57to conform a little bit more to my scheme and do that, and I don't have a problem saying that or whatever it is."
19:02He he was inferring like that. like more like, "Yeah, you're a cog. You're more cog than you are me trying to fit to
19:08your offer to you thing."
19:10>> Yeah. It's that arrogance that that's in the >> So now here he is and it's like you're looking at this and going, "Oh, well,
19:19Justin Herbert, we're going to shorten up his drop and now he's going to be able to process better because we made
19:24his drops more precise." um that's a band-aid for the for for a solution that is needs that has a bigger root problem.
19:34And so because it's going to take longer, you've got to actually the footwork will help you be more efficient, but if you can't see it right
19:41away, the footwork ain't doing anything because the footwork is a reflection of what your your eyes see and process. And so he's put the cart before the horse
19:50and we're seeing that right now. as far as like, you know, when we take a look at some of the other roller coaster stuff. I mean,
19:58Jackson Dart, there's going to come a point that we're going to look at this and go, can he stay healthy because they
20:06they enabled him as a runner? you know, because I think, you know, I know a lot of people think he's a very good
20:13quarterback or on his way to being a very good quarterback, but I would claim that these quarterback coaches were
20:21probably had um dart forced on them and they said, and when they were asked, "Can you develop them?" They're like, "Well, I know what that means. Can you
20:30develop them or are you going to be fired, you know, or should you just quit now?" because and they're not going to
20:35have time and they're going to and they know that the politically how this works just like it's in Washington, you know,
20:42is that you say you're going to do something then you blame everybody else for what you not you're not going to
20:46actually do. Um and you find a way to scapegoat it and claim that or or and then if there is success that had
20:53nothing to do with you, you claim it anyhow. Um you know, whatever side of the aisle you're on, that's basically the the truth with it. And it's the same
21:01way in corporate America sometimes and and with football. And they're not developing, you know, if you think that they're developing his pocket skills by
21:09the what they did in in the spring. Um, no, that's just show. I mean, that's they think they are maybe to a degree,
21:17but they they know they know that they're not really doing what they need to do to develop him. And so the running
21:24part of that they have to keep they have to have uh an aspect to let him run, but they also know the diminishing returns
21:33of that is that he can get hurt. So, of course, they traded for JJ McCarthy, not necessarily because they think he's
21:39going to be better than Jackson Dart, but it gives them a chance to to say, "Well, if we can't get a draft pick next
21:46year that we want, get the player we want, we at least have another opportunity with McCarthy if Dart falters again, you know,
21:56>> and you have a lot and it gives you a little bit longer of a runway to make sure that Dart's 100% healthy when he
22:03gets on the field."
22:04>> Yes. Right. So, you kind of have a double-edged sword. Both ends are are good for your organization. Hey, you can
22:12rehab this quarterback from like an emotional standpoint with JJ McCarthy and and hope he fits into your culture and starts playing better ball and you
22:21can rehab the physical Jackson dart of, hey, we're going to give you a longer runway here and leeway to getting back
22:28to 100% before we put you on the field.
22:30So, yeah, I agree. I think it's a it's a good move because Jamus is, you know, he's he's fine. He's he's Jamus, man.
22:38It's he's what he is what he is.
22:40>> Yeah.
22:40>> So, you're not going to win this year anyways.
22:43>> You want him as your emergency quarterback right now. That's pretty what he is.
22:46>> Exactly. And you got to kind of you got to >> you got to attempt to win games because your roster is not bad.
22:54So, it's just one of those interesting things, too, is like what do I do with Neighbors? Luke Neighbors does not look
22:59good. We've talked about this before.
23:01Like he looks not and I said he's not going to look anything like himself for the first at least the first half of the
23:07season. He looks like a complete shell of himself. I I if they lose a couple more games, he still doesn't progress
23:14and look like he's, you know, old Malik neighbors. I wouldn't be shocked if they're like, "We're just going to sit you for an extended period of time and
23:22bring you back last quarter of the year because our season sunk or if they're like, you know, we're just going to
23:27shelf you and, you know, >> Yeah.
23:28>> get you back with Jackson Dart next year to where you are 100% healthy." So, that'll be interesting to kind of kind
23:35of check into.
23:36>> No, without a doubt. And I think that when you look at, you know, you look at Trevor Lawrence as an example of what
23:42continuity does. um because this is his second year in Le Comb's system and he's now starting to throw a little bit
23:50better against the Blitz which was a thing that he was not known to be very good at. Um, and now it's year two with
23:57him. And I think that that's a um, you know, that's something that we have to understand is that you have to have
24:04continuity. You have to have surrounding talent. You have to have coaches that fit the talent to the scheme. And you have to force your quarterbacks to
24:14stretch a little bit and not just enable them so that you win games if you're going to want to have them for the long
24:21haul. which means if they're not quite ready yet to be stretched on the field like that, then you shouldn't be playing
24:27them. And I think that these are the things that we're missing and why we have the quarterback roller coasters that we do.
24:35>> Yeah.
24:35>> Um so let's talk about let's stay with the quarterback. We'll talk about the Saints offense. I I looked at Tyler
24:42Shook this week in the gut check that came out today and, you know, as I was watching that offense, I I thought,
24:49"Okay, let's look at explosive plays.
