0:00So I think we all agree at this point that Jeremiah Smith is a generational receiver prospect, but how valuable is that really?
0:08Like how does having a top three receiver in the NFL, assuming he becomes one of those, how does that affect a
0:15defense in terms of how they call it? How does that improve a team's odds of winning?
0:20Like how much does it really move the needle?
0:23We'll talk about that today. We're also going to hit on some offseason moves that maybe haven't gone the way that we thought they would so far.
0:32We're going to look at special teams value and how impactful it really is from week to week.
0:38Cough, cough, Rams. And finally, we're going to talk about David Bailey and the Jets and his breakout game.
0:44We teased that last episode. We're going to get to it today.
0:48Starting though, EJ, Jeremiah Smith. How good is he?
0:51What is he really worth? Will he actually substantively change whatever the worst team in the league this year that gets the number one overall pick?
1:00How much will he actually advance the ball forward, so to speak?
1:04Let's just start off with Jeremiah Smith and who he is.
1:07For those of you that don't follow college football or really know what Jeremiah Smith is other than a top draft prospect,
1:15Jeremiah Smith, receiver, Ohio State University, factory for NFL wide receivers at this point.
1:19He might be the best one. He's been doing it for a couple of seasons now.
1:24So every opponent has to know and concentrate all their resources on shutting him down.
1:29Well, not so much this season among FBS college football receivers with 25 targets or more.
1:35Smith is deep breath. Number one in targets. Number two in catches.
1:38Number two in yards. Number two in TDs. Number four in yak.
1:42Number one in yards per reception at 19.1. And my favorite.
1:46How is that 11, by the way? 19 catch.
1:49Come on. Welcome to college football. And my favorite receiver stat, as we all know from draft time, is yards per route run.
1:57And he is currently sporting a I've never seen that 5.42 yards per route run.
2:01For context, really, really good in yards per route run.
2:05The JSN territory from last year is just over four.
2:08Like, really good is over two in the NFL.
2:11If you're at two, two, two, two and a half, you're doing great.
2:15If you're at three, you're a top ten, probably top five receiver in the NFL.
2:20If you're over four, you're basically JSN or Puka at the height of your powers.
2:25He's over five. He's almost at five and a half.
2:28That's, again, I've never seen it outside of a, you know, small, maybe one game sample size, something like that.
2:35All of that with a staggering average depth of target of 15.1 yards.
2:39This is not Dinkin' Dunk, Yak, Merchant, whatever else.
2:42He's basically good at everything. His physical profile is amazing.
2:45He is tall. He is much larger than your average wide receiver.
2:49Moves like someone much smaller. His NFL passer rating when targeted is 148 flat.
2:54To remind everybody, perfect is 158.3. So that means if you throw at him, the result is going to be 148 passer rating.
3:02So he's real, real, real good. He's rare good.
3:04The bigger question is the one you teased on the opening.
3:08How much does that move the needle given that receiver is a downstream position?
3:13It is dependent on all these other things. It is the last in the chain that gets the ball, right?
3:19Offensive line has to snap it and protect. Quarterback's got to find it, get through his progressions, get the ball to him.
3:26Then all these good things happen. So given all that, is he worth the top overall pick if the quarterback class is a little bit shaky?
3:35He is the best player in the class. I think we all agree on that.
3:40In fact, we all probably thought that two and a half years ago, right?
3:45He was arguably the best player in the nation as a true freshman.
3:49He was the best player in the nation as a sophomore.
3:52Everybody knew he was the best player in the nation going into this year.
3:57He's on pace for like 2,000 receiving yards and damn near 30 touchdowns this year.
4:02Like it's just not fair. It's flat out not fair.
4:05He could have been an NFL player a couple years ago when he was like 18.
4:10And I think when you're looking at this kind of prospect, even weighing him against past quote unquote generational receivers, right?
4:17Jamar Chase was seen as that. Didn't even play his junior year because he didn't have to, right?
4:23He sat out his last year, which was the COVID year in 2020.
4:27Sat that out, came out in 2021, was a super high pick, immediately productive, immediately great, triple crown winner within four years in the league.
4:36You know, if you're weighing Jeremiah Smith as a prospect against Jamar or against Julio, which a lot of people compare him
4:43to Julio because of his size and speed and everything like that.
