The Athletic Football Show artwork

Week 7 preview: Super Bowl MVP returns, "biblical greed" consequences & deep dive on the Buccaneers defense

STACKED extracted the fantasy-relevant player signal from this podcast and kept the full transcript here for context.

1 hr 27 min
Duration
Estimated from transcript
Oct 23, 2026
Published
Fri, October 23, 2026
42
Player insights
31
Players mentioned
Topics
Brock BowersKenneth Walker IIIAntonio WilliamsJoe BurrowMichael Penix Jr.Rashid ShaheedTee HigginsTerrance FergusonBryce YoungCaleb DouglasCyrus AllenDavante AdamsJa'Marr ChaseJahmyr Gibbs
Player analysis

Player insights

42

Antonio Williams

PositiveRole58:54

The source highlights Antonio Williams as the next receiver taken after Max Clair in the draft, noting he 'has had a nice season for a Washington team that's been going through it' and 'made a couple really nice plays on Monday night football,' indicating he is contributing meaningfully despite being a third-round pick; this contrasts with Clair's lack of production and underscores the Rams' draft mismanagement at receiver.

Insight page
NegativeRole60:00

Antonio Williams is mentioned as context for the Rams' receiver depth; the source notes there are other receivers available in the third round who could have provided more value than some of the Rams' draft choices.

Insight page

Brock Bowers

NegativeRole19:15

Bowers has been used similarly to a wide receiver by the Raiders under Clint Kubiak; the source mentions Bowers as a comparison point for how the Chiefs might use tight ends like JSN against Seattle, suggesting the Chiefs may have studied how the Raiders deployed Bowers in a similar role.

Insight page
PositiveMatchup51:30

Against the Rams' dime package, Bowers is a different beast; he is faster and quicker than the safeties and corners the Rams deploy in dime, and can bully those defenders. The Raiders passing offense is third in EPA per drop-back and 14th in success rate against dime looks, and Bowers' ability to win against both safeties and corners in coverage gives the Raiders a significant advantage in this matchup.

Insight page
PositiveUsage52:30

Bowers is getting the ball on nasty blade-out routes that complement Kirk Cousins' willingness to rip throws to receivers on the outside; Cousins is very aggressive this year when he thinks Bowers is on the out route, creating a strong complement to the Rams' hard inside leverage coverage strategy.

Insight page
PositiveMatchup60:52

Brock Bowers could posterize the secondary if Trent McDuffie doesn't play; the source sees this as a favorable matchup for the tight end.

Insight page

Bryce Young

NegativeMatchup67:30

Young and the Panthers face a difficult matchup against Tampa Bay's defense, which excels at forcing fast throws and defending short over-the-middle routes (second in EPA per drop back on success rate). Carolina's offense rarely throws to the running back against the blitz (3.8% of the time, lowest in NFL by ~2%), so Young will need to either execute over-the-middle throws—which all QBs have struggled with against Tampa—or rely on RPO concepts where Carolina has shown competence.

Insight page

Caleb Douglas

PositiveRole60:08

Caleb Douglas has been decent for Miami even if the numbers aren't crazy because that offense is inconsistent; cited as an example of third-round receiver alternatives the Rams could have considered.

Insight page

Cyrus Allen

NegativeRole15:45

Allen is being used on seam routes and intermediate options for the Chiefs; the source highlights a ridiculous seam ball throw to Allen against the Chargers but questions whether he's the best option for the intermediate middle-of-the-field routes the Chiefs need against Seattle.

Insight page

Davante Adams

NegativeInjury54:00

Adams ruptured his hamstring and is out 6-10 weeks, a significant blow to the Rams' receiving corps that was already struggling. This injury, combined with Kobe Turner's move to injured reserve and Puna Ford's season-ending triceps rupture, has decimated the Rams' offensive weapons.

Insight page

Ja'Marr Chase

NegativeInjury33:00

The source notes that Ja'Marr Chase missed a big chunk of the Jacksonville game and both of the Bengals' receivers were on the injury report against Miami. Chase did play against the Dolphins but was still dealing with injuries. This context is important when evaluating the Bengals' offensive adjustments and personnel usage post-bye week.

Insight page

Jahmyr Gibbs

PositiveUsage23:00

The source emphasizes that the Lions' run game is back and performing at a high level, even without their starting center. The Lions' zone and gap run schemes are executing well, with particular praise for how they use gap blocking where guards wash people down and Penei Sewell down blocks to allow the running back to kick out the end. The source believes if the Lions can pop three to four explosive runs against the Packers' gettable run defense, they will take control of the game and keep the Packers out of pure pass scenarios.

Insight page

Jalen Hurts

NegativeRole17:30

The source mentions Jalen Royals in the context of the Chiefs' receiving options and whether he can help attack the Seahawks' defense in intermediate areas; the source suggests Royals probably won't be a significant contributor in this matchup.

Insight page

Jalen Jackson

NegativeRole32:37

The source notes that Jalen Jackson 'lost his cool completely in addition to a host of other problems he's had,' but clarifies that 'he will be back though like he's the suspension is over,' indicating he has faced behavioral issues and suspension but will return to the team.

Insight page

Jalen Royals

NegativeRole17:30

Royals is unlikely to be a meaningful contributor for the Chiefs against Seattle; the source questions whether he can help attack the Seahawks' defense in the intermediate areas and concludes 'Probably not.'

Insight page

Jaxon Smith-Njigba

NegativeMatchup18:38

The source examines how the Chiefs defense under Steve Spagnuolo will scheme against JSN in Week 7 against the Seahawks. The Chiefs are expected to press JSN at the line to disrupt timing, though the source notes this may be less effective than it was against Brock Bowers because JSN's superpower is his ability to get off contact at the line of scrimmage early in routes, making him trickier to get hands on compared to Bowers who separates later in the down against press coverage.

Insight page

Joe Burrow

NegativeRole36:00

The source examines the Bengals' under center snap usage and Burrow's comfort with the scheme. Burrow has historically shown reluctance to turn his back and throw into the middle of the field from under center, and when the Bengals do run deep drop back under center plays, Burrow immediately balls out to the check down. The source suggests this may be a timing and footwork issue, as shotgun concepts allow quicker shortcuts and access to receivers, while under center requires more time to set up. The source notes Burrow loves to stand back with feet planted in the shotgun, showing little lower body movement, which allows him to be hyper-accurate and always ready to throw.

Insight page
NegativeRole37:25

Burrow's lower-body movement and foot placement from the gun is minimal, which allows him to be hyper-accurate and ready to throw; however, this rigidity also makes him vulnerable when pushed outside the pocket. The source notes that under-center play action has been explored but hasn't yielded results, and that Burrow's predictable personnel usage (Mike Gesicki on field correlates with pass plays; Eric All in on 73% of rushing attempts) telegraphs offensive intent to defenses.

Insight page

Jordan Whittington

NegativeRole60:32

Jordan Whittington is a 12-snaps-a-game role player when the Rams have all their other players healthy; the source loves what he does for the offense when it's working, but does not like him as much if he becomes wide receiver two, suggesting his value is limited to a complementary role.

Insight page

Josh Jacobs

PositiveRole29:00

The source notes that Josh Jacobs is back for the Packers, which should make the run game more consistent. The source brings up Jacobs in the context of the Packers' potential to be a contender, suggesting that with Jacobs healthy, the Packers' running game may be more reliable going forward.

Insight page

Kenneth Walker III

PositiveUsage2:31

Walker is leading the league in rushing yards with 665 yards through six games, more than Bijan Robinson and James Cook despite playing one fewer game; he's sitting on an absurd start to the season and has driven a huge part of the Chiefs' schematic transformation, with Kansas City now leading the NFL in run action percentage (combining play action and run rate) after being 28th last year.

Insight page
PositiveMatchup2:31

Walker faces the Seahawks, his former team that didn't want to pay him in free agency; Seattle has not allowed a 100-yard rusher since October 27, 2024, setting up a classic matchup between the Chiefs' transformed running game and the Seahawks' elite run defense.

Insight page
NegativeMatchup21:00

The source notes that even with Charbonnet coming back from injury, the Seahawks' run game faces a tough matchup against Kansas City's strong run defense. The Chiefs have a better rushing success rate and rush defense than the Seahawks, with Minnesota leading the pack in almost everything but Kansas City's run defense having been fantastic this year. The source questions whether Charbonnet's return will make the necessary difference right out of the gate.

Insight page

Lamar Jackson

PositiveInjury32:30

The source reports that Lamar Jackson is back at practice as of Thursday, which makes the Bengals-Ravens Week 7 matchup much more compelling. The source describes this development as thank God very much something to watch, indicating relief that Jackson is healthy and available for this important divisional game.

Insight page

Malachi Fields

NegativeRole60:08

Malachi Fields is cited as an example of receivers available in the third round who are NFL-caliber players; the source suggests these alternatives could have provided more value than the Rams' draft strategy.

Insight page

Michael Penix Jr.

NegativeProjection45:00

Penix ranks among the worst in the NFL when pressured; his EPA per drop-back under pressure is near the bottom, alongside Aaron Rodgers, Jalen Daniels, Cam Ward, Bo Nix, Baker Mayfield, and Sam Darnold. His pressure-to-sack rate has spiked from 12.4% last year (second-best among full-time starters) to 23% this year, driven by his inability to move in the pocket and lack of off-schedule improvisation. The Falcons are being blitzed on 46.7% of dropbacks, and Penix struggles against aggressive coverage schemes.

Insight page
NegativeRole47:00

Penix is the stiffest starting quarterback in the league in terms of pocket movement; he cannot execute subtle pocket movement like Jared Goff and lacks the flexibility to throw hot over blitzers when defenses send seven or eight on the line of scrimmage. Dennis Allen's blueprint (sending seven and daring Penix to throw over the top) has exposed this weakness, and Penix is not nimble enough to mitigate pressure through movement.

Insight page

Patrick Mahomes

PositiveMatchup13:33

Mahomes is well-equipped to attack the Seahawks' defense in the zero-to-five yard range, where Seattle allows an 87% completion rate by design; the source notes Mahomes is 'the quarterback in the league best equipped to attack exactly those things' with quick, accurate, and decisive throws in tight windows, and is also dangerous scrambling outside the pocket.

Insight page

Puka Nacua

NegativeRole55:30

With Terrence Ferguson still out, Nakua is being forced into 11 personnel alongside Mumpfield, Atwell, and Jordan Whittington—a significant downgrade from the Rams' intended receiving corps.

Insight page

Rashee Rice

NegativeInjury15:45

Rice is expected to return at some point but his game is not suited for the intermediate middle-of-the-field routes the Chiefs need against Seattle; the source notes that even when Rice comes back, he won't fill the void left by Taequan Thornton's injury in generating explosive plays.

Insight page

Rashid Shaheed

NegativeUsage10:44

Shaheed is getting only two catches per game for the Seahawks, which the source describes as 'the tough part' of the Seahawks' offensive situation; the source expresses frustration that despite investing significant money in Shaheed, the offense is not getting enough production from him in the passing game.

Insight page
NegativeRole10:44

The Seahawks' decision to invest in Shaheed over Kenneth Walker has become a point of contention; the source notes that for roughly the same money given to Shaheed, Seattle could have had Kenneth Walker and Denzel Boston instead of Jadari Price, Bryce, and Shaheed, illustrating the opportunity cost of the receiver investment.

Insight page

Sam Darnold

NegativeMatchup20:02

The source identifies Sam Darnold as a critical weakness for the Seahawks offense in Week 7 against Kansas City. Darnold is dead last in the NFL in EPA per drop back when pressured per Next Gen Stats, performing in a league of his own negatively. The Chiefs are expected to attack this weakness by pressuring the quarterback rather than focusing solely on JSN, as the Seahawks' pass protection is not great and Darnold is struggling to process the offense when under duress.

Insight page

Tanner Hudson

NegativeUsage34:00

The source notes that the Bengals' under center play action passing game has not been explosive, with easy completions being spitting the ball in the flat to Tanner Hudson. These are easy completions that become like little things tacked onto the side of the offense rather than central to the offensive identity.

