The Athletic Football Show artwork

Bears hold off Patriots in Thursday night thriller

STACKED extracted the fantasy-relevant player signal from this podcast and kept the full transcript here for context.

32 min
Duration
Estimated from transcript
Oct 23, 2026
Published
Fri, October 23, 2026
14
Player insights
9
Players mentioned
Topics
Caleb WilliamsDrake MayeColston LovelandCole KmetD'Andre SwiftEli RaridonHunter HenryJaylen JohnsonRome Odunze
Player analysis

Player insights

14

Caleb Williams

PositiveProjection0:00

Williams demonstrated elite quarterback play in a high-pressure Thursday night environment, displaying command of the offense and pocket presence. The source notes he made six throws worthy of end-zone angle review, consistently made tight-window throws under pressure from a strong Patriots front, and showed nuanced decision-making and mobility. His performance included a scramble where he stepped up, bent back to his left losing yardage, then skirted out the left side of the pocket—a display of rare movement ability. The source states: 'how many people can move like that?' and compares his overall trajectory to Patrick Mahomes and Josh Allen.

Insight page
NegativeRole7:00

Williams took a critical sack late in the game that dropped the field goal make percentage from 72% to 28%, nearly costing the Bears the game. The source describes this as 'indefensible' and 'a dumb young quarterback thing to have done,' though notes that his other 50 plays in the game exonerate him from this mistake.

Insight page
PositiveProjection19:45

Caleb Williams demonstrated elite athleticism and decision-making in high-pressure moments, exemplified by the Bears' third-quarter scoring drive. On third-and-two early in the drive, he ran 30 yards to pick up five yards, outrunning the defense through the backfield on a "ridiculous, like a stupid play unless you're as athletic as Caleb Williams." After a holding call backed the Bears to second-and-12, he stepped up in the pocket and fired a dart to Loveland for 22 yards. On the touchdown to Loveland, he bootlegged, jumped, and threw against his own body momentum to get the ball to Loveland quickly enough for him to turn upfield and break tackles. The source stated: "in six snaps, he made three plays that just not very many people in the world are making" and called it "the perfect like thumbnail of who he is as a player." the source compared Williams and Drake May to the tier of Lamar Jackson, Patrick Mahomes, and Josh Allen, saying "Drake May and Caleb are not to that level yet. But watching this game, I was like, man, I really think that they can be those guys."

Insight page

Cole Kmet

NegativeInjury27:36

Cole Kmet suffered an injury during the Bears-Patriots game, creating a potential concern for the Bears' offensive depth. The source noted: "Cole Komet got hurt in this game. And I'm like, OK, like this this offense can be a wagon. But can you trust it to hum at the level you need it to to overcome this defense all the way through?" The injury raises questions about the Bears' ability to maintain offensive consistency, particularly given concerns about the run game and defensive limitations.

Insight page

Colston Loveland

NegativeRole9:00

Loveland had two tough drops in the game. He dropped what the source describes as 'Caleb's sickest throw of the game'—a crosser in the first half where Caleb bent a ball to him. Later, on a fourth-and-two play, Loveland dropped a perfect ball from Caleb, forcing a timeout and creating a frustrating moment. However, he redeemed himself by making a crucial catch on the very next play after the timeout, showing resilience.

Insight page
PositiveRole19:45

Loveland showcased elite tight end upside on the Bears' third-quarter scoring drive, executing multiple plays that demonstrated his ability to win at the point of attack and create after the catch. On the drive, he caught a 22-yard dart from Caleb Williams on second-and-12, then scored a touchdown after Williams bootlegged and threw with momentum; Loveland shook his defender and broke tackles to reach the end zone. The source noted that on this drive, Loveland "big boy somebody down the seam" and then "shakes a guy and barrels through two more to get into the end zone," leading the source to tweet that "that's when I thought Colson Loveland might be the best one of the best tight ends in the league coming into the season." Despite some drops and frustrating moments elsewhere in the game, this drive exemplified his potential as a top-tier tight end.

Insight page

D'Andre Swift

PositiveUsage8:00

Swift is described as 'an absolute lightning bolt every single time he touches the ball' and 'a case of dynamite.' The source notes the Bears' run game is still struggling overall, with some frustrating second-and-10 runs, but Swift's explosiveness stands out as a bright spot in the offense.

Insight page

Drake Maye

PositiveProjection14:00

Maye displayed veteran-level quarterback play and pocket awareness, showing progression throughout the game. Early in the game he relied on scrambling and bailing, but as the game progressed the Patriots adjusted protections and Maye began preemptively moving in the pocket, demonstrating knowledge of blocking assignments and pressure angles. The source highlights a play with four minutes left in the third quarter where Maye checked the protection to his left side, directing the tight end and running back, then threw a bomb to the tight end over Devin Bush for a touchdown. The source also notes an impressive play where Maye 'dunked Dylan Thienemann into the earth' before hitting Hunter Henry on a crosser, showing physical dominance and decision-making. The source compares his overall talent level to Josh Allen and Lamar Jackson.