24:52Let's look at third down plays. Let's look at touchdowns, interceptions, and sacks." You know, just to get a few for the past three games. And and kind of
25:01one of the things that I saw was that Kellen Moore really understands how to distribute the ball and he understands
25:09how to to create 5050 decision scenarios for defenders that they can't they're not quite sure what to key on because one of the things that I noticed in the
25:21red zone is that you know Shook has eight touchdown passes and if I remember correctly six of them are to tight ends.
25:29Um y two of and and two of them are to his receivers Vle and to um to
25:38>> when you look at the tight ends um or just overall every single one of those eight touchdowns there was late motion
25:47pre- snap and the and um it was almost 5050 that the late motion receiver got it or it opened it up for somebody else
25:58which means that two things are happening. the design is good and Tyler Suge is actually reading the field well enough in that compressed situation with
26:07the si with the scenarios there to find the open man like so it's it's a combination that Suge's executing well the design is creating a clear opening
26:18um a lot of the time um so that's cool because they're getting tight ends matched up one-on-one against safeties and linebackers and so that off that
26:28looks cool and even when when no already has like two or three touchdowns in three weeks and he's able to run routes
26:35that he runs well, which are like the the underneath in breaking routes. Like he can he can give you the double up on
26:42the outside and move a safety and get inside. Those quick hitters, those little turn backs. That's what you want him doing. You don't want him being the
26:50go up and get it guy, even though he looks like the athlete to do that. So, they figure that out with him. Jawan
26:56Johnson, you can basically have him do anything because he's a wide receiver who's changed to tight end. So, it's he's the perfect um conversion project
27:07for a move tight end. Like, he he worked out. And then, you know, with Vele, you can put him one-on-one because he's
27:13going to win with his length and he did that. And Al, I mean, it doesn't matter.
27:17You can throw anything to him.
27:19>> Yeah. He's been awesome.
27:20>> Yeah. So, so you look at that and you think, okay, that's good. The the other thing he'd say is explosives. He's hit I
27:28think he I'm trying to remember how many explosives there were, but I'd say that it was almost even between throwing shallow intermediate throws that turned
27:38into yak plays versus deep throws. Now, Suge isn't Suge isn't hitting them pinpoint the deep throws. Um but he's
27:49putting them in enough of an area that guys can go up and get it. either they have to dive or win a contested play.
27:54Um, but he's he's making plays on script and he's also only had like a couple of plays offscript that that he made that
28:02were explosive. So, what that's telling you is he doesn't have to be Caleb Williams in his rookie year to get an
28:07explosive play. He can actually stay within the system, deal with pressure, make the throw, and stay, you know, and be efficient. And then when you look at
28:16the sacks is the same thing. Seven out of the 10 plays were coverage sacks.
28:21like good coverage where maybe the coverage said, "Okay, we know what they're gonna do." And they went deep and said, "We've got you covered and now
28:28you have no time because and we were able to run a twist or we added an extra blitzer and the and the line couldn't
28:35handle it." And by the time, you know, Shook finished his drop and made one read, he was under heavy pressure and,
28:42you know, so most of his sacks weren't even his fault. And, you know, my you I heard somebody say, "Oh, he could have
28:47thrown more of these away." I I would disagree. Like I would say he maybe had one play that you could argue that with
28:54a lot of times he either had to make you know and or like Detroit made a really nice play where they blitzed him to his
29:01right side and collapsed the pocket off the right edge so he couldn't go to his right and it forced him to the left and
29:09let Aiden Hutchinson clean up clean up on him from the left side. I mean, so it was like a very well-designed pressure
29:18um to manipulate the pocket and manipulate him into that. So, when you start looking at things like this, you know, what I'm seeing is all right,
29:27Tyler Suge's 14 games in, he's going to be 15 games in. We probably want to see 18 to 30 before we make a conclusion
29:33about what he is. So, but >> the the scheme is good. If if defenses start saying, "All right, we're going to
29:42play more zone in in the red zone and maybe blitz a little bit or do something to confuse him and he doesn't have the
29:50answer," that would be a concern for you to start to go maybe I need to stop starting him. Um maybe if he's um if
29:58they figure out a way to shut down the tight ends, which I don't think they're going to be able to do because they're
30:02using 13 and 12 personnel a lot. And with Kamar out there now for a little bit, you know, he's going to be he's
30:08going to be fine as long as he stays healthy in terms of what he can do to counter as a receiver and a runner. So,
30:16I think that there's and with what Vele does, there's enough talent to distribute the ball and they're putting him in the right spots and it's going to
30:25be hard for defenses to just shut all that down right away. And he's making good decisions. I mean, he had he has
30:31three interceptions. Um, two of them were bad routes run by um Fant.
30:37Basically, one he didn't settle, one was thrown behind him. Um, and it should have been where Fant probably should have broken inside. So, there was it was
30:46at best it was a it was a miscommunication that you would maybe fall to the quarterback, but he only had three. And
30:54if you took those two away and then you added two to Vle where the safety there were two the Raiders and the um Ravens
31:03both had a safety in position to jump the route that was an inbreaker by Vle and they were a little reticent to
31:11really get in there because if they did they would have had a a pick easy pick.