Insight page

Ted Hurst

NegativeRole60:20

Ted Hurst for the Buccaneers has done some stuff; cited as an example of third-round receiver alternatives the Rams could have considered.

Insight page

Tee Higgins

NegativeInjury33:00

The source notes that both of the Bengals' receivers, including Tee Higgins, were on the injury report against Miami. Higgins played against the Dolphins but was still dealing with injuries, which affected the Bengals' personnel usage and offensive approach in that game.

Insight page
PositiveUsage43:00

Higgins is catching significantly more intermediate play-action dropbacks (10-19 air yards) than historically observed; Burrow ranks 7th in EPA on these plays with 23 such passes in the upper third of the league, and Higgins is receiving a larger share of these targets than anecdotally expected.

Insight page

Terrance Ferguson

NegativeInjury55:30

Ferguson still isn't back, forcing the Rams' 11 personnel to be Puka Nakua, Mumpfield, Atwell, and Jordan Whittington—a significant downgrade from their intended receiving corps.

Insight page
NegativeInjury58:30

The source mentions that Terrence Ferguson got hurt, which forced the Rams to adjust their tight end usage; despite Ferguson's injury, the source notes the team 'still could have played 13 personnel with the guys that they had,' suggesting adequate depth at tight end even with Ferguson unavailable.

Insight page

Ty Simpson

PositiveProjection57:53

The source characterizes Simpson as a lottery ticket quarterback pick, with the speaker joking that 'Ty Simpson is the prince who was promised and his song will be the song of ice and fire,' suggesting optimism about his potential despite the Rams' receiver depth issues; the source is willing to 'buy the lottery ticket on the quarterback' and states 'I like Ty Simpson,' indicating confidence in his upside even as the team struggles at receiver.

Insight page

Xavier Worthy

NegativeMatchup16:16

Worthy had a nice game doing receiver work against the Chargers but will face a much tougher assignment against Seattle; the source notes Seattle's defense will make it 'really, really difficult' for Worthy and it will be 'a physical afternoon' for the Chiefs' receivers.

Insight page

Zach Charbonnet

NegativeInjury10:03

Charbonnet is due back for the Week 7 Chiefs-Seahawks game; the source notes the Seahawks were supposed to have both Jadari Price and Charbonnet available but got unlucky with Price's injury, forcing them to lean more heavily on Emmanuel Wilson and George Helani.