Insight page
NegativeRole17:00

Maye threw a red zone interception on a seam route to Eli Rariton, a play the Patriots had successfully executed earlier for a touchdown. The source does not fault the decision itself—the look was sound and the route concept was viable—but criticizes the ball placement. The source notes that if Maye misses low and inside, the linebacker carries it; if he misses high and outside, the ball goes out of bounds. The source states: 'you got to know where to put that ball,' characterizing this as a rare miss in ball placement from an otherwise excellent performance.

Insight page
PositiveProjection23:00

Drake May demonstrated elite-level quarterback play in the Patriots' comeback effort, leading multiple scoring drives and showing the ability to execute under pressure. The source noted that both Drake May and Caleb Williams displayed the kind of performance that suggests they could reach the tier of elite quarterbacks like Lamar Jackson, Patrick Mahomes, and Josh Allen. the source stated: "Drake May and Caleb are not to that level yet. But watching this game, I was like, man, I really think that they can be those guys." Additionally, the source praised May's ability to execute when the offense was in difficult situations, noting that "on the Patriots touchdown drive to cut it to 2120 2721, the Eli Raritan touchdown... they just effortlessly dug out of it like half a dozen times in this game." The source concluded: "that's all the indicator you need that these quarterbacks were on a heater tonight."

Insight page

Eli Raridon

NegativeMatchup17:00

Rariton had a speed advantage down the seam that the Patriots liked and tried twice—once for an explosive touchdown and once for an interception. The source notes the Patriots had a clear look they liked with Rariton's speed advantage, demonstrating scheme-specific targeting.

Insight page

Hunter Henry

PositiveRole14:00

Henry was on the receiving end of a key play where Drake Maye, after checking the protection and directing the tight end and running back, threw a bomb to Henry over Devin Bush for a touchdown. The source also notes Henry was targeted on a crosser late in the game after Maye 'dunked Dylan Thienemann into the earth' on a blitz.

Insight page

Jaylen Johnson

NegativeRole25:15

Jalen Johnson had a rough performance in the Bears' secondary, particularly on the Patriots' Hail Mary touchdown play. The source noted he "does not look like himself" and has had "a rough season." On the Hail Mary, Johnson had a "turn down on Drake May" and his effort to tackle May on a scramble in the second quarter was criticized as ineffective. the source stated: "his effort to tackle Drake May on a scramble in the second quarter, like personally offended me. It took me like 10 minutes to move past it." Additionally, Malik Muhammad is described as "their best outside corner right now," suggesting Johnson is not the primary option at the position. The source expressed concern about the Bears' secondary depth, noting that Johnson's struggles combined with the lack of a real edge rusher creates defensive vulnerabilities.

Insight page

Rome Odunze

PositiveRole9:00

Odunze had a redemption arc after a difficult season and an offensive pass interference penalty in the end zone earlier in the game. He made a crucial third-down completion late in the game—described as a 'throwback' by the source—and followed it with another chunk play on the next snap. The source notes this catch came after a Xavier Thomas holding penalty that had brought the drive back, yet the Bears still converted. The source states: 'For Rome to have kind of a weird season and then have that OPI in the end zone and then come back and make that catch and then come back on the next play and get another chunk.'

