The Athletic Football Show artwork

A surprising Steelers offense leads the Week 7 Hangover

STACKED extracted the fantasy-relevant player signal from this podcast and kept the full transcript here for context.

1 hr 2 min
Duration
Estimated from transcript
Oct 27, 2026
Published
Tue, October 27, 2026
33
Player insights
27
Players mentioned
Topics
Puka NacuaBrock BowersJonah ColemanMatthew StaffordTrey McBrideAaron RodgersAlvin KamaraBo NixBrian Thomas Jr.Chris OlaveCody WhiteCourtland SuttonDarnell WashingtonDavante Adams
Player analysis

Player insights

33

Aaron Rodgers

PositiveProjection0:13

The source highlights that Rodgers is playing in a way not expected, particularly in willingness to throw over the middle of the field; he has the seventh most throws 11-20 yards between the hashes this year, addressing the biggest complaint from last year.

Insight page

Alvin Kamara

NegativeUsage0:33

The source criticizes the Saints' run game, noting they carried the ball 17 times for 18 yards, which is impossible to operate with in the NFL in 2026; this represents a complete failure of the running game.

Insight page

Bo Nix

PositiveUsage46:55

Bo Nix showed improved aggression in the Broncos' 30-16 win over the Cardinals, particularly when the offense went into empty formations. He completed three of four passes of 10+ air yards out of empty, including a seam ball to Cortland Sutton against cover two on the first play, a 47-yard gain to Marvin Mims on a hole shot against cover two, and a back-shoulder throw to Jalen Waddle. The source notes this represents a positive step, though they want to see more aggression from play action and true gun formations.

Insight page

Brian Thomas Jr.

NegativeRole30:00

The source mentions Brian Thomas Jr. as a type of player the Rams should consider acquiring to add verticality to their offense. The source is unsure if the Jaguars would trade Thomas Jr. at this point but suggests that acquiring a player of his caliber—a downfield threat who can create space—would be worthwhile for the Rams to open up their offense and create more dig windows and crosser windows for underneath receivers.

Insight page

Brock Bowers

NegativeMatchup35:00

The source notes that the Rams' game plan for Bowers involved playing a bunch of man coverage, including rat and robber coverage, with whoever the rat or robber was looking for Bowers on the over. The source explains that the Rams put a corner or corner-esque body on Bowers on pretty much every single snap, showing they were not afraid of any other Raiders pass catchers taking advantage of other matchups. This defensive approach was designed to neutralize Bowers' impact in the passing game.

Insight page
NegativeMatchup37:18

The Rams' defensive game plan successfully neutralized Bowers by deploying man coverage and rat/robber coverage schemes designed to prevent his 12-15 yard in-breaker and deep over routes. Defensive backs played hard outside leverage in one-on-one situations, and the Rams' safeties provided inside help on corner routes, forcing Kirk Cousins to hold the ball or throw incomplete. The source notes this defensive approach was 'impressive' and highlights that with no other reliable pass catchers to beat them, teams can reliably take Bowers away.

Insight page

Chris Olave

PositiveRole0:50

The source identifies Olave as a star pass catcher for the Saints, part of the optimistic case for the offense coming into the season.

Insight page

Cody White

NegativeUsage39:23

White was targeted on third-down crossing routes in the Raiders' offense, representing a limited role in the passing game during the Rams matchup.

Insight page

Courtland Sutton

PositiveUsage47:09

Sutton was targeted on a seam ball against cover two on the first play of the Broncos' offensive drive in empty formation, representing one of the aggressive intermediate throws the source highlighted as encouraging.

Insight page

Darnell Washington

NegativeRole0:44

The source praises Washington as the only 300-pounder who consistently catches the football, highlighting his red zone value; he scored on a fade route and provides a unique answer in the red zone for the Steelers.

Insight page

Davante Adams

NegativeInjury25:00

The source notes that Devante Adams is going to miss significant time, which impacts the Rams' offensive ceiling. The source questions whether the Rams can get back to being a great offense if Adams is going to miss as much time as expected. The source also mentions that the Rams' offense can get back to being good without Adams, but the ceiling is capped by his absence and the current state of the pass-catching options.

Insight page

DK Metcalf

PositiveUsage0:36

The source praises Metcalf's play-making ability, highlighting a 51-yard completion where he extends the play and finds space, and another scramble drill where he tracks the ball over his shoulder like an outfielder, demonstrating exceptional receiving skills.

Insight page

Fernando Mendoza

NegativeProjection44:14

Fernando Mendoza is objectively a much more talented quarterback than Kirk Cousins at this stage. However, the source does not believe inserting him into the Raiders' current situation would fix anything this season, as he would be 'throwing him out to the wolves' with limited workable wide receivers and a non-existent run game. The source worries this could set negative habits and is not convinced the season is doomed enough to warrant the change. Clint Kubiak has been adamant that Kirk Cousins is the starting quarterback with no real conversation about a change.

Insight page

Jacoby Brissett

NegativeMatchup56:53

Jacoby Brissett faced a difficult matchup in Week 7 against Denver's pass rush with the Cardinals missing two backup offensive linemen, resulting in a rough day. The source explicitly states 'that's exactly what happened,' confirming the predictable negative outcome when a backup-heavy offensive line faces a strong defensive front.

Insight page

Jalen Brooks

NegativeMatchup53:36

Brooks was targeted on a go ball on third and 10 against a pressure look in double coverage, which fell incomplete. The source describes this as a poor decision by the Cardinals' offense, chucking up a contested throw rather than executing a proper pressure plan.

Insight page

Jaylen Waddle

PositiveUsage47:27

Waddle was targeted on a back-shoulder throw from Bo Nix in empty formation early in the fourth quarter, described as 'a really good ball.' This was one of three completions of 10+ air yards out of empty, representing improved aggression from Nix.

Insight page

Jaylen Warren

PositiveUsage0:40

The source emphasizes Warren's explosive play-making in multiple contexts: making one-handed catches in traffic, converting critical third-and-short situations by bouncing runs inside the two-minute warning, and being dynamic between the tackles and on stretch runs; he does so many things for the offense.

Insight page

Jonah Coleman

PositiveRole55:55

Jonah Coleman is the Broncos' best running back and will be important to the team as they figure out the best version of their offense. In the Cardinals game, Coleman was an above-average runner, which the Broncos have not had consistently this season. The source notes he can 'make them right a little bit, grind out six when four is there,' and believes his ability to stay ahead of the sticks will be huge for an offense that needs to maintain positive yardage.

Insight page
PositiveRole56:05

Jonah Coleman was an above-average runner in Week 7 against the Cardinals, a notable improvement for a Broncos rushing offense that has been below average for much of the season. The source notes he can 'grind out six when four is there,' suggesting he provides the kind of consistent ground-game execution the Broncos need to keep their offense ahead of the sticks and in rhythm.

Insight page

Kirk Cousins

NegativeProjection44:53

Kirk Cousins has been an average to above-average quarterback for large stretches of the season. The source believes he can have games where he throws for 280 yards and two to three touchdowns, making the passing offense look pretty good. However, the source also notes that in the Rams game specifically, the Raiders ran up against a really good pass defense. The source values Cousins' down-to-down consistency compared to the potential upside of Fernando Mendoza, and does not believe the season is 'quite that doomed yet' to warrant a quarterback change.

Insight page

Marvin Harrison Jr.

PositiveUsage56:53

With the Cardinals' receiving corps limited by backup offensive linemen forcing quick decisions, the source observed that the Cardinals were 'throwing up to Brooks' on multiple occasions, including go balls down both sidelines and into double coverage. This suggests Harrison Jr. was not the primary target in a game where the Cardinals' passing attack was constrained by protection issues, relying instead on contested throws to other receivers.

Insight page

Marvin Mims

PositiveUsage47:23

Mims made a guy miss and ran a 47-yard gain on a hole shot from Bo Nix against cover two late in the third quarter. This was one of three completions of 10+ air yards that came out of empty formation, representing aggressive downfield play.

Insight page

Matthew Stafford

NegativeProjection23:00

The source notes that Stafford played a fine game against the Raiders but was not asked to do anything extraordinary by Sean McVay. The source emphasizes that McVay was pulling the right levers on offense, meaning Stafford did not need to make big throws. The source also notes that Stafford is a good quarterback who can make two or three big throws per game, but is not playing at the special level he did last season. The source expects Stafford to be good but not great going forward, which reframes the Rams' realistic expectations.

Insight page
NegativeProjection31:00

The source states that Stafford caught lightning in a bottle with the way he played last year and is not necessarily playing at that special level right now. While Stafford has been a good to very good quarterback for the Rams every year except 2022, the source does not expect him to replicate his special 2024 season. This reframes the Rams' realistic expectations downward, as they can no longer rely on Stafford playing at a Super Bowl favorite level.

Insight page

Pat Freiermuth

PositiveUsage0:04

The source highlights Freiermuth's conversion on a blitz response play in the second half, flipping the ball to him against the blitz for a productive gain; this was part of the Steelers' strong blitz response strategy.