Insight page
Full transcript

Episode Transcript

963
0:00Welcome to The Athletic Football Show brought to you by the U.S.
0:03Bank Smartly Visa Signature Card. I'm Robert Mays. The Week 7 preview is here.
0:07Me, Dave Helman, Derrik Klassen. Game of the week between the Seahawks and the Chiefs hit one thing from four other games.
0:13Went under the hood with the Bucs offense. A lot of good stuff on this one.
0:18Let's dig into the Week 7 preview with me, Dave and Derek right now.
0:22It's the Week 7 preview here on The Athletic Football Show.
0:25We're going to hit five games at the top.
0:27That includes a game of the week treatment for Chiefs Seahawks and that is what we're going to dig into first.
0:33Really don't need to set this one up right.
0:36We have the Super Bowl champions going against the team of the decade that's currently undefeated.
0:40Is that juicy enough for you? I love it.
0:43I love an old AFC West rematch to like, you know, the kids don't know this was a division rivalry at one point in time.
0:50We did not point this out in real time last week because we were distracted by a lot of other things about the game.
0:56We did not mention the fact that Seahawks Broncos, the beauty of the uniform matchup.
1:00Fantastic. Oh, it's a perfect matchup. Why are we doing this all the time?
1:04We just need to be doing way more of this and the Chiefs uniforms don't need any.
1:09We don't need throwbacks for the Chiefs like the Chiefs are very classic, but imagine that blue against this Chiefs red and
1:15just thinking about old school AFC West days. We need more of that.
1:19It would pop. But yes, this is very little explanation needed.
1:22I really don't even know what I'm going to do with the Chiefs.
1:25I'm going to be a little bit more of that.
1:28I'm going to be a little bit more of that.
1:31I'm going to be a little bit more of that I'm going to be a little bit more of that.
1:37I'm going to be a little bit more of that I care that the Seahawks record is probably not as good as
1:43you would have guessed going into this. This is still a very talented team and narratively the Super Bowl MVP going back
1:49to Seattle leading the league in rushing looking like a freaking superstar.
1:52Kenneth Walker sitting on 665 rushing yards. He's got more than Bijan and James Cook playing one less game.
1:57I get just absolutely absurd start to the season.
2:00And of course, not only is it his old team, the one that didn't want to pay him in free agency.
2:06Seattle Seahawks have not allowed a 100 yard rusher since October 27th of 2024.
2:10And so what gives a very classic what gives game the Chiefs running game or the Seahawks defense.
2:15Let's start with the narrative part of that. I'm curious where you guys land on what the conversation has looked like around
2:21all of this this week, because understandably, you have a Chiefs running game that looks incredible and has truly transformed what the
2:27Chiefs offense feels like we'll figure out quality over a 17 game span.
2:31But when you look at approach, the Chiefs lead the NFL in run action percentage, which is a next gen stack combining play action rate and run rate.
2:38They're number one in the league. They were 28th last year.
2:41Like it is truly the single biggest seismic shift schematically of any unit in the NFL, arguably from last season to this one.
2:48And Kenneth Walker has driven a huge part of that.
2:51And it's working. And then you look at what Seattle is right now and their inability to run the ball and having
2:57that be the starting point for everything else kind of falling into place within this offense.
3:01I think you could make a really solid argument.
3:04That's why it's felt so uneven when we've seen Sam since we've seen Sam Donald get back.
3:08And so Derek, are you in a place where you're looking at the sliding doors moment of the Chiefs or the Seahawks
3:15just allowing Kenneth Walker to leave as a mistake?
3:17Is it just something that is the cost of doing business?
3:20You can understand at the moment. Because there's been a lot of I can't believe the Seahawks chose Rashid Shaheed over Kenneth
3:26Walker type takes this week, which it's obviously more complicated than that.
3:30But I'm just wondering where you guys land with this.
3:32I mean, it does feel like and we talked about this in the moment, like with the draft, when you let somebody
3:38like Kenneth Walker go knowing that your other running back, Zach Charbonnet was coming into the season injured.
3:43You kind of like pin yourself in terms of what you can do with the 32nd pick.
3:48And there were a lot of good players that went after that pick that I think that would have been more helpful for the offense.
3:55And I think the other thing, too, the Seahawks offense last year really was the tale of two offenses for the first half of the season.
4:02Teams thought it's a Kubiak offense. They're going to run outside zone.
4:06Let's load the box and really make them do that way.
4:09And then it turns out JSN is the best receiver in football.
4:12And so we're going to start playing defense a little bit differently.
4:15Well, now defenses can play them a little bit like that.
4:19They can play the cloud stuff, keep JSN as much of a cover on it as they can.
4:24But the Seahawks can't punish teams in the run game the way that they were down the stretch with Walker, especially in the playoff run.
4:30And so I think you're just seeing that spiral into a lot more of Sam Darnold has to take on more of the burden as a quarterback.
4:38And even if you can thread a needle for what the Sam Darnold offense can be, it will never be that.
4:44And so they really should have, I think, thought about what it was going to mean for the offense if they lost the run game.
4:51Obviously, they got unlucky with the price injury, but still.
4:54That's where I land is. They were supposed to have Jadari and Price and they don't.
4:58And you could argue knowing Charbonnet wasn't going to be available.
5:01Maybe you do a little bit more than Emmanuel Wilson and George Helani to ensure yourself at that position.
5:06But Charbonnet, there weren't really a lot of guys available.
5:09It was such a weird year. There weren't many free agent running backs.
5:13It was really just like Tyler or Algier. And then there were no guys available in the draft.
5:18And maybe that should inform your thinking. They took one of the best ones.
5:22It's six games, right? Like the idea of, well, they made a mistake by not doing this.
5:26Kenneth Walker has an $18 million cap hit next year.
5:29Kenneth Walker is going to touch the ball like 400 times this year.
5:33There is a chance that that is not a long-term sound investment by the Chiefs.
5:37It may be. He looks incredible. But we can't make declarations about this stuff six games into the year.
5:42If the Seahawks hadn't played the stupidest game in the world against Washington and they were 4-2.
5:47And then the second stupidest game in the world after they played the Broncos.
5:51I really feel like the magnifying glass is going to be on them because they're the defending champions.
5:56And the guy they let walk is incredible. And that, I mean, that sucks for them.
6:00But I'm really not worried about the Seahawks at all.
6:03Charbonnet is due back for this game. Price will be back at some point.
6:07And I think this is going to stabilize and be fine.
6:10And more than anything, and I know. I think I'm a little bit more hesitant about it than that.
6:15I don't know if stabilize and be fine is where I would go.
6:19I'm not really worried yet because I do think that the lack of a run game is fueling a lot of this.
6:25But the idea that it'll be fine, I'm not sure I'm quite there yet.
6:29I that is the benefit of winning the Super Bowl.
6:32It'll probably be fine. Like I'm I need way more to be worried about it.
6:36And like I know Abe Lucas got torched against Denver on Thursday night.
6:40And yeah, like it's not all pretty. And what I was going to say is.
6:44I wish I was getting more than two catches per game from Rashid Shahid.
6:48That's the tough part of this. It is tough.
6:50And it's more complicated than they chose one over the other.
6:53But if you just stack up two potential timelines for the Seahawks, they could right now.
6:58And I know it's not as simple as this, but just like let's play here.
7:02You could right now, if you were Seattle for the same money, essentially that you gave to Rashid Shahid, you could have
7:08Kenneth Walker and Denzel Boston instead of Jadari and Bryce and Rashid Shahid.
7:12Oof, that hurts. I mean, you that that could have happened.
7:15You can't bank on that. You can play that game with them.
7:18Maybe they pick a different receiver. You absolutely can.
7:21But I'm just saying, like, if you look at the doors and the choices and what they could have done and the
7:27alternatives, like I can understand being a Seahawks fan and being a little bit frustrated, even if we shouldn't be making declarative
7:33statements about this stuff after six games. But we don't even know what their preferred build looks like.
7:38Like we barely got Price and we didn't see him with Charbonnet.
7:41And they're not going to be the best offense in the league.
7:44But I just I think this will be fine.
7:47And you're probably right. Fine is open to interpretation.
7:49Like, are they going to look as great as they did in the first half of last year?
7:54To me, it's good enough to win the Super Bowl.
7:57Do you clear the bar where your offense is good enough for you to win the Super Bowl?
8:02And I think that's that to me is the most compelling argument on the other side of this is that, yeah, in
8:08terms of optimization and again, they don't value running back that way.
8:12They would if they had even offered Walker the same deal as the Chiefs did, he probably would have taken the Chiefs
8:18deal based on, you know, stuff that Michael Sean Dugar said to me and on this show.
8:23So it's more complicated than all of that. But I think that's the thing that's hard here.
8:27Knowing you're in a championship window and knowing what Walker would have given you, you could have afforded to keep him.
8:33And does that just give you peace of mind and certainty about what the offense looks in the short term when in
8:39the short term you are a Super Bowl contender?
8:42I think that's like that's the pushback I'd give to the overall big picture machinations that are happening here.
8:47And I will say, I think Kenneth Walker landed in the perfect spot to make them look dumb.
8:52Because we said this going into it, like I loved what this fit could have been for the Kansas City offense.
8:58And I think we've seen all the cascade effect.
9:00I mean, just what you talked about with the run action, them going from that not really being part of the offense.
9:07And now they are leading the NFL in it because they can be explosive, because teams are scared of what they're going to do with Kenneth Walker.
9:14This really was like the perfect situation for them to make them look as dumb as possible for having let him walk.
9:20I guess they have a late buy. Their buy is week 11.
9:24Let me hang out until then and see what this looks like.
9:27If Charbonnet is coming back this week and I anticipate Price won't be gone too much longer than he has been already,
9:33I'm just, I'm not ready to panic. And it's a valid point that they're in a Super Bowl window, so you can't
9:39just hand wave starting three and three. But it's a long season.
9:42It's a juicy topic. It's the only reason. Especially this week.
9:46I just think it's a worthwhile conversation, even if I'm not even close to being where some people are in hammering them
9:52for doing it the way that they did it.
9:54But why I think that for this game specifically, whether Seattle can slow him down is important, is that it potentially pushes
10:00the Chiefs into a version of the offense where you're really having to rely on the drop back passing game.
10:06And we talked about it. I mean, this is a team that's used a ton of play action this year.
10:11And Derek, it was funny when I was going back and watching the Chiefs over the last couple games to prepare for this conversation.
10:18And you watch all the elements of the offense where they're under center play action in a way that they never were before.
10:24But at the same time, there's still a ton of RPO.
10:28They're letting the quarterback really do a lot of operating from the shotgun because he's Patrick Mahomes.
10:32And you look at the combination of all of it.
10:35And where I landed, I was like, oh, yeah, this is actually kind of similar to the conversation we've been having about the Panthers all season.
10:42How the Panthers offense is this weird mishmash of shit when it actually in reality, the Chiefs are kind of doing the same thing.
10:49And so it's that was it was just funny because we when we've talked about the Panthers, it's like they kind of
10:55seem like this weird thing that's hanging out over here that no one else plays like this.
11:00But the Chiefs kind of play like this, even if the ratios are slightly different.
11:04I think in terms of like some of the output rights are a little bit different.
11:08Like Carolina gets their explosives because they have two skyscraper receivers and the quarterback is pushing the ball.
11:13And the Chiefs were pushing the ball before Taekwondo Thornton went down, but maybe won't be able to now, whereas the Chiefs,
11:20their explosives are in the run game. Panthers, it's really not.
11:23But in terms of like if you're just looking at formationally, some of the RPOs that they're throwing, the areas of the
11:29field that they're trying to attack, what they're letting the quarterback do, it's not that different in terms of the construction of
11:35it all, which is again, it is funny that we were like the Panthers are such this grab bag.
11:40And I do think it's cool that the Chiefs have arrived here because the Chiefs have been a team for a while
11:46where it's like, I think they've wanted to be under center and like they've definitely toyed with it on and off for seasons.
11:53But this is the first time in a while they've had a running back where it's like, oh, defenses are actually scared
11:59of us being in looks like this because of what he can do.
12:02Just as a starting point for some of the numbers in this conversation, the Seahawks are allowing five yards per attempt and
12:09negative 0.35 EPA per drop back against under center play action drop backs this year per next gen.
12:14Like it's just been a non-starter. It makes sense.
12:16Just think about the areas of the field you're trying to attack, like the movement that you're trying to get from second and third level defenders.
12:23The Seahawks are content to just say like, we can slow play the run up front because we got glass eating dudes.
12:29Like you're not going to hurt us this way.
12:32And so if they, if the Chiefs struggle to run the ball efficiently, if the under center play action game is not
12:38something you can lean on against this team, what does the approach on offense look like?
12:42And if you watch the Chiefs and just the way the Mahomes is willing to operate, a lot of the under center
12:49stuff this year, especially against man coverage, because that's been a concern for the Chiefs for a while.
12:54It's a lot of crossers, right? Like we're going to have our guys running away from people horizontally.
12:59It's a lot of things underneath and it's a combination of that and stretching horizontally with some of the motions.
13:04And we've seen if you can create those windows, those windows can exist against the Seahawks.
13:09You can create them within five yards of the line of scrimmage and within the first half a second of the play.
13:15Which quarterback in the league is better equipped to attack exactly those things than Patrick Mahomes and especially the way that Patrick Mahomes is currently playing?
13:22The Seahawks this year, 87% completion rate on throws between zero and five air yards.
13:26That's by design, right? Like that's how they want to play.
13:29You just have to be willing to one, not get bored with it and two, be really quick, accurate and decisive in how you're attacking it.
13:36And that's exactly what you get out of Patrick Mahomes.
13:39So most games, I'm not really interested in what's happening in that zero to five yard range.
13:44Like I don't really care. In this game, I think it's probably the most important area of the entire field.
13:50It's very rare that the like the note, they call it the no cover zone, especially for defenses like this.
13:55We're like, yeah, the point is that we're going to let you throw it.
13:59But I do think part of the beauty of Patrick Mahomes over the last few years is he's fine being bored and