31:16Um so he still would would have wound up with three. So, it's he's if that's the only tendency that he's shown is that he
31:24doesn't gauge the height of the safety on an inb breakaker to one receiver in two games. Um I think overall this is a
31:32guy that maybe he won't stay a top five quarterback, but I think he's going to have a chance to stay a top 12
31:39quarterback um this year in this offense. And if he doesn't, those signs that that I would point out to you can
31:45go to football guys and you can see some more of the signs that I mentioned. you can look at that and go, "Okay, this is
31:51when maybe I need to this is why I probably need to have a good backup with him." Um, or a good number three in a
31:58two quarterback system and um know where the war the canaries in the coal mine might be for me to start um being
32:07worried. But right now, I keep playing them.
32:10>> Oh, he's he's playing he's playing good ball and he's executing Kell Moore's offense. And here goes this. something that Kell Moore does a really good job
32:16of. He plays to the strengths of his playmakers. Like that's the thing I I always looked at when he was in
32:23Philadelphia in particular, right? Where like you had seasons where God Smith and Brown weren't, you know, 800 plus yards, right? 700 plus yards.
32:34And he made Jaylen Herz an efficient passer. And I think Tyler Suge is a better passer of the football than Jaylen Herz is. Um, and one thing as
32:43well, um, with Kell Moore is he has Jordan Tyson at his disposal, too, when he comes back from injury. So, you're
32:50going to have another playmaker to make Tyler Suge's life easy. And I think once that run game gets going, I know ETN has
32:57the hamstrings, so he's banged up a bit.
32:59But, I mean, once you can get a more consistent run game, they're going to be pretty dangerous on offense. Um, and I I
33:06agree with you in the sense of what Tyler SH's been doing. And yeah, I I think he's, you know, on the upward
33:12trajectory of being a top 12ish quarterback for sure.
33:16>> Yeah. And I think age is kind of a thing that, you know, people talked about age as a draft nick. He's 26 as a rookie.
33:23And I know that's rough, but like I kind of the way I look at it is people always ask me about age and I don't pay
33:30attention to it. And they're like, well, why not? I said because the NFL hasn't even [ __ ] figured out how to develop
33:35a quarterback, much less draft one. So exactly bigger fish to fry.
33:43>> I'm in that same boat cuz you know I I keep I get asked a lot about Trinidad Chambers and I'm like he's by far the
33:52best quarterback in college football.
33:53Him and Kamario Taylor. That kid's really Mississippi State. He's a he's a baller but Shameless is the best quarterback in college football. And while he's old,
34:04I'm like that's what is that's good.
34:07Like that's probably good because the more you see the more you have prepared for like you just get better at being a
34:15quarterback. Like that's why guys like Zack Wilson like those guys don't Drew Lock like they don't work out as
34:25longterm starters. Like that's just the reality. Mitch Trabiscy, you can keep going on and on. like they'll have spurts in their career where like yeah
34:33that's the guy. Like I remember Will Levis had absolute great first game.
34:38You're like this is it. Tennessee's got one [laughter] >> and now he's fighting to be a backup. So it's like >> these guys that look the part where your
34:49GM closes his eyes and says, "What does my quarterback look like?"
34:54Those guys rarely pan out if you really think about it. like your big time white knights like Trevor Lawrence wasn't panning out
35:05for a bit. Liam Cohen kind of resuscitated Trevor Lawrence a bit >> and said, "Hey, you know, we can play winning football with this guy. We just
35:13need to give him great intermediate infrastructure.
35:18He can distribute it there." Awesome.
35:20That's what he did. But then we have the next class like Arch Manny. Like that's like kind of him. It's like
35:27>> robo quarterbacks. That's what I call him.
35:29>> Yeah. It's like we think these guys like your Justin Herberts, your Drake May, like these guys pan out, they're young,
35:36they're moldable, but I would rather have the Sugs, the Chamblases because they've seen more football, they're more experienced, more mature,
35:48right? They've failed more. And that's a good thing. Like that is a good thing in today's world
35:56where you can have a process by that point in your career where you're coming out, you know, to be a pro. You have a
36:05process like you're old enough to have that and have that level of maturity.
36:10And I think that's a that's an important factor in being, you know, the face of an NFL franchise. Now, there are some
36:16cases where organizations really do fail you and and don't set you up for success. I think Tennessee is a big one
36:23with Cam Ward right now and like it's just a total total dysfunction. Um, but if you get with the right offensive-minded head coach, with the
36:34right infrastructure, you can really flourish because, you know, they have they have continuity built in to where you're not hopping from coordinator to
36:42coordinator every single year, which is one of the difficult parts of having a defensive-minded head coach as a young quarterback, right? Like that's like,
36:50think about it like Drake May's got Rabel, right? Like it's that's that's harder. Um and obviously in Charger land it's you have you know Harbaugh who's an
37:01offensive mind if not his offense right so it's like you don't have continuity because Mana could be fired next year who knows so having continuity is super
37:12important for quarterbacks and you know obviously with CJ Strad and you have beick and now Kaye that makes it more difficult to transition year to year um
37:21but yeah that's kind of my my inkling about that type of stuff. Yeah. I mean, I'll finish I'll finish it like this.