4:47As prospects, I still think he's the best one.
4:50Just looking at the productivity, at the polish, at the physical skills, coming out of college, if you said, would you take
4:57LSU Jamar Chase or Ohio State Jeremiah Smith? I think most people probably take Jeremiah Smith.
5:02I'm not saying he's going to be a triple crown winner in the NFL like Jamar Chase was, but just as prospects, he's that good.
5:10He's on that level. And so for me, when I was diving into this topic, my thought was, what if he does
5:18become the NFL version of Jamar, right? That super weapon in the NFL.
5:22Or what if he does become the mid-2010s Falcons Julio that also was basically unstoppable?
5:27Or JSN last year, right? What if he becomes 2025 JSN?
5:31Or what if he becomes early-mid-2010s Antonio Brown? That undisputed, first-team, all-pro, Hall of Fame talent kind of guy?
5:37What happens if he actually is that? And so I looked at how defenses changed when they played against those kind of
5:44receivers at the height of their powers. Go back to 2014.
5:48I looked at third down man coverage rates because on third down, which is a pass-heavy down, you know, I want to
5:55see what did you do against Pittsburgh? What did you do against Atlanta?
5:59That tells me how much you respect and or fear Julio Jones and AB.
6:04The Falcons were 32nd in man coverage rate faced.
6:07The Steelers were 14th on third down in 2014.
6:10In 2015, the Falcons were 16th in man coverage rate faced.
6:13On third down, the Steelers were 9th. So they both went up.
6:17And then 2016, keep in mind, this was while both of these guys were getting first-team all-pro like every year.
6:24In 2016, the Falcons Super Bowl year, on third down, the Falcons went up to 9th in man coverage rate faced.
6:31The Steelers were still 10th. It was about 47% to 48% man coverage rate faced on third down for both of them.
6:38So I saw that trend go up, which surprised me at first because I was like, wait, if you have an elite
6:45receiver, don't you want to play less man coverage because they're going to torch you?
6:50And so then I went to 2021 through 2024 for the Bengals.
6:542021, third down, Jamar's rookie year, the Bengals were 30th in man coverage rate faced on those passing downs.
7:002022, they went up to 21st in man coverage rate faced.
7:042023, if I just looked at the first 10 weeks when Joe Burrow was healthy, they were 9th in man coverage rate faced on third down.
7:12And then 2024, which was the Jamar triple crown year, on third down, they were 8th in man coverage rate faced.
7:19Again, over 40% of the time. So that trend happened again.
7:23I was like, all right, that's something to pay attention to.
7:26So then I looked at Seattle, 2025 into 2026 so far this year.
7:31Last year, Seattle was 28th in man coverage rate faced on third down.
7:35JSN slaughtered everyone. This year, they are facing the 5th highest man coverage rate on third down in the NFL so far.
7:42So the overall lesson, when you have that guy at receiver, what we think Jeremiah Smith is going to be.
7:49Your number one job as a defensive coordinator when facing that guy is to not let the offense dictate the matchup.
7:56If we're playing a lot of zone coverage, there are ways to get Jeremiah Smith on a safety.
8:01God forbid there are ways to get him on a linebacker.
8:05You're going to play man coverage. You're going to put a corner on him matching body type for body type.
8:12You're hoping you have a good enough corner that's not going to get murdered.
8:16I was going to say matching body type at corner in the NFL to Jeremiah Smith is a low percentage proposition.
8:23But even if your corners aren't very good, it's probably better than leaving yourself vulnerable to a safety or to a linebacker
8:30somehow having to handle him in space. So you're going to play man coverage and you're going to provide zone help over the middle.
8:38Whether you're playing one lurk all day long on third down.
8:42So we bring that safety down to the intermediate middle.
8:45His job is basically just to keep an eye on Jeremiah Smith so we can handle crossing routes.
8:51You have a post defender and then the corner is working with the sideline as well.
8:56So it's almost like you're building a quasi box around him, but with man coverage.
9:01And we don't want passes to be uncontested. Right?
9:04Because if we're playing a bunch of zone, that could also lead to uncontested passes.
9:09And we know that he is just so big and strong and fast that after the catch, he can still hurt us too.
9:17He's not just a contested catch guy. So that was a fascinating trend that I saw.