14:05the offense is fine being bored because eventually they will get into a couple of scenarios where they can do that.
14:11And like, to me, it's not even just that Andy Reid and the offense and the quarterback are really good at attacking one to five.
14:18I think Patrick Mahomes is also good at getting the ball to the back when he needs to.
14:23And that is something that Seattle doesn't really handle all that well.
14:26And Seattle can be up and down if the quarterback can run around a little bit and scramble.
14:31And Patrick Mahomes, when he's at his best, is as dangerous as anybody at that outside of like maybe Josh Allen.
14:37And so even if there are, you look at the Chiefs receiving core and what Seattle can do down the field, defending
14:43down the field, you're like, man, I don't know if this is a good matchup.
14:47But they kind of are, Mahomes and the Chiefs are like the perfect quarterback and team right now to be like, we
14:54will win this game eight yards at a time.
14:56There is another element to that that I think is really interesting, though, and it's just the Chiefs receivers executing.
15:02You know, like, I mean, get open. If you're open, that's great.
15:05I cannot help but think about the San Francisco game that we just watched where Mike Evans made so many clutch plays for the 49ers in that game.
15:13He also got mauled doing it. So that's it's funny because I think that when I was looking at the Chiefs receiver
15:19injuries and I thought, what do they need in the long term to get this thing over the hump and be like
15:25really viable by the end of the season? My first thought was they need somebody that can replace what Taequann Thornton's skill
15:31set is because he'd been so important in them generating explosives.
15:34In this game, I think to me it's a do you have somebody that can be an option in the intermediate middle
15:40of the field on exactly the types of things you're talking about?
15:44Because even when Rice comes back, that's not his game.
15:46And so I still feel like they could use one more guy that is just viable in those areas.
15:52Like Mahomes rips that seam ball to Cyrus Allen against the Chargers, which is a ridiculous throw.
15:56You can't these guys can do it. I just wonder, is there a better option for right now on those sorts of routes?
16:03Because if it's not Cyrus Allen, who is it?
16:05Because it's not Xavier Worthy or Rashid Rice, in my opinion.
16:08We keep saying the Niners should trade back for Juwan Jennings.
16:11I don't think if he gets traded, I don't think that this is like a bad Juwan Jennings team.
16:17They do not have like an option like that.
16:19I think that that could kind of work. I worry about that for this game where, I mean...
16:24It's totally fair. Xavier Worthy is a great example, which I thought Xavier Worthy had a nice game doing real receiver stuff
16:30against the Chargers for the most part. But Seattle's going to make that really, really difficult.
16:35And it's going to be like a physical afternoon.
16:37How do you hold up doing that? I think the last point, just about the way that the Chiefs have been approaching
16:43this, because of the guys can't really get off of man coverage on third down.
16:48It's not what they are. They've used a lot of motion on third down, and they've been very good at that.
16:54And so getting guys in stacks and bunches off of motion, getting guys on the move, creating strain against zone defenses by doing that.
17:00Like, Worthy should either... If it's third and seven, he should be running a crosser.
17:04He should be doing one of those insert motions on the move and running a deep crosser off of that in order to create strain.
17:11Or he did this against the Raiders of the Chargers.
17:14I think it was the Raiders, where it's third down.
17:17He starts running that shallow that he's run a dozen times this year, and he snaps it back off against the corner for a 12-yard completion.
17:24That's it. That should be the menu. Whether that's enough in combination with everything else in the long term, that still is
17:30the question I have about the Chiefs. And I think exactly what you're bringing up in this game specifically, think about the
17:36offenses that have hurt the Seahawks over the last couple years and what they're willing to do and what they're willing to access or can't access.
17:44It's Stafford just throwing the ball, guys, by Ernest Jones' ear in some of these just really small windows against zone coverage.
17:50Is the Cyrus Allen... What's his first name? Andrew Armstrong.
17:52Andrew Armstrong combination. Is that enough for you to attack those areas in this game?
17:57Jalen Royals do anything for you? Probably not. That collection, we probably need an upgrade again, even when Rasheed Rice gets back.
18:03It sounds weird because I'm not emotionally invested in the outcome of this game.
18:07And it's nothing personal against Kenneth Walker, but I kind of hope Seattle can hold him in check because I just...
18:13Just as an experiment. I want to see what this Chiefs offense looks like if they're not getting 150 rushing yards.
18:18And I know all my fantasy teams don't care to see that outcome.
18:22Yeah, that's fair. Or don't care to explore that reality, but I get why you're interested in it.
18:27And I know that the Dolphins technically did that.
18:30This is clearly a different beast than Miami. I don't know.
18:33I know. Groundbreaking analysis, I know. Seahawks, Dolphins, I think, similar in terms of overall defensive quality.
18:37Totally. Derek, what is the one thing you're watching in this game?
18:41You alluded to it a little bit before, some of the JSN stuff, but let's talk a little bit more about that.
18:47What is the number one thing you were keeping an eye on with this one?
18:51I just kind of want to see what Steve Spagnuolo's plan is for JSN.
18:55And it's kind of convenient that earlier this year, they played the Raiders and Clint Kubiak and Brock Bowers, who they've kind
19:01of used him as similarly as you can to a wide receiver like JSN.
19:05And so I came into this being like, okay, are the Chiefs maybe going to have Montserrat, Elaine, or Noel Williams follow?
19:11Are they going to play a bunch of cloud coverage, which teams have been just spamming against the Seahawks this year, obviously.
19:17Are they going to pressure Sam Darnold? And I think they have been a team, Steve Spagnuolo in the past has run a lot of cloud coverages.
19:25They're really not doing it this year, because I think they want to be a little bit more of a press sort of team.
19:31And so they have not been doing that. We're back to FU Chiefs.
19:35Yes, we are. And I do think that they will probably try to press JSN and disrupt the timing and stuff of it.
19:41I don't think that will work as well as Bowers, but because Bowers can separate later in the down against press, but
19:47you're going to get hands on him at the line of scrimmage.
19:51I do think JSN is a little bit trickier to get hands on early in the route.
19:56One of the best things he does is that ability to get off of contact the line of scrimmage, the superpower of his.
20:02And so I just, I wonder how much, you know, of the press man, press quarter stuff they really want to try.
20:08The big difference, I do think, between what they were doing against the Raiders and what I think they might do in this game.
20:15Against the Raiders, they really did not blitz or pressure the quarterback.
20:18Because I think the way that Kirk Cousins is seeing it right now, the way that the Raiders operate their passing game,
20:24where it's four and five out all the time, the spacing is beautiful.
20:28They're just a good, we can beat the Blitz team right now.
20:31Sam Darnold and the Seahawks are not. Like Sam, I think, is struggling to see it right now.
20:36Their pass protection is not great. This to me feels like a, we handle JSN by getting to the quarterback sort of game.
20:43And so just how they do that, I think I'm really interested in.
20:46Darnold dead last right now in EPA per drop back when pressured per next gen.
20:50And it is, he's in like a league of his own when you look at the numbers currently.
20:55And we alluded to it a little bit in the Walker conversation, but when you look structurally at what defenses are doing
21:01to the Seahawks this year compared to last year, they are 31st in the NFL this year in the percentages of single
21:08high coverages that they're seeing per next gen stats.
21:10It's 39%. It was over 50 last year. It's a 10 percentage point drop.
21:14And a lot of those percentage points have been put into like cover six and cloud coverages.
21:19And so the way that teams are able to approach them is just different.
21:23And so you're asking a lot of the quarterback and just putting so much more on him.
21:27I think you feel the entire offense, just kind of the weight of it.
21:31I think you feel that strain. And that's what you've gotten from the Seahawks offense in this passing game specifically for most of the season.
21:38And it's not likely to get better this week.
21:41Just even with Charbonnet coming back, I mean, you know who's, depending on who you ask, some of the stat services are
21:47different, but depending on who you ask, the Chiefs have a better rushing success rate and rush defense than the Seahawks.
21:53Like Minnesota leads the pack in almost everything, but Kansas City's run defense has been fantastic this year.
21:58And so it's awesome that Charbonnet is back. Is that going to make the difference you need it to right out the gate?
22:04I don't know. The word I was looking for was concertina'd when something folds in on itself.
22:09I don't even know. I don't even, that's, that's much, that's a lot, even for Tafts.
22:13Do you know where I get that term from?
22:16This is the most embarrassing part of this. It's used a lot on the Great British Baking Show.
22:21Okay. When the cake starts to squeeze underneath the weight.
22:24I actually love that show. That's not embarrassing. That's impressive.
22:26My wife's going to be mad at me for not knowing that word.
22:30All right, before we move on, let's take our first quick break.
22:33The NBA season is here. When you turn on the games, turn on The Athletic Live on YouTube.
22:38Become part of the show in the interactive chat, along with hosts, Zach Harper, Kofi Oboa, and The Athletic Slam Dunk NBA staff.
22:45The Athletic Live is presented by Google Gemini. Check it out now and subscribe on YouTube.
22:49All right, let's get to our next game here.
22:52One thing from the Packers and Lions. Derek, this is you, buddy.
22:55The one thing you are watching in Packers-Lions is what?
22:58This Packers defense is playing really well right now.
23:00The coverage is good. The menu is good. Their pressure stuff is good.
23:04Can still move them around in the run game pretty handily.
23:07And I think the teams that, like, when they really want to get four hands on people, some of the gap stuff,
23:13you can move these D tackles, even if they're kind of explosive.
23:16The Lions run game is back, baby. Like, they are back to...
23:20And this is even without their starting center, which we can talk about, because Cade Mays is set to potentially return this week.
23:26That, I think, could be huge for them. Because I think, too, when you look at what the Lions do best in
23:32the run game, their zone stuff is fine, but I think some of the communication has been up and down.
23:38Tate Rattledge is a... He always plays heavy on the combo, so sometimes he doesn't climb to the second level as quickly as you would like.
23:45But when they get into their gap stuff, and you can just have these guards wash people down, and Panay Sewell is
23:51down blocking so that Rattledge can come around the side and just, like, kick out the end, it's really, really impressive.
23:57And this, to me, feels like a game that, for a Packers run defense that I think is gettable in that realm,
24:03this feels like if the Lions can pop three, four explosive runs, they're just going to take control of this game and
24:09keep them out of those pure pass scenarios that have hurt the Lions a little bit this season and are some of
24:15the best stuff that the Packers do right now.
24:18So this, to me, just feels like we've gotten the Lions run game back to where it needs to be.
24:23Can you really go and control a game against a team and a defense that is, like, back into being one of the better units in the NFL?
24:31The offensive line settling for Detroit is just so important.
24:34And there was a moment early in the season we talked about this.
24:38They were banged up, right? You had backups in there, and so that was part of it.
24:42But there was at least, I mean, that Buffalo game was it where it's like, man, are we going to have to do this again?
24:49Where you're just trying to find yourself over the course of the season up front.
24:54The guards, it's still up and down. They're young players and they're both, their play style, I think, lends to a little bit of volatility, both of them.
25:01They're kill shot players. Yes, and that's okay with me.
25:04Like, I'm fine with kill shot players. And I think the Lions obviously already had their bye.
25:09And so there's a little bit of a reset about what we're doing well, what we want to do more of.
25:15And I think I wouldn't be surprised if they leaned into truly just being more of an outside zone team after dabbling
25:21in some other things that maybe Petsing is a little bit more fluent in over the first month of the season.
25:27And why I think it makes sense to do that, not only is that your comfort zone of who you've been as
25:33a team for the last few years, part of the reason I think some of that stuff didn't look great is Scruggs
25:39maybe not being as fluent in some of the mental processing parts of that.
25:43We're like, we're getting into the right runs. We're getting the points right, all of that.
25:47I think there's a chance Mays, even after missing time and being new to the scheme, is better in that area.
25:53And so if you can get on the same page a little bit more often, and you're still bringing like the ass-kicking
25:59element that the rest of the offensive line is, I think there's a chance we haven't even seen the best version of
26:05this thing as we get a little bit deeper into the season.
26:09This was one of the most exciting free agency pickups of the offseason, in my opinion.
26:13And it's easy to put it on the back burner because Mays got hurt during training camp.
26:18And because it hasn't been a glaring, glaring issue.
26:20I think that's also part of it. The Scruggs trade is like, it's kind of, we haven't really talked about it in
26:26the moment because there's kind of a throw-in. It's a really good job by Brad Holmes to get a usable offensive lineman in that deal.
26:33I remember talking about it over the summer and being like, Brad Holmes decided never again.
26:38Like, we're not doing this again. And good for him, man.
26:41And he was right. But for it to be as good as it's been without him and now to plug him in,
26:47I mean, that's so exciting to think about. Hopefully it looks half as good as I've been imagining.
26:52Derek, why do you think the Packers run defense was so good against the Bears, but overall has relatively struggled?
26:58I'm pretty sure they're like 28th in run defense DVOA.
27:00They are very low. I think a large part of that is this, this was just one of those things where backup
27:07quarterback is in for the second week. We kind of know what we're seeing.
27:10We do not respect the passing game and we can just be a little bit heavier.
27:15Like we can, we can kind of just get after the run game and not have to worry so much about making
27:21sure that we're going to be there for the pass.
27:24And so I just, I will say too, I do think their linebackers are starting to play a little bit better as the year is going on.
27:31Like Zaire Franklin, I think has, Dave and I were actually texting about this like a week ago.
27:36I totally agree. He's really settling in. Zaire Franklin was whipping ass against somebody.
27:40I'm drawing a blank on which game it was.
27:43It might've been that Bears game. Because like he was really good in that game.
27:47He's played well. And that's another one where credit to Brian Gunkus to get him for Colby Wooden.
27:52And then Colby Wooden gets cut by the Colts.
27:54So you essentially got him for free more or less.
27:57And he's been a good player for you. You felt that.
28:00Two more points on Packers Lions. One, sounds like Brian Branch is going to be back.
28:05Kelvin Shepard came out this week and said, it's going to be a feel thing in terms of how much he's going to play.
28:11But the reinforcements are coming for this Lions team in important areas.