37:28Um, I wrote this. This was a scouting report I wrote on Patrick Mahomes. Okay.
37:33It was like, "Every team wants intuitive quarterback play from a technically sound passer with prototypical physical dimensions and topshelf athletic ability, and everyone would like to win
37:44the lottery. Teams have to prioritize what's most important to them when searching for a quarterback. the the way most teams behave, they hope that if
37:52they pick a quote safe, technically sound athlete that checks the easy to define boxes, it can lead them down a path where his play becomes intuitive.
38:02But all too often, they wind up with a prospect that looks like he rolled off an assembly line, but without the
38:07programming necessary to develop into the player that meets the organization's expectations on the investment. So, if the decision is an utter failure, well,
38:17at least they can provide a list of qualities. the player possessed that justified the choice. If the decision's a limited success, well, they can
38:25proclaim hope for the player to eventually turn a corner and develop those elite skills, raise public expectations, and prolong their tenure
38:33in leadership. Um, so that buying a lot that time allows him a shot at landing enough talent around the quarterback so
38:40any plateau that takes place with his development doesn't doom the team's chances for contention. But every so often, at the risk of earning derision
38:49from fans and media and colleagues, an NFL organization will veer from the established template of robo quarterbacks rolling off the NCAA
38:58assembly line and invest in a player whose onfield intuition is notable, but it's accompanied by unconventional technique, atypical physical dimensions, or decision-making that's feared as
39:10irredeemably reckless because it's the world um because it's the road less traveled by organizations. ations. The list of failed players that don't fit
39:19the robo quarterback template are more prominent in the historical lexicon. But unfortunately, the root causes of these failures, which often have to do with
39:28factors that have nothing to do with intuitive play, physical dimensions, or technique, get conflated with these behaviors. Johnny Manzel didn't fail
39:37because he was shorter and lighter than the prototype. He didn't fail because he threw off platform and played the game with a creative intuitive streak. Manzel
39:46didn't work follow um he didn't work he didn't follow team rules or apply himself with enough maturity to maximize his talent. I mean Ryan Lee, Brandon
39:56Weeden, EJ Emanuel, and Josh Freeman were robo quarterbacks with physical dimensions and technical specifications that an assembly line would have been
40:04proud to build. and their failures weren't inaccurately conflated with their style of play because conventional decision-making even when incorrect earns a lesser punishment than creative
40:15decision-making that fails. So on that note, I'd argue Weeden and Emanuel's cases um that their failures to sustain starting jobs were due to a lack of
40:26productive creativity within a traditional passing strategy. Another way of saying it is they weren't aware intuitive players. So, if Mahomes becomes the first quarterback taken in
40:35this class, he's likely going to a team that not only has a GM or coach with a more flexible mentality than most of the
40:42league, but one that doesn't allow a cover your ass mentality to dictate important decisions. And if he has long-term success, it's only going to
40:50happen if the GM and coach both value Mahomes for how he plays right now. He Mahomes will not be a good choice for a
40:57team that has a coach or general manager that can covets the safety of a passer that thinks, moves, and functions as one
41:04of the thousands that could have rolled off an assembly line. It's not that Mahomes can't develop into a technically sound quarterback. It's that he needs an
41:12organization that's going to allow him to build on his strengths. And his strengths are not the part of that straight and narrow path of traditional
41:20quarterback development. He has the caliber of arm and accuracy allows him to make pinpoint throws without the constant need of fundamentally sound
41:27footwork. A former shorts stop and son of major league baseball player, he throws the football with the accuracy, velocity, and acrobatics of an
41:36infielder. And then I go on to talk about what Mahomes does. But really what we're, you know, what I'm basically saying is,
41:45>> you know, what he does well, you've got to play up and you can't get so into the box that you take away what makes a
41:53player special. And you got to let the player be special if you see them being special. Johnny Manzel honestly is closer to Patrick Mahomes as a thinker
42:05and seer of the field. It's that he didn't want he he didn't want it. He didn't want >> that's like it's kind of funny because
42:14like you kind of have those, you know, like the Pokemon, right? You have the evolutions where the top, you know, the
42:23the most advanced Pokemon is Patrick Mahomes in that sense, right? where everything has been tied together, right? Your Mahomes, your Allens. Like
42:31in that middle tier, you got your Baker Mayfields, right? They're athletic enough, tough enough, risky enough, and have tied it and reigned it in enough to
42:41where it works for stretches of time, but it's still good enough for their long-term starters because they figured that part out early in Baker's career.
42:52Didn't have that figured out, right?
42:53Yeah. But Manzel was on that trajectory if he wanted to be. Yes.
42:59>> Like if you watch the the Manzel documentary, you listen to Manzel speak, >> he'll tell you he didn't he didn't give
43:06a rat's butt.
43:07>> No.
43:07>> About learning how to play quarterback.