Insight page
Full transcript

Episode Transcript

393
0:00Welcome to The Athletic Football Show presented by the U.S.
0:03Bank Smartly Visa Signature Card. I am Dave Hellman.
0:05What a treat of a Thursday night game. The Patriots and the Bears played a banger at Soldier Field.
0:11Caleb Williams and Drake May putting on a show.
0:14Derrik Klassen and I recapped all of it. And if that wasn't enough, we did get a visit from our own Robert
0:20Mays who was in attendance at Soldier Field. We got Robert's breathless reaction to everything as well as just breaking down every
0:26aspect of one of the best games of the season so far.
0:30Without further ado, let's get into it. Well, Derek, as the Chicago Bears hold off the New England Patriots 30 to 24,
0:36I have I have two main takeaways that I want to start this off with a aside from the NFL's insistence that
0:42its officials throw 20 flags a game this year.
0:45What a freaking football game, dude. Like you could not ask for better.
0:49We had Thursday night goofing. We had high level quarterback play.
0:52We had four or five holy shit moments. A plus no notes.
0:55Thought number two. We could have sold a live stream of Robert Mays watching this game live at Soldier Field and made a mint off of it, dude.
1:03Like, can you imagine Robert going through the end of half Hail Mary or the seven?
1:08Holy shit. Caleb Williams throws or the Colston Loveland drops or the Xavier on Tom.
1:12Thomas blocking the back flag. I just feel like he must have lived and died four different times over the course of this game.
1:19It would it would be the highest viewed thing on our YouTube channel.
1:23Not even close now immediately. And for the rest of time, it would not be touched if we had video of of
1:29literally any one of those moments, let alone the entire game.
1:32But this. This game was just. All right. So where are we starting?
1:36Where do you want to start with this? Because it is it's a lot to digest.
1:41I'm going to start biggest picture of all. I think what we just saw is what the NFL will be for the next decade.
1:47Those two are special, special football players that felt like I realize this is prisoner of the moment on a week seven and Thursday night football.
1:55That felt like watching Patrick Mahomes and Josh Allen to me.
1:58That felt like the next version of that coming along.
2:01And I realize that that feels like a lot.
2:04But May was second in MVP last year and Caleb Williams was this heralded superstar freak prospect.
2:08Like this is what these guys were always going to be capable of.
2:12You know, screw it, dude. Like, of course, on a long.
2:15That's what I'm saying. Screw it. Yes. On a long enough timeline, all of our predictions could look shitty and like, who
2:22knows what could happen over the course of three years, let alone 10 years.
2:26Of course, we don't know that for sure. But Drake May has already put together a case to win MVP and played in a Super Bowl playoff performance.
2:34Notwithstanding, I don't really give a damn about that in the big picture of who he is as a player.
2:39And then Caleb Williams just keeps doing this. I mean, how if you're on the fence, a what are you watching?
2:45Like, what are you actually watching if you're on the fence about Caleb Williams and be how many more times do you
2:52need to see him do it before you're just an outright believer?
2:55I mean, my notes are just littered with seven different times that I wrote.
2:59Holy shit, Caleb. And it's it's week after week with this.
3:02So I don't know if they're going to be MVP candidates in 10 years, but I'm comfortable making that bet that you're probably right, dude.
3:10Like, I don't think it's that wild of a take.
3:13I just could not stop myself from resisting the feeling of like these two are just going to play so many games,
3:19not necessarily against each other because AFC NFC, but they are going to play so many games over the next decade where
3:25it's just like, wow, that guy took over the football game or it's crazy.
3:29He made this throw X, Y and Z. And like, I just thought that the way both of them battled in this game was phenomenal.
3:36And to me, it's it's not just the superstar freak athlete stuff.
3:40And they had that right. Like Drake May, what he was doing as a scrambler in this game was incredible.
3:46The five or six Caleb Williams throws into tight windows were just like, oh, my God.
3:50But to me, it's you watch these two, the nuance that they're playing with, because like last year, the Bears offense was good, right?
3:57But it was because they ran the ball and they were explosive in it.
4:01It never quite felt like Caleb Williams fully had control of the offense in this game.
4:06I was like they didn't run the ball in this game.
4:09Exactly. It was all Caleb just like making the right throw all the time on time accurately.
4:14It just felt like a very, very good quarterback.
4:16So let's get into it in more detail. But I think you hit the nail on the head and I want to
4:23state it better because like the game itself was good.
4:25And let's not minimize some of the other heroism in this game, right?
4:29Like off the top of my head, Gabe Ackis was a freaking monster for the New England Patriots in this game.
4:35Rome Odunze had like, oh, my God. Hello, buddy.
4:38Oh, look at this. When are we putting the Chicago Bears at the table?
4:42You want to do it right now? When they can defend an end of half Hail Mary is when they can go at the table.
4:49Or just defend anybody, period. We don't even make it specific to the end of half Hail Mary.
4:54They were pretty good other than that, honestly, all things considered.
4:57Well, yeah, the offense is really good. The defense is genuinely concerning.
5:01I'll say this. Number 10 for the New England Patriots is a player.
5:05Yeah, man. My goodness. Those two quarterbacks. And they had him dead to rice like four or five times in that game.
5:11And just the sheer amount of plays that dude was making, unbelievable.
