NFL: The Insiders on Jameis Winston

PodcastThe Insiders Podcast: 49ers owner Jed York suspended 8 games, fined $500k + Aar...October 3, 2026

From the episode

Jameis is still the guy, at least for this week and probably for the next few weeks while J.J. McCarthy gets up to speed.

Mentioned at 42:52 – 43:31

STACKED’s take

NeutralRole

Winston remains the Giants' starter while McCarthy develops.

Jameis Winston is the starting quarterback for the Giants for the immediate future while J.J. McCarthy gets up to speed. The team is looking to evaluate his performance under normal conditions after a weather-impacted game last week.

Jameis WinstonQB · NYGPlayer page — value, ADP, projections, and every insight

Jameis WinstonNeutralRole

Winston relegated to backup role; used as QB-sneak specialist with 4 rushes, 1 TD in Week 7.

Yahoo Sports NFL

Jameis WinstonNegativeRole

Winston benched mid-game; McCarthy takes over as Giants starter.

NBC Sports Rotoworld

Jameis WinstonNeutralRole

Winston is the Giants' backup QB on a $13M extension with health contingency.

Yahoo Sports NFL

Jameis WinstonNegativeRole

Winston benched; McCarthy takes over as Giants starting QB.

Yahoo Sports NFL

Jameis WinstonPositiveRole

Winston's 2-1-1 record and veteran leadership justify his two-year extension beyond backup duties.

Yahoo Sports NFL

Jameis WinstonPositiveRole

Winston's 2-1-1 record and veteran mentorship justify two-year extension, aids young QBs.

Big Blue View

From the episode

STACKED’s take

More on Jameis Winston and from NFL: The Insiders