Source + player page
Underdog Fantasy Football - Josh & Hayden fantasy football takes on J.J. McCarthy
Every source-backed video insight STACKED has extracted from Underdog Fantasy Football - Josh & Hayden about J.J. McCarthy.
6
Insights
2
Positive
4
Negative
Insight ledger
All Underdog Fantasy Football - Josh & Hayden insights about J.J. McCarthy
NegativeProjectionOct 27, 2026
JJ McCarthy is QB21 this week. After his bye, he faces the Eagles, Commanders, and Jaguars—not a great stretch of defenses. While the Commanders are a solid spot start, the other weeks coming up are not ideal for fantasy purposes. Adnai Mitchell is not interested in McCarthy as a fantasy asset right now.PositiveProjectionOct 26, 2026
Completed 20 of 28 passes for 252 yards in Week 7 win over Texans; described as possibly his best game to date. McCarthy showed precise sideline throws with defenders diving, threw with full velocity on some attempts, and displayed aggressive play-calling. Offensive line provided solid protection despite Texans' strong defensive line, allowing McCarthy to execute the game plan effectively. Has already proven his fifth-round draft pick value, with a chance he could play so well it becomes a real discussion point for the offseason.NegativeProjectionOct 23, 2026
Giants rookie QB in first start against Texans in Week 7. Bold prediction: will not throw for 200 yards in this game despite Hayden throwing 243 yards in a quarter. Giants team total at 16 points, dead last in league. McCarthy has been with team for two weeks; Giants were not planning for him to start against elite Texans offense in Week 7. Bold prediction: JJ McCarthy will not throw for 200 yards in Week 7 start against Texans; context includes first start after two weeks with team, Giants offense ranked dead last at 16th in team rating, and Texans' strong pass defense against bad quarterbacks.PositiveProjectionOct 20, 2026
J.J. McCarthy is a recommended Superflex pickup due to his rushing upside and inherent value as a starter. He is ranked ahead of Tanner McKee, though he faces a difficult upcoming schedule against the Texans, Eagles, Commanders, and Jaguars that presents turnover risks.NegativeDepth ChartAug 12, 2026
The source notes that Kevin O'Connell expressed frustration with J.J. McCarthy's development throughout the previous season, leading to speculation that he may be traded, with the source comparing his potential situation to the Carson Wentz contract deal.NegativeProjectionNo date
J.J. McCarthy is cited as a primary culprit for the underperformance of the Vikings' passing offense last season, which hindered Justin Jefferson's fantasy production. He is currently dealing with an ankle injury, and the source suggests he could potentially be traded, which would be a positive development for the team's offensive stability.