5:14And then Cairo Santos, I feel so... We're sitting there in the stands and I'm like, he's going to try to kick a 58-yard field goal?
5:22Like, it's truly mind-boggling. I'm so glad he made it, mostly in part because I felt so bad for Caleb if that
5:28kid could not go on in after taking that sack.
5:31Just like truly devastating. And after the second half he had, to potentially lose the game on that sack would have been soul-crushing.
5:38And so, man, you guys can tell I'm a little amped.
5:41And you should be. I would be concerned if you weren't.
5:44Your quarterback just did that? Are you kidding me?
5:47How was the atmosphere? It looked electric. It was awesome.
5:49It was awesome. I just, even walking to the stadium, there was a guy who was walking down Roosevelt to get to the stadium.
5:56And he recognized me and he was just like, it feels so different going to these games right now.
6:02And it's cool. It's like, it's just, it's cool to be able to say that, you know?
6:07And so I think that people feel that. It honestly, maybe just because I don't go to very many games, but the
6:13quality of the game, the back and forth, the quality of the quarterback play felt like a playoff game.
6:18I mean, it really did in a lot of ways feel like a playoff game.
6:23It had that sort of vibe to it. And maybe that's just being caught up in the moment.
6:28But I really do think that it had that sort of feel.
6:31That's when you buzzed in, I was in the middle of saying like, and we'll get to so many elements of it,
6:38but I'm just so happy that it delivered on that level where like it felt like that through the TV screen and
6:44the quarterbacks were just throwing punch after punch. I just, it, it delivered.
6:48I mean, it surpassed my expectations and I was geeked going in just as a neutral observer.
6:53Can I rank them? My worst moments. We were talking about that.
6:56Yes. Where was your heart pumping the most? Yeah.
6:59My heart wasn't even pumping when they allowed the touchdown before the half.
7:02That wasn't even like a heart pumping moment. That was like, I can't believe this is happening sort of thing.
7:08I went to the bathroom and I'm watching it on my phone as it happens.
7:12And I'm just losing my mind. So that was one.
7:15I handing the ball off to an offensive lineman illegally inside the 10 yard line and torpedoing the drive as a result of it.
7:22That one's up there. And then Caleb taking the sack.
7:25I'm literally sitting there with my head in my hands being like, I can't believe he just took that sack.
7:31There's the one thing you cannot do is that moment is take that sack.
7:35And so it does not take away all of the amazing stuff he did in the second half of that game.
7:41Those two third down completions on back-to-back drives. My God, the one to Rome is like, I was showing Casey on my phone, like the replay of it.
7:49I was like, watch this throwback again. And so it doesn't take that away, but I cannot believe he took that sack.
7:55So those are my three, like I'm losing my mind moments.
7:58The beauty of football is that Cairo Santos makes the longest kick of his career and just drills it, by the way.
8:05Drills it. And now we're not talking about Caleb being an idiot for the next week and a half.
8:10Thank God. Thank God. Because the way that he played, he didn't deserve it.
8:14It's the same as like Drake throws a terrible red zone interception.
8:18He was amazing the entire game. And so those two moments should not define the games that both of those quarterbacks had.
8:24I'm very glad that they will not. Yeah, I really quickly, the Ben Johnson trying to hand the ball off to a guard.
8:31Do you think he thought he found a loophole or he just thought he could get away with some shit?
8:36I don't know. I don't know. It was a frustrating game for as explosive as the offense was.
8:41The run game is still struggling. Like there were a couple of second and 10 runs in this game.
8:47They're a little bit frustrating, but I don't want to fix it on that.
8:51Like they were so explosive. Burden is just an absolute lightning bolt every single time he touches the ball.
8:56He is a case of dynamite. And then I honestly, I feel so good for Rome.
9:01For Rome to have kind of a weird season and then have that OPI in the end zone and then come back
9:07and make that catch and then come back on the next play and get another chunk.
9:12Like everybody had a little bit of it. And then Lovell had those two tough drops.
9:17Then the fourth and two, the fourth and two, that was when my heart was pounding out of my chest.
9:22I could literally feel my heart pounding out of my chest.
9:25And so for him to come back and make that catch, everybody chipped in over the course of the game, which was nice to see.
9:33It's a nice down to to Loveland really quickly was sick because they went to him right before that and he dropped it.
9:39Like Caleb put it on him. That is a perfect ball.
9:42And the fact that they won, like tried to go to the line, had some sort of miscommunication, have to burn a timeout.
9:49That's a frustrating moment. And right after that, quarterback is calm as hell, rips it to the guy who just dropped a
9:55pass and they nail it and they move on.
9:58And it's like, that's what good football teams do, man.
10:01Good football teams are resilient in those moments. And even that the Rome completion on third down, that was after a hold.
10:07Remember the end of Xavier and Thomas hold that brought him back on that drive and then they still got it.
10:13And so and Loveland also, you know, not to shit on Colson Loveland.
10:17He dropped what I thought was Caleb's sickest throw of the game before the Rome completion late in the game.
10:23He bends a ball on a crosser to Colston or in the first half and he drops it.
10:28And so, again, I'm glad a lot of the guys that had tough moments came back and made their presence known over the course of the game.
10:36But I don't want to completely hijack your guys' show, but we planned on doing this.
