From the episode

Like he looked like a superstar in year one. And he's been like, honestly, mostly a negative player for the last year and a half. So it's like, what are you getting?

STACKED’s take

NeutralProjection

Thomas' unclear trajectory—superstar year one, negative year two—makes his true caliber hard to assess.

Brian Thomas Jr. is a difficult player to evaluate because his profile is unclear: he looked like a superstar in year one (1,282 yards, 75 yards per game, third in NFL receiving yards) but has been mostly a negative player for the last year and a half; the source notes uncertainty about his caliber within his archetype—whether he is elite, inconsistent, or bad now—though his ball skills, yards-per-target efficiency, and deep-shot ability remain valuable assets.

Brian Thomas Jr. headshotBrian Thomas Jr.WR · JAXPlayer page — value, ADP, projections, and every insight