Source + player page

Bleeding Green Nation fantasy football takes on Tanner McKee

Every source-backed article insight STACKED has extracted from Bleeding Green Nation about Tanner McKee.

80
Insights
25
Positive
16
Negative
Insight ledger

All Bleeding Green Nation insights about Tanner McKee

PositiveSleeperOct 25, 2026
ESPN's Moody identifies McKee as a fantasy sleeper (4.6% rostered) with Jalen Hurts out for the season due to blood clots. McKee threw for 215 yards and 1 TD against the Panthers last week and faces a Cowboys defense allowing 21.6 fantasy points per game to QBs (fifth most in the league) and 11 passing TDs this season. He attempted 45 passes last week with targets to DeVonta Smith and Dallas Goedert (both questionable). Worth considering in deeper single-QB leagues and as a QB2 in superflex formats.
NegativeRoleOct 22, 2026
McKee faces the same pass protection crisis as Hurts; the source emphasizes the need to help McKee identify problems and deliver with confidence through better formation usage. The Eagles' under-center play-action against five-plus rushers is 0/15 with no successful plays, and the source argues the coaching staff must adapt formations rather than continue asking McKee to execute broken concepts. Empty formations offer McKee five receiving options and clearer pre-snap coverage reads, particularly when pressure arrives within 2.5 seconds.
NegativeProjectionOct 19, 2026
Backup quarterback evaluated within a dysfunctional offensive system that makes fair assessment difficult. The source states: 'I didn't think Tanner McKee played well, but I am tired of trying to evaluate quarterbacks, running backs, and offensive linemen within an operation this dysfunctional. It isn't fair on the players.' McKee showed capability on individual plays (e.g., a beautiful throw to Darius Cooper on under-center play action), but the offensive scheme's protection breakdowns and poor sequencing prevented him from settling into the game; three incompletions and two sacks on five under-center play-action snaps.
PositiveRoleOct 18, 2026
Gets his third career NFL start and first non-Week 18 start against the Panthers. McKee will start at least four games, a significant opportunity as a free agent after the season to prove he deserves to be a starter, top backup, or just a guy. He took all first-team reps Thursday and Friday with command of the game plan; Offensive Coordinator Sean Mannion spent considerable time discussing specifics tailored to McKee's skill set. The source notes McKee doesn't have Hurts' raw talent but might do some things better within the offensive framework.
NegativeRoleOct 16, 2026
Tanner McKee will start in place of Hurts this Sunday. The source notes he has not looked good at all and has regressed since his rookie season. McKee inherits an offense that has converted 10 of 38 third downs in the second half, has gone 18-straight possessions over the last six quarters in the second half without scoring a touchdown, and is last in scoring in the NFL, averaging 6.4 points in the second half. The Eagles are last in the NFL in the second half in yards per play (3.6), passing yards per play (60.6), and tied for 31st in red-zone efficiency (33.3%).
NegativeRoleOct 16, 2026
McKee is starting Week 6 against the Panthers after Jalen Hurts was ruled out with a blood clot in his calf. The source notes McKee struggled in the offseason and failed to initially beat out Andy Dalton in the team's eyes, but teammates including Zack Baun and Dallas Goedert have expressed confidence in his readiness. Baun said McKee 'has got some sort of Tom Brady career arc to him, because he's totally capable, he's tall, he knows where to go with the ball, he gets it out on time and he's got a lot of confidence in these receivers.' McKee has prepared as a backup since being drafted in the sixth round in 2023 and has two career starts (both in Week 18). He posted an EPA/dropback of -0.29 in the preseason under new coordinator Sean Mannion, down from 0.18 in the previous system, but says his timing, anticipation, and understanding of the offense have improved significantly since training camp.
NegativeRoleOct 15, 2026
Set to start against the Carolina Panthers despite a turbulent offseason. McKee logged a 68.9 passer rating in Week 18 against Washington, playing significantly worse after DeVonta Smith left the game. The source notes McKee showed promise in limited past action but struggled during offseason QB2 reps rotation with Andy Dalton, with neither player establishing clear separation. McKee was initially designated as emergency third QB before being moved back to QB2 after Dalton's Week 3 interception. The source expresses low expectations: "It's not easy to imagine McKee will thrive this Sunday" given the Eagles' offensive struggles, potential absence of DeVonta Smith and Saquon Barkley, and an uncertain offensive line.
PositiveDepth ChartOct 9, 2026
Tanner McKee won the backup QB competition with Andy Dalton after splitting reps during training camp. McKee was initially passed over for the QB2 role in favor of Dalton for three weeks, but after Dalton threw an interception on his only pass attempt against the Bears, the Eagles turned back to McKee for their Week 4 game against the Rams. McKee is now established as the primary backup to Jalen Hurts, with the Eagles moving forward with him and rookie Cole Payton behind Hurts.