9:22Right? It was teams not necessarily forming a hard double, but playing man and zone around him together.
9:28Uh, or rather all these other great receivers. And I do feel like whoever takes Jeremiah Smith.
9:33Assuming he's going to be that guy, the man coverage rates that they face on third down is going to skyrocket, which
9:41means defenses will be more predictable, which provides a different kind of value in its own right.
9:46Because if the offense goes into the game knowing, Hey, third down, we're getting man, we can plan for that too.
9:53And then it just comes down to my guys are better than your guys.
9:58And Jeremiah Smith's better than a lot of guys.
10:01So I just, it was such an interesting trend.
10:04I didn't expect it. I really didn't. But the more I thought about it, the more it made sense.
10:10Reminds me very much of, strangely enough, high school basketball defense.
10:13Right? If you've got somebody coming in and they're the scorer, they're the threat that you have to account for.
10:20It's box and one. Right? You know, sometimes triangle and two, but you know, box and one.
10:26Wherever that guy goes, our best defender is pretty much going with him, just shadowing him.
10:31And the four guys are going to deal with the other four guys.
10:35And it leads me to believe based on that trend, it's surprising, but it's really cool.
10:40And it does make sense when you think about it in terms of, Hey, we tried this.
10:46They proved who they were. All those guys you talked about proved who they were as NFL receivers.
10:52We can't keep doing what we're doing and getting what we're getting because they're massacring us.
10:57So we need to do something different. So they ratchet up coverages and they start basically paying more undivided attention to that threat.
11:05The downstream effect of that, especially on third down, since you were looking at third down, you know where it really makes me want to see him go?
11:14So any place with a mobile quarterback. And I mean a, a quarterback who is a true running threat because if you
11:21get man coverage, the more those scrambles. You get man coverage on third down, you are getting probably if it's Jeremiah Smith,
11:28a defender and a half down the field, at least 10 to 15 yards away from the line of scrimmage with their backs turned.
11:36And if you have a, now I'm not saying he's going to go there because of the picks, but if you have
11:43a guy like Josh Allen, if you have a guy like Lamar or Caleb or whoever, that when they decide to turn
11:51it loose, they can roll for 10 or 15 yards.
11:54Third and seven doesn't look so long anymore because if you let Jeremiah Smith go, they're just going to throw it to
12:01him and he's going to pick it up. If you don't let Jeremiah Smith go and you've got a quarterback with wheels, he's going to pick it up.
12:10So you're kind of damned if you do and damned if you don't.
12:15And that's how somebody as good as Jeremiah Smith can affect the game.
12:19Even when you're not throwing it to him, he can make bigger lanes for your running back, right?
12:25Again, more attention paid to him. You run the other way.
12:28He's big enough to block and certainly will do that again, coming from the school of wide receivers who block good Ohio State.
12:36But you can use him. I'm not saying use him as a decoy, but even when he's not getting the ball, he
12:43can have a profound impact on your offense. And the defensive structures faced and what your offense can then make against those defenses.
12:51So very, very valuable player. But the other thing is it provides all kinds of negative pressure for GMs.
12:57And what do I mean by negative pressure? If he's as good as we all think he is and he turns into
13:04that guy that you're talking about, one of the top two, three receivers in the league, game changing talent.
13:10And you don't take him. Whoever fired, whoever you take has to be that good or better.
13:16And what are the chances that anybody is that good or better?
13:20We just said he's the best player in the class.
13:23So you might need and I mean desperately need a quarterback and your team might be sunk without them.
13:29And now you're in this crazy catch 22 of, well, what I should do is take the best player available, which is Jeremiah Smith.
13:37But maybe I already have another good receiver. And who's going to throw the ball?
13:42I got to take a quarterback. If you take a quarterback and they're just OK, maybe they're the 15th best quarterback or the 18th best quarterback.
13:51But they are not a difference mover, needle mover, right?
13:54Game changer that we think Jeremiah Smith is going to be.
13:58That pick is always going to be compared to Jeremiah Smith, regardless of the situation.
14:03And it creates this negative pressure, which is going to be a real like the meme with the guy trying to press the two red buttons, you know.
14:12I sweat and bullets. I should pick Jeremiah Smith.
14:15But if I don't and this guy is anything less than exceptional, everybody's going to say you should have picked the exceptional guy.