Insight page

Puka Nacua

NegativeUsage23:00

The source details Nakua's usage in the Rams' Week 7 game against the Raiders, noting that Sean McVay threw eight boot-to-flat concepts to him in different ways. The source was impressed with the variety of motions and formations used to get Nakua into the flat: shuffle motioning in, inserting, and even bending him back behind the line of scrimmage for deep swings. This reflects McVay's hallmark approach of dressing up the same core plays in multiple ways to create defensive confusion.

Insight page
NegativeInjury27:42

The source expresses concern that Nakua is not healthy despite being targeted 12 times per game. The source notes that Nakua missed Friday's practice with various ailments throughout the season, and while he still produces (11 catches on 17 targets), his health status puts a cap on the ways he can affect the game. The source worries about whether Nakua can be the downfield threat he was last year, suggesting his current production is limited by injury rather than scheme or role.

Insight page
PositiveProjection27:42

The source notes that if Nakua can return to his 2024 form where everything under 10 yards is 'absolutely insane,' the Rams offense can get back to a good spot. The source acknowledges that last year Nakua became an awesome downfield player and nearly achieved offensive player of the year caliber, but this year has not shown as much of that. The implication is that a healthy Nakua returning to his short-area dominance would significantly improve the Rams' offensive ceiling.

Insight page

RJ Harvey

PositiveUsage53:24

Harvey was the target on a screen pass that went for 52 yards, one of three massive explosive plays that swung the Broncos-Cardinals game. The play was called brilliantly by Sean Payton, catching Arizona's blitz off the open side of the formation and replacing the blitzers with Harvey in space.

Insight page

Russell Wilson

NegativeRole18:41

The source notes that Wilson is not one of the best four quarterbacks in the world and lacks the breadth of knowledge or elite athleticism (like Lamar Jackson or Josh Allen) to bail himself out of plays. While the source sees potential for Wilson to become a ninth or tenth best quarterback in the right environment with more development, the current Steelers offensive environment limits what the offense can accomplish. The source emphasizes that without elite quarterback play, consistent offensive production is difficult to achieve.

Insight page

Tre Tucker

NegativeRole39:00

Tucker is a good and useful NFL player but not suited for the X receiver role the Raiders are asking him to play. When tasked with running digs against cornerbacks like Jalen Watson, the matchup does not work in his favor. The source notes this limitation was evident multiple times in the Raiders-Rams game.

Insight page

Trey McBride

NegativeMatchup51:47

McBride had a corner route that appeared to be caught but was ruled incomplete early in the third quarter when the Cardinals were down 13-6. Later, he could not hang on to a third-down throw right after Bo Nix's scramble touchdown, forcing the Cardinals to punt. These plays represented critical moments where the Cardinals' offense stalled.

Insight page
NegativeRole56:53

In Week 7 against Denver, the source felt the Cardinals' receiving options were severely limited, stating 'all they had was McBride,' suggesting he was the primary reliable target in a game where the offensive line struggles forced the Cardinals into difficult passing situations.

