From the episode
he's fallen to be the 18th overall player on Keep Trade Cut... He had one of the best rookie wide receiver seasons we've ever seen... he led the entire NFL in target share... higher than Justin Jefferson's rookie year, higher than Jamar Chase's rookie year.
STACKED’s take
Nabers at 18th overall is a steal; rookie season better than Jefferson/Chase despite bad QBs.
The source calls Nabers' fall to 18th overall on Keep Trade Cut and in startup ADP 'ridiculous' for a 22-year-old with one of the best rookie wide receiver seasons ever. In 2024, he led the NFL in target share, was second in targets per route run, and had the seventh-highest points per game (higher than Justin Jefferson's and Jamar Chase's rookie years), all while playing with Tommy DeVito, Tyrod Taylor, and Drew Locke. He had 2.3 yards per route run with a terrible quarterback carousel. The source argues he is in the same talent class as CeeDee Lamb and Amon-Ra St. Brown, and that his value loss is due to injury noise and Giants QB uncertainty—not a change in talent. The source suggests he could have been a top-three startup pick had he stayed healthy and would easily trade Jefferson, Lamb, or St. Brown straight up for him to get four years younger.
Malik NabersWR · NYGPlayer page — value, ADP, projections, and every insight