14:22It's not that hard. Yeah. The debate that I think everybody's going to be having, at least as of right now, Arch.
14:29Arch has put out a lot of good tape, but there's also been enough bad tape where it's like, is he the first overall pick, though?
14:38Right. I think a lot of people are starting to gravitate towards Mestemaker.
14:42It's QB1 in this class. And I like Mestemaker.
14:45I really do. And we'll have plenty of time to do a full evaluation as we get in the draft season.
14:52Like there's still half the college season to go.
14:55But I would say as of right now, seven weeks into the college football season, I think is what we're at now.
15:02He, I think, is probably the most common answer for QB1.
15:06So then it really comes down to, let's say we're Miami.
15:09Right. Who I think are probably the odds on favorite to land with the first overall pick.
15:15Right. Also have a mobile quarterback, which, to your point, Blake Willis can roll.
15:20So if you're playing man coverage on third down, he could pick up a bunch of first downs for you.
15:26So you're weighing Malik Willis and Jeremiah Smith versus Drew Mestemaker and Chris Bell and Caleb Douglas.
15:32I'm not saying I'm 100% yes, have to take Jeremiah Smith.
15:35But on first blush, I'm a lot more confident that Jeremiah Smith is going to live up to the expectations compared to Drew Mestemaker.
15:43And that's nothing against Mestemaker. Right. I do like him as a prospect.
15:48Jeremiah Smith is just that rare. And it would be really sick to see Jeremiah Smith and Bell with Malik.
15:54A-chan hopefully comes back healthy. That could be a fun offense in pretty short order.
15:59So, again, can be a game-changing threat if they have the entire season worth of tape on Malik and can do their
16:06evaluation and say, hey, he is moving in the ways we want him to move.
16:11With this, we think he'll be this much better.
16:14And they decide to roll. It'll be very much like what the Saints did with Tyler Shuck this offseason, which was like, hey, we are good.
16:23We think we're going to invest. We're going to grab a bunch of targets for you.
16:28And we're going to see if you can really turn the needle up.
16:32And that would be fun. So it'll be a fascinating thing to watch.
16:36Like you said, there's a ton more of the college season to go.
16:41Lots more evaluation to go. But it's a fascinating discussion because you rarely see players who are this good, quite frankly.
16:48Today's episode is sponsored by Factor. And I have used them for going on five years now, believe it or not.
16:55If you don't know who they are or what they do, Factor ships fresh, never frozen, dietitian approved meals right to your doorstep.
17:02And all of those meals can be heated up in the microwave in just two minutes.
17:07They taste great. There's a ton of variety. I'm talking over 100 different rotating weekly meal options.
17:13You're never going to get bored. And they have dozens upon dozens of add-ons too, like pumpkin flavored cheesecakes and protein shakes.
17:20If you're interested in trying it out for yourself and seeing why I've used it for basically a half decade now, you
17:27can go to factormeals.com slash bootleg50off and use promo code bootleg50off while you're there.
17:32And that will get you 50% off your order and one free breakfast item per box for a year while supplies last.
17:39That's code bootleg50off at factormeals.com slash bootleg50off to get 50% off and one free breakfast item for a year.
17:45Thank you to Factor for supporting the show. And now let's get back to it.
17:50All right, hot topic this week has been the Rams special teams and how truly awful they have been so far this year.
17:58Kind of saw it coming a mile away, right?
18:01Early in the Bills game, you give up a big kick return on the opening play.
18:06And I remember putting out a tweet like right after that.
18:10I was like, it's hard to take them seriously as a true Super Bowl contender when their special teams is this awful.
18:17And then it just got worse from there. But per Aaron Schatz, the Rams now have a negative 15.3% special teams DVOA,
18:24which would be the worst in history over a full season.
18:28This is just the first five games. And it's not just an issue with missing field goals or bad punt coverage or
18:35bad kickoff returns or bad kickoff return coverage. It's just kind of all of it rolled into one.
18:41So I wanted to talk about the value of special teams, you know, for winning programs, but also how much of an
18:48anchor it can be for a winning program that doesn't have all three ducks in a row, all three phases of the game, offense, defense, special teams.
18:57Like you can have an amazing offense and an amazing defense if your special teams is this bad.