Insight page
Full transcript

Episode Transcript

770
0:00Welcome to The Athletic Football Show brought to you by the U.S.
0:03Bank Smartly Visa Signature Card. I'm Robert Mays. It's the Week 7 Hangover with me and Derrik Klassen.
0:08We got St. Steelers, Rams Raiders, and Broncos Cardinals.
0:11Three games. Let's dig into it right now. It's the Week 7 Hangover.
0:14Three games we're hitting today. Steelers, Saints, Rams Raiders, and Broncos Cardinals.
0:18Derek, let's start the show with where the day started yesterday.
0:21That is with the game that took place in Paris.
0:23Steelers knock off the Saints 16-10. Your biggest lasting takeaway from this game was what?
0:27I mean, I just continue to be extremely impressed by what the Steelers offense looks like.
0:32Like, I just didn't think that this would necessarily be an above average unit, but I think they have like a pretty
0:38good mix of the offensive line has obviously gelled into something that this is what we hoped it would be.
0:43There are so many plays in this game where Zach Frazier's climbing to the second level at a really impressive way.
0:49Mason McCormick is just clearing somebody out of the way.
0:52I think Maxi Inachor, there's some ups and downs because he's a rookie, but like, I think mostly you don't feel like
0:58there's a bad rookie tackle out there. I think that that's been nice.
1:01Fautanu loses a couple of reps to an awesome Chase Young, but like, other than that, is a really good player.
1:07So you have all of that. You have a quarterback who is, we've talked about this, playing in a way that we
1:13didn't think that he would play anymore. And I think the biggest way, the biggest realm that you see it is when
1:19Rodgers at his, at his worst doesn't want to make certain throws.
1:22It's often over the middle. He has the seventh most throws 11 to 20 yards between the hashes this year.
1:28That's just, that was the biggest complaint we had last year.
1:31And this year he's doing some of that. And then just on top of like, these skill players are good enough, man.
1:37Like DK makes some plays. Jeremy Bernard is a nice piece.
1:40Jalen Warren, he does so many things for them, but the, the catch that he makes when they try to, they're backed up in their own end zone.
1:47And Rodgers like pops a ball right over the defensive end.
1:50And Jalen Warren has to go stab this ball with one hand and brings it down.
1:55And I'm just like, when your back can just make catches like that look so easy, you can get eight, nine yards when you're not supposed to.
2:02And it just, you, you can feel that this offense can really move the ball.
2:06Yeah. I there that some of the checkdowns were really productive plays for them in this game.
2:11Like Caden Ellis either couldn't get to Warren in the flat or got caught up in traffic a couple different times or missed tackles.
2:18And so even the checkdowns were turning into productive plays, which last year, I think with the connotation around how they were
2:24checking the ball down and all the balls going to the backs was probably a negative one.
2:28This year, I think there's been a lot of positive plays there.
2:32Even Rico Dottle seemed like he had some juice in this game.
2:35Like when he was touching the ball, the fact that Warren has been so explosive this year, I think that the worst case scenario is Dottle gets back.
2:42His touches are just kind of DOA compared to what you're getting from Warren.
2:46And while he's not been as dynamic as Jalen Warren, obviously, when he touches the ball, I'm not actively upset.
2:52It's not Jalen Warren. And I think there's a world where that would have happened.
2:56Yeah, I was a little bit scared of that too.
2:59And I thought, yeah, Dottle looked great in this game.
3:01And I think like they do complement each other.
3:04Well, like Jalen Warren is good between the tackles.
3:06But I do think that there's a little bit more like Rico Dottle is full head of steam.
3:11I'm going to kill this linebacker sort of runner.
3:14And I think that that helps them because obviously everything Warren gives you in the passing game outside the numbers on some
3:20of their stretch runs is really dynamic. And you saw that in this game.
3:23I mean, there was, I think, a third and short that he bounced like 10 yards inside the two minute and he's
3:30able to go make like a really nice play.
3:32Like he just the blend that they have now at running back, I think, is really impressive.
3:37And then you're just feeling the passing game. I think because that burden is taken off of them with how good the run game has been.
3:44You can feel the passing game doing enough to make this like a pretty viable offense.
3:48Even yesterday, I don't think it's the best example of what you're talking about because there weren't that many of those throws.
3:54Really, the only ones we're talking about in like kind of the short to intermediate area in the middle of the field.
4:00He flips the ball to Friermuth against the Blitz for a productive gain in the second half.
4:05That was one of them. And then the Jeremy Bernard slip screen on third and 10 in the fourth quarter.
4:10That's a beautiful call. I mean, that's a perfect call in that moment.
4:14So it was kind of just responding to the Blitz or design throws.
4:17But for the most part, I agree with you.
4:20Like he's willing to access that stuff in a way that he wasn't last year.
4:24To me in this game, the stuff that we're seeing from him or we saw from him that wasn't that prominent a
4:30year ago is the extension of the place. Like he extends the play slides up and left in the pocket to find
4:36DK Metcalf for that 51 yarder down the field.
4:38And then he had another one later in the game where he just finds a little bit of space.
4:44And makes a play off schedule deep into the down that he just wasn't really doing a lot of last year.
4:49And so I think there have been games where it's a little bit more apparent that he's willing to kind of play
4:55the plays in the ways that we've wanted him to.
4:58But even in this one, I think you saw the ways that Rogers is contributing to what the offense feels like.
5:04There are positives that we've been wanting to see for the last couple of years.
5:08I 100% agree. I mean, he had like a big scramble late in this game where he converts like a pretty big critical down for them.
5:15He's moving. He's moving. And so like that play was really good.
5:18The the Friermuth conversion that you mentioned, that will that play was so good because that was their blitz responses.
5:24The last couple of weeks have been really good.
5:26Obviously, I thought they did a really good job of that against the Bucks as well, who have been one of the better pressure teams.
5:33And then obviously what they did against the Saints today, like that I thought that was a really good play.
5:39The DK Metcalf play where you mentioned where he scrambles out a little bit to his left.
5:43That's a fantastic throw. That's also an exception. It's also exceptional job tracking that by DK Metcalf, like finding that over his
5:49shoulder like an outfielder like that play was amazing.
5:52And so because last year, I think the issue with the offense was if those DK Metcalf plays weren't connecting, what did they have?
5:58The run game wasn't quite as good. And the other underneath stuff just wasn't quite as good either.
6:03But now that we have a Jeremy Bernard who that was the whole vision, if we can spit the ball out to
6:09him four times a game, can he get us two first downs?
6:13And he's been really, really good at that. And so I just it's not the sexiest offense in the world, but this
6:19is a legitimately good offense that can that can beat a lot of teams.
6:22Yeah, I'll be curious to see what it looks like over the course of the year.
6:27There are still stretches where it's a little bit frustrating, but not even close to what we've been talking about over the
6:33last couple seasons, just in terms of the types of throws he's willing to make and trying to make consistently.
6:38We did not mention, I mean, one of my favorite plays the day after the DK Metcalf 51 year completion, them throwing
6:44the fade to Darnell Washington for the touchdown is just an incredible.
6:48But it's again, my wife is watching these these Europe games with us because just in the morning when we're getting ready
6:54and drinking coffee on the couch, she was enamored with Darnell Washington.
6:57Just like watching what he is. She's like, she's like, he's huge.
7:00And I was like, yeah, he absolutely is huge.
7:03He's he's the only guy like that, man. It's he is.
7:06So I love that they have that, too, because they really do have like answers in the red zone.
7:11Now, the fact that they can get inside the five and they can be such an effective run the ball team, you
7:17can spit it out to Jeremy Bernard. And then, oh, you also have the only 300 pounder who's going to consistently catch the football.
7:23There's such a bizarre team, but I'm starting to enjoy it.
7:26I really am. I think the Bernard part unlocks it, though, because last year it's it's a very similar group of pass
7:32catchers to what it looked like last year. But they didn't have somebody who was as useful as this.
7:38Just all the different things that you can do with him.
7:41He's just a good. He is a player with utility like that.
7:44That's what he is. And that was the entire promise of him coming out.
7:48And it's so fun to watch a guy as a prospect and just have an idea of what you think he might be.
7:54And then he comes into the NFL and he's exactly that type of player.
7:58And that's how I feel with Jeremy Bernard. He's exactly what we thought he might be in the NFL.
8:03And that is just a useful, good at everything, not great at anything.
8:07You are going to be a productive part of the offense and contribute to what we are in a positive way for the next 10 years.
8:14Like that's exactly what Jeremy Bernard, I think the promise of him was.
8:17And I think that's exactly what we've seen from him so far.
8:21He is the most like 83 overall in Madden type of player.
8:24And that's exactly what they needed on this offense.
8:26He also in this game too, blocking his ass off on a number of those plays.
8:31Like he really is somebody who gets after it too.
8:33And so there are just a lot of parts where I'm just impressed the way that this is put together, given that
8:39they've got some good players and obviously the offensive line is great.
8:43But there really isn't that many like overwhelming talents on the offense.
8:46And so the fact that they are consistently putting it well together, the offensive lines kicking ass, they just keep putting together
8:52drives and games that are really impressive to me.
8:54We talked about this a little bit last night, but I think the natural follow-up question and an understandable one, considering how
9:00we've talked about the Steelers for the last couple of years is to what end, right?
9:05So what do you think that is? Like, what do you think the end point is or the ceiling is or the
9:11outlook is for a team that feels like the current Steelers do?
9:14I mean, I still feel like there is a ceiling and cap to the offense as far as relating to like potential championship caliber.
9:21But I mentioned this a little bit, I think, on the Sunday show.
9:24For the last handful of times that really since like even the end of the Roethlisberger era, every time they made the
9:30playoffs, it was just like, well, they're kind of wild card fodder.
9:34Maybe they'll stumble into winning the game, but this is not going to be like a serious game by the time they
9:40get to the divisional round if they do. I don't feel that way about this team.
9:44Like, I think that there are plenty of matchups where they could go into that wild card game.
9:49It will not be like a huge spread and they could absolutely win that game because both sides of the ball, I think, have enough to them.
9:56And like they're a team that like in the right matchup, like maybe they can win a divisional game if they catch a team on the right day.
10:04And the defense is really playing at a high level.
10:07And Rodgers decides he wants to continue making these throws over the middle of the field.