43:10No, he didn't care. He wanted the lifestyle. He wanted the Johnny football. That's it, man. He didn't care because he was on a trajecer
43:34and like a good starter. A good story of that is I remember it was his rookie year and it was early games and they
43:43were saying he wasn't playing from the pocket enough. He needed to stay in the pocket more. Now they said that about
43:50Jackson Dart, but they had to spend a whole lot of time coaching him. I think it was Hugh Jackson who was the coach at
43:57the time with Cleveland that was saying that >> and and from the week before to the ne in the middle of the week to the next
44:06game, it was the Steelers game in Pittsburgh and I watched that game and Johnny Manzel stayed in the pocket and played like he had played in the pocket
44:17for years. When you see a guy do that who is known as a wild man and then stay in there and look like a veteran and you
44:28see that you go that is a talented player.
44:30>> That's he was he was a he was a he was a hooper man. I mean he was just one of
44:35those dudes that like the game came so easy to him >> and like the hard things came really easy to him even if he didn't know it.
44:46That's the funny part. like he didn't care. He was just out there hooping, man. I mean, that's just he was just
44:52such an intuitive, natural, just had such great feel for opening enclosures, but like Brady Yeah. He was
45:03>> Yeah. He just didn't know it or didn't and didn't really care to understand it either, which is the funny part. And
45:08he'll tell you that like when you listen to him speak, you can you can discern that type of stuff. Um, but that's the
45:13fascinating part is like so many of these quarterbacks like want the knowledge, want to know, but like he just didn't care and just be able to do
45:20it.
45:22>> So, let's talk about rookies. Who do you think's going to break out soon?
45:26>> I think number one, I think, is Jeremy Bernard.
45:30>> Okay.
45:30>> Pittsburgh. I I I think, you know, watching him versus like Roman Wilson, right? I think he outnapped Wilson 15 to
45:36five after Wilson's drop led to a pick.
45:39It was right through his hand. safety picks it. Aaron Raj is freaking furious.
45:44Um I think Jeremy gives him a really interesting dimension in the run game too in two facets as a blocker. Like he
45:52made some he made two really key blocks like one on the Darnell Washington big- time rumble for like 40 50 yards, right?
46:00And then he made some really nice interior blocks when he was inserted on a backer, right? where it's like you're walling off letting Jaylen Warren get
46:08the second level. Like that's stuff that Roman Wilson can't do, right? And stuff that Michael Pitman Jr. can't really do either. DK Metaf at least to that
46:16caliber to where you understand how to move a backer just slightly enough to give Warren your his backside like stuff like that. And that's kind of who Jeremy
46:27Bard was in college. like he was just kind of that do it all dirt get down and dirty type playmaker and then he made a really nice play over
46:37the middle of the field running a running an over route showed great timing anticipation and and dove and caught a nice ball from Rogers.
46:47So I mean he's one of those I I looked at and I'm like I think he's going to have to take a step because no one else
46:55is like DK Metap doesn't look good.
46:57Michael Pitman Jr. doesn't look good. He looks hurt. Roman Wilson's making too many mistakes and is just not the caliber of player
47:07that you can feed eight plus targets to.
47:09But also too, from a postcatch standpoint, none of those guys, you know, Pitman Jr., Metaf, Wilson offer you anything. Like Bernard was one of
47:17the best postcatch players in this cycle, right? You saw that going back to his Washington tape, right, three years ago. And that's an interesting part of
47:28him is I I think he can really break out and be that guy. I think another one um the only big other one besides Kenyan
47:37Sadique, I think he's got a chance with the the the Mitchell and Taylor injury.
47:41I think he does have a chance and I like his utilization against the Lions. That was >> that was really encouraging because they
47:48did what he did really well and Frank Reich I think did a really nice job with him there. Um because if you slow play
47:53him and I I said, you know, what I wrote about him was he can be a Vernon Davis type player. I mean, he's got the size,
48:00the speed, the athletic traits to do that and really hurt you over the middle of the field. Um running drags and
48:07delays and some of the easier stuff um to get him in space. But um at Hurst, I I think their passing has been so
48:16anemic. Um, and now with Daniels at quarterback, I think Daniels might look to a fellow rookie, which he spent time with. Um, but now Gwin has an injury
48:26that just popped up. You know, IA hasn't been good at [clears throat] all since his last hamstring injury, and injuries for him have started to pile up ever
48:35since college. So, you're kind of wondering, you know, is he going to be the same player he was early in his
48:41rookie year where he was, oh my gosh, if you're if you're a Dynasty player listening to this, he was worth a lot of
48:47lot of money in Dynasty. Um, early in the season last year when he was on fire, but he's cooled off sign
48:54significantly since then. So, you know, with Nick Millan on IR for presumably eight plus weeks, like they need a pass catcher to step up. And I think it has
49:05to be Hurst. Um, the only issue there is I don't know if Zack Robinson's creative enough to to move him around and make that
49:13happen. And that's a big part of, >> you know, watching Tampa Bay play football right now is just the lack of
49:20creativity on the offensive side of the ball is pretty palpable, >> right? I mean, you have Kenneth Gainel who's a phenomenal route runner out of
49:26the back field. He's barely utilized.