28:15And which brings me to an on-the-spot question I'm going to ask both of you guys.
28:19Both of these teams, do you think these teams are like real contenders in the NFC?
28:24Like, can you see a path for either, for both of these teams by the time we get to like December 15th?
28:30It's like, oh yeah, that team could win the NFC.
28:33I'm biased because I picked the Lions to have a great season.
28:36Like, I picked the Lions to, I think I picked them to get to the Super Bowl.
28:41And a lot of it was the schedule, but the infrastructure here, particularly on offense, like it's easy to get excited about
28:47the offensive line, the quarterback, the skilled players. And we don't have to rehash off-season conversations, but if the defense can just
28:53not be on fire, then this could be a pretty good team.
28:56And they have not lived up to that to this point in the season.
29:00Brian Branch coming back, I'm not going to get too optimistic.
29:03I'm worried the defense could be bad enough to sink them, but it's easier for me to talk myself into this offense
29:09being like the best in the league and driving everything.
29:12Whereas, do the Packers have the gear to reach that level consistently?
29:15Like, can, even if you have some insane games like the Bears game, and they had moments against the Cowboys that would
29:22have looked better if they hadn't dropped some touchdowns, but like, can the offensive line in the running game be good enough
29:28for it to get to that level? That's the other part of this.
29:31Josh Jacobs is back now. And so, you would assume that the run game may be just a little bit more consistent for the Packers.
29:38And I think, why I bring up the Packers in that conversation is that it does feel like there's a vacuum of
29:44like second and third tier teams that really do have a shot.
29:48And if you're one of those teams where the quarterback is playing really well, and in the Packers case, they've cobbled together
29:54the defense enough, like, I don't know. I just feel like each of these teams where two weeks ago, we were asking
30:00some really big existential questions about them. For both of them, I'm kind of like, I don't know, man.
30:05They might just be good. Like, they might just win the division and be an 11-win team and be really scary by
30:11the time we get to the end of the season.
30:14Both of them. Even knowing how much we all like the 49ers and what a wagon they look like, what else in
30:20the NFC is making you feel like it's not your year?
30:23You know? And the Niners are... I feel like there's a half dozen teams.
30:27Yes. Other than the Niners, there's like a half dozen teams that if you told me they met the Niners in the
30:33NFC Championship, I'd be like, I mean, like, why not them?
30:36And I do think the Packers and Lions are them.
30:39Famous last words. I think so highly of the Niners.
30:42I'm not trying to shit on them, but like, they don't impress me the way that some other like great teams have
30:48impressed me to this point in the season. Oh, I don't know about that.
30:52I think the only... I would push back on that.
30:55If Mike was healthy, I would say they do.
30:57That's my concern. That's my concern. That's a very real point.
31:00It's not about... That's a fair, yeah. I think that my pushback to that would be what they've looked like is that
31:06sort of team, whether they can sustain being that sort of team because of all the injuries, that's an entirely different question.
31:13But what they've looked like, but it's just period so far, I mean, it's the same kind of deal with, well, the Packers have cobbled this together.
31:20The Niners defense has looked so, so good on top of what the offense is giving you.
31:25If you told me right now that Mike Evans would be the version of Mike Evans in the Super Bowl that we
31:31have watched so far and everything else about the Niners would stay the same, I think I would say they are like a truly special team.
31:38But now we're down to like wide receiver six.
31:41That's concerning to me. In 2023, I remember feeling like, what are we even playing the games for?
31:46Like the Niners and the Lions that year were obviously really good too.
31:49And it's not to say this team isn't great, but I don't see the Niners.
31:53If I'm the Lions or the Packers, I don't see the Niners and I'm like, I don't know how we're going to beat that.
32:00Like I would be like, yeah, I'll take my chances that we can get this done.
32:05I think that's all teams. I mean, no one's like that good.
32:08Some years just feel more overwhelming to me than others, I guess.
32:11I don't even remember. I don't know the last time I felt like that.
32:15But I think that right now, if you could tell me they're going to stay healthy, I think the Niners are that quality of team.
32:22They've been so, so good so far this year.
32:25But whether they can, I think is a very real question.
32:28The durability is baked into it, unfortunately. It just is.
32:30Let's get to our next one here. Bengals at Ravens.
32:33Dave, this is you, buddy. The one thing you were watching in Bengals-Ravens is what?
32:37It's worth saying Lamar Jackson is back at practice as of Thursday, and so that is thank God very much something to
32:44watch and makes this game so much juicier. But we prepped these shows on Tuesday.
32:48And so... You're ahead of it more than I am.
32:51I prepped these shows on Tuesday. So, of course, I'm watching Lamar Jackson, but I'm really curious about what the post-buy Bengals look like.
32:57And that is, it's such a hot topic of conversation because everybody wants to know which way they're trending.
33:02And the under center stuff has been a hot topic of conversation.
33:06They ticked all the way down to like 17% under center snaps in week four, and they were at about 20% in their last game against Miami.
33:13And what does that mean for the rest of the season going forward?
33:17Because we spent so much time and energy talking about how big of a piece of the offense is this going to be?
33:23Are they going to scrap it at the bye week when they self-scout?
33:27And what's the reality of that? And how does this team want to play?
33:31Because when you have a five, when you have a week six by, it's just a hilariously small sample size to try
33:37to figure out what they actually want to do.
33:39And Jamar Chase missed a big chunk of the Jacksonville game.
33:43Both of their receivers were on the injury report against Miami.
33:46T and Jamar played against the Dolphins, but still dealing with injuries to both of those guys.
33:50Their tight end usage ticked way, way up against the Dolphins.
33:53They were running a ton of 12 personnel. So what is this exactly?
33:57Was the under center stuff all talk? Are they going to scale it down a little bit?
34:02Are they going to lean into more elements of it?
34:05I really don't know. And I feel like now we start to answer this question of what the Bengals offense is going to look like.
34:11My gut feeling is that what we saw in the Dolphins game is indicative of what it might look like moving forward.
34:18And I think it's for this reason. The entire point of going to a more under center play action plays, I think it's a couple different things.
34:25One, that's where a lot of the easy buttons for NFL offenses are.
34:29Right? It just makes things easier. Well, it doesn't make things easier for them.
34:33If you're not good at it, it doesn't make it easier.
34:36If it's not going to make things easier, then that's one strike against it.
34:40The other part of it is it was supposed to make them more explosive in the passing game.
34:45That hasn't happened. The only real completions they're getting off of that stuff are it's a slide route to Eric Hall.
34:50We're spitting the ball in the flat to Tanner Hudson.
34:53It's easy completions. Those are plays worth seeking out, but those just become like little things you're tacking onto the side.
34:59It feels like coming into the year, they wanted the under center stuff to be a central part of the overall offensive identity and approach.
35:06Now, it seems like we're going to get closer to a place where you have to do enough under center passing to
35:12protect your under center run game because that's where there might actually be benefits.
35:16And so it then just becomes a tendency breaker set of considerations rather than this is a pillar of what we are offensively.
35:22And I think we're probably trending in that direction.
35:25I hope they can navigate that because they do feel predictable to me.
35:29They have been. Yeah. The splits aren't great. They get under center to run.
35:32And even when they do play action, they're averaging like four play action snaps a game.
35:37But that might be enough. I hope so. That might be enough.
35:40If you're doing it four times a game, I think it's about getting from a place where it's 80-20 to closer to like 65-35.
35:47And is that enough to make sure that if you look at stuff that this is a weird comparison, but there are
35:53like the Bears or I look at the Bears with this stuff because they are maniacal about tendency breaking type stuff.
35:59The Bears run the ball out of the shotgun 35% of the time.
36:03If you do one out of every three times in some of these situational things, is that enough to protect yourself?
36:08And I think that is probably the mindset that the Bengals have to adopt when it comes to the under center stuff.
36:14We talked about this in the production meeting and I looked it up.
36:18Per true media, you know how many under center snaps with no play action the Bengals have run?
36:23Zero. None. Yeah. That is the compromise to me.
36:26Do you think that the quarterback is willing to do it?
36:29Because I've posed the issues before like when we've talked about the play action under center stuff and this was even true
36:35of Burrow in college by the way. The year before he broke out it was more of an under center offense and
36:41he didn't look like a superstar first overall pick.
36:43But in the NFL whenever they've tried to do it, my initial thought was like he doesn't like to turn his back
36:50and throw the middle of the field stuff. And I think when you watch them right now when they do the deep
36:56drop back under center stuff, he is immediately like balls out to the check down.
37:00Like that's just what he does. There's part of me now that wonders if it is also a timing issue because like
37:06just like the footwork of timing in the gun versus under center concepts are just different and how you're cycling through stuff is just different.
37:13Like it's when you're in the shotgun, you can shortcut and you can get to stuff quicker when you want to your
37:19base is also underneath you all the time in a way that it's not when you're sprinting back from under center.
37:25Yeah, you're not ready until like two seconds into the play.
37:28He loves to stand back there with his feet planted and just watch him watch how little movement there is in his
37:34lower body when he's playing the position from the gun.
37:37It's very like dead leggy and I think that's one of the things that allows him to always be ready to throw
37:43to be hyper accurate and if you're pushing him outside of that you're taking away some of the stuff that makes him
37:49good but I still think it's a compromise worth exploring because you're allowing him to keep his eyes on the defense but
37:55you're still protecting some of those under center runs.
37:58Whether we see more of it, who knows and maybe it goes poorly the same way the under center play action shit
38:04has but I think it's at least an area you could potentially try to mine to accomplish what we're talking about.
38:10The other thing I'm curious about and this is kind of in the weeds, I mentioned predictability and I don't know if
38:16there's a fix for it with their current personnel and this goes back several years because Mike Gusecki is on this team but their personnel is so predictable.
38:24They have attempted six, they've attempted 28 runs when Mike Gusecki is on the field this year and I think six of those came out of the gun.
38:31So you have a tight end that's going to telegraph that you want to throw the ball.
38:36Eric all is in on 73% of their rushing attempts like it's very it's it's just kind of predictable the way that
38:42they use these guys and the way they bring them in and but that stuff you can check yourself on in the
38:48by right that's exactly that type of stuff you can hopefully check yourself on at the this is the perfect week to
38:55be talking about it because I want to see what it looks like coming out of the by it they they are
39:01not explosive running the ball and and that's why they want to be able to get under center and do it and
39:07so the the two other things I'd bring up as part of this conversation I think are worthwhile one one of the
39:13reasons that I think you might be willing to explore some of the under center play action stuff is to protect the
39:19offensive line right and take fewer sacks well he's already taking fewer sacks and so now you're in a spot where well
39:25we're already taking fewer sacks like let me do this you know and then the other part of it is like the
39:31gun play action stuff I think can potentially be an area for them to tap into to be explosive that was the
39:37Jamar chase touchdown against the Dolphins like the if the part of the reasoning and part of the motivation for the under
39:43center play action was to be explosive down the field but you have enough gun half boot stuff that moves a launch
39:50point and that allows you to push the ball and you can find it somewhere that's just one more reason to just
39:56say you know what this is how we live this is who we are and so I get it like I think
40:02there's a fascinating tension here between trying to do all this stuff because you realize the benefits of it and understanding you're
40:08not getting those benefits so it's probably worth scrapping but at least you tried at least you're not going to get to
40:14the end of this season and say man I wish we would have put more time on task with this in training
40:20camp to see if we could do it because the whole argument for how they approach camp and leaning into it as
40:26hard as they did was if we have to snap back into the other thing we'll be fine well guess what they
40:32have we are it's fine they like they can just do this and so it wasn't wasted time it wasn't a wasted
40:39effort and I think that would be one of the things that would be hard to live with if you if this
40:45stuff wasn't working and when you went back to the other stuff it also wasn't working it is and so now you
40:51can just retreat is maybe an unfair word you can go back into the embrace of the world that you have been
40:57enjoying for a while here if that's what happens and that's fine and I think it's worth saying the Bengals will probably
41:03be fine but if if they just go back to what has worked I'm I don't want to talk about it anymore
41:09I don't want to spend next summer talking about how they might tweet yeah that's that's fine yeah that's fine yeah with
41:15the boy who cried under center yeah we'll just all right Joe you're in the gun it's fine that'll work we don't
41:21have to talk about it Derek just specifically about this matchup one thing about the Ravens defense against this version of the
41:28Bengals offense that interests you I'm putting you on the spot I think that Joe Burrow this year when you've done some
41:34of the coverage switch stuff on him whether it's dropping people off of the line of scrimmage which obviously the Ravens will
41:40do a ton or some of the just funky get into too high pressure stuff I don't think Joe Burrow sees that
41:46like all that well and like we'll tend to take some of the easier options for that the Bucks got him with
41:52an interception this way they got him with a couple actually doing doing that sort of stuff and so I think with
41:58as bizarre as some of the Ravens like in the back end have been with some of that stuff I actually do
42:04think that you could get a couple of plays that way because I will say like the Ravens defensive numbers this year
42:10are not spectacular like they're a mildly above average unit but I think that that's only going to continue to get better
42:17because of how weird some of the stuff that they're doing this just feels like by the time they get to December
42:23I like I trust Jesse Minter they have like five players who are all pros at their best like I just think
42:29that they're going to continue to get better and this to me feels like a game that I think they'll be pretty
42:35good a lot of funky cover two variations in defined past situations and the Browns got him on it last week the