10:11And the offensive line is kicking people's ass. Like there is a because they can run the ball so well and the
10:17defense can play at a certain level. There's a certain amount of they can control the game and play it on their terms.
10:23And if you can do that well enough, like I do believe that you can win a playoff game or two.
10:29What do you make of the other side of the ball in this game?
10:33I so they were they were really funny in that I felt like they were throwing a million simulated pressures and then
10:39like not actually pressuring for a large part of this game.
10:42They eventually turn to it. They get the huge Patrick Queen sack at the end, which was a really good call where
10:48they got the protection to slide to the right.
10:50Queen gets a one on one against the right guard and just beats him.
10:54I thought that was really impressive. But for the most part, it was a lot of trying to make Tyler Shuck feel
11:00hot and then having enough bodies and coverage to dissuade him from throwing down the field.
11:05And in a lot of ways, they did do that.
11:07Like Tyler Shuck was fairly efficient in the one to 10 yard area, beating some of the simulated pressures, throwing underneath, particularly targeting the flats.
11:14Like I thought Jalen Ramsey and Patrick Queen were slow to the flats a lot of the time, but they really were not giving up that many explosives.
11:22And then eventually, if you know that Tyler Shuck is just going to keep throwing these flat routes, keep throwing these flat
11:28routes, you get the situation in the red zone where Peyton Wilson is dropping off the line of scrimmage.
11:33And he's like, I know that he's going to throw this drives on it, picks it off.
11:38And so it was one of those games where it felt like they were giving up this thing all the time.
11:43But I think it was kind of on purpose.
11:46And I think that they mostly executed their game plan pretty well.
11:49Jeremiah Wright was actually playing right guard for the Saints, which is part of the problem is that you have a backup
11:55right guard in there along with a backup left tackle.
11:58And now it was it was a that was a very frustrating sequence because you that's they're down 1610 in the fourth quarter.
12:04The first two passes on the drive guys are open.
12:07He's going to the right place with the ball quickly.
12:10Two of those passes get batted down in a row.
12:12And then on third down, you have the pressure picked up.
12:15You have enough guys to block this up and the backup right guard loses to Patrick Queen right as Tyler Shuck is
12:21trying to take a shot down the field. He takes a sack.
12:25They have to punt it away. The game is over.
12:27And it was indicative of what was overall a frustrating game to me for the New Orleans Saints offense.
12:33You cannot operate in the NFL in 2026 if you carry the ball 17 times for 18 yards.
12:38It's impossible. It's a non-starter. And it's not like I think the only way that you can somehow maybe sort of get
12:44away with making that work is if your passing game is really explosive and really trying to take the top off.
12:49Like the Packers, for example, their run game isn't very good, but they're what they're trying to accomplish in the passing game
12:55is we're going to get 20 yard chunks. 25.
12:58We're going to hit a 60 yard bomb. The Saints, you know, they hit the I think it was the deep the
13:04deep post route when they did try to like block up one seven man protection play.
13:08Other than that, we're just not particularly explosive in this game.
13:11And they're not an offense that does a lot of targeting the tough windows over the middle of the field.
13:17And I think they're a little bit up and down in how willing they are to push the ball down the field
13:23because when they get heated up, they don't want to do that.
13:26And so I think that they've run into an issue where you can't run the ball.
13:30So you're not efficient there. So we feel like we have to be efficient in the passing game.
13:35But it's just really, really hard to live that way with a quarterback who's only in his second season, an offensive line
13:41that's not an offensive line that's just not pass protecting all that well right now.
13:45What do you make of the middle of the field stuff?
13:48Because he was not afraid to make those throws last year.
13:51I think some of that is because of what we're talking about with the pressure stuff.
13:56And I think that he had moments last year where he was willing to stare down the barrel of the gun.
14:02But I feel like it's a couple of things.
14:04I think with him, he's kind of willing to make those throws.
14:07But I think that there is some amount of when the games start to unravel for him the way that they often have this season.
14:14I think that you feel him turtle up a little bit.
14:17This was an issue, I think, like with early Jared Goff, where when games would start to get away from him a
14:23little bit, you would just kind of feel him turtle into himself and not really make all the aggressive throws that you wanted.
14:29And so I think that there's a little bit of that.
14:32I also do just think that because of what we're talking about with them not being able to move the ball in
14:38the run game, I think that the passing game has become so much like, can we just get five yards?
14:44Can we just get five yards? And I think that it's a little bit by design because they don't have many other options right now as an offense.
14:52Yeah, when you're using 9.5% play action, not always easy to access the middle of the field when you're doing that.
14:57That's not a fake number, by the way. That was their play action rate in the game yesterday.
15:02That's so bad. You can't, again, you cannot live in the NFL doing that.
15:06It's really hard. You can't. And that's the frustrating part of this.
15:09And listen, I'm now having to live with the stark reality of having the Saints in the wins pool.
15:15And when I was trying to build an optimistic case for, but listen, the optimistic case for the Saints coming into the
15:21season for me was, could they be a 9 or 10 win winner of the NFC South?
15:25It did not go beyond that. As I'm trying to build that case, part of it was the passing game really showing some flashes last year.
15:32I like some of the design of it. When I made that choice, Jordan Tyson, I don't think, was out for a huge majority of time.
15:39And I was like, all right, I can see this taking a step forward because I really like, or even taking a
15:45modest step forward as a passing game. I like what we saw from the rookie quarterback.
15:50Olave is a star. You get one more pass catcher in there.
15:53And overall, I liked how they approached that. But the entire bit of optimism about the offense was, okay, we could not
15:59run the ball last year from an efficiency standpoint.
16:02And because we weren't able to consistently do it, we didn't even try to do it.
16:06And so you're putting so much on the quarterback in the passing game.
16:10I expected after signing David Edwards in free agency this year and after signing Travis H.
16:14And all right, the running game would at least be competent.
16:17We would get it to a place where it'd be something we could lean on.
16:21And I know that H. And has been hurt.
16:24But I know they have two backup offensive linemen in there.
16:27But when you watch the run game, it's completely DOA.
16:29Like, it has absolutely no shot. There are a couple plays in that game.
16:33The first run of the second half. They're having Eric McCoy try to block the three technique to the left side.
16:39Why? Like, in what universe is he going to be able to make that block?
16:43And then they're asking the backup right guard to block the shade to his side with absolutely no help whatsoever.
16:48So what they're asking the linemen to do, independent of the quality of those linemen, doesn't make a ton of sense to me.
16:55There's a play in the late in the second half.
16:57I think it was in the fourth quarter where it's a second and five.
17:01Peyton Wilson blitzes. No one touches him. It's a five-yard loss with him just running through the A-gap.
17:06And so I know that the guys that they thought would be out there that would make up the running game, they
17:12have not had that full stable of players right now.
17:15But when you watch what it looks like, I think it's an indication that a lot of the issues they're having there
17:21are not based on the talent that needed to be improved.
17:24I think this is a structural concern. I think it is as well.
17:28Our 30th in rushing offense DVOA. The only team's worst are the Raiders, who their offensive line continues to be a mess.
17:34And like Ashton Gentry is just not healthy. And then the Green Bay Packers, who are on like multiple different offensive linemen that they wanted either.
17:41And like, I think to your point about the talent upgrades, they signed David Edwards this offseason.
17:45He was obviously fantastic with the Bills. A really good player.
17:48I just think he's looked as good as you want him to.
17:52And that to me is like when you're just dropping a guy who I don't think athletically looks any worse than he
17:58did last year, but just isn't playing to the same level.
18:01That to me speaks to like, OK, something else is going on here that is not just about the players that are there.
18:07It's an ecosystem concern. I mean, it's a very clear example of one.
18:10And it's so hard to play offense this way.
18:13Like what you were asking of the quarterback, you are now putting him in a position where the burden that he's asked
18:19to carry is in line with what teams usually ask the best dropback quarterbacks in the league to carry season after season.
18:25You can do a little bit of this with Patrick Mahomes and Joe Burrow.
18:29Like if that's how you want them to play, I think you can survive on offense.
18:33Even if Tyler Shuck, I think, has had some really nice moments.
18:36And even in this game, I thought did a very good job doing what was asked of him.
18:41There's still going to be such a limit on what your offense can be when this is the burden you're asking the quarterback to carry.
18:48And he's not one of the best four quarterbacks in the world.
18:51Yeah, when he's not one of those guys that can just either has the breadth of knowledge for having done this for
18:57it's his seventh season in the NFL or whatever, or is not just one of those freak athletes like Lamar Jackson, Josh
19:04Allen, where he can just bail himself out of plays.
19:06And the thing is, like, I do think Shuck sees it well.
19:10And I do think he's a good athlete. He's just not to that A-plus level of those guys, at least yet mentally.
19:16You're just not going to be able to put together consistent offense playing that well.
19:20And it really is. It does make it difficult and annoying to watch because I still think that, like, when I watch
19:26him, I see a lot of stuff where I'm like, one day he can be the ninth or tenth best quarterback in
19:32the NFL in the right environment with a little bit more development.
19:35Like, I still see that there. It's just that what the environment is now, you're just not going to get the best
19:41stuff out of him with how this is going.
19:43Every conversation in the offseason where you could kind of talk yourself into this team, it's like, okay, if the run game
19:49gets better from what we saw with the passing game last year, can they be the 16th best offense in the league?
19:55Oh, well, this was a really good defense over the back half of last year.
20:00Statistically, they really stopped the run extremely well. You know, they were a team that I think if they could do that
20:06again, they have pressure players to kind of live in that world.
20:09And the defense is just completely unraveled. Like, I understand if you're Gail Benson coming out and saying the stuff you did
20:15last week because of what you thought your team might look like this year based on how last season ended and what they do look like.
20:22It is because we have teams like the Rams, like the Chargers, the Texans, that are real disappointments because they were title contenders.