49:29You know, you're you're not utilizing Johnson at all, which is shocking because he's your only level three threat in terms of field stretching
49:39capabilities and you're not utilizing him there. Ted Hurst is a great postcatch athlete. You're not utilizing him in the screen game or getting him on
49:46delays and crossers and you're not doing any of that stuff, right? Um it's just pretty monotone, you know, grayscale football, which is annoying, but um I
49:56think if you're going to make a change, I think Ted Hurst has to see the rock a bit more. But I think those are those
50:02are definitely the two I mean three with Sadique for me. Who who do you think?
50:07I'll say Malachi Fields because with Malik Neighbors not looking great, they're going to have to put the bulk of the offense elsewhere and if they're
50:16going to have to a passing game, they're going to have to utilize fields a little bit better. Um they were a couple plays
50:22away from doing that against the Rams two weeks ago. Last week they only gave him two targets. I think they're going
50:27to have to manufacture some offense through him and I think that they he has enough skill that they could probably do
50:33that. The guy I want the most is we all know who he is. We all know that he's not going to be like playing um unless
50:42somebody gets hurt and that's Kenneth Walker getting hurt and that's EMTT Johnson, you know.
50:47>> Yeah, he's looked awesome. [laughter] >> Yeah, he's looked awesome, man.
50:50>> So, it's like how do you you know, you're to me if I'm picking a rookie this year, it's like I'm just going to
50:56hang on to him because everyone's loving what what Kenneth Walker is doing and I'm loving what he's doing. I don't want
51:04him to get hurt. I don't I want him to have a fantastic season. He's a fantastic player. He's so much fun to
51:10watch. But if I'm just gonna play the odds, the odds are likely he's going to miss two to four games.
51:16>> So, >> yeah, based on previous years. Yeah, for sure.
51:19>> Yeah. So, I, you know, I'm holding on to him. The other guy I'm probably holding on to that we already saw a little bit
51:24of a flash early, but I think people got a little over their skis on him is Antonio Williams. I like Antonio
51:31Williams. I think he can become a good player. But the idea that he had a he had some good zone routes and he got
51:38open in that first week. But you knew that as long as Stefon Diggs and Terry McLuren are playing. I mean, seriously,
51:45we're like, you're you're going to literally say, "Let's go ahead and take that backup singer and let them sing with Luther Van and Whitney Houston."
51:56Okay.
51:57>> They're going to be the main the main attraction. I I I do agree with you on the Williams front. I I think he I loved
52:03him coming out of Clemson as you know he he can be a zone beater but he's also you know pretty crafty in terms of how
52:10he can beat man went above the rim he can do a lot of things >> but if one of those guys gets hurt and
52:15misses time then I think it's we can kind of really see him be the secondary guy there especially with Chica you know
52:21missing time at the hamstring >> um you're going to see a lot of him in 11 personnel um which is which is a good
52:28thing for him getting playing time as a rookie because presumably Diggs won't be there next year and McLaren might not either. So yeah,
52:37>> I just don't I don't want to play musical chairs right now. I mean, if I don't have to, I just rather go, you
52:42know what, I'll sit on EMTT Johnson. You guys can go ahead and take your chance with everybody else cuz if if in two
52:47games something happens to Kenneth Walker and it's like it's on you, EMTT, you're going to be the one to do it. I
52:53feel like a league winner. Yeah, >> he would be 100%. I think he I mean yeah I mean I'm interested to see if they
53:00make you know if those guys are the next you know Sonic and Knuckles type tandem.
53:05>> Yeah.
53:05>> As we get Johnson's feet more wet. I think that could be definitely it. I think they could be the new Sonic and
53:11Knuckles you know of of the league so to speak.
53:14>> Love it. All right. So Matthew Golden you know is you know he's what wide receiver eight right now? Wide receiver
53:23nine somewhere in that range. You know, we got Christian Watson, wide receiver, six. Um, what do you feel about Matthew Golden from what you've seen of him thus
53:32far?
53:33>> He's been the best receiver on the Packers in my opinion. I think some of the targets and, you know, the first
53:39read looks have gone Watson's way as they should is this is his what, fourth year in the system, fifth year almost.
53:45So, >> um, but Golden's, you know, been put at X, right? And that was the big news coming out of campus. choose point X and
53:55he's been phenomenal.
53:56Like he he's getting he's getting separation. He's winning the ball. He had that really nice play in the end zone um last game which is a really
54:05high-end high degree of difficulty play.
54:08>> Yeah.
54:08>> Um that you don't see many receivers making. So I I think he's got the full package. He was my number two receiver
54:16in that class. I had him higher than the 10 actually.
54:19>> Me too. So, I mean, he just has such a great skill set to be a threele three level winner. Can play inside or out,
54:27move him around, and you're gonna they're gonna have to because they're going to throw the ball 35 40 times a game. They have no run game. So, it's
54:33like like they're going to have to put this, you know, put it on Golden Watson, especially now Jaden Reed being off the
54:39neck surgery. So, I I think he's been awesome. Like if you can trade for Matthew Golden, like you gotta do it
54:46because he's he's getting ready to really blow up. And I don't know if Christian Watson's gonna ever play 17 games in a row. That's the other thing
54:56is like if Christian Watson misses time, like you're going to see Golden getting 11 to 14 targets a game.
