0:00Before we jump in, if you're listening on the Player Profiler feed right now, we're inviting you into a very special giveaway.
0:06If you want to be entered to win a certified signed Kenneth Walker jersey, all you have to do is follow us
0:12on your preferred podcast platform, Spotify or Apple, and drop us a comment with your username on our YouTube.
0:18We'll select one lucky winner on the show after the Week 6 games conclude.
0:22No purchase necessary. Welcome into the Lineup Fantasy Football Show.
0:24I'm Mitch Anderson. I'm Justin Mello. And we have officially passed the one-third mark of the Fantasy Football regular season.
0:30It is time to evaluate your team, where you're at in record and points for, and so we're going to break down
0:36the top 24 running backs for the rest of the season.
0:39We've got a very special giveaway happening right now.
0:42If you want to be entered to win a certified signed Kenneth Walker Chiefs jersey, all you have to do is follow
0:48us on your preferred podcast platform, Spotify or Apple, and then just drop us a comment with your username to enter.
0:54One lucky winner will be selected on the show after the Week 6 games conclude on Monday.
0:59No purchase necessary. And as always, the lineup is presented by Dabble Fantasy.
1:02Download and sign up for Dabble, then use the promo code LINEUP to get $20 in bonus cash as soon as you play your first 10.
1:10But Mello, kick it off with our number one running back rest of the season.
1:14It's Jameer Gibbs. Yeah. We already all knew this.
1:17You didn't have to click this video or turn on this episode to know it's Jameer Gibbs.
1:21This is the first time in really over a decade that the Consensus 1.1 has lived up to the expectations with flying colors.
1:28If you remove Week 4, where he was the RB17, still solid, he has finished as a top 3 running back every
1:34week so far this season, including two RB1 overall finishes.
1:37Absolute fantasy cheat code. Can I say something to you?
1:40A little bit sacrilegious that's going to stay within this call, within the family of everyone watching the lineup right now.
1:46I received a text earlier that someone who has Parker Washington received a trade offer of Kyron Williams and Parker Washington for Jameer Gibbs.
1:52And they said, I'm assuming you're not taking this.
1:55And I told them that they should. Because I think Jameer Gibbs is so far and away the best asset in fantasy
2:01football right now, I would be doing anything to go acquire him if that's even reachable.
2:05Even your Parker Washington, that is stunning to me, Mitch.
2:08I agree that I would too. I'm telling everyone how serious I am about Jameer Gibbs.
2:13But on to number two, you should be plenty serious about this guy too.
2:17Bijan Robinson, absolutely zero debate at the number two.
2:19Besides the blowout in Carolina where he's still scored 11 points, he's been a top 15 back every single week, including three
2:25top six finishes and two games with over 140 rushing yards.
2:29Hopefully, Panics can stay healthy because this is certainly a different Falcons offense with him at the helm.
2:34And it's helping to get the best out of Bijan.
2:36Yeah, definitely my number two. If there were a guy that you could maybe debate there, it's Ken Walker, who we'll go ahead and put at three.
2:44His worst weekly finish this year is the RB7.
2:47He was on by week five, so only four weeks.
2:49But still, the worst finish he's had is RB7.
2:52This Chiefs offense really has been running through him entirely.
2:55Doesn't appear that that's going to be changing anytime soon.
2:58He's averaging 26.5 opportunities per game, which sounds like a video game stat.
3:01A no-brainer. It's crazy volume. Didn't even get close to that in Seattle with Zach Charbonnet totally screwing him over down by
3:07the goal line and on passing downs. Now, Ken Walker in Kansas City, though, RB1 every single week.
3:1226.5 opportunities is like what my five-star running back at Missouri State gets in college football, the video game.
3:18Like, when you're just like feeding a guy. Literally.
3:20That's absolutely unbelievable. This is so solidly our S tier.
3:23And to me, like, I love these next guys, but it's a huge drop-off.
3:27They're the big three right now. Let's talk about the guy at the top of the A tier, though.
3:32Jonathan Taylor. We had our concerns, Melo, going into the year about efficiency.
3:36And honestly, we were completely wrong. As we've seen Taylor drop to 3.9 a carry this year.