20:28I don't think we really talked about the Saints that way.
20:31And they're not nearly as disappointing as those teams, but they are disappointing.
20:35Like, what we've gotten from this version of the Saints in year two when you might have expected them to take a
20:41step, they have taken none of those steps. And it is pretty disheartening.
20:44It is. Do you know who's—so the Saints right now in overall team DVOA are 27th.
20:49Do you want to know who's right behind them?
20:51The Miami Dolphins. It's brutal. Like, it's when you are in line with the Miami Dolphins, who the whole point of their
20:57season was they are hamstrung with their cap. They are really just trying to get by with a bunch of draft picks,
21:03seeing what they can get for next year. It's very different than what we thought with the Saints, where you're right.
21:09Like, I think coming into the season two, there was an optimistic case that they could win this division.
21:14And they look, to me, pretty clearly like the worst team in a division that is kind of weird and doesn't necessarily have, like, a dominant frontrunner.
21:22Yeah, and that's it. It wasn't, can this be like a team that wins a playoff game?
21:26It's, can this team be 18th in overall team DVOA?
21:29And that has not happened. And I think you really—it's so soon to be having, like, hard conversations about what the future looks like.
21:36But I think your point about the Kellenmore offenses and what we had seen from the Kellenmore offenses, that your worst fears are being realized here.
21:43They won a Super Bowl in Philadelphia when they have Jeff Stoutland as the run game coordinator and Saquon Barkley.
21:48Yeah. But in situations where we have not seen that, the run game has had real issues.
21:53And so how you bridge the gap and how you tie everything together when that has been a consistent problem over multiple
21:59years, over multiple stops, that would be something that I'm concerned about.
22:02Yeah. And that'll be, you know, I'm sure one of the bigger offseason talks that we have about them.
22:07But it's—it is pretty concerning that it's looked this way so far.
22:11All right, let's take our first quick break and then come back and shout out a little Rams Raiders.
22:16The NBA season is here. When you turn on the games, turn on The Athletic Live on YouTube.
22:21Become part of the show in the interactive chat along with hosts Zach Harper, Kofi Oboa, and the Athletic Slam Dunk NBA staff.
22:27The Athletic Live is presented by Google Gemini. Check it out now and subscribe on YouTube.
22:31The Los Angeles Rams take care of business against the Raiders 35-21.
22:35Big time bounce back game for the Rams. Your biggest takeaway from Rams Raiders was what?
22:39So we can talk about how real this get-right game was, given I think that the Raiders' defense specifically is probably worse
22:45than we thought over the first three weeks of the season.
22:48However, this to me felt very much like a Sean McVay, Matthew Stafford, we're going back to basics sort of game.
22:54It was so much just like inside run duo, and they did it pretty well.
22:58It was so much— Yes, exactly. That's what you need to be.
23:01Just do the shit that works. Do the stuff that we know can take you deep into the playoffs.
23:06They were doing that, and I should have counted.
23:09I swear they threw eight boot-to-flat concepts to Puka Nakua.
23:12Like, the eight different ways that they were just trying to spit him out the ball doing that I thought was pretty impressive.
23:18The way that they were using the tight ends I thought in the red zone was really impressive.
23:23So this to me felt like, okay, we don't have Devontae Adams.
23:26What are we going to do? We're going to go back to our day one install stuff, and we're just going to
23:32make it work and dress it up as well as we can.
23:35And it worked really well. Like, I thought that this was a game where it felt like there was no pressure on
23:41Matthew Stafford to really do anything extraordinary. Like, I thought he played a fine game, but I don't think they asked a
23:47whole lot of him because I just thought that Sean McVay was kind of pulling a lot of the right levers on that side of the ball.
23:55We talked so much after that game against the Cardinals about how this team was struggling to dictate the way its games
24:01were being played in the way that it could last year.
24:04And I think so much of that is just what the approach looks like on offense and what the approach feels like on offense.
24:10They were under center on 69% of their snaps in this game per next gen.
24:14They ran the ball 56% of the time. Matthew Stafford finished with a 53% play action rate.
24:19And that was the offense. And that's what the founder, it doesn't have to be this extreme all the time.
24:25And it can't be this extreme all the time when you don't have a 60% rushing success rate like they did.
24:30But I think this has to be the foundation of the approach as often as you can make it that.
24:36Because when this team is running the ball with the efficiency it was running the ball and their ability and they can
24:42just lean on easy completions off play action. And if necessary, can the quarterback make two or three big time throws, which
24:48he didn't even really need to make in this game.
24:51But if necessary, can he do it? I think that has to be what they try to be on offense.
24:56Whether the ceiling of that is high enough considering the current state of the pass catching options, that's a different consideration.
25:02But as a starting point, the offense looking and feeling the way that it did on Sunday, I think has to be
25:08the first step to them getting back on track.
25:10Like, all the stuff that they did in this game gets them back to being a good offense.
25:15Which, to your point, I don't know if they can get back to being a great offense if Devontae is going to
25:21miss as much time as he is in all those considerations.
25:24But I think this at least gets them back to being good and making sure that they can play the game a little bit on their own terms.
25:32And I really was just impressed with the different ways that they were dressing stuff up.
25:36Like, I mentioned the stuff to Nakua and they're having him, you know, motion across the field and just having him sprint
25:42straight to the flat to get there. They're having times where he's shuffle motioning in, he's inserting, and then he's getting to the flat.
25:49There was one where they, like, kind of, like, bent him back behind the line of scrimmage for, like, a deep, like, swing off of this stuff.
25:56Like, just so many different ways to give him space and access into the flat that I thought was really impressive.
26:02And that, hasn't that always been the hallmark of the Sean McVay offense?
26:06Is that it's the same four plays. He's just dressing it up so many different ways that you are struggling to attack it.
26:12And it makes, it almost makes the defense look stupid.
26:15You're like, how do you not cover the flat route for the eighth time?
26:18And it's like, well, because he's dressing it up in a way that you don't think that that's what you're getting.
26:24And this, this to me felt like a classic game in that way from him.
26:28I mean, just when you're having to worry about getting gapped out in the run game, even when it's in 11 personnel,
26:34because he's going to be inserting on some of that stuff.
26:37Like, if you're the person responsible for covering the flat, you're in conflict consistently because they're running the ball 60% of the time.
26:44Like, it's the, at the core of it, that's why they're so hard to play against is for all the reasons that you're saying.
26:50Just before we get into some of the other like big picture stuff, the Puka touchdown is such a sneaky, nasty play by him.
26:57Like, he comes back to the ball so hard on that play that the way that he attacks it is what allows
27:03him to create after the catch because he's making the actual catch so far away from where the two defenders in that
27:09area thought he was going to make it. Like, it's really, I feel like a lot of the best receivers right now
27:15are really good at that about like coming back.
27:17Yeah. Cause I think it was Quay Walker, like really like drives and tries to get over the top of it.
27:23He's like, surely he's going to be, yeah, exactly.
27:25Like where he was, but he just comes back to the ball, like two yards and immediately flips it inside.
27:31And it's just like, you just don't think the guy is going to be able to do that.
27:36And so I still worry a little bit about can Puka Nakua be the downfield threat that he was last year?
27:42Cause I mean, that was such like what really accelerated him into being almost offensive player of the year caliber was he really became an awesome downfield player.
27:49This year, I don't feel like we've seen as much of that, but if he can be classic 24 Puka Nakua where
27:55everything under 10 yards is absolutely insane, they can get back to a good spot.
27:59My concern is that he's just not healthy. I agree.
28:02Exactly. Yeah. I don't, I just don't think he's a hundred percent.
28:05And so I think that puts a cap on the ways that he can affect the game.
28:10When I watched the receiving court to two takeaways from just watching the past catching group overall, let's, let's say let's call it three.
28:17One. I don't think he's healthy, even if you're still able to throw him the ball 12 times a game.
28:22It's hilarious that the guys like every week, it's like, Oh, Puka missed Friday's practice with so-and-so ailment.
28:27And then you look at the stat line after the game is over.
28:30It's like he had 11 catches on 17 targets.
28:33And then the two other ones were one. I actually think Kanata Mumfield's got something to him.
28:38He's, I think I still want to see more, but I do.
28:41I am glad that at least putting him on the field has not been like a total waste.
28:46And I was worried about that with this receiver core.
28:49To be clear, the third point was going to be they need someone else.
28:52Okay, there we go. Yeah. Like they need someone else.
28:55He can do some stuff. And I mean, his first big catch in this game, he is lined up isolated as an X receiver.
29:02He gets great. It's a great release off the line of scrimmage.
29:05He puts a little shake at the top of the route against Hezekiah masses and catches like a 15 yard completion on third down.
29:12I mean, that was a really nice, it might not have been third down actually, but it's a, it's a defined drop
29:18back situation where he's isolated as the X receiver and makes the play.
29:21Like he's Devante Adams on that play and does a decent job.
29:24But overall, I think part of the reason what you said about Puka, the fact that they don't really have a downfield option.
29:31That's why I think they need to go get somebody else.
29:34Like if they have somebody that can create some space within the offense, I think that would be worthwhile.
29:39I don't think that the Jags would trade him at this point.
29:42I don't know. I'm not, I'm not sure if the Jags would trade Brian Thomas Jr.
29:47At this point, but that's the type of player I would be like, all right, screw it.
29:51Like, can we throw a pick at them and get some verticality to the offense?
29:55And what would that do for us? Like that might be a worthwhile consideration for a team like this.
30:00I think so. Like they, cause I just don't think the offense is going to be able to function if they can't open it up.
30:07And it's not even just to access some of the explosive stuff down the field.
30:11It's so that we can find more of those dig windows, more of those crossers windows for guys underneath, like, you know,
30:17whoever the tight ends are going to be Puka Nakua, obviously guys like that.
30:21And I think it's especially important for them because kind of by design, the run game is just not explosive.
30:27Like they, they are, it's a run game that is trying to beat you up six yards at a time.
30:32And there are games where they can do that.
30:35It's been a little bit more up and down this year slightly, but this is a game where you saw like, yes,
30:41they can absolutely crush you in that way. And so I think if you're not going to even aim to be a