10:40I wanted to no matter the outcome, I was going to have to jump in and say hello.
10:45I'm so glad you don't know. This is such a cool change of pace.
10:49Like, you know, we we have fun doing this, but like it's, you know, we're in our offices removed from all of this.
10:56Like, it's really cool to like be part of the energy of an environment like that.
11:01Like, I'm I'm getting a buzz just from your excitement about this.
11:04Listen, man, I I my favorite place to be in the world when I was a kid was that place with my dad.
11:11It's my favorite place to be in the world.
11:13And so even walking to the stadium and getting in there and standing in the north end zone where our seats was, where our seats were.
11:21I feel really close to him when I'm there.
11:23And it just it's it's really special. And there's really nothing else in my life that makes me feel that way now,
11:30you know, 20 years later or whatever it is.
11:32And so that's why it's important to take these opportunities like it.
11:36We're getting we're getting older. There isn't a lot of stuff that takes you to a place that feels really special and different.
11:42And when I'm in that building, there's just something about it.
11:45And so I'm glad I went. I'm glad it was a banger of a game.
11:50And I appreciate you guys letting me butt in here.
11:53I'm glad Casey got this experience to negate the the J.J.
11:56McCarthy experience, the like, wait, I thought they were supposed to win experience.
11:59So we're so we're walking out of the stadium and my wife goes, man, it's really nice when they win.
12:05It sure is. She's like, if you're Casey, all you want is an entertaining game where they win.
12:10So that was amazing. And so that's exactly perfect football game.
12:14We're really glad you went. And we're very happy you called in and I'm positive you're going to go rewatch this as
12:20you're like winding down activity for the night. Our joke now as we get older is every time we hear like a
12:26banging dance song when we're out, like either at dinner or something, it's like, you want to go out now?
12:32You want to go out? And so that's weird.
12:35That's what we have a joke about. We could show us.
12:38You want to go out? You want to go like hit the town right now?
12:42We're not going to do that. Just be very clear.
12:45We've discovered everything in like a breathless 10 minutes, but I guess I'll reiterate this.
12:49And I mean, we just outlined all of it, but like, you know, Cairo Santos hits the kick of his career.
12:55Roma Dunze and Colson Loveland. We just talked about it.
12:58Like they had these redemption arcs in this game.
13:01It's not to, it's not to undermine any of the contributions that anybody else made here, but these two quarterbacks just put on a show, man.
13:08And like, that's what you want from a game like this.
13:11And it, it felt meaningful that it happened. And yeah, like, I don't, I don't know what it means in the big,
13:18big picture, but this is, this is the future of the league on display in an island game.
13:23And I think the future is going to be okay.
13:26Exactly. Like, and again, like these guys did cool stuff last year where the explosive plays chucking it down feel like May
13:32was the best downfield door basically in the NFL last year.
13:35Everything Caleb Williams was doing in terms of the explosive play.
13:38It was as cool as it could get. This was the first time, not necessarily the first time we've seen sprinkles of
13:45it this year, but really watching these two go head to head and it just looking like these dudes were 30 years
13:51old and they'd been here before and they'd done this shit before.
13:54It was, I already highlighted all this stuff with Caleb just in terms of how I felt like he was commanding the
14:01offense, how I felt like he was commanding the pocket, which to me was really impressive.
14:05And then Drake may same thing. Like early on, I think it was a lot of, I'm just going to bail and
14:12we're going to get out of here. I thought as the game went on, they started to change their protection stuff.
14:18And there were moments where you could see him like preemptively moving in the pocket as soon as he took the snap,
14:24knowing what we have blocked up, what we don't, where's the pressure going to come from?
14:29It gets him a half second of extra time and he's able to make a throw.
14:33And then I thought one of my favorite plays that he made, there was four minutes left in the third quarter.
14:39He's sitting there checking the protection to his left side, basically telling the tight end and the running back where to go.
14:46We're going to full slide the other way. And he just throws a bomb to the tight end over Devin Bush for a touchdown.
14:52And it's like, that looks like real deal veteran quarterback stuff.
14:56And oh yeah, also these two are like the most talented guys in the league outside of Josh Allen and Lamar Jackson.
15:02That was, I can't get over how excited I was watching those two do that.
15:06It was a phenomenal football game. Like Caleb had like six throws in this game that I can't wait to go watch
15:13from the end zone angle when it becomes available.
15:15But the thing that might stick with me the longest, honestly, is Drake just dunking.
15:19I think it was Dylan Thienemann into the earth before he hit Hunter Henry on that little crosser.
15:25You know, like I think like Thienemann came free on a blitz and he's just like, no, sir, that is not happening right now.
15:32Just incredibly impressive stuff. We hit on the Caleb sack, which I mean, it's indefensible.
15:36And honestly, that that was a perfect example of, you know, coaches talk about this with players all the time where I
15:42was sitting on the couch with Carmen. And I was just like, no, no, you can't do this.
15:47What are you? You cannot kick this from 58 yards.
15:50Santos just showed you what he looked like from 53.
15:53This is a terrible idea. Oh, and it it rippled the net from 58.
15:57Never mind. So good on Ben Johnson for trusting him, I guess.