3:41What we did not factor in is the fact that the Colts will do anything to get the ball in this guy's hands.
3:47Fourth among all running backs in carries. Six touchdowns on the ground.
3:51He has been the true engine of the Colts offense.
3:54As long as he's out there, he is going to continue to get so much work.
3:58And he's locked in as my running back four for the rest of the season.
4:02Yeah, and speaking of guys that get fed, let's put Derek Henry here at five.
4:06King Henry is never going to hit the cliff.
4:09I'm convinced he took some sort of youth serum or something at some point in his life.
4:14He's just never going to actually show signs of aging.
4:17The Ravens are absolutely feeding him the rock. He is feasting.
4:20Lamar Jackson seems like he'll be back sooner rather than later.
4:23We're still not 100% sure. But as we saw last year, the whole offense really depends on Lamar Jackson.
4:28So getting him back will be great for Derek Henry from a fantasy football perspective as well.
4:33Although he was great last week without him even.
4:35I don't care that he doesn't catch passes. I trust him wholeheartedly every single week.
4:40Derek Henry is the roadrunner getting chased by Wile E.
4:42Coyote. No matter what you think, he's not going over that cliff.
4:46He's staying on top of his game. We just talked about Jonathan Taylor being fourth in the entire NFL in carries.
4:52Derek Henry is number one. This guy is truly the heart and the engine of this Ravens offense.
4:57Let's jump to number six, though. Another guy that there's been a lot of cliff conversations with.
5:02Christian McCaffrey. I keep saying it, but the days of Christian McCaffrey being a full-on fantasy cheat code might just be over.
5:08And that doesn't mean he's not still incredible. Five touchdowns in his last four games.
5:1225 targets on the year. We've seen a little bit of a tick down in carries.
5:17But for the long term, that's probably a good thing for him.
5:20He may not be the cheat code volume machine anymore.
5:23But that doesn't mean that he and this undefeated 49ers offense have not been so efficient that they can make it work anyways.
5:29And I'm still incredibly high on Christian McCaffrey for the rest of the year.
5:33Same here. This is the first time Kyle Shanahan said he's going to lower the volume for McCaffrey, and he actually meant
5:39it, which I don't think we all called his bluff, and it wasn't a bluff.
5:44Come the NFL playoffs, I think he's just going to touch the ball 40 times.
5:48Completely different scenario, yeah. Yeah, but that won't help you in fantasy.
5:51Still a great piece, though. Still somebody I'm absolutely starting.
5:54And the same can be said about James Cook, who's our RB7 rest of season.
5:58I know he fumbled a couple times on Monday night, but he's still an incredible running back on an incredible offense, who
6:04should still be a solid RB1 for the rest of the season.
6:08We're not seeing quite the level of receiving work that we were hoping we were going to see going into this season.
6:14Ty Johnson really is being, Ty Johnson's really operating in that third down role, the pass-catching role.
6:19But still great overall usage for James Cook, who scores touchdowns.
6:22He's efficient. Still an RB1. Yeah, James Cook has been phenomenal.
6:25The one thing I'll point out, just from an NFL point of view, this has nothing to do with what they're going
6:31to do with him on the field and what's going to happen in fantasy football.
6:35But 11 fumbles for James Cook since the start of 2025.
6:38No other running back has more than six in the same time span.
6:42Just crazy. Definitely a ball security issue with him, but he's so good that he's not going to lose any real meaningful work.
6:49On to number eight, though. Another guy in our A tier.
6:52Kyron Williams is just so good, man. This offense is so good.
6:55He has such an important role in it. RB5 on the season and hasn't landed under 15 points yet in a game this year.
7:02Four top eight finishes. His worst finish when he scored those 15 points.
7:05He was the RB15 in week one. There's no reason to believe he's going to slow down anytime soon.
7:11He has a fantastic schedule down the stretch. I'm buying hard into Kyron Williams right now.
7:15Unless you're trading for Jameer Gibbs. Yeah. If you're sending him and Parker Washington for Jameer Gibbs, you can do it.
7:21Otherwise, though, stop disrespecting Kyron. He's been great. At number nine, we have Ashton Gentry.