42:41Browns had the right calls in some of those moments to get him on it one thing I do think is worth
42:47mentioning about this version of the Bengals offense because we've talked about this with Burrow and like are they accessing the middle
42:53of the field as often as some of these other teams are with the construction of everything right now okay intermediate play
42:59action dropbacks this season in the hashes and seams 10 to 19 air yards Joe Burrow is one two three four five
43:06six seventh in the NFL in total drop back EPA on those plays and he's thrown 23 of those passes which is
43:12in like the upper third of the league and so they are and with T Higgins and his usage specifically we're just
43:18seeing T Higgins catch a lot more of those balls than anecdotally I remember him doing and so there are enough additional
43:24layers to this and there are enough improvements elsewhere where that would be the frustrating question if you were a Bengals fan
43:30where it's like why does this feel different why will this be different I think the lack of sacks the fact that
43:36they are willing to attack areas the field that they weren't attacking as much of before and the last part of this
43:42that's worth mentioning is what the right tackle is yeah if you if you can just sit there and be like you
43:48have you're one-on-one with TJ Watt the whole game have fun that's an avenue that this offense did not have previously and
43:54so I do think there are enough things that maybe feel a little bit different that we don't have to get back
44:01into a place of it's the same old story with the same old dead ends we'll see but I think you can
44:07tell yourself a story about it it's gone under discussed nationally that Amarius Mims is has grown into what you hoped he
44:13might look like when he was drafted I mean it's truly when you look at that man this is what you dreamed
44:19of is for him developing into this sort of player and it doesn't help that the left tackle is a guy you
44:25kind of got to worry about but when you can spend resources to help that guy because you don't need to help
44:31the right tackle it goes a long way we're getting off track here but I was thinking about this somebody on social
44:37media said he was like the best right tackle in the league and I'm I am not here to rank them right
44:43now but I was just anecdotally thinking I was like well Lane Johnson retired a few weeks ago and Vanessa will move
44:50to left tackle and I'll write a read I mean yes a Darnell right is worth mentioning as well they're very they're
44:56very different players like Darnell white Darnell right is an absolute weapon in the run game he is not the past protector
45:02that Amarius Mims is right now I don't think that's like a controversial thing to say I'm not even an all-pro level
45:08player they're just different types of players my goal is not to rank anybody but I was just thinking about it and
45:14I was like holy shit like he's he's probably higher up the list of right tackles than I would have guessed before
45:20I started thinking about it Darnell right got a holding call last week because he wiped all the man off the face
45:26of the planet so wait that that is he's still capable of doing that before we move on let's take one more
45:32quick break next one here is me Niners at Falcons my one thing I'm looking for in this game is how do
45:39the Niners try to heat up Michael Penix because when you have this year it has not gone very well we mentioned
45:45the stat earlier where Sam Darnold is dead last in the NFL and EPA per drop back when pressured Michael Penix is
45:51down near the bottom the only guys worse EPA per drop back when pressured this year than Michael Penix Aaron Rodgers Jalen
45:57Daniels Cam Ward Bo Nix Baker Mayfield Sam Darnold I mean that's a lot of offenses that we've talked about what is
46:03wrong with this quarterback or what is wrong with the offense and like this is kind of the thing with Michael Penix
46:09because when they played that first game against the Packers they really weren't getting to him like the ball was out really
46:15consistently they were finding guys open they were chucking it downfield and you saw all of what the offense can be when
46:21he's not touched and they're calling the right plays and they're calling throws that really make sense for him and I think
46:28we've seen over the last couple weeks the Bears game specifically Dennis Allen was like we're gonna send seven and we're gonna
46:34dare you to throw over the top of somebody and he just isn't really flexible enough to do a lot of that
46:40stuff consistently it reminds me a little bit of a a madman where they where they had the Jaguar account and Jaguars
46:46are just these like really when they're working they're humming they're like beautiful cars but they break down all the time like
46:52they always have like something wrong with them so Michael Penix is like when when everything's right that thing is purring baby
46:58and then but there's every like week it seems like if you do one thing to it the car is breaking down
47:04everything's not right as often as I would prefer for what I invested in both a Jaguar and a top there's like
47:10a rock in the engine like every time you do something or like maybe a more apt metaphor is like it's a
47:17piece of dust and like a computer chip like some small thing can make this go awry in a way that is
47:23frustrating to me because when it's going well I love watching the guy play but we already know this if you make
47:29him move off his spot he is not a nimble player I think you can make an argument that he's probably the
47:35stiffest starting quarterback in the league right now in terms of movement in the pocket even a guy like Jared Goff who's
47:41not a great athlete the subtle pocket movement that you get from Jared is actually very good at this point in his
47:47career Michael Penix can't do that that was always the case but he was able to mitigate it because even if the
47:53performance under pressure and the off schedule even smiled improvisation stuff wasn't there he didn't take sacks this year he is taking
47:59sacks and so now the negatives are coming from two directions when he gets pressured and I think that's what's made it
48:06a little bit troubling this year he is the fourth highest pressure to sac rate in the league over the last two
48:12years it was 12.4% which only Jordan Love was better among full-time starters this year it's 23% and you feel that and
48:18I think that's driven a lot of those advanced numbers when he gets pressured is that those sacks are happening teams are
48:24and teams are teams know this by the way teams are blitzing him per next gen on 46.7% of the Falcons dropbacks
48:3046.7 so he's more or less turning every defense he plays against into Brian Flores yeah and like because again oh you
48:36gotta crank it up to be Brian Flores let's call it the midpoint between Brian Flores and Deronte Jones there you go
48:42Brian Flores before this year because yeah Brian Flores himself has become something else but yeah and it's he's become something else
48:48he's involved in something we don't understand he's become another Brian Flores they've like stacked two on top of each other the
48:54Penix thing is funny like the end of Redden and Evil yes the the Penix thing is like I think when more
49:01teams were doing blitzes where it wasn't as much mugging the front and we weren't generating as many free rushers and it
49:07was like we're gonna be in more static looks and you're just gonna replace a backer that's firing he's so good at
49:13seeing and throwing that but if you're putting seven or eight on the line of scrimmage and someone's gonna pop free and
49:19the idea is you have to throw hot over them he's just never really been somebody who's good at that and I
49:25think Dennis Allen kind of put a blueprint out this game's interesting because the Niners don't do that a ton but I
49:31think they can like Fred Warner's been blitzing more this year Upton Stout like what Kyler Gordon just did Upton Stout can
49:37do that and so I just I hope they do the Niners can do this and that's my question about this game
49:43specifically we if you guys want to hear like a longer conversation about the Niners defense me and Fran Duffy earlier this
49:50week spent a chunk of that midweek show just talking about what is different about this defense and what we've gotten from
49:56Raheem Morris because it was a question we had in the offseason like what would this version of the Raheem Morris defense
50:02look like the biggest change has been the five-man front stuff that they're using that's also worth mentioning for this game like
50:08the fact that they're willing to get into some of that five down stuff against a very outside zone heavy team in
50:14the Falcons is worth paying attention to when they're in that five down stuff the Niners run defense is significantly better out
50:20of base than it is out of nickel and so I'm curious do we see the Falcons maybe try to get into
50:26lighter personnel to run the ball because of that but the other tweak that we've seen with the defense overall is that
50:32they're willing to bring more pressure they're up over a 30% blitz rate there they haven't been afraid to do that Derek
50:39pointed out with Warner from the start of the season and so by looking at what Dennis Allen did and saying hey
50:45we're gonna try to tap into some of that stuff you really don't have to play against type or outside of yourself
50:51that much to convince yourself in this game against this quarterback this is the right approach like let's heat this guy up
50:57and see if he can take it one more here Rams Raiders our last one Derek your one thing from Rams Raiders
51:03is what yeah this to me is I mean I feel like every time we talk about the Raiders I want to
51:09talk about their offense because it's really cool and so we'll do that a little bit is Bob Bowers your favorite player
51:15in the NFL right now oh man probably not but I think if I had to do a top five he's in
51:21there I think I think if I did a top five he would be in there I still think my favorites are
51:28like I love Fred Warner like Will Anderson Jr some of those players but like you might be my favorite offensive player
51:34actually I'll say that I was I was gonna say like not counting linebackers and people who hurt other people for a
51:40living offensively it's probably like him and Lamar Jackson or am I like I just when those guys are on the field
51:46it's just I feel like I'm watching something special so to that point the Rams defense runs more dime than anybody in
51:52the NFL we knew that going in that's been true for a couple of years now and the Raiders offense their passing
51:58offense specifically has been pretty good up against that and they've they've seen a couple of teams who are willing to do
52:04that the Chiefs do that a lot or can in certain scenarios and the Bills have done that and against those teams
52:10and all the other times they've seen it this year they've been really good they are third in EPA per drop back
52:17and 14th by success rate against those dime looks and this is a Rams defense that it's supposed to be their identity
52:23that they're very good at that and they've been kind of good at it but not elite and I actually think in
52:29a matchup like this where the idea when they go dime they get a little bit bigger they have these safeties who
52:35come onto the field we can match up with your tight ends and stuff like that I think Brock Bowers and Michael
52:41Mayer are kind of a different beast right now like not even just like true yeah like against Bowers like he's faster
52:47and quicker than all of your safeties and guys who you're going to have against him and he's going to go against
52:53the corners as well but like I think he can bully those guys and I will say the one thing I'm curious
52:59about how the Rams put together their coverage menu just outside of the the personnel a lot of teams the last couple
53:05of weeks the Bills really did this and the Chiefs were doing this a little bit they were playing so hard inside
53:12leverage on Bowers saying we are not going to give you the the crosser for free he still gets that nasty blades
53:18out that's the nasty blades out there last week it's like a perfect complement to that and Kirk will throw it like
53:24Kirk is very this year like if he thinks Bowers is on the out he's gonna rip it or or anybody on
53:30the out and so I just I really think that this is a matchup where the Rams dime defense has not been
53:36as good as they want this year and so unless the pass rush really turns it up I just have a lot
53:42of faith in in what this Raiders passing offense can be and this is will be a kind of unique test for
53:48them to go improve that two thoughts regarding that Trent McDuffie not practicing as of Wednesday guess keep an eye on that
53:54as the week goes and Kobe Turner was moved to injured reserve all that as was Puna Ford I mean half the
54:01team so we have to talk about that because we have not really talked about the the doomsday for the Rams came
54:07after we did the conversation on Sunday night I can't remember where I was it might have been on my way home
54:13from the hangover on Monday Derek where I got home looked at my phone and it I got the notification Devante Adams
54:19out six to ten weeks and then I saw the video of McVeigh staring down the barrel of his zoom camera and
54:25he was like yeah Devante Adams ruptured his hamstring he's gonna be out six to ten weeks Kobe Turner we're moving him
54:31to IR and Puna Ford ruptured his triceps he's gonna be out for the entire season and I think I literally said
54:37what the out loud as I like heard that it was just supposed to happen on Sundays yes what the hell I
54:43like I he listed all that off and I was like oh my God and now we're at a place where we
54:50were on Sunday I think all of us collectively are like as has been ugly but are we really in like the
54:56sky is falling full-on panic mode and now you're in a spot where you're receiving core is decimated and we'll talk about
55:02why it feels that way in a second the defensive line is was supposed to be one of the strengths of your
55:08roster you're that has been completely wiped out for the most part the depth you have there miles Garrett still isn't playing
55:14and now I'm at a place where this is gone from very disappointing but they'll probably turn it around to I don't
55:20know man like I've got some very real questions about whether the current state of this roster is going to be able
55:26to pull them out of this nose dive I'd feel a hell of a lot better if I knew when miles Garrett
55:32was going to be available but I I don't and it'll now be I mean six six weeks six weeks that you
55:39haven't had miles Garrett to sort of help elevate everything else that's going wrong on defense and hopefully it's soon but with
55:45each passing week it bothers me a little bit more the offense has already felt out of sorts and now you're in
55:51a place where Terrence Ferguson still isn't back you and we're so now our 11 personnel is going to be Puka Kanata
55:57Mumpfield to to Atwell Jordan Whittington like it I don't know man like I think I'm in a place where I'm genuinely
56:03really worried about this I'm pretty freaked out as well and because this is not like here's I know that I was
56:09like the anti Ty Simpson guy and all that stuff but I said before they even picked the quarterback before they did
56:15that it was like if you are a Super Bowl team you should really be thinking about the depth that certain positions
56:21especially on offense when you think that you have a machine sort of offense because their tackles the sneaky thing about the
56:28the Rams their tackle play has not really been good at any point during them being like a really strong team they've
56:34just been able to stay out never invested in it exactly they had havenstein forever and then they'd sign Whitworth in free
56:40agency they've made they've spent no real draft picks at the position and forever they're the only NFL offense and certainly the
56:46only good one that has a tackle where one was a seventh round picker and undrafted free agent and the other was
56:52a fifth round pick and it's pretty remarkable that that they get passable to good tackle play with what they've spent on
56:58it but it's also part of like why they play a way to make it not matter and they haven't been able
57:04to play that way this year it's it's one of those things where it teeters the fine line of like it's super
57:10impressive they can get away with it and then as soon as it becomes you can't get away with it you're like
57:17oh yeah their tackles aren't very good and so I think we're seeing it this year and I think if they had