16:01I think it's funny that the Bears spent a fourth round pick on a punter and like that didn't cross their mind in that moment.
16:08Like maybe Torrey Taylor can cough and corner this thing, but it worked out.
16:12It worked out and I was honestly stunned by that, too, because I was I was talking to Keegan Abdu a little
16:18bit before hit before when Caleb took that sack and it dropped them from a 72 percent make percentage to 28 percent.
16:24Like probably in terms of probability for the field goal.
16:27So like and like 50 percent in that moment is a ton, especially when like, you know, we can say this all the time.
16:34You can't always predict it, but it just felt like with the way those two quarterbacks playing when the Patriots got the ball back again.
16:41And they were going to drive and make it a game and like really make it like take it down to the last play.
16:48So the fact that they made it a two score game was like it just this game delivered it every single way, man.
16:55So like I am glad, like you said to earlier, I'm glad we don't have to do discourse over that moment.
17:01It is undeniably like a dumb young quarterback thing to have done.
17:04The other 50 plays in this game, I think, exonerate him from from that.
17:08I'd be curious for your take on the Drake interception.
17:11It was like it's beyond obvious that the Pats, they had a look that they liked with Eli Raritan having like a speed advantage down the seam.
17:19They I mean, they tried it twice. One was an explosive touchdown.
17:22The other was a really ugly looking interception. But I don't know if I hate the decision.
17:27I think I just hate the throw. I think it was just a bad ball.
17:32Like like I think that I think if you think you can get this ball, the seam route over the linebacker and
17:38away from the post safety, because he's holding the safety with his eyes like to the left hand side.
17:43And he's trying to throw that seam down the right.
17:46I think he just if you're going to throw that ball, this is a thing that like I think quarterback the best quarterbacks are really good at.
17:54It's no way you're going to miss if you're going to miss.
17:57And in that scenario, well, if you miss low and inside and the linebacker carries it really, really well.
18:03So like credit to him, obviously. But if you miss low and inside, there's going to be a linebacker there.
18:09If you miss high and outside ball just goes outside of the back of the end zone and it's really not the biggest thing in the world.
18:16And so that to me is just like you got to know where to put that ball.
18:21But I didn't mind the decision. And like I really don't think he made it many other bad decisions in this game.
18:28That was just in terms of the ball placement, a pretty rare miss from him.
18:32I thought a couple other things I want to hit on.
18:35I mentioned it. I thought, you know, maybe statistically you're going against Caleb Williams.
18:39So statistically, I don't know how gaudy it's going to look.
18:42But I mean, the Pats did get to Caleb three times, including on that big sack that could have ruined the game for Chicago.
18:49I just I think the Pat the Pats front is so physically impressive.
18:53Like I already mentioned Gabe Akis. I know he had his his roughing penalty is one of the stupidest things that happened in this game.
19:00It helped move the Bears from their own 30 to the plus 33 on one snap, like just an unacceptable penalty, considering
19:06Caleb had let go of the ball a full two seconds before he hit him.
19:11But for the most part, a really exciting young player.
19:14And I just I think this Patriots front has just more to it than it did last year.
19:19I mean, I couldn't agree more like I think Draymond Jones, it has been playing really well for them.
19:24Gabe Akis has been really good. Obviously, we knew the tackle play could be really good.
19:29Like their front, I think, is playing at a really high level.
19:32And that's the thing. Caleb obviously played really well in this game, but this was not like, you know, him getting to sit back in some cozy pockets.
19:40They pressured him a good amount and he was just making a lot of plays.
19:45You know, the Robert mentioned it, the the crosser that Loveland dropped, the deep one.
19:49Caleb is getting his head torn off on that play and he just stands there and looks down the barrel of the gun and makes the throw.
19:57And I just thought he had so many moments like that.
20:00I think when he was deciding to get out of the pocket and his I don't remember exactly when this happened.
20:06I don't know if I have it in my notes, but do you remember the scramble he had where he like stepped
20:12up, bent back to his left and like lost yardage, like two yards in the pocket and skirted all the way out the left side of the pocket?
20:20I was like, how many people can move like that?
20:23Actually, you're talking about the third and two, like right at the start of the second half?
20:28Yes. Yeah, that sounds right. So, so much crazy shit happened down the stretch of this game that it's like buried in my notes.
20:35But the Bears, if I was trying to explain to somebody why Caleb Williams is special and good and awesome, the Bears
20:41first scoring drive of the third quarter is like all you really need to watch.
20:46Because on third and two early in the drive, he ran 30 yards to pick up five and just outran the defense looped through the backfield.
20:53Just a ridiculous, like a stupid play unless you're as athletic as Caleb Williams.
20:57And then a couple snaps later, they get a holding call that backs them up to like, I think it was like second and 12.
21:04And he just steps up into the pocket and fires a dart to Colson Loveland.
21:09Yeah. Like you mentioned for 22 yards and then on the touchdown to Loveland, he boots out and kind of like jumps and throws against them.
21:16The momentum of his own body and gets the throw to Loveland quickly enough that Loveland has time to turn up field