7:25He's been tough to trust, especially with this newer ankle injury and the work share with Mike Washington and even Dylan Lauby to a certain extent.
7:33He got involved a little bit the last week or two.
7:36And the Raiders offensive line has been less than superb, better than last year, but that's a really low bar.
7:41I'm still not too concerned, though. We're talking about an elite talent whose volume should spike up as he gets healthier with that ankle foot injury.
7:49So I think he's still going to be a solid RB1 rest of season.
7:53You just got to trust the process. Yeah, absolutely.
7:55He's going to be the last guy in our A tier.
7:58Honestly, if we're being serious here, he's kind of fringe at the end of that A tier.
8:03Let's drop to B. Let's talk about Javante Williams.
8:06He is a guy that is just going to go as the Cowboys go.
8:10If it's a great offensive day, he's going to be a big part of it.
8:14If it's a slow day, he's going to suffer.
8:16We saw that against Tampa Bay in a game that he salvaged with that early touchdown.
8:21Other than that, it was a bit of a disaster.
8:24The efficiency has been up and down, but I want guys in this high-powered Dallas offense.
8:28I think Javante continues to get the lion's share for the Cowboys, so it's hard to get off of him here.
8:34Pause. No, I agree. I like Javante Williams a lot.
8:37I heard it the minute I said it. You knew you weren't escaping that one, brother.
8:41Let's talk about some Jeremiah Love, though, who's our RB11 rest of season.
8:45I know it hasn't been great, but don't let the back-to-back disappointing weeks fool you.
8:49This guy is going to be a league winner.
8:52Even Tyler Algier only had three carries last week.
8:54You would have guessed, based on Jeremiah Love's two fantasy points, that Algier was heavily involved.
8:59He really wasn't. It was just a weird game against Detroit.
9:02And we see rookie running backs every single year go nuclear down the stretch.
9:06That is fully in the cards for the Cardinals running back, Jeremiah Love.
9:10I know it's tough right now, but I'm sticking with him.
9:13I think he has incredible upside down the stretch.
9:15In the cards is a great pun, by the way.
9:18I had it in my notes, but not as a pun.
9:21And then as I read it, I was like, damn, that was unintentionally extremely clever.
9:25Let's move on here to our last RV1, DeAndre Swift.
9:28Kind of got his groove back last week, despite the loss.
9:31And now we get Caleb Williams potentially back in the mix moving forward.
9:35Manungai dealing with the turf toe. It kind of wheels up right now.
9:38Swift should be in for plenty of volume. He had that quiet stretch in the middle of the start of the season.
9:45But we've seen the ceiling this guy can have in this Ben Johnson offense.
9:49And I'm very excited for him moving forward. Yeah, he's been absolutely great.
9:52And somebody who really hasn't been is Chase Brown, who's our next running back.
9:56I think it's far from panic time, though, for Chase Brown.
9:59I agree. There's a lot of things I don't like, which I think a lot of people would say the same.
10:05He's not been efficient. And he hasn't been a true workhorse like we thought.
10:09Samajay Pirine has been cutting into his work share.
10:12So, like, those are two things I don't like.
10:14But on the flip side, it's just Samajay Pirine.
10:17It's not like he's competing with, like, a legitimate good running back who we know could really take the job away from him.
10:23And Chase Brown still is the RB1 on this explosive offense.
10:26The points will eventually come. I just think he'll continue to come up short of the ceiling that so many people hoped for earlier in the season.
10:34I say this as someone who literally brought up Samajay Pirine over the offseason.
10:38As someone who had been almost as, if not more efficient than Chase Brown in 2025.
10:42And that being a little bit of a red flag.
10:45I think the panic's gone too far on Chase Brown.
10:48And I think that everyone needs to just chill out a little bit.
10:52Chase Brown's going to be just fine. I want pieces of this Bengals offense.
10:56He feels like a pretty decent buy low still to me.
10:59But let's move on to Brees Hall. Your buy low this week, Mello.
11:02He was fantastic before the injury. Getting the true dual threat workload.
11:0638 carries and 7 targets in his first two complete games.
11:09Whether it's this week or next, he should be back soon.
11:12And I expect Brees Hall to operate as a low-end RB1, high-end RB2 moving forward.