57:23drafted whatever tackle you want to put I am not sure Freeling it doesn't really matter to me Lomu I don't really
57:29care if they had done that or drafted any of the receivers at 13 Makai Lemon Denzel Boston whatever it literally does
57:35not matter to me you would have solved issues that were obvious depth problems even before the season and so like honestly
57:41with the D-line stuff like that's unfortunate you did have D-line depth those guys have been really good that's whatever nobody said
57:47going into the season you needed more D-line depth that's right we said before this stuff happened you should probably think about
57:53where we're at at tackle and receiver and now it's it's like season like catastrophe sort of levels for them potentially you
57:59shouldn't be at a place where one receiver injury sends you to the phone and that I think that is exactly where
58:05they are team the Super Bowl favorites should not be in that spot which that's where I I did I differ with
58:12you Derek because Ty Simpson is the prince who was promised and his song will be the song of ice and fire
58:18we're not worried about that and if that pans out then you feel good about it I love how he's doing this
58:24this is very well done by you what bothers me is really okay buy the lottery ticket on the quarterback that's fine
58:30and I would even say Warren McClendon's been fine this year and our Jackson lost his cool completely in addition to a
58:36host of other problems he's had he will be back though like he's the suspension is over tackle is not a five
58:42alarm fire to your point they feel screwed at receiver and they're suddenly had to okay they only had to they had
58:48two and a half with Ferguson their second round pick is a weekly healthy scratch Max Claire good player he is a
58:54healthy scratch well yeah good I should I should have said good college player he's a good college player he's a weekly
59:01healthy scratch for a team that had four tight ends going into the year they had all they had everything they needed
59:07even with Terrence Ferguson getting hurt they still could have played 13 personnel with the guys that they had and I laughed
59:13Derek because he's we're fans of his game the next receiver off the board in the second round was Antonio Williams who
59:19has had a nice season for a Washington team that's been going through it made a couple really nice plays on Monday
59:25night football he was a third round pick but he was the next receiver taken after Claire yeah he was like nine
59:31pigs later yeah yes I just if you want to if you want to do the quarterback lottery ticket that's fine I
59:37have no problem saying that because I like Ty Simpson but you can't have both of your first two picks not contributing
59:43to a team with Super Bowl I love this so much this is the only man in America we're like the Rams
59:50are Max Claire's fault it is it's true leave time alone he kind of right though because like Max Claire gets drafted
59:56and he's immediately at best like tight end four and it's like even if you're gonna use them a lot that's kind
60:02of crazy whereas it and Dave it's not even just Antonio Williams because usually we do like who's just the next guy
60:08off the board the other receivers right after that in the third round Malachi Fields Caleb Douglas has been decent for Miami
60:14even if the numbers aren't crazy because that offense is whatever Jacoby Lane who I know he got hurt this offseason but
60:20like had been really good when he was playing Ted Hurst for the Bucks has done some stuff like there were a
60:26lot of receivers you're all NFL players they are all NFL players yes they are NFL players that are not just like
60:32this is one of those situations too I love what Jordan Whittington is for the offense when it's working and they have
60:39all their other players and he's a 12 snaps a game role player well now if he's wide receiver two I don't
60:45like Jordan Whittington so much whereas I think some of these other guys could have given you a little bit more you
60:51can galaxy brain a draft pick galaxy braining two major draft picks when your goal is to be in the Super Bowl
60:57is I don't know if that's great process and that's not Max Clare's fault I'm I'm directing that at the Rams brain
61:03trust more so than Max Clare this is a team that they have done this in the past and it has not
61:09always burned them there is a level of like biblical greed and hubris to some of the things that they do that
61:15I almost appreciate the audacity of some of it every once in a while where it's like bring me Miles Garrett right
61:21fine cool great I appreciate that shoot your shot but this offseason specifically there we flew very close to the sun I
61:28will say if you could give me a date to circle for Miles Garrett's return it would do a lot to ease
61:34my anxiety about the Rams like I'm not putting X's every day on the way yes I would yes I would be
61:40crossing off the calendar like okay it's Miles Day but that isn't happening and each passing week makes me more concerned and
61:46to the going back to the point we were making at the top of this Trent McDuffie might not play it's it's
61:52easy to imagine Brock Bowers posterizing the secondary well a week ago I would have been like oh well it's you know
61:58it's the Cardinals they'll be fine it's a get right game a week ago I probably would have thought of I'll probably
62:04take care of the Raiders now like why why would we think that why would we think any of these are gimmies
62:10and I'm not willing to totally throw in the towel yet even if we move them off the table but we're inching
62:16in a very scary direction with how this season could ultimately unfold for the Rams having not done that I've not done
62:23this so far this year but we're gonna dig into an under the hood on this week seven preview for those of
62:29you guys are new to the show we did this we've done this segment essentially since we started for a lot of
62:35the preview shows we spend 10 ish minutes just digging into a unit around the NFL that has been of interest to
62:41us that we haven't spent a lot of other time talking about I was traveling when you guys had the production meeting
62:47for this show earlier in the week when you picked the Bucks defense as the group that we really wanted to dig
62:53into if you leave Derek and I alone we're gonna find a way to talk about if the cats away we're gonna
62:59dig into Josiah Trotter talk Derek I want you to explain to the people why the Bucks defense is the unit that
63:05you guys under the dark cover of night decided that we were gonna talk about it under the hood today I think
63:12because the team is one in five quarterback that has obviously been injured we've only done a little bit of like referencing
63:18in passing like oh yeah the Bucks defense is cool and you know Josiah Trotter made this play against the Bengals whatever
63:24but I don't feel like we've really sat with the fact that they are one of the best eight ish defenses in
63:30the NFL right now they're playing at a really high level and I think you're seeing the Todd Bowles formula kind of
63:36working again outside of Brian Flores they bring pressure and heat at quarterbacks more than anyone else in the league and it's
63:42funny because if you look at if you look at a lot of the numbers you you would think that some of
63:48these teams that blitz a lot get home a lot but they really don't because it's kind of like a there's a
63:54paradox of because they blitz so much teams are crafting their entire game plan around like they're gonna blitz the hell out
64:01of us and they're gonna get somebody free and so they don't get home a lot but they are forcing teams to
64:07throw short all the time throw one to ten yard area throw we're throwing slants we're throwing quick outs we're throwing short
64:13crossers all that stuff and the gambit with that if you're a defense you you have to be fast you have to
64:19close you have to tackle you have to do all that stuff really well they're doing it man like I think the
64:25linebacker play has improved Josiah Trotter has been good the corners are playing out of their minds like Parrish and McCollum I
64:31think are playing really good ball the safeties I think are playing well like it's just this was a team that I
64:37felt the some of the Todd Bull stuff could still be cool they just need players and they got like four players
64:43this year whether it's guys improving like Zion McCollum and Jacob Parrish or bringing in like a Josiah Trotter and getting David
64:50Walker back from injury where it's like all right man they've got all the talent to do the stuff that they want
64:56to do of all the units and teams that we watch and keep an eye on across the league a smile comes
65:02across my face when I watch the Bucs particularly the Bucs secondary you guys are pumped about this group coming in yeah
65:08I both of you were and credit to you guys for seeing that it could come together in this way because it
65:14has so far you are I mean you've said all the names Derek but Jacob Parrish is a dog man he's awesome
65:20he he is so fun and the thing I love about it too so Zion McCollum's had a really great year as
65:26well he's six to 200 pounds like when I see Zion McCollum break up a comeback to George Pickens I'm like oh
65:32yeah okay that makes sense he's a big physical corner Jacob Parrish is five nine and an eighth Dave Dave Hellman loves
65:39himself a short king I as a short king when a five nine guy is just whooping ass in the NFL it
65:45just lights up my heart is so fun to watch Jacob Parrish he's great in coverage he was he he was awesome
65:51against the Cowboys receivers he was good in this Pittsburgh game his run fits are incredible dude like against the Steelers he's
65:57gonna get in there and lay the hammer on you McCollum is awesome Tykee Smith is just fast and violent like that
66:03is just how I would describe his game Josiah Trotter has been incredible and I think it's worth mentioning Antoine Winfield hasn't
66:09been out there the last two weeks if you know if on who's been playing safety for them and it still looks
66:15really good Keontae Scott was like Dfay Melifongu just as like a we need a piece to play around with here yes
66:21yeah Keontae Scott when he got drafted we were like oh Todd's gonna blitz him a lot and it's gonna be fun
66:28yep that's what happened yeah it's truly what he is he sends him after the quarterback like four or five times a
66:34game he sacked Aaron Rodgers the other day he uh he broke up he was right in the B gap and broke
66:40up a Dak Prescott pass in the Thursday night game he's exactly what you dreamed he might be when you drafted him
66:46the one thing that really isn't great is the big free agency addition they made we've talked about it before Alex Anzalone
66:52is not doing a ton for me to this point in the season but there are so many young fun players that
66:58I don't really care it offsets it for me there's enough on balance that they've they've came out okay and I do
67:04think the thing that I want to kind of spin it forward to this game that they're playing against the Panthers the
67:10the Bucs specifically have been so good when they force you to throw fast and then specifically over the middle they don't
67:16give you anything in on one to ten yard passes over the middle they are second in EPA per drop back and
67:23on success rate I think on their blitzes like when they make you throw the slants the short over the ball routes
67:29they kill it because I think their linebacker droppers are good and the coverage has been good where you can get them
67:35sometimes is I think two ways if you attack the perimeter a lot in the RPO game screen game all that stuff
67:41if you watch what the Steelers did they were throwing like four strong concepts and they were tagging RPOs on the backside
67:47of gun runs and they were really making them go tackle in space that way they give up enough space there because
67:53all their blitzes are we're loading seven on the line so naturally you're out leveraged to the boundary the other way is
67:59to get five out and throw to the back this game is interesting to me because Carolina we've talked about it Robert
68:05they do all the RPO stuff like that will be a part throw the ball in the back but they don't throw
68:12the ball to the back at all especially against the blitz this year on on plays against the blitz they have thrown
68:18to the back 3.8 percent of the time which is the lowest in the NFL by about 2 percent like they just
68:24don't do it and so they're really going to have to kill them either Bryce is going to have to do a
68:30really good job throwing over the middle which every quarterback has struggled to do against in the season or their RPO stuff
68:36is going to have to hit which to Carolina's credit and Bryce's credit they are very good at that and the Steelers
68:42were good at it last week so how much of that they can get away with I am really curious about in
68:48this game you look at some of the numbers just to revisit them one more time before we move on about how
68:54they've and this is this is worth a larger discussion like this is just probably a midweek show two weeks from now
69:01the blitz is back like that that is this if we're going to be in this under center world again what is
69:07the defensive response we're going to blitz you out of it we're going to make you pay for wanting to play this
69:13way and I think that you have felt the utility of teams that are sending a lot of bodies at the quarterback
69:19this year and have a real plan for it it the Cowboys game is a perfect example from the Cowboys played into
69:25their hands like if we you are making us play a certain way we're we're playing your game from the start and
69:31if that's the case the defense has already won to an extent and I think the Bucs have done a very good
69:37job of that 33 percent of opponent throws this season against the Bucs have gone to the sticks it was 41 and
69:43a half percent last year just for some context 33 percent essentially makes you this year's Cleveland Browns in terms of how
69:50much you're pushing the ball downfield 40 and a half percent is Jordan Love pretty sizable difference that's the gap stylistically in
69:56what how teams are having to play against the Bucs this year and you watch some of the stuff they're dialing up
70:02it's good shit they're getting two guys on the back consistently like not a lot of free runners like if you look
70:08at the numbers it's about in line with other blitz heavy teams but multiple times in that Dallas game they're making Javante
70:14Williams pick like you're either blocking Anzalone or you're blocking the nickel you're not going to get them both and so just
70:20how good they've been at picking on pass protection rules has been so impressive and they're making teams play that game 2.57
70:26average time to throw against the Bucs this year 6.5 air yards per attempt that is such a condensed scrambling like we
70:32are playing a little bit unsettled offense that they are forcing teams into doing and so that's the structural stuff you guys
70:39mentioned a lot of the personnel things there was a two-play stretch against Dallas down near the goal line where the first
70:45play Yaya Diaby tosses Brevin Spanford on the goal line and gets a run stuff just tosses him on the next play
70:51Tyler Smith is pulling to kick out David Walker and David Walker jolts Tyler Smith back about a yard and a half
70:57into the backfield and that play goes for no gain the David Walker part of this to me he's been the one
71:03that's really jumped out because when we when the Ruben Bain pick happened I think a lot of us were like God
71:09they needed that I mean you're going into a season with Diaby and Al-Kadeen Muhammad and this was they needed to get
71:15this guy and then David Walker has come in and what would we have known right like he didn't play last year
71:21yeah he didn't play last year and he's a fourth round pick from a small school he's been awesome as in both
71:27one-on-one situations and where I think he's just a demon his ability it reminds me of like the young Bosa's they were
71:34really good at this when you send him as a looper on stunts his ability to put his foot in the ground
71:40and go downhill about the DAC the DAC play oh boy like oh boy and so you the so many of the
71:46young players on this team and again to your guys's credit that was the vision for this coming in if a lot
71:52of these guys hit at every level of the defense is there still enough juice to their approach for this all to
71:58fall into place and it's been six games we'll see but so far I think they've made good on the the picture