55:03>> Yeah. And that I was writing about that this week on Monday's excuse me, Tuesday's article is that, you know, I could nitpick. There was one
55:11ball where he probably should have used his hands differently, but then he made two plays where like the one one of them
55:17you just described where he had to turn back to catch the ball and he used the the technique you want to see. And so
55:23when you see a guy where is more often than not he's using the correct technique for the ball, you know that
55:30occasionally you're going to have lapses and that's all that it was. But so I like that Watson is making the primary
55:36guy plays like he is making them when they're throwing them. Um he is able to go up and get it and and show that
55:44ability. Um I want to see a little bit more of that from from Golden, but all the other things that you asked Golden
55:52to do, he's doing very well. Crushing it.
55:54>> Yeah. So, I'm completely with you on him. And I think that he's a player that he's only on his way up as long as, you
56:02know, I I think if he had a better quarterback, he'd be unbelievable. Um, >> yeah, Jordan Love has not been great.
56:11Um, I think that's the thing, too, is, you know, there's some quarterbacks to where you need above average, above average to great line play to really
56:20see, you know, them be consistent. And Jordan looks one of those guys because he doesn't have the out of structure capability that, you know, in his own
56:31division, Caleb Williams, right? You take Jared Goff and give him that Packers line, you're going to see the same thing. Like, it's just the reality
56:39of it, right? Um, and but that's the difficult part with Love is he doesn't have an escape hatch.
56:45>> Yeah.
56:45>> Um, and that's a really difficult thing for a player like him. And that's I mean that's really neutering the Packers
56:53offense in a way because you have to throw the football like there you're not getting anything on first and 10. Like
57:01you're at second and nine and you run the ball again and it's third and eight and what are you going to do? like
57:08you're you're losing the down and distance battle every single time you you step out on the field. So, and it shows I think, you know, he's got to
57:16grow >> under pressure.
57:19>> Yeah.
57:19>> And that's it really both physical pressure from the defense, but also do in pressure situations. And it's just I don't know if it's going to happen at
57:29this stage in his career.
57:30>> Yeah. He never he was never able to do it at Utah State. He would he would tilt in those situations kind of like Jimmy
57:36Garopppolo would tilt. Um, you know, but the difference is is that if we're talking about the the Simpsons monkey with symbols that, you know, love's feet
57:47and arm are like high-end premium symbols. Like, you [laughter] know, >> the problem the problem is he doesn't know how to use them, you know, and
57:58that's if he knew how to use them, he would be what they thought, you know, but he's he he he didn't show the
58:05ability to do that. That's why it's like you look at a party, he didn't have high-end legs and a high-end body, but
58:12he could move. You could see that he knew how to do it, right?
58:15>> Um, and to me, that's more important than having it because you're not you're not teaching them. And this is another
58:20example of that. Long term, you have some good games, everybody gets on the wagon, and now you're like, what's wrong with Drake May? What's wrong with Justin
58:28Herbert? What's wrong with, you know, Baker Mayfield? What's wrong with this is this is what's wrong. Defense adjusts. they get a book on you and can
58:37you grow. All right, so last but not least, Devont Smith.
58:44Is he a legit wide receiver one and he's being limited by Jaylen Herz? Or is he a
58:52very very good wide receiver too who can't do the wide receiver one stuff you need and and Jaylen Herz knows that? Or
59:04is there something in between?
59:07>> I think he's a bonafide I think he's a top five six receiver in the league.
59:11>> Oh wow. Okay. I I think he's absolutely fantastic. I think we have like when we talk about just what he does well and
59:20it's pretty much everything like you you can kind of conflate his size and say all right he doesn't go for the middle
59:25well but he does he he wins he wins with a different type of strength and physicality that's his hand strength like he's in the strongest hands in the
59:33league and you can't really take that away from him even though he's 100 probably 75 pounds soaking wet. Um, you kind of saw that play in the Bears game
59:41when Jaylen Johnson was draped all over him and he just took the ball away. Like he does that with consistency he did
59:47that against Pat Certain his rookie year. Um, and he's been able to do that and I think he's one of the better route
59:54runners in the league. I think he's good after the cat. She's smart, understands where to be, when to be there. And I
60:02think he is limited a bit by what Jaylen Herz can do. um that intermediate level, which is I think where he's at his very
60:11best as running those routes because he looks he makes everything look the same.
60:15There are no tells, you know, during his releases or his stem work. There's no tells. So, it's tougher when you're running, you know, routes 15 to 18 yards
60:25down the field, but you don't have a quarterback that can drive the ball. Um Jaylen Herz is a good quarterback, but
60:32he's not a great thrower of the football. And so that's where he's neutered neutered in a sense in that realm. Um but everything else he's
60:40fantastic. I I think he's you know he's the I think the third or second highest graded receiver I've ever had in my
60:46database. Um and him and Jamar Chase is one and two. Um coming out I think I I had him a hair higher than Chase in a
60:54couple senses. Um, but I think he's a superstar type player, but it's just, you know, you you're neutered a bit by
61:03um the lack of pure arm talent of what Jaylen Herz doesn't have. And I I'm higher than most on Herz because he's a
61:12good quarterback, understands situational football, understands the timing element of what conceptually needs to be done, but he just can't get
61:23it there quick enough because he's not as talented as some of these other guys like a like a Joe Burrow is just like a
61:32a way better version of Jaylen Herds um in terms of a passer. can anticipate it, but he also has the ability to drive the
61:41ball to multiple quadrants is, you know, Jaylen Herds doesn't. He can't he just can't do that. But like, you know, I
61:47could imagine Smitty with, you know, like a Matt Stafford in in Los Angeles and that'd be incredible, right? Um, but he's on pace, I think, for like 1300
61:57plus yards, which is a great season. Um, but I'm really worried about the Philadelphia offensive line, which is going to be the, you know, for an
62:05athlete like Smith who's can be pretty third level dominant at times. That's what Herz does. Well, that's going to be an interesting, you know, you know,
62:15item for the Eagles to figure out because I don't know how much better that line's getting at this stage in the
62:21this stage in the year when you you know, you're you're you're missing thicker, you know, you're missing you're missing a lot of good pieces that are not Lane
62:31Johnson in my line.