11:16Yeah, once he's back, he'll be just fine. Let's talk about Chuba Hubbard of the Carolina Panthers.
11:21I'm putting some respect on his name and he's in the B tier.
11:25I think he deserves it. I really think he deserves to be in the B tier with what he's done this year.
11:31He has been what so many of us had hoped Jonathan Brooks would be.
11:35And speaking of which, Brooks' return off IR is not going to come anytime soon.
11:39Sure, it could maybe be an issue in the fantasy playoffs for Hubbard.
11:43But at this point, I'm really not worried about that at all.
11:46He's been incredible. He's a top 10 graded running back per pro football focus.
11:50He's looked to the part. He should continue to do so.
11:53So you're right. I think he belongs in his B tier.
11:56Let's move on to a guy that is going to kick off our C tier.
12:00I always talk about Colson Loveland and Kyle Pitts coming in and out like a revolving door through the fantasy football jail.
12:06This guy's in there for right now. And it's Saquon Barkley kicking off our C tier.
12:11What do we do with Saquon, man? Two weeks ago, I was so excited for him.
12:16Now expected to return soon. But there's always the caution around what to expect coming immediately off of a hamstring injury.
12:21You zoom out from Saquon himself and you look at this whole environment.
12:25We have this team lose Lane Johnson to retirement.
12:28Cam Juergens to a trade. The offensive line's in shambles.
12:30Jalen Hurts doesn't look like he knows how to play football anymore.
12:34And Saquon is still so talented. If you watch him play and you isolate on Saquon himself, you can tell he still has the juice.
12:41But the offensive environment is just terrifying me right now.
12:44I just I don't know what to do. I'd love your take.
12:47One last thing. Craziest part about Saquon season is that he is still yet to find the end zone.
12:52Yeah, I'm nervous. And it's it's funny. It's not for the reasons I think people might have thought Saquon would bust that he might hit the cliff.
13:00He has not. He has looked explosive electric. He's looked awesome.
13:03He can't finish a game, which obviously hurts you more than if you were just ruled out because you're starting him and
13:09he's leaving the game in the first quarter. But some of those other environmental factors like you talked about, like with the
13:15offensive line, retiring, being hurt, getting traded and Jalen Hurts not playing well.
13:19That stuff's actually starting to really concern me. So I think he does probably belong in the C tier as opposed to the A or the B.
13:27My favorite thing with Saquon is when you just start him in your lineup and then like three plays in.
13:32He pulls the Jonathan Taylor touchdown celebration, but he's actually grabbing his hamstring or his ankle and coming out of the game.
13:39It's like this guy's driving me crazy. I still have hope, but the vibes are bad for Saquon Barkley right now.
13:44Vibes are pretty horrific. Let's get a positive vibes guy here.
13:48Let's get Basil Tootin. Let's go. Here in the C tier.
13:51Positive vibes. He really has not truly exploded yet this year, which is why we have him this slow, but it feels inevitable.
13:57Like he's going to have a blow up spot at some point soon.
14:01He's been producing solid RB2 numbers. The volume keeps going up.
14:04He had a season high 22 carries in week five.
14:07And also he has pro football focuses single highest run grade among all running backs.
14:11He has looked the part. He has been very good.
14:14It's a nice balance of floor and ceiling. And part of me thinks he should be higher rest of season than we
14:20have him despite having him this slow. It's really just like I said, he hasn't shown the explosion through five weeks yet.
14:26Yeah, man. He's been such a safe, good floor running back, but it just, it wouldn't shock me if down the stretch
14:32all of a sudden we're like, wow, what an explosive year out of Basil Tootin and he finished as the RB12.
14:38Like, I just, I fully think that's in the cards, but onto another guy that we just talked about a lack of explosive plays.
14:45How about Bucky Irving? Absolutely exploding against the Dallas Cowboys on Thursday night football.
14:49And I won't lie. It kind of feels like a perfect sell high spot to me.
14:53And that's not a knock on Bucky. I think he's going to be great for the rest of the season.
14:59I think he's like a very strong RB2. I just have kind of hit the point that every time any player plays
15:05against the Dallas Cowboys defense, I'm probably just going to try to deal them after that.