72:04that you guys were painting in the summer the cruel irony is it's coming together just in time for what might be
72:10a lost season and I think it's another yeah it's another reason to highlight this game they they would be in such
72:16a better spot if they had held on against Pittsburgh obviously but their next two games are division games so if you
72:23beat Carolina and Atlanta against all odds you could climb back into this thing if the Panthers beat them it's not mathematically
72:29over but our simulator at the athletic our buddy Greg Allman pointed it out to me today it their their odds drop
72:35to like three percent if they don't win this game so if the Panthers have a chance at home it's in yeah
72:41it's in Charlotte they have a chance to like shut the door on Tampa before Halloween and so like even though the
72:47records are not playing he's I think Todd Bowles said he's gonna make that determination at the end of the week okay
72:53but he's practicing okay so I mean that obviously that kind of changes the math entirely for the offense if that's all
72:59we got from Jaden from Jalen Daniels by the way well done hats off yes that yes he they again they didn't
73:05really win they only won the Dallas game but like they were in the Green Bay game they were in the Pittsburgh
73:12game and he didn't make some great plays but like they he he allowed them to have a shot in all these
73:18games exactly and that's more than late and whatever but he like they were in these games they did not embarrass themselves
73:24offensively with an undrafted rookie in this game for a multi-game stretch think about the other backup performances we've gotten this year
73:30from other guys where it's just like the team didn't have a chance Tanner McKee against the Panthers didn't have a chance
73:36the Cooper rush games didn't have a chance like Jalen Daniels gave them a chance and that that was enough that moment
73:42of him with Rogers after the game did you guys see the clip of that legitimately very cool it was so after
73:48the game obviously during the broadcast they're talking ad nauseum about him worshiping Rogers when he was growing up he would watch
73:54his highlights before every single game and so the cameras caught them after the game and Jalen Daniels is talking to Rogers
74:01and he's about to he goes he goes hey Rod I don't want to be that guy and then Rogers immediately goes
74:07I'll send it to you for getting his jersey and then Rogers asked him for his that's awesome it's just it's one
74:13of those moments where it's like that's really cool like that just imagine that imagine you're an undrafted free agent your quarterback
74:19for coming into training camp you have no idea if you're even going to make the team one of your starts in
74:25the window where you get to play is against the guy that you was your idol growing up and you get to
74:31have that moment with that guy that guy after the game like tell Jalen Daniels in May that that was going to
74:37happen like that that's just an incredibly cool moment about this season not to mention Jalen Daniels probably cemented himself a future
74:43in the NFL for that's several more years absolutely absolutely it so if that's the last time we see him I just
74:50feel like that was a a parting shot worth getting into let's talk about what we want to know coming out of
74:56week seven in the NFL I got two one Dallas Cowboys offense why are you doing this to me can we get
75:02can we get defense we've moved on from the can we get yeah the defense like listen our expectations for you were
75:08low we all knew the defense could do this this is like we were all hoping for the 17th best defense in
75:14the league that's whatever the offense looking as out of sorts as it has over the last couple weeks my real what
75:20do I want to know is can can you find your footing again like can we get back to a place where
75:26this feels like the offense it was supposed to feel like and it has been frustrating part of my optimistic case for
75:32the Dallas Cowboys coming into this year why I liked watching them last year is that they had started to move outside
75:39of a lot of the things that made the previous iterations of this offense frustrating to watch when they're sitting there in
75:45the gun and it's all spread out we're all stop routes and nonsense I didn't like watching this team last year we
75:51were doing just the requisite amount of all the things that make the game slightly easier on your offense we're using more
75:57play action we're more under center we're just like pushing the buttons that you don't just because your quarterback can do it
76:03doesn't mean it's the right approach if it's if it's not too good for Patrick Mahomes it's not too good for you
76:09and that's where I am with the Dallas Cowboys offense and so we the this year so far they have been in
76:15spread formations on 44 percent of their of their plays 44 percent I don't think there's another team above like 32 percent
76:21against the Bucks it was 58 against the Packers it was 64 64 their motion rates overall have dropped 10 percentage points
76:27from last year if you look at 25 and 26 combined they're 64 seasons right 32 teams times two their 2025 rate
76:34would break 21st of those 64 seasons their 2026 rate is 54th they've been in the guns 67 and a half percent
76:40of the time this year compared to 59 last year this is the biggest one we talked earlier in the show about
76:46run action rates the Chiefs are number one the Cowboys last year were at 55.7 percent this year they are at 44
76:52and a half percent it is dead last in the NFL by a lot some of that is driven by the running
76:58game not being very good so far but you can't scrap it now you can't be in a place six weeks into
77:04the year where it's just like well the running game is not working we're going to be in the gun 70 percent
77:10of the time and throw the ball 70 percent of the time like we need to get back to a place where
77:16there's enough ingredients in this thing where you feel the potency and talent of the offense overall and I want to see
77:23if we can start getting back there against a team that theoretically will not pressure them to the degree that the last
77:29two opponents did but even if they do you need a better answer than the one you've had like you can't be
77:35playing the game on these teams terms when you have the talent and the quality that this team has offensively and that's
77:41the thing you mentioned all the spread formations we've said against the blitz the last couple weeks all they do is get
77:47in these two by two spread formations and they're like Javante will figure it out and it's like he's good at pass
77:53pro but not if he's getting overloaded every single play and so they just I think why it's been so frustrating for
77:59me really quickly is that my case for why they would be good was that they could do anything they could get
78:05under center they could play action they could motion they could that was it it was like they can't do last year
78:12and they didn't have to imagine it they did it last year and they have reverted back to and I will say
78:18this I really love Dak Prescott I think he's a great player I think at this stage in his career it's probably
78:24fair to say that like them getting into the spread stuff is probably like he just likes it man it's like the
78:30Joe Burrow thing like I think there probably is a certain amount of it where he's like I'm comfortable with this and
78:36it's like at a certain point you have to tell him like we have to do other things to make that even
78:42worth it if they didn't have the proof of concept last year I'd be fine hearing that argument being like oh well
78:48he just doesn't like it he can't really do it yeah I hope you both learned a valuable lesson I hate myself
78:54so much just I hate myself so much and it's funny because I think that when we had those conversations in the
79:01preseason there were people just like oh look at these national assholes hyping up the Dallas Cowboys and every time I wanted
79:07to be like I've never done this I refuse to do this they were a team that I actively loathed as strong
79:13I had a real distaste for a lot of the things the Dallas Cowboys did for a long time I finally started
79:19to come around over the last year for a bunch of different reasons and immediately I regret it immediately that's Dallas Cowboys
79:25football immediately I regret this anyway my other one thing that I want to hit just very very quickly let's stick in
79:31the NFC East we were not going to talk about this we have to what does the J.J.
79:36McCarthy thing look like like it what J.J. McCarthy starting for the Giants what does it look like you know what allow
79:42me to put hey allow me to put glib cynicism aside for a second and J.J.
79:47McCarthy was not good last year I don't particularly expect him to be good for the Giants me neither this is so
79:53much more interesting and so obviously the right way to do this like what what are we getting out of 12 starts
79:59of Jameis Winston even if he has some moments but he doesn't like we did this on the hangover if the entire
80:05argument for a rookie for a veteran quarterback is well the ball is going to the right place you know like they're
80:11able to run the offense it wasn't there are guys that are open he's not throwing them the ball like at that
80:17point if it's going to be volatile anyway give me the more talented guy like it's not even a discussion the more
80:23talented guy who what even after everything he's been through in the NFL is like maybe 24 is he even 24 super
80:30young and and listen I there's been some discourse about this this week and discourse I understand I think some people looked
80:36at well Kevin O'Connell couldn't make J.J. McCarthy work and so that means that he's broken and not worth it J.J.
80:42McCarthy was actively very bad last year the Vikings offense isn't killing it right now and so I at least am open
80:48to the idea that this is a we spent a fifth round pick on a dude who is a top 12 pick
80:54that is toolsy he has first round tools so why not it's a free it's a free roll and so I I
81:00get it like I think we all kind of just looked at it in the moment was like whatever but it's a
81:06worthwhile trade if you're the Giants I don't know if it works but I'm at least interested in watching this more than
81:12I was the Jameis Winston version of this thing just neighbors and Isaiah likely can play just being transparent like we come
81:18in on Sunday and we set up the TVs how we want them and what we think is the most important and
81:24the most interesting the Jameis Winston Giants for me are going in a quad box that I will look at four times
81:31and then I'll like listen to the hangover to see what the Giants did the J.J.
81:35McCarthy Giants I'm keeping an eye on that for better or for worse I just watched the fourth quarter like it's yeah
81:41I don't know how good it was but it was at least more engaging than whatever the first three quarters looked like
81:47so that's really all this comes down to yeah can he do anything that Jameis Winston was not doing that's all that's
81:53all it is there's also you can probably trick a less discerning person that it's just Jackson Dart yes just replace one
81:59young first round pick one quarterback with another it's great who runs around a little bit likes to get hit chuck it
82:06down the field okay but like that that is it's a bit and it's a good bit for the record but like
82:12if you're gonna lose Jackson Dart a game in a and three plays into the season I mean what a shitty place
82:18to be and I feel for Giants fans it's almost miraculous that you get a chance to plug a young talented guy
82:24that you haven't seen a lot of football from into this situation because it like what does it serve to watch Jameis
82:30Winston or Cooper Rush play these games like at least this is a ball of clay you can hopefully mold and if
82:36it doesn't work out oh well but it's just so much more interesting I have to assume the Giants fans are exactly
82:42are more interested in whatever this is going to look like than how they were feeling over the last couple weeks so
82:48that's one of my what do I want to know what does it look like with J.J.
82:53McCarthy in this offense what do you got for me what do you want to know coming out of week seven I
82:59want to know what happens in the Jake Plummer Bowl Broncos at Cardinals that is not how I thought you would say
83:05that I don't think it's fair to frame this purely as like a test for the Broncos like the Cardinals are just
83:12some speed bump like they just beat the Rams and they have had moments of of high of functioning good football where
83:18they've scared some teams having said that this is still the 27th defense in the NFL by DVOA they're allowing points on
83:2446 percent of their drives they're allowing a touchdown on 35 percent of their drives they're forcing a three and out at
83:30the third lowest rate in the NFL this is as as good of an opportunity as you're going to get in the
83:36NFL to quote unquote get right even knowing what the Cardinals did against the Rams and they've had some other moments as
83:42well the NFL is really hard this is as easy as it gets and if I had to guess the size of
83:48the Broncos fan base and the location it's not exactly going to be a hostile environment I bet there's gonna be a
83:54lot of Denver fans in Phoenix go look like not a disaster I want to know if the Broncos cannot look like
84:01a disaster in a game Derek what do you got for me one what do you want to know coming out of
84:07week seven I mean mine is actually in like a similar vein the Saints can you get back on track because the
84:13Steelers are foreign to I think that they're a pretty solid team but they are not infallible they almost lost to a
84:19Jalen Daniels Bucks team last week and so the Saints sitting at two and four were like the New York game was
84:25really weird they kind of squeaked one out against Baltimore this year I think they have an opportunity where if you can
84:31beat Pittsburgh and you can take a breather they have their buy in week eight and then you have a very beatable
84:37Cleveland team after that there's a chance that they can like settle the heartbeat of their season I think if you lose
84:43the Steelers game you end up pretty far behind the eight ball in terms of being able to win a very winnable
84:50division and so can they just do it this is a Steelers team that again I think they are good but they
84:56are beatable and so can they get back on track I desperately need that version of the Saints to show up for
85:02the wins pool I like I desperately need I have the Steelers I need them to win this game we need it
85:08parlez-vous français les a les bons les a les bons en roulet I can't believe I flubbed that did you take French
85:14in high school absolutely like five years yeah you have it you have to it's like constitutionally required how good is your
85:20French right now could you like get by if you went to France right now it's it's been 20 years I would
85:26just it's it's bad now but like if I was there I could like read the street signs and ask for direction
85:32it takes me like three days when I'm in a Spanish-speaking country to like feel mildly comfortable again where I can like
85:38get myself by I feel I think I would have irrational confidence and the first Parisian I met would just shoot me
85:45down so hard it would be really humiliating all right that is all we've got for today I will not be on
85:51the recap show tonight because I'm going to Bears Patriots yes so uh very much looking forward to that the listeners won't
85:57hear this until after the game is over if if the outcome is either really good or horrendously bad we're gonna call
86:03you okay that's fine we're gonna call you and put you on the air it's well for me it's gonna be that's
86:09the funny thing is for me it's obviously no matter what happens it's gonna be really good or horrendously bad like I'm
86:15going to feel one of those two ways no matter how the game actually unfolds it feels like a missed opportunity that
86:21we didn't get you on the phone after the JJ McCarthy game I wouldn't I wouldn't pick up I would I would
86:27not have answered if you guys had done that all right that is all we've got for today we will be back
86:34on Sunday doing all things week seven for now that's all we got appreciate you guys listening we'll talk to you soon
86:40thanks for tuning in make sure to hit that subscribe or follow button so you never miss an episode if you enjoyed
86:46what you heard please like comment and leave a rating we'll see you next time

More episodes from The Athletic Football Show

6