62:33>> Yeah. Yeah. I mean, you know, it's fascinating because for a long time I felt like Devont Smith was that guy that
62:42you'd put wide receiver 11 through wide receiver 15. Like where you would say, "All right, he's fantastic in the middle of
62:52the field. He's fantastic after the catch. If you give him if you don't put your hands on him at the boundary, he's
62:59going to win it. and if you put your hands on him while he's going up for the ball, he can still win it. Um the only
63:05thing that I didn't like was I felt like he got um physical corners could just take him out of the play early in the
63:14route. Like that's >> Yeah, he can get pinned for sure.
63:16>> Yeah. So that was that's my only thing.
63:19But really when it comes down to it, the the Eagles know that too. They saw it year one and they just stop they just
63:27decided, you know what? Um, we're gonna do more plays where he doesn't have a chance of that happening. We're going to
63:34run more routes where we don't have to worry about that as much, though. And then, you know, there's occasions where a lot of a lot of defenses don't try to
63:44to pin that guy to the boundary because they don't have the quarterback caliber to do it. Um, and you can see that with
63:50the Bears last week because I just watched that play that you were you were mentioning just to take a look at it
63:55because I was like, that's what I want to see is like when you told me that. So I looked at him like, well, the
64:00quarterback was playing off. He didn't pin the guy. But I don't see a lot of guys getting pinned like that. And when
64:05you have a reputation like Devont Smith, which is, oh, if you miss, he's gone.
64:11That strikes fear in the hearts of of defenders because they don't play bump and run, you know, to that level as much
64:20anymore with the way offense is. So yeah, I'm totally I'm totally open to the idea that he's a wide receiver one
64:27by a good margin. Um especially because of the way he's being used. If if we were back in the mid 2000s,
64:35maybe it'd be a different story.
64:37>> You're just a boundary X and you're >> unless you're like Brandon Marshall, like that size of player, you're not you're not winning with any consistency.
64:46But yeah, I think >> you know in fantasy I think his wide receiver won in real life as well. Um it's just it just looks different
64:56but doesn't mean it doesn't look good, >> right?
64:58>> And so that's the that's what I typically see from Smith. But I mean obviously he's not you know archetypically similar to like Malik
65:05Neighbors or you know Jamar Chase or Luther Burden like you know those guys who you know have a running backish stature but the length of your
65:16prototypical receiver.
65:18um he doesn't have that, but he does have, you know, exceptional fluidity and the ability to make everything look the same, which is which is really, really
65:26important at that position.
65:28>> I'm just angry that Paul Richardson played about five to seven years to >> Oh, he was incredible at Seattle. Yeah.
65:34He's one of the best defense we've ever seen.
65:36>> Yeah. And >> it's just absolute fear.
65:38>> Yeah.
65:39>> From defensive backs.
65:40>> His his his ability to win contested catches were insane. One of the most acrobatic receivers that I've seen. I would put him in my top probably in my
65:49top 10 list of acrobatic receivers.
65:51>> Brandon Lloyd. Oh yeah, for sure.
65:53>> Exactly. You know, for sure. And so it I watch him and I think and also there was a time I was doing some stat studies
66:01where I think in terms of like I don't remember what the stat was, but like he was on the same trajectory as Antonio
66:10Brown um in terms of what that stat was.
66:13It was fascinating. Um, but he's just he was too small for the era and he was literally like by the time he was out of
66:22the game it switched like two three years later.
66:26>> Yeah.
66:26>> And you're just like God that guy was he was one of my absolute favorite players.
66:31>> He's fun to watch.
66:32>> Yeah. Yeah. So listen, this was always we have a lot of fun doing this and we appreciate the feedback that you guys
66:40give. Um, you know, follow Brandon at Angelo_fantasy.
66:45You can find me at Mattwatt Waldman.
66:47And, you know, we hope you guys have uh a good couple of weeks. If you're if you're 0 and4, hopefully you get it, you
66:53know, or 0 and three, you get it, you know, you kind of get off to a um you kind of rebound a little bit. And if
66:59you're starting off well, then good for you. Let's keep it going. And we'll have fun watching some of these quarterbacks who are who are getting put into the
67:07fray.
67:08>> Yeah. [laughter] All right, have a good one, fellas.

More episodes from Matt Waldman

6