15:10Cause that's going to be the best they do.
15:12Dallas's defense has like made it their job to maximize fancy football points for the opposing offenses.
15:17But some pro Bucky stats, 17, 15, 16, and 21 carries in his last four.
15:21He has an absolute stranglehold on the RB1 job in Tampa.
15:24If things do improve, we could see Bucky skyrocket from the spot.
15:28But even if they stay how they've been, I think he's a rock solid RB2.
15:32I agree. I think he's fine to hold, but also I do like the idea of maybe trying to move him as
15:38well, just because he is coming up off this blowup spot and we don't really know what the rest of the season will look like.
15:45And I feel kind of similarly about Jalen Warren here at RB19.
15:48I still do like him rest of season. He's been incredible without a doubt.
15:52But with the return of Rico Dowdle, that could affect his usage to some extent.
15:57Will it be enough to bring Warren down from his current elite production?
16:00Yeah, I think there's probably a pretty good chance of that.
16:03But will it be enough to ruin Warren or make him unstartable?
16:07No, I don't think that at all. I mean, he's just been so good.
16:11Even if the volume goes down, he'll still be the 1A in this offense.
16:15He's completely earned that right with how good he's been.
16:17Super involved in the passing game. But he's been so good, especially the last few weeks, that if you want it to
16:24try to sell high, I don't hate that idea either.
16:26Yeah, I think that's actually the perfect way to put it.
16:30Let's jump to Quinshon Judkins, who became a little bit of topic of conversation in the comment section.
16:35Our guy Snook named him as a bye Monday morning, and we've since gotten the news that he's been seen in a
16:41walking boot in his day-to-day with the ankle injury.
16:43To me, the boot is likely a precaution, but obviously something to monitor.
16:47We talked about this in that episode, but one of the biggest green flags last season and going into, you know, the redraft process was the touchdown upside.
16:55And even though the Browns have looked so much better, he still hasn't managed to hit the end zone more than the one time in week four.
17:02And so the appeal to me right now without that touchdown upside is that Judkins has been getting so much receiving work.
17:0911 targets in the last two games. And if he can keep that up, I love the value of those touches through
17:15the air for running backs, especially in the case of Judkins, who I don't know if you saw this stat on the broadcast.
17:21He has gone for one yard or less in 31% of his carries in 2026.
17:26Yeah, it hasn't looked pretty, but at least he's catching it.
17:29That's been the saving grace. Hopefully he can start scoring touchdowns.
17:32Let's talk about someone who's touching the ball a lot.
17:35That's Aaron Jones. And we're going to put him in the D tier, but he's been great to this point.
17:4032 year old running back, almost 32. He turns 32 next month.
17:44Volume King in the big 2026. Fifth in the NFL in carries, which should be Frank is just mind blowing.
17:49Never would have guessed that going into the year.
17:52And some of what I said earlier about Jalen Warren with Rico Dattel.
17:55I do think the return of Jordan Mason after the week six by will do damage to Aaron Jones's usage and fantasy value.
18:02But Jones has been good enough to still be the one A in this offense.
18:06I still think he is going to get the bulk of the work.
18:10So he still can definitely be considered a flex option or even an RB two, depending on the matchup any given week.
18:16Yeah, absolutely. Onto our next guy. This guy, I swear to God, every single year.
18:20He's just the undertaker meme. Ramondre Stevenson. He looks terrible.
18:23You think he's done. Then boom, he's on fire and the backfield's all his.
18:27We have no Travion for a couple of weeks here dealing with a high ankle sprain.
18:31The New England Patriots offense is fully back. And I feel like you can actually slot in Ramondre Stevenson as like a
18:38higher end RB two for the time being. I would make the argument him and Aaron Jones are somewhat flippable here.
18:44It'll be interesting to see what the splits look like once Travion's back.
18:47But for the meantime, over these next few weeks, you should be able to get a lot of great production out of Ramondre Stevenson.
18:54Yeah, I like him now more than down the stretch, but still somebody who's probably going to be startable for pretty much the rest of the season.
19:02RB 23, though, is Cam Scadaboo. You really have to hurt for Cam Scadaboo, who fumbled away the victory in week five.