30:47super explosive rushing team, you need to be able to find it elsewhere.
30:50And I think the other consideration would be that like, I still think Matthew Stafford is a good quarterback and he can
30:56make those two or three throws a game. Last year, it could be like six or seven throws a game where he
31:02was truly just like on freaking fire. I don't feel like he is necessarily playing at that level right now.
31:08So you really do need a little bit more help from some of the other talent, help from the scheme and things like that.
31:14Yeah. That's, that's part of the unfortunate truth. I think is that they caught lightning in a bottle with the way that he played last year.
31:21And he's been good for multiple years in a row.
31:24Like Matthew Stafford has been a good quarterback and a very good quarterback for the Rams pretty much every year.
31:30He's been there outside of whatever the disaster season looked like in 2022, but he was obviously playing at a special, special level last season.
31:36And I just don't think that's going to happen again.
31:39And so it just reframes what the realistic, realistic expectations for this team are, even if they do turn it around to an extent.
31:46But I think it, we probably have to have like an honest conversation about what they can accomplish overall with the current state of the receiving core.
31:53And with what we have seen from Matthew Stafford so far this year, they go for being like the Super Bowl favorite to a team.
32:00Like, can they come back and claw their way into making the playoffs?
32:04And like, I still think that like, if they go and get somebody at receiver or Pukinokua, just he can get healthy at some point.
32:10Like, I still think that the offense can be good enough for them to make a Super Bowl run.
32:16It's just that now I think it has to reframe to be like, they're probably going to have to play some more lower scoring games.
32:22And the defense is really going to have to kick into a gear that I think we thought was possible.
32:28But if they don't reach that second or third best defense in the league caliber, especially once Miles Garrett comes back, then it's probably not good enough.
32:35That's a good point. It's they're just going to have to win games a little bit differently than they have over the
32:41last couple of years if they want to realize even similar type of ceiling.
32:45Before we move on to that side of the ball, I just very quickly when you watch the Raiders defense right now
32:51and you watch them in a game like this, I think you're just kind of reminded of where the personnel deficiencies on the Raiders defense still exist.
32:59Tonka Hemingway was coming off of a he had a concussion last week.
33:02He only played 20 snaps in this game. And there are so many plays where the Rams are in like 11 personnel or 12 personnel.
33:09Now the Raiders are a nickel with Quay Walker walked out onto the line of scrimmage, which I can understand, right?
33:15You want to be in some five down fronts against a team like this.
33:18And those interior three guys, including Quitty pay as a five technique against 330 pound Kevin Dotson are just getting moved off the ball.
33:25And that was probably my biggest concern about the Raiders defense overall coming into the year.
33:29And I think yesterday they went up against a team that is perfectly designed to take advantage of it and did throughout the entire game.
33:36I mean, that's a great point. One of my biggest notes from this game was the Rams are resetting the line of
33:42scrimmage every single run like they are getting. It felt like an automatic three yard gain at minimum every time that they
33:48were running the ball because I just thought that they were resetting it so well.
33:52And you have a splash play every now and then where Max Crosby just nice into the backfield.
33:57But like otherwise, like you said, they were really moving these guys at will.
34:01And like some of these defend these defensive linemen have had decent moments against lesser offensive lines this season.
34:06I think that, like you said, with Tonka Hemingway, maybe not being 100% himself in this game.
34:11I just you kind of felt them falling away in some of the ways that you would be worried about.
34:16We've just have so much so many examples over the last several years that you need true difference making glass eating players up front.
34:23If depending on the style of defense that you play, right?
34:26I mean, we've talked a lot about the Falcons this year where I think that if you play like a down downhill
34:32attacking style, you can somehow you can sometimes get a little bit more than the talent level would lead you to believe.
34:38If you're going to play the way that the Raiders want to play, we're in you're in a lot of these even
34:44fronts and you're asking guys to kind of eat up space like you need difference making type players to be a good
34:50defense if you're going to play that way. And they just don't have those guys like they when you looked at the
34:56roster coming into the year, we knew they weren't going to have those guys.
35:00And so I just think we're at a place now where some of the stuff we thought might be true about the
35:06Raiders has kind of come into focus as they're playing against offenses like this.
35:10Yeah, it's a lot of guys who can be useful role players.
35:13And again, there are still games where they are.
35:16It's just that they are not force multipliers for the most part outside of obviously what Max Crosby can do.
35:21And even in this game, I would say Sean McVay and the Rams did a really good job of just keeping him
35:27at bay with a lot of runs at him, I think to tire him out.
35:31And then in the passing game, I thought that they were just consistently chipping, sliding, all that stuff, really trying to take him out of the game.
35:39The biggest personnel deficiency to me on defense was the interior of the defensive line.
35:43The biggest personnel deficiency for the Raiders to me on offense was what they had at receiver.
35:47And you felt that in this game too. I mean, the Rams were just throwing.
35:51It was two different things in this game for the Rams.
35:54I believe they had six or seven DBs in the field, six or seven on 70% of their snaps in this game.
36:00It was it was zero. The raw number is 46 snaps of at least six defensive backs.
36:05And I'm glad you say seven because I looked this up because it just felt like it was crazy in the moment.
36:11They had 19 snaps in this game with seven DBs on the field, which is more is which is 15 more than
36:17in any other game by any other team this season.
36:20It was a completely unique game, which is funny because I came into this game being like, what are the Raiders going
36:26to do against dime, which is six DBs. And the Rams were like, we're going to up the ante and we're going
36:32to put seven on the field and dare you to throw against that.
36:35I have a couple of layers to that that I find interesting that I'm curious about your take on one.
36:41And the biggest thing that says to me is we have less than zero respect for your ability to run the ball.
36:47Correct. Less than zero. And understandably, so it was kind of jarring.
36:50I mean, so it was like 616 left in the first quarter and the Raiders come out in 12 personnel.
36:56It's their version of 12 personnel, but still 12 personnel and the Rams are in dime defense on first and 10.
37:01I'm like, my God, what a disrespectful approach to the game.
37:04And this is, and the Raiders finished with a 26.7% rushing success rate per next gen.
37:09So the disrespect was warranted. So that's the first layer of it.
37:12The second layer of it is it felt like if we put all these DB bodies in the field and we play
37:18a lot of man, we can put any of these guys on Brock Bowers and trust that they can probably cover him
37:24because we have a corner or a corner esque body.
37:27On him on pretty much every single snap. And we don't, we aren't afraid of any of your other pass catchers taking
37:33advantage of whatever other matchups that leaves. And I think that those two kind of facets to it makes sense as to
37:39why the Rams approached it this way. And they got every single benefit of attacking the game in the way that they did.
37:45A hundred percent. Like they, I thought what their, their game plan for Bowers was, like you said, we're going to play a bunch of man coverage.
37:53And they were playing a lot of like rat and robber coverage.
37:56And whoever the rat or robber was, was I'm looking for Brock Bowers on the over.
38:00Like they were not going to let him get those 12 to 15 yard in breakers, the deep over routes.
38:06And so when you're doing that, whoever is playing him one-on-one man coverage, well, they know they can just play hard outside
38:12leverage and just not give him anything. And I just thought that there were a number of plays where they did really well at that.
38:19Like, honestly, I think the first third down of the game, Rams have seven DBs out there and they're like robbing him
38:25with, I think it was Cam Kitches was the middle of the field player.
38:28He almost steals an interception a little bit later in the game.
38:32There's about nine minutes left in the second quarter.
38:34They're robbing over the middle of the field again.
38:37And Brock Bowers, okay, the Raiders have figured this out.
38:39So we're going to run Bowers on a deep corner route.
38:42Well, because the Rams DB knows that he has inside help.
38:45He's like, I'm just going to stay under this corner route and I'm never going to give it to you.
38:51He's not open. Kirk can't make the throw. So I thought their game plan in that sense was impressive.
38:56And then you mentioned it, who the hell else was going to beat them?
39:00Like, I think Trey Tucker is a good and useful NFL player.
39:03Trey Tucker is not a good or useful X receiver.
39:06And that's what they had. Specific type of NFL player.
39:09Exactly. And he can be really good in that role.
39:11When you ask him to be the X receiver and run a dig against Jalen Watson, it just ain't going to work
39:17the way that you want it to work. And you saw that a number of times in this game.
39:23I mean, they're trying to throw like third down crossing routes to Cody White.
39:26You know, I mean, and that's, it's just tough place to be.
39:30And again, I, I'm trying to figure out where we should land with the Raiders.
39:34And it's obviously been sort of a strange season.
39:36They get out to a hot start. And I think a game like this, it's just laid out right in front of
39:42you where some of the roster deficiencies are, but we should have been able to anticipate a lot of those deficiencies.
39:48Like coming into the season with a receiving core that's built the way that this one is, even if you have Brock
39:54Bowers, it's going to be really tough when teams have a sort of have a plan to reliably take him away.
40:00There's no one else that you're really scared is going to beat you.
40:03And so none of this, I don't think should be that surprising on either side of the ball.
40:08The one thing that I do want to sit with a little bit and ask you about is where are we at
40:14with the inability to run the football? How much of this is Ashton Jensie's health?
40:18How much of this is the plan? How much of this is an offensive line group that again, it was like, all
40:24right, well, can they, can we get more out of them than last year's group did?
40:29But what is the talent level? Even if that is kind of the, those are the dynamics at play.
40:34Like that's the one area where I do kind of want to sit with it because I want to get a sense
40:40of what our realistic expectations of that element of this team will be like moving forward because for a Clint Kubiak team,
40:46you're going to need to get hopefully to a certain level for this all to come together on offense with Fernando Mendoza
40:52or whoever's in there over the next couple of years.
40:55I think the unsatisfying answer is that it is a little bit of everything.
40:59I think that like part of it is even if Kubiak, I think at times can dress up the run game pretty