21:22and get and break tackles and get into the end zone instead of just getting caught by the pursuit.
21:28So like in six snaps, he made three plays that just not very many people in the world are making.
21:34And it's just the perfect like thumbnail of who he is as a player.
21:38I'm so glad you brought that up, too, because I tweeted.
21:41I know I know Loveland had some some other frustrating plays in this game, but that drive to me, I was like,
21:47that's when I thought Colson Loveland might be the best one of the best tight ends in the in the league coming into the season.
21:54I was like, it's that drive where he just big boy somebody down the seam and then two plays later, you're in
22:01the red zone and he just shakes a guy and then like barrels through two more to get into the end zone.
22:07So I do think that's the other thing, too, that like I think really impressed me about this Bears team is that even when they have.
22:14They have the penalties and Loveland is having drops and Rome has his moments.
22:18I said just the resilience of such a young team is startling to me.
22:22Like I just usually with these young teams, you have so many starts and fits and they'll let these moments snowball away from them.
22:29And I just think that it's such a credit to the coach that Ben Johnson is.
22:34It's such a credit to the resilience of these young players.
22:37I just they're a team that the more they it sounds dumb, but like the more they play football, the more you get to see them together.
22:45I'm just like, yeah, man, like I buy what this is going to be at like the highest level.
22:50I'll give the Pats a little bit of credit here, too.
22:53Like show me a game. And obviously you don't want this.
22:57It's sloppy football. Show me a game where the offenses are digging themselves into this many holes and getting out of them.
23:03And I'll say they probably have good quarterbacks. They probably have really good quarterbacks because on the Patriots touchdown drive to cut it to 2120 2721.
23:10The Eli Raritan touchdown. Morgan Moses had a holding call that backed them up after a successful conversion on that on that drive.
23:17And then Eli Raritan himself false started putting them into a first and 15 and they just effortlessly dug out of it
23:23like half a dozen times in this game. Both of these teams really did it.
23:28And that's all the indicator you need that these quarterbacks were on a heater tonight.
23:32That's that's the other thing we've done a lot of and we've talked about how good Drake May was, but we've talked
23:38a lot about like how good the Bears are, how good this team is.
23:42This to me felt like, you know, we mentioned it felt like a playoff game.
23:47This to me was like Houston versus Jacksonville, where I was like somebody had to lose that game.
23:52But both of these teams have like make a run sort of stuff to them like that.
23:57I just thought what I was watching for these teams.
23:59I think those I think the Jaguars are like a higher quality team.
24:03And I think that the absolute peaks of Houston's defense with the way C.J.
24:07Stroud is playing is maybe a little bit higher than these teams.
24:11But I don't know, man, these teams still these teams both feel to me like very obvious playoff candidates to me.
24:17Playoff candidate for sure. I mean, the Bears are now not like the Bears are five and two.
24:22And I mean, obviously necessary, like NFC contenders is maybe like a tad strong.
24:26But like I they feel to me like they will get to the playoffs as 10 or 11 win teams and it will not feel fake at all.
24:34So let's let's let's touch on the other side of this.
24:37It reminds me of our season preview of the Bears where we spoke glowingly about them for 15 minutes because we weren't talking about the defense.
24:45And I thought the defense acquitted itself. Well, at times in this game, particularly in the early going, like they mentioned it
24:51on the halftime show before the Patriots started getting more tight ends on the field.
24:55They couldn't do anything. And obviously their offensive line is compromised by injury, and I'm sure that had something to do with it.
25:02But the Bears defense was getting after it for a little bit.
25:05Kyler Gordon had another really nice game after what he did against Atlanta.
25:09But like the Hail Mary is completely ridiculous. And there were plenty of other moments where I was like, I don't know
25:15how seriously I'm supposed to take this. And this is the part where I think we need to say the name Jalen Johnson.
25:22Rough night, dude. It's been a rough season. Rough.
25:25Yeah. He does not look like himself. Yeah. At this stage.
25:28Like, I know that he's a rookie and he's up and down.
25:31But like Malik Muhammad is like their best outside corner right now, I think.
25:35And he got banged up in this game. Yep.
25:38Which. And so like if there is something to be concerned about, it is like the defense is still up and down.
25:44I will say, though, like, you know, we've talked about this a little bit before.
25:48I don't think the defense is good. Obviously, they have some personnel deficiencies.
25:52The pass rush is not great unless they're blitzing heavy.
25:55The DBs are still extremely up and down. There is something about it, though.
25:59If you can just get into the playoffs with a play caller like this, I'm like, I don't know, man.
26:05You can do some stuff like they almost beat the Rams last year because of the shit that they were throwing at Matthew Stafford.
26:12And that Rams team was insane. I mean, Mays has been saying it as a bit for most of the season, but
26:18their third down numbers continue to look pretty good.
26:21Like they're finding ways to get offenses off the field.
26:23They did it several times on this in this game.
26:26I just I don't know, man. And maybe maybe I'm letting the the fail Mary loom too large in my mind.
26:32But like that that shit can't happen. I mean, you think about it.