19:08But you have to hurt more for his fantasy managers, who have to watch him finish no better than the RB 17 in any given week this year.
19:16He really has been disappointing. It's become kind of like a quasi committee on a less than superb offense here in New York.
19:22So I do have concerns about Scadaboo going forward and the usage, the efficiency, just this offense as a whole.
19:28But he's still more involved than basically any of the running backs that we have not talked about thus far.
19:33So you kind of have to put him this high just by default.
19:37Yeah, I I completely agree. I actually think this is a good week for him.
19:41Little hint hint about something we're about to talk about in a few minutes.
19:45But at number 24, the only guy in our F tier, Amari and Hampton did not even make the list over this
19:51guy who's still on the IR, Travis A. Chan Jr.
19:54Let's wrap it up with him here. I just kind of wish he didn't even make the list either.
19:59But I think he probably does profile as the last of the RB 2s.
20:03Week one, we saw what the receiving upside could be and what you had hoped to see from him going into the year.
20:10Nine targets leading to seven catches for 32 yards.
20:12But then the next two weeks, he was healthy, only four targets and a combined 25 touches.
20:17There just seems to be this lack of trust in A.
20:20Chan to shoulder the load in New Orleans. And so I have my concerns about when he gets back, but he will
20:26have a role in this high powered Kellen Moore offense.
20:29And when he's in there, I think he's a solid stash and he's a guy you'll be able to slot in as
20:35an RB 2 or preferably a flex. Yeah, I agree with that.
20:39Those were our top 24 running backs. Before we get out of here, let's hit our week six Mount Rushmore.
20:44We are going to name our four favorite plays at the running back position, a.k.a.
20:49the guys we think are going to rush for more yards than their projected lines on dabble.
20:54Give me your first guy, Melo. Give me that guy we just talked about, Ramondre Stevenson.
20:58I'll take his over. Travion Henderson banged up with the ankle injury, not going to be active against the Jets like you mentioned.
21:04Stevenson has had 23 plus fantasy points in each of his last two matchups against the Jets.
21:09A lot of that damage has come through the air.
21:12But in this spot without Travion, potentially a positive game script.
21:15I think he's going to do a lot of that damage on the ground.
21:19He looked phenomenal last week against the Raiders. Could continue to do so and be a big part of this offense.
21:25I always love when this happens. When you take a guy I was planning to grab and I just feel so much better about it.
21:32Ramondre lock him in at number two. Kenneth Walker over 86 and a half yards.
21:36Kenneth Walker with the fresh legs coming off of a bye, taking on the Chargers who have allowed 119 rushing yards per game, 12th most in the NFL.
21:44Sign me up. Not to mention this should be a positive game script for the Chiefs being favored by eight and a half points over LA.
21:51Ken's beat this line three out of four times and I expect him to make it a fourth here.
21:57We're hammering Ken Walker here in week six. Yeah.
21:59Pick any running back against the Chargers. Never mind Ken Walker.
22:02I like that pick a lot. Next, I'll go with Ashton Gentey over 58 and a half rushing yards.
22:08Last week was rough, but let's not overreact. He gets another week to heal up with that ankle injury.
22:13Probably will be feeling a little bit better come Sunday.
22:16And now he gets to play a Bills defense that has been allowing a ton of yards and a ton of fantasy
22:22points to opposing running backs over the last two years, really.
22:25They have not been able to figure out this run defense.
22:28So I love Gentey in a bounce back. I love that.
22:31You had me at Bills defense. Let's wrap it up with the guy we just teased.
22:36Cam Scadaboo over 57 and a half yards. We keep talking about how this guy is getting flooded with volume and he's just having issues with efficiency.
22:44If there's a get right spot, it's here against the Saints who are allowing 150 rushing yards a game.
22:49Third most in the NFL. Scadaboo has hit this line four out of the five games he's played going for 58 or more yards.
22:56I expect him to beat his line this week and have a little bit of a bounce back here after that fumble against Washington.
23:02But those were our top 24 running backs rest of season, along with our four favorite plays at the running back position presented by Dabble.
23:09Before we get out of here, Melo, did we miss anything?
23:12Got nothing. All right. We'll catch you guys next episode.
23:15We'll catch you guys next episode.