19:03Dare I say, it kind of doesn't matter because that anchor is just so heavy.
19:08It's testing the theory. Can you really just win with two great phases in the NFL and whatever on special teams?
19:15And the Rams are testing it and it's not working out because the Rams just became the only team in NFL history.
19:22Again, the offense is great to gain 400 plus total yards, put up 30 plus first downs, score five plus touchdowns, convert
19:29more than half of their third downs, have no turnovers in a game and lose.
19:34It's tough since 2022. This is not a new problem either.
19:38The Rams have never ranked higher than 20th in a season in special teams DVOA.
19:43And most of the time they've been closer to the bottom.
19:4620th was their high watermark. That's rough. That's the best year.
19:50That's rough. Crazy, dude. So the Rams, how did we get here?
19:54The Rams are counting on their high profile stars and they have lots of them on both sides of the ball.
20:01They have been collecting them. Certainly that has been one of the biggest stories of the offseason.
20:06It's one of the reasons that everybody was looking at Los Angeles is a Super Bowl favorite.
20:12And they're hoping that that vast array of stars on offense and defense will make so much impact that special teams won't really matter.
20:20We'll be so far ahead because of all the firepower we've assembled that it won't really make a difference if we miss
20:27a kick here or there, if we give up some field position.
20:31That's what they're hoping. But games in the NFL are so close.
20:35We talk about this all the time. Game of inches, multiple lead changes, five, six lead changes throughout a game.
20:41That it's inevitable that special teams will come down to being a deciding factor and play a role throughout the season.
20:48And when they do, the Rams lose because of them more often than they win by a bunch.
20:54This is an organizational approach is what I'll say.
20:57This is just how they believe they should do it.
21:00Much like the Rams are different in the draft than many other teams, they're different in how they approach special teams than many other teams.
21:09The results are sort of indisputable. Like if you've never been higher than 20th and honestly your average is probably closer to
21:1623rd or 25th, you're losing all of the things.
21:19Like you said, it's not just missed extra points or missed field goals or anything else.
21:24You're losing field position both from your punting unit and your coverage units.
21:28Like it's all the things and they add up and in games that are so close week to week, the Rams are
21:35losing out because they have deprioritized this third phase in a way that a lot of people do.
21:41We don't talk a ton about special teams on this podcast.
21:45We do sometimes and we do recognize its importance.
21:48But the Rams basically kind of said, meh, we can win without it.
21:52Watch us. It's the arrogance isn't the right way to phrase it, but I'm struggling to find a synonym that fits here.
21:59The arrogance to assume that your offense can get so many yards that the hidden yardage difference between your bad special teams
22:07and their good special teams is somehow going to make up for that.
22:11Or the arrogance to think that our defensive line is so ferocious that, you know, it's going to make up for the
22:18difference in average field position that we're going to lose on special teams.
22:22If we're getting so much good field position with third down stops or third down conversions, it's all going to even out in the wash.
22:31That hasn't necessarily been true so far. I mean, it's more true, I would say, for the offensive side than the defensive
22:38side, but not true to the point where they're actually getting wins out of it.
22:43Right. So I want to quantify the hidden yardage difference specifically for the Rams and the typical scoring drive efficiency that you're
22:50going to get as a normal average NFL team based on the different field positions that you're going to get, especially on kickoff returns.
22:58Right. So the Rams average starting field position when they receive a kickoff is the 27.6 yard line.
23:04Keep in mind, the NFL average is usually about the 30 yard line with the new kickoff rules.
23:10So they're starting about two and a half to three yards below average in terms of average starting field position.
23:16The opposing average starting field position against them on kickoff.
23:20So when the Rams are kicking off and they're covering a kick, they're allowing their opponents on average to start at the 33.6 yard line.
23:28Doesn't seem like that big of a difference, right?
23:31It's six yards. Okay. Our defense is good enough to make up that six yardage difference.
23:36Our offense is certainly good enough to make up that six yardage difference.
23:40Like what, what's the big deal about that? If you're looking at a differential of six yards, every single kickoff throughout the
23:47course of a game, throughout the course of a season, they've had 48 combined kickoffs for this special teams unit, whether they're
23:55kicking off or whether they're receiving 48 combined kickoffs.
23:58That is a 60 yard differential per game, just from your kickoff unit, both covering and kicking that differential.
