Source + player page
FantasyPros - Fantasy Football Podcast fantasy football takes on Baker Mayfield
Every source-backed podcast insight STACKED has extracted from FantasyPros - Fantasy Football Podcast about Baker Mayfield.
27
Insights
18
Positive
6
Negative
Insight ledger
All FantasyPros - Fantasy Football Podcast insights about Baker Mayfield
PositiveValueSep 1, 2026
The source suggests Baker Mayfield is an undervalued asset who could potentially be the Steelers' quarterback next year, noting that Tampa Bay's refusal to commit to a long-term deal and his desire for revenge against Cleveland make him a compelling narrative and potential future starter.NegativeValueSep 1, 2026
Baker Mayfield is considered a viable quarterback option in the middle rounds, though some prefer the rushing upside of other targets.NegativeProjectionAug 27, 2026
Jake Ciely notes that Mayfield's performance last season was hampered by playing through injury and a decimated offensive line where only the center played the full season; with better health for both Mayfield and the line, there is hope for a rebound.NegativeProjectionAug 18, 2026
Baker Mayfield's outlook is downgraded due to concerns about his performance when his receiving corps is depleted, as seen in previous seasons.PositiveValueAug 13, 2026
Baker Mayfield is highlighted as being ranked too low by the market, making him a value target at the end of drafts.NegativeInjuryAug 13, 2026
The source suggests that Baker Mayfield should avoid playing in preseason games to prevent injury, especially given his high-intensity playing style and lack of a long-term contract.PositiveRoleJul 28, 2026
Pat Fitzmaurice is excited about Baker Mayfield's prospects with the new offensive coordinator Zach Robinson, noting that Mayfield had injuries he was playing through in the prior season. The new coordinator is expected to enable volume distribution to wide receivers, which is a positive development for the offense overall.NegativeProjectionJul 28, 2026
Baker Mayfield's 2025 season took a bad turn coinciding with Emeka Ibuka's hamstring injury in week six. Mayfield was also playing through injuries during the season, contributing to the Buccaneers' offensive struggles. The expectation is that with a healthier offensive line and new offensive coordinator Zach Robinson, the passing game should improve in 2026.NegativeValueJul 23, 2026
Baker Mayfield is going undrafted in standard 12-team, one-quarterback leagues and will be available on waivers. The source suggests he could be a late-round flyer as insurance if concerned about Jalen Hurts, providing a reliable every-week starter option.PositiveProjectionJul 17, 2026
Baker Mayfield was selected in the mock draft from the 11th spot as the QB pick.PositiveValueJul 17, 2026
Baker Mayfield is a late-round quarterback option with top 12 history on his resume.PositiveValueJul 14, 2026
Mayfield is listed as a late-round quarterback option (QB19) with history of top-12 production; going outside the top 90 in ADP provides excellent value.PositiveProjectionJul 2, 2026
Andrew Erickson cites Baker Mayfield's 40+ touchdown season in 2024 under offensive coordinator Liam Cohen as evidence of Cohen's offensive system's productivity. This context supports Erickson's projection that Trevor Lawrence, entering his second season with Cohen, could replicate or exceed similar production.PositiveProjectionJun 25, 2026
Tony Ayo identifies Baker Mayfield as a dark horse MVP candidate at plus-5,500 odds—the darkest of dark horses. He argues Mayfield is statistically capable (threw for 4,541 yards two years ago, which is an MVP-caliber line), is playing for a contract at a critical fork-in-the-road moment, and could easily win his division and make the playoffs if the Buccaneers put together a good season. Mayfield has talent around him (Godwin, McMillan, and depth in the receiving corps), though it's harder without Mike Evans. Mayfield is also a visible, established media figure (All-State commercial guy, household name), which is crucial for an MVP award that is fundamentally a media award.PositiveProjectionJun 5, 2026
Baker Mayfield played all 17 games last season, which may affect his eligibility for comeback player of the year discussions.PositiveValueJun 5, 2026
Baker Mayfield's odds for comeback player of the year are not favorable, as he is not even in the top 10 for the award.NegativeRoleJun 5, 2026
Baker Mayfield's performance last year was disappointing, and there are concerns about his ability to lead the Buccaneers effectively this season.PositiveProjectionJun 5, 2026
If Baker Mayfield can stay healthy, he has the potential to lead the Buccaneers to win the division, as the offense is good enough to succeed.PositiveValueJun 3, 2026
Baker Mayfield is a solid pick in the fifth round, with little fantasy drop-off compared to Brock Purdy, and he has exciting weapons like Emeka Ibuka.PositiveProjectionNo date
Baker Mayfield, when he's an underdog, counted out, or playing for a contract, produces at a high level. The Buccaneers are rolling the dice with him but guaranteeing production from the QB position. The source notes he plays 'like his hair's on fire' and is fun to watch, though his reckless playing style raises durability concerns. He hasn't signed a long-term deal yet because the organization wants to see him stay healthy before committing multi-year money. His underdog mentality and contract motivation should drive strong 2025 production.PositiveProjectionNo date
Expected to play without a deal in 2026, which is a positive indicator for his fantasy performance. Source states: 'you always want to bet on Mayfield when he has a fire under his bat... This is when he always plays his best ball.' Source is moving him up in fantasy rankings specifically because playing without a contract will motivate him to prove doubters wrong, which is his pattern. This doesn't necessarily translate to team wins for the Buccaneers, but Mayfield individually should perform at a higher level.PositiveValueNo date
Baker Mayfield is identified as a clear bounce-back option at quarterback, going outside the top 12 quarterbacks in ADP; the source views him as a value target in deeper quarterback selections.PositiveProjectionNo date
Expected to play without a deal in 2026; source is moving him up in fantasy rankings because Mayfield historically plays his best ball when he's an underdog or being counted out. This motivation will drive strong individual performance even if the Buccaneers have holes. Source wants to bet on Mayfield in fantasy and betting contexts when he has fire under his bat.NegativeBustNo date
Baker Mayfield is identified as a dynasty landmine to sell or avoid in 2026, suggesting his value is headed in the wrong direction.PositiveProjectionNo date
Baker Mayfield had an MVP-level first half last season and was a 4,500 yard, 41 touchdown passer just a year removed, making him a valuable asset the Buccaneers should not let walk at age 31.PositiveProjectionNo date
Baker Mayfield is in contract negotiations with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and is reportedly nowhere close to agreeing to a new deal, though the hosts believe this is posturing and both sides will eventually reach terms.NegativeInjuryNo date
Baker Mayfield has a history of playing through injuries that has impacted his performance. He played poorly down the stretch last year with Tampa Bay because he was injured, and in Cleveland he battled shoulder injuries that contributed to his departure from the team.