NegativeProjectionSep 1, 2026
Backup QB's preseason performance deteriorated significantly. He completed 12 of 22 passes for 55 yards and an interception in the final game, finishing the preseason looking far less comfortable than expected. The source identifies his core limitation: he cannot create consistently outside structure, so when the original concept breaks down, he must make a quick decision. Film shows him drifting around behind the line of scrimmage attempting to manufacture plays that aren't there, rather than climbing the pocket and taking available yards. The source emphasizes McKee's strengths are anticipation, accuracy, and operating within structure; his weaknesses are improvisational play and movement skills. This explains why teams view him as a valuable backup but not starter material. The Eagles' rotating backup QB approach (Dalton, McKee, Payton) prevented anyone from developing rhythm, with McKee suffering most.
NegativeProjectionAug 29, 2026
Quarterback Tanner McKee did not help his case in the backup competition. He completed 12 of 22 passes for 55 yards and an interception against Cincinnati, exposing himself after looking better than Dalton in the first two preseason games. With 1:11 left in the first half, McKee had Britain Covey open down the sideline for what should have been a touchdown and missed him. The backup job seems not so certain now after his solid showing against New England (16 of 22 for 173 yards and two touchdowns).
NegativeProjectionAug 29, 2026
QB2 candidate with poor preseason performance against Cincinnati; completed 12 of 22 passes for 55 yards, 0 TDs, and 1 INT with a 2.5 yards-per-attempt average. Most yards came on checkdowns to Carson Steele; made several errant throws including a missed wide-open Britain Covey for a touchdown. The source notes this represents a stark contrast to his performance exactly 386 days prior (20-for-25, 252 yards, 2 TDs) and states 'it's hard to envision McKee garnering anything near that on the trade market' now. Coach Sirianni indicated McKee needs extra reps to get comfortable in the new system, but the Eagles appear displeased with the QB2 competition results.
NegativeProjectionAug 29, 2026
McKee was inaccurate and held the ball too long in the preseason finale. While he wasn't helped by Makai Lemon's drop that turned into an interception, he hardly did enough to help himself. His worst miss came when he overthrew an open Britain Covey for what should have been a touchdown. The source expresses concern about his decline, noting he's looked much worse this offseason compared to previous performances and specifically against the Bengals last summer. Preseason numbers: 34/54 (62.9%), 263 yards (4.9 y/a), 2 TD, 1 INT, 79.5 passer rating. The source worries the Eagles' approach of splitting QB2 reps between McKee and Andy Dalton may have undermined McKee's confidence.
NegativeProjectionAug 27, 2026
Has been doing 'a good deal of dink and dunk this summer' and continued that pattern on Wednesday with many short completions; capped off a drive with a touchdown throw to Tank Bigsby, though the source notes 'Seemed like McKee should've found him streaking open sooner but the result was ultimately good'; was slightly off target on some throws to Brandon Hayes before finishing camp with a touchdown pass to Erik Ezukanma to beat Shaun Wade in coverage.
PositiveRoleAug 23, 2026
McKee outplayed Andy Dalton in preseason competition and has emerged as the clear frontrunner for the Eagles' backup quarterback role. He completed 16-of-22 passes for 173 yards with two touchdown passes and no interceptions (125.8 passer rating) against New England despite working primarily with the third-string offensive line and skill position players, while Dalton finished 3-for-10 for 44 yards. The source argues McKee gives the Eagles a better chance to win if Jalen Hurts goes down, and that he "needs to be the Eagles' No. 2 QB" based on his sharp, decisive performance and improvements shown throughout the preseason.
NegativeRoleAug 19, 2026
McKee started stronger than he finished; he threw a good comeback ball to Danny Gray along the right sideline before hitting a wide open Eli Stowers 15+ yards down the field (the source notes the rookie tight end's best plays have come on coverage busts), and hit Will Shipley on a short curl where the running back turned upfield for lots of YAC; McKee had a back shoulder completion over the middle to Samari Toure that may have been intentional or off-target, but he ended practice with an interception to Kindle Vildor in a scrimmage scenario.
NegativeProjectionAug 18, 2026
McKee averaged only 3.5 yards per attempt in the preseason game and struggled with decision-making under pressure. On a specific rep, the Ravens sent pressure and the Eagles initially handled the rush well, but the Ravens sent one more defender than the protection could account for. Stowers made himself available as a quick outlet, but McKee held the ball and took the sack instead of releasing it. The source notes this is especially damaging for a quarterback who lacks high-end pocket creativity, as McKee is not likely to consistently escape free rushers or turn broken plays into positive gains, making his internal clock and decisiveness critical to his success.