24:04If you applied that 60 yard penalty, we'll call it that.
24:07If you applied that 60 yard penalty to their defense in terms of average yards allowed per game, that takes them from
24:15third best in the league down to 21st. That's how many yards per game that is.
24:20If you apply it to their offense, it takes them from first in terms of offensive yardage production per game down to 10th.
24:27So it affects their defense more than their offense, just because their offense is so good this year.
24:33But that is an absurd hit in hidden yardage per game.
24:37Like that's, that's indefensible. If I'm a special teams coach, like I can't, I can't be giving up 60 yards to the opponent every single week.
24:46Like a corner gets benched if they're giving up 60 yards per game, because that translates to damn near giving up a thousand yards in a season.
24:54And when you look at scoring drive averages, like here's the actual, the true danger for them.
25:00If you allow a team to start a drive at the 27 yard line, the average scoring drive percentage is 35%.
25:07All right. Decent. I would say it's average. If you allow them to start from the 33, that scoring drive percentage jumps to 45%.
25:15It's a 10% scoring drive average from six yards of starting field position.
25:19With an average drive count per team per game of 10, you're basically giving them an extra scoring drive every single game just from that.
25:27Now you might wonder why? Like why, why is that translating to such a, a large, uh, jump in scoring drive percentage for six yards?
25:35It's because if you're looking at how field goal ranges have changed and how good kickers are at nailing 50 to 60 yard field goals.
25:44Well, most kickers. Most kickers. Not the one that just let go.
25:48It's relevant to this discussion. It is. It is.
25:50If you're looking at the average length of a drive in football, it's give or take 30 yards, right?
25:57Whenever a team takes possession on average, they're going to gain 30 yards.
26:01Sometimes it's way less than that. Sometimes it's way more than that.
26:05Obviously, if they're punching into the end zone, your typical drives can be way longer.
26:10If you're the Eagles, you're going to watch them not get 30 yards quite often.
26:1530 yards from the 27 yard line is the opposing 43, which means if you're kicking a field goal from there, it's a 60 yard field goal attempt.
26:24Not impossible by today's standards, but there's still a rather short list of kickers that I think have the green light to kick from 60 plus.
26:33And, uh, the Rams did not have one of those to say the least 30 yards from starting at the 33 makes it a 54 yard field goal.
26:42The difference in the number of kicks from that particular yard marker compared to from the 60 to 61 yard line is about 75 to nine last season.
26:51So teams are much more willing to kick field goals from that range.
26:55And they're certainly much more willing to go for it if they're on the opposing 37 compared to if they're on the opposing 43.
27:03So that is why the scoring drive percentage kicks up is because you're, you're putting them into field goal distance, makeable field
27:10goal distance by giving up those six yards of field position on the kickoff unit.
27:15And when you're doing that 48 times in five games, yeah, it's going to look like that.
27:21So special teams matters. Field position matters. It's not just a nerdy analytics talking point.
27:26It's real. It's tangible. It translates. And if you're that bad, if you're, if you're the Rams special teams, it doesn't matter
27:33that you have the number one offense, the number three defense.
27:37It does not matter. You will lose games. And they lost because of that.
27:41Yeah, we just watched it happen. And somebody might wonder why this happens organizationally.
27:46And when you look at the Rams, they do operate differently in the draft.
27:50And that is they marched to the beat of their own drummer very much so.
27:55And they've had some great success doing that. But typically they've had a lot of later round picks because Les Snead famously
28:02got rid of his high picks for a long time or traded them away for these high profile stars on offense and defense.
28:10And it left them with either less picks or a lot lower picks or both.
28:15And so they had to fill in other spots on offense and defense, typically those lower picks later than the fourth round,
28:22late fourth round into the compensatory picks, five, six, seven.
28:25Other teams are picking up one to two guys that are special teamers.
28:30They just haven't operated that way for years. And eventually it hollows out the back end of that roster.
28:36And you're also starting to see it on defense, like the defensive backs outside of the very high profile guys that they've
28:43brought in with those high pick trades are kind of slow.
28:47Those kind of guys are starters now, either because of injury or just that's who we have on our 53.
28:53And that means the guys behind them that aren't that good are your special teamers.
28:58And in a war of attrition like the NFL, you get this.