41:05well and obviously did this in Seattle. It is still very like one note in terms of what they're trying to accomplish.
41:11It is a lot of they're just trying to hit outside zone perimeter stuff.
41:14And I think this is an offensive line group that to me, I think struggles with that in a lot of ways.
41:20And I would just say to the right side of the offensive line in general is just not good.
41:26Like those are not to me, NFL starting caliber players.
41:28And I think that you just feel that on a week to week basis.
41:32And then I think the other part of it, you know, mentioning Gentry's health.
41:36I think Ashton Gentry to me at his best is a runner who if we block three, he's finding a way to get six.
41:43Like he is just one of those like grinds out and like makes the offensive line right sort of runner.
41:48But if the offensive line is so bad that like those little crevices don't even open up either, he's just going to
41:54get smacked in the backfield and he's not going to have enough of those Kenneth Walker run around and make a crazy
42:00play to go make an explosive to balance it out.
42:03And I think that he's like that generally. I think right now he cannot cut laterally.
42:07And I think that you really feel what that's doing to the effectiveness of the rushing offense.
42:12Are we at a point where we're a little bit worried about this?
42:15The guy you drafted in the top seven in a draft where there was a lot of really good players taken after
42:21him and what this has looked like, even if you account for the fact that he hasn't been 100 percent?
42:27I think yes and no. I think to some extent, yes, because there were obviously a number of really good players that they could have taken otherwise.
42:34I still do believe that there's a decent chance that next year they fix the offensive line a little bit.
42:40It's second year in the system for everybody and he's healthy.
42:43And by week six, he has 550 rushing yards.
42:45And we're like, oh, yeah, he was just hurt last year.
42:48And I still, I think, am willing to give a young player that sort of level.
42:53But I do think that it's probably more likely than not that he's a good to pretty good running back rather than a top five.
42:59Oh, my God, sort of running back. And I think that might be a little bit tough to stomach.
43:05That's a tough place to land. Exactly. If you take him that high, he needs to be Bajon Robinson.
43:10Or, you know, Bajon Robinson being the literal best running back in the league is, I think, a really high bar.
43:16But of that caliber where in a given season...
43:18They were drafted in the same spot! Exactly. Exactly.
43:20Exactly. Exactly. And you feel how different those two guys are.
43:23Yeah. It's kind of I'm landing in the same place, even if it's going to be hard to find, come to like
43:29a real conclusion until we see him a little bit healthier.
43:32And by the way, Ashton Juntie was drafted one spot before Bajon Robinson was.
43:36He was the sixth pick in that draft. And I believe Bajon Robinson was the seventh pick in the 2023 draft, correct?
43:42That sounds correct. Eighth. Eighth. Oh, man. To rub salt in the wound, the seventh pick in the 2023 draft was Tyree Wilson.
43:49That's a tough one. Juntie is definitely not that bad.
43:51That's a tough one. Last thing here. What do we make of the Fernando timeline?
43:55Do we want to see him? Do you think it matters?
43:58There's like when you watch that game, I don't I don't come away from that game feeling like the way I did
44:04about watching Jameis Winston and like, all right, it's time.
44:07I don't I don't need to watch this anymore.
44:10But when do you think it would be realistic or worthwhile for us to see Fernando Mendoza?
44:14So selfishly, of course, I want to see him.
44:17He's a really good quarterback prospect. And I think he objectively is just a much more talented quarterback than Kirk Cousins at this stage.
44:23I do think, though, I'm kind of in line of like, I really don't think it fixes anything for this season, because
44:29I think thrusting a young quarterback like him into a situation where you really don't have many workable wide receivers and the run game is non-existent.
44:36Like you are just, I think, kind of throwing him out to the wolves in a way that is is kind of
44:42asking for things to really go wrong and really to set some some negative habits and stuff like that.
44:48And then, like you said, this is not a Jameis Winston.
44:51We have to move on from this quarterback situation.
44:53I think Kirk has been an average at times above average quarterback for large stretches of this season.
44:58Even if I think in this game they ran against ran up against a really, really good pass defense.
45:03I still think that there can be games where Kirk throws for 280 and two or three touchdowns and they look like a pretty good passing offense.
45:11And I think even if Mendoza might have games or throws that are like, oh, my God, in a way that Kirk Cousins is not going to have.
45:18I do think the down to down consistency of what you get from Kirk Cousins right now is valuable.
45:24So I think the only reason I would play Mendoza is not to fix anything this season, but they just get to
45:30a point where we're like, this is done. We're going to get him reps.
45:33And I just I don't think the season is quite that doomed yet.
45:37I think that's right. I just wonder when when you try to split that difference, like when you feel like, all right,
45:43this is the right amount of time to get this guy, even if the circumstances aren't great.
45:48I think that was always going to be the case with how they were approaching it.
45:52And Clint Kubiak, I mean, right before we started recording, came out and was adamant that there is no real conversation like Kirk Cousins is the starting quarterback.
46:00And so I think with how steadfast they've been with it and for all the reasons that you said, I I don't expect it to happen anytime soon.
46:07And maybe it just doesn't happen at all. But when you when the season and feels like it's become something that it
46:13didn't feel like over the first month, I think it's worth the conversation at the very least, like the one that we're having right now.
46:20Exactly. We're like the first three weeks of the season.
46:23It was like, man, are the Raiders going to like be punchy and be like a wildcard team?
46:28And I think that that ship has probably sailed, but they still feel like a competent and competitive football team.
46:33And until the loss column is so big that that doesn't matter, I feel like they're going to continue to let this thing rock with Kirk Cousins.
46:41All right, let's take one more quick break and then come back and chat a little Cardinals Broncos.
46:46All right, your biggest takeaway from the Broncos 30 to 16 win over the Cardinals yesterday is what?
46:50I mean, they got Bo Nix to throw the football down the field a little bit.
46:55I thought that that was like if you're going to be a serious offense and try to convince me that you are
47:01still one of the best eight to 10 teams in football and the defense is playing the way that it is at a really high level.
47:08I wanted to see a little bit more aggression out of this passing offense.
47:12And I did think you saw it and specifically when they went into empty, Bo Nix was really willing to rip it.
47:18Those were like two of the four plays. Yes, it was like you.
47:21I don't know what it is. I don't know if he like just loves the spread look of it all.
47:27It like empties out the coverage for him, whatever.
47:29But literally the first play of the game, they get him in empty and he just like chucks this little seam bender to Cortland Sutton against cover two.
47:37There was one later in the game where just at the end of the third quarter, he throws the hole shot against cover two.
47:44Marvin Mims makes a guy miss and runs it.
47:46It's like a 47 yard gain. And then early on in the fourth quarter, they go to two by three empty again.
47:52And he finds Jalen Waddle actually running with the pole runner in Tampa too, but he puts it on his back shoulder and it's a really good ball.
48:00And I'm like, OK, these are the throws that if you can make two of those a game and the run game
48:06can look OK and you can have, you know, getting a 60 yard touchdown scramble is not going to happen every week.
48:12But if we can get more Bo Nix scrambling and actually getting positive plays there, it's like, yes, this is the formula
48:18for the 15th best offense in the league. And if the defense is going to be elite, that's all it's got to be.
48:24It's just that for the first six weeks of the season, they weren't even doing that.
48:28I don't even think I realized that the Marvin Mims completion was out of empty because the two I had in mind
48:34were the Cortland Sutton seam ball in the first drive and then the Jalen Waddle back shoulder throw later in the game.
48:40So literally three, like the three, I think he had four completions of 10 plus air yards.
48:45Three of them were out of empty. Three of the four.
48:48And I can't remember what the fourth one was.
48:51And so it's not just they were using it a little bit.
48:54But yeah, yeah. Like it's it really was just like, get him an empty.
48:58He'll throw it. I mean, I think that's it's a good thing that he was willing to do it.
49:03But I part of me does. I would like to see it in more ways than if we do this, he will throw the ball that way.
49:10I think I definitely agree with that. Like, this is good.
49:13This is a good first step, right? That it's like, OK, they have rediscovered some way that he's willing to do it.
49:19I think you still want to see probably a little bit more from play action where he's willing to do it.
49:25Probably want to see a little bit more true gun.
49:28Can he push the ball down the field? That's not just go balls.
49:31But still the fact that they found some way to get him to target that 11 to 25 yard area.
49:37It was it was encouraging. And then again, he he was willing to access stuff a little bit more as a scrambler
49:43in this game in a way that I think has been a little bit more up and down the first six weeks.
49:49Yeah, I think there's still some gaps to be closed, but absolutely an encouraging step in the right direction.
49:54People will look at the air yards and they'll be like, oh, yeah, he averaged like we.
49:59It's time to go on my ramp. We there are so many things that are happening on the Internet right now that
50:05are breaking the brains of the people who follow professional football online.
50:08Let's take this piece by piece. One, checkdowns are not inherently bad.
50:11They're not. They're not inherently bad. They can be good or they can be bad depending on when you take them, how
50:17efficient they are, what other throws were available. Like the idea that checking the ball down is always bad is hilarious.
50:23Checking the ball down is often good, but it's about why you're checking the ball down.
50:27That that's rant number one to looking at a guy's air yards at the end of a game and being like, that
50:33is all that matters is not always a good indication of what the game looked like.
50:38The air yards in this game were significantly better.
50:40He was one of six on throws of 20 plus yards.
50:43If you're just going to chuck a bunch of arbitrary balls down the field, it doesn't really change what you look like playing quarterback down to down.
50:51Like we said, there are, there were more aggressive intermediate throws being taken in this game.
50:55But if you throw six 50 yard incompletions, your air yards are going to look good at the end of the game.
51:01That has no bearing on what the game actually felt like.
51:04And so I just think there are so many things like the, the checkdowns thing to me.
51:09And like last year, last year's hospital balls is this year's check down merchant.
51:13Like that's what we've done over the first seven weeks of the season is that we've used, people see one shirt and
51:19they hear one term and then they fixate on it in a way that has no bearing on the games that are actually being played.
51:25And it's driving me insane. It's like the checkdowns specifically are like the checkdowns are only bad if they are clearly hamstringing