26:36They came out of half and went right down the field and scored a touchdown.
26:40You could be put like you could be in a blowout if if you don't give up the most ridiculous touchdown I've seen this season.
26:48And yeah, I mean, Jalen Johnson was rough on that play.
26:51Theeneman like took out his own guy hunting for a tackle on that play.
26:55Jalen Johnson had a turn down on Drake May.
26:57And I know I know that they'll throw flags at you for hitting a quarterback.
27:02But like like he his effort to tackle Drake May on a scramble in the second quarter, like personally offended me.
27:08It took me like 10 minutes to move past it.
27:11And so some of that stuff combined with like not having like a real deal game changer at edge rusher.
27:16I thought Austin Booker continues to play really well, in my opinion.
27:20But I don't know. The numbers say that it's pretty good, but I'm not I'm not all the way sold on this on this defense.
27:27And then I really would like it if Kyle Manunga could get back.
27:31Cole Komet got hurt in this game. And I'm like, OK, like this this offense can be a wagon.
27:36But can you trust it to hum at the level you need it to to overcome this defense all the way through?
27:42Because of the run game stuff, I'm a little worried.
27:45But honestly, what we said at the top of the show, too, like if the passing game is just going to be
27:52more consistent, maybe the run game doesn't have to be dominant for this thing to be what they want it to be like.
27:58That was obviously the formula last year. But if they're making up enough of that ground with the passing game being consistent, I don't know, man.
28:06I kind of still believe that even if the math of how they're getting there is changing a little bit, I do
28:12still believe that they can be like a top five offense and and have games like this against what I think we
28:18both agree is like a very, very good New England defense.
28:22And like if you can score 30 on defenses like this, like you've got a shot in just about every game.
28:28And you know what, even even with a couple of embarrassing moments, I mean, New England scored 24 points.
28:33And and really other than like the Carolina game.
28:36And well, excuse me, I wouldn't want to leave out the Packer game.
28:39The Packer game was pretty brutal, but like for for how down I was on the Bears defense heading into the year,
28:46like you can get by with this like for them for the most part.
28:50I don't know what that means for like how deep they can go into the postseason.
28:54But I do have to give them credit that it looks better than I probably would have given them credit for in August.
29:01I think that's fair. It's them and the Lions kind of came into the season with the same formula in theory at them and the Cowboys.
29:08Really, the Lions, the Cowboys and like the Bengals and all them came into the same came into the season with the same formula.
29:15The Bears are look a lot better at it than the Lions or I think the Cowboys do.
29:20That is like at least unequivocally true. It's like some amount of success, right?
29:24Unequivocally true. Although I guess you could argue like the Lions are getting Brian Branch back soon.
29:29The Cowboys have a host of guys hopefully coming back from injury at some point.
29:34I don't know what the Bears reinforcement is. Other than if they can just continue to win on third downs, I guess.
29:40And maybe the Bears reinforcement is Kyle Manunga getting back and reducing this running game.
29:44I don't know who it would be. I would have to sit here and think about it a little bit.
29:50But like if the Bears really think they've got it and the offense is what we think it is, they should poke
29:56around for some defenders before the trade deadline. They should they should take a look or two.
30:01Warts and all these are these are great problems to have.
30:04The Chicago Bears are five and two. Just. Just.
30:07Just a great night for ball, man. I don't know.
30:10Is there anything else we need to hit? I don't think anything.
30:13Just one last reminder that to me, watch watching this game, I think for the last.
30:18When did Lamar Jackson and Mahomes come on like twenty eighteen twenty nineteen since since that moment, it has felt like Lamar
30:24Jackson, Patrick Mahomes and Josh Allen were this three headed monster of something totally different.
30:29And Drake May and Caleb are not to that level yet.
30:32But watching this game, I was like, man, I really think that they can be those guys.
30:37And so we'll see how it develops over the next couple of years.
30:40But I really was like, they have that gear to them.
30:43Like I said, it's it's hard to project that stuff out too far in the future.
30:48But at the very like I agree with you.
30:51And even if we can't predict the future, like I want you to be right.
30:55I hope you're right. Like just because like I want as much.
30:58Somebody's got to carry the torch after those guys.
31:01And I want as and they're not done yet.
31:04They still have five years, you know, until it's really over.
31:07But you know what I mean? I want as much of that as I can possibly get.
31:12I'm signing up to watch that every single time.
31:14So here's hoping it's the first of many for both of these guys.
31:18Like you said, even if they're not going to play each other that often, just if they're doing that on a regular basis, we're in good hands.
31:26All right. That's all we got for a banger of a week seven Thursday night game.
31:30We got plenty more content coming your way. Loaded week seven preview coming to the podcast feed and YouTube.
31:36We talked chief Seahawks in detail. We talked Bengals Ravens.
31:39We talked Packers Lions. Speaking of the NFC North Niners Falcons, plenty of other stuff I'm forgetting about because it's 11 o'clock
31:45on Thursday night, but really looking forward to a loaded week seven.
31:48We appreciate y'all so much and we'll talk to you next time.
31:52We'll be right back.

More episodes from The Athletic Football Show

6