The Athletic Football Show on Michael Penix Jr.

PodcastQuarterbacks at a crossroads in 2026August 25, 2026

From the episode

I think Michael Penix has enough obvious flaws that it's hard for me to see him ever really like developing into a top 12 guy. I think you have the injury history. It's pretty immobile and inflexible. Doesn't really have touch on the ball.

Mentioned at 59:58 – 60:20

STACKED’s take

NeutralProjection

Penix has a mature process but lacks the traits to be a top-12 fantasy QB

The source expresses skepticism that Michael Penix will develop into a top-12 NFL quarterback due to injury history, immobility, and lack of touch, but acknowledges he plays with a mature process, avoids negative plays, and has shown statistically strong production compared to peers like Bryce Young.