51:31you from doing other, making other good plays. And I think with Bo Nix that that has been true at times, but
51:37like you watch, you know who checks the ball down a lot?
51:41Patrick Mahomes. But he's still willing to make a lot of the important throws that he needs to, where you don't feel
51:47like, oh my God, this guy's checking the ball way too much.
51:50And so that really is the difference is that only when it starts to feel like he's clearly passing up something in
51:56service to do this, or his eyes are immediately going there, whatever it is, but checking it down, especially within the vacuum
52:02of like an individual play, often not a bad thing.
52:05It is usually better than the other outcomes. Well, part of the conversation around this is that during the Thursday night game,
52:11there was praise for Drake May checking the ball down in that game.
52:14And it's like, well, why is he allowed to check the ball down?
52:18For so many reasons. Because of the other plays that he was making, I would say.
52:22That particular line of discourse to me has just been very, very frustrating over the first seven weeks.
52:27And I, at some point I was going to have to get it off my chest.
52:32Anything else about the offense for the Broncos in this game that you wanted to bring up?
52:36Like for me, this was a game that came down to like three or four massive explosives.
52:41It was the scramble. It was the RJ Harvey screen.
52:44It was the whole shot that you're talking about.
52:46Like those plays, the three of them really did help swing the game.
52:50That scramble touchdown is an absolute backbreaker. That happens.
52:52And then McBride can't hang on to the third down throw right after it.
52:56And the Cardinals are forced to punt. And then the other big swing, if we want to get to the other side
53:02of the ball, to me, that happens is there, the Cardinals are down 13, six early in the third quarter.
53:07On first down, they, there was a big corner route to Trey McBride that looked like he caught it.
53:13He didn't. Then you get into second and 10 on third down.
53:16They have no pressure plan. They chuck up a go ball for a player whose name I cannot remember right now.
53:22Was it Brooks down the left side? Yeah. Where it's just like double coverage and it's not close to being completed.
53:27It was down the right side. They just like chucked up a go ball on third and 10 against a pressure look to Jalen Brooks.
53:34It falls incomplete and they're punting. And then the punt was blocked immediately.
53:38That's, that's, it's funny you say that, that it's a lot of swing moments because down to down, it didn't feel like
53:44the game was like super out of like Arizona's favor.
53:46And then obviously by the final scoreboard, it looks like they just got completely stomped in this game, but they were pretty competitive for a lot of it.
53:54And then it really was just like two or three complete blow up moments for them that the game just falls away completely.
54:00I think that's exactly right. I mean, again, it's 13, six early in the third quarter.
54:05That ball to McBride falls incomplete. The block, the punk gets blocked, gives the Broncos the ball at the 40.
54:10And then Harvey goes 52 yards on the screen and the game is essentially over.
54:14And I will say too, that screen call was awesome.
54:17Like I don't, incredible. That's because there Arizona is trying to blitz off the left side, which is the open side of the formation.
54:24So no tight end on the, uh, on that side of the ball.
54:27And they blitz, I think the linebacker and then like whoever the down safety or nickel was, I can't remember who it was.
54:34And they both scream off that side and they throw the screen to Harvey, like right replacing it.
54:38So you now have five players just sprinting at the quarterback.
54:41Harvey has a ton of room to go. And so that was, that's just like a great call in that moment to
54:47catch a defense that, you know, wants to do a bunch of that stuff, catch them on a first and 10.
54:53I thought that was an awesome call. Two other thoughts about that side of the ball before we get to the Cardinals offense versus the Broncos defense.
55:01One, uh, if you want to do this, you have access to it.
55:04Go look at the personnel groupings that the Broncos used in this game.
55:08Um, just the list of it. It's hilarious. It's like a bit that Sean Payton does every single game.
55:13Is it all of them? Yes. So I'm, I'm currently looking at it.
55:16The Cardinals in this game used one, two, three, four unique personnel groupings.
55:20They had 45 plays of 11 personnel, 21 plays of 13 personnel, eight plays of 12 personnel, and then one play out of jumbo for groupings.
55:27Usually like four to five, four to six is like a normal number in any given game.
55:32The Broncos in this game used one, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight, nine, 10 different personnel groupings.
55:37He's just trying to prove a point. I don't know what the point is.
55:41It really is a bit at this point. But yeah, I don't know what exactly he's trying to say, but he's trying to say something.
55:48He does it as a way to keep defenses unsettled.
55:50It's part of their approach offensively. When you just see it laid out like that, it's hilarious.
55:55And then the last part about this, about the offense specifically, Jonah Coleman's a good player.
55:59Jonah Coleman's their best running back. And I think he will be important to this team as they try to figure out
56:05whatever the best version of the offense looks like over the rest of the season.
56:10A hundred percent. Like this has been a rushing offense.
56:12That's been below average success rate for a lot of the season.
56:16And obviously the overall numbers in this game are skewed for their rushing, you know, yards per attempt because the Boenick scramble is ridiculous.
56:22But Jonah Coleman specifically was like an above average runner in this game, which the Broncos have not had for a lot of this season.
56:29And so he can just make them right a little bit, grind out six when four is there, like that sort of thing.
56:35I think that that's going to be huge for them because this is an offense and a quarterback that I really think
56:41needs to stay ahead of the sticks. And if they can do that more consistently, they're going to be in a good way.
56:48Anything about the other side of the ball that you wanted to hit before we got out of here?
56:53I mean, for me, it's the Cardinals had two backup offensive linemen in and it was going to be a rough day
56:59at the office for Jacoby Brissett against this past rush.
57:01And that's exactly what happened. And it was, I think you're now feeling the fact that like this receiving core, I mean,
57:08the amount of like, there were multiple go balls that they were just throwing up to Brooks because you mentioned the one down the right side.
57:15I know for a fact, there was one down the left-hand side where they just chuck one up into double coverage.
57:20I really did feel like all they had was McBride.
57:23I will say I was really impressed. And this is, again, partly against you're playing against a handful of backup offensive linemen.
57:29But I was impressed with a lot of the kind of backup in depth pieces up front for the Broncos, like Savion
57:35Jones, backup interior lineman, has a sack in this game.
57:38I thought Dondra Tillman had a number of really impressive plays, especially as a pass rusher in this game.
57:43And again, that's against backup left tackles. But I just thought that this is a defense where obviously they've got a bunch
57:49of star players, even without Patrick Sertan right now.
57:52But their kind of secret weapon is how deep their front is, both on the interior and on the edge.
57:57And I think that this was a game where you were just reminded that they've got some good players who can do
58:03a lot of good stuff on their second wave.
58:05Jonathan Cooper's back now. And so, I mean, Zach Allen got banged up in this game.
58:10I don't know what the exact prognosis is, but I'm 100% with you.
58:13Q Robinson has contributed this year. Malcolm Roach had a big play in this game.
58:18They've got a bunch of guys that can affect the game.
58:21They really do have two hockey lines of players up front.
58:24And the other one that, when I watch him, I've been really impressed with some of the stuff he's done in space
58:30this season, because we were wondering what it was going to look like with him kind of moving into a full-time role
58:36rather than just being their designated blitzer coming off the second level.
58:39I think Sernod's like a really useful player. He's not putting them in bad positions consistently as like a second level player
58:45with range and coverage in the way that you thought might happen this year.
58:49There is a certain kind of linebacker who you can use in like very specific ways, and he works for you.
58:54And if you can take out the stuff that hurts you and he can at least get to a certain level there,
59:00you can be in a good spot. Like Drake Thomas is this for the Seahawks.
59:05Like he's a very incomplete player, but he is really good at the things that he's good at.
59:09And they do a good job schematically of kind of hiding some of the stuff that he's not great at.
59:15And I think now that it's another year in the system, obviously with Van Joseph, and I will say I continue to
59:21just be so impressed with the way that he calls and teaches this defense.
59:25Like he is just so well coached again, man.
59:27They are awesome at this because again, they're one of the best defenses in the NFL and Patrick Chertan has missed like half the season.
59:34It's unbelievable. It's time, man. It's it's time. He deserves another shot.
59:37They are. It's again, they're missing their best player and they've got some horses up front.
59:42No pun intended. But this is still a group that you look at the way it's coached on the back end and
59:48just the things that they're taking away. It's just so well put together.
59:51And you look at we don't have to get into like the whole Vance Joseph history and like the way that it
59:57went the first time and all that. But I think he is more than justified in getting another crack at this thing,
60:03considering what the Broncos have looked like pretty much since the back half of the 2023 season.
60:08I mean, pretty much everything from the 70 point game and on.
60:11They have been like a really impressive defense, which is it's so funny that he can go from that and like holding the job.
60:18And now he is year over year. One of the best defenses in the NFL.
60:22They finished fourth in defensive DVOA in 2024. They were fifth in 2025.
60:26And now they're currently sitting at fifth again. Seven weeks into the season.
60:29It's been about as consistent as it gets over that period of time.
60:33I mean, even Seattle obviously has just really been the last two and a half years compared to the last three and a half years for the Broncos.
60:40I mean, it's they're really they really stand alone when you think about units that have been that consistently good over that stretch with them and Minnesota.
60:48I mean, those are really the only two teams.
60:50And the Vikings were outside of the top 10 in 2023 before finishing in the top five each of the last two seasons.
60:56So those those two units have been really, really consistent in a way that you just don't often see on that side of the ball.
61:03And so continue to be very impressed with them.
61:06All right. That is all we've got with the week seven hangover.
61:09We will be back tonight. If you're watching this on Tuesday, it'll be last night with our week with our Monday Night Football Recap.
61:16If you're watching this on YouTube, encourage you guys to like and subscribe, do all that fun stuff for now.
61:21That's all we got. Appreciate you guys listening. We'll talk to you very soon.
61:25Thanks for tuning in. Make sure to hit that subscribe or follow button so you never miss an episode.
61:30If you enjoyed what you heard, please like comment and leave a rating.
61:34We'll see you next time.

More episodes from The Athletic Football Show

6