29:02We'll just call it a leak, right? This leak of yardage on every kickoff, on every punt, on everything else.
29:09All the margins are really small. Also, a seemingly small amount of yards has a large impact.
29:14And it is because of how this team has approached the third phase and the draft in combination, we find ourselves at
29:22this place where they're firing special teams coaches midseason.
29:24It's the first time I believe McVay has ever fired an assistant coach midseason was when he let Chase Blackburn go.
29:31I believe that's true. So it doesn't happen. He is not typically angry at the podium after a loss.
29:38He can be frustrated. I have not seen him that emotional.
29:41We talk about emotional decisions and we talk about emotional blitzing and emotional this and emotional that.
29:47Emotion is part of the NFL and it should be.
29:50But I have not seen McVay in particular that hot, that angry, right?
29:54This is this is hurting him as a coach.
29:57It's hurting his pride and his perception and quite frankly, his output as a football team.
30:03And that's when that's when things move the needle.
30:06That's when changes get made. The NFL is when it's like, all right, rubber hits the road.
30:11We just did great as I outlined on offense and we still lost the game.
30:16And, you know, you saw it. Changes were made pretty much immediately.
30:20And I think there are probably more to come while they try and figure it out.
30:25But it is not there is not a quick fix for this.
30:29You can't simply say, well, let's do the last three years of the draft over and like start investing after the fifth round in special teams.
30:38Like they might start it this year. I would imagine they probably will if they're smart because they have to close this gap.
30:45It doesn't seem like it matters until it does.
30:48And by then it's too late. Speaking of things that matter, if you made it this far in the episode and you're
30:55still enjoying it, take a quick second. Make sure you're subscribed on the YouTube channel.
31:00If you are already subscribed, thank you very much.
31:03We appreciate it. And if you haven't already, it's important because an independent show hitting 100,000 subscribers does not happen all that often.
31:11And when it does, the industry notices. So you can help us.
31:15We appreciate it. All right, let's get into offseason additions that both worked how we thought they would and also definitely did
31:22not work how we thought they could. I kind of want to start with the ones that haven't gone as well as I projected them to.
31:31Just because I did not expect this whatsoever. Also, caveat, not really the player's fault, in my opinion.
31:36The Raiders paid Tyler Linderbaum $27 million a year.
31:39And we talked about, okay, center was easily the weakest link on their offensive line last year.
31:45They were one of the three worst teams as far as average yards before contact per attempt, let alone the rest of their rushing stats.
31:53It wasn't a good run game. You drafted Ashton Gentry super high, but you didn't really have the line in front of
32:00him that could allow Ashton to be Ashton. Get a new center, you know, and if your quarterback works out, then fine.
32:08Like, we're okay with overpaying a center because we're underpaying a quarterback.
32:12Kind of all comes out in the ether hunky-dory, right, finances-wise.
32:15Like, they just needed a center so desperately. The $27 million didn't bother me that much.
32:20However, if you're looking at the Raiders' stats so far this year, they are still dead last in yards before contact per attempt at .4 yards per attempt.
32:30They are 27th in rushing EPA per play. They are 27th in rushing success rate.
32:35It looks like this has not worked. But I would contend it's not necessarily Tyler Linderbaum's fault.
32:40He himself is doing his job. The guard situation around Tyler Linderbaum, remember the entire interior offensive line, has to work together as a unit.
32:48The guards are awful. Burford hasn't worked. Jackson Powers Johnson has been a liability.
32:53And the only reason he's getting snaps is because Caleb Rogers is way worse in pass protection than even JPJ has been.
33:00JPJ is just a really god-awful run blocker so far this year.
33:04There's no good answers here at the guard spot.
33:07And I am reminded that the goal you should have for building a great offensive line is just don't have a weak link in the chain.
33:16Like, you can get by with five average to solid guys.
33:19You don't need a superstar as long as you don't have somebody who is bottom five at their position.
33:25They might have two of those right now. And so it feels like no matter what Linderbaum does, like just watching the
33:33tape, the combo blocks, the communication on these combos is terrible.
33:36Like, they're not in sync on those. Maybe you could partly put that on Tyler.
33:41But I'm going to defer to the pass tape of Tyler Linderbaum where he was totally fine with combo blocks compared to
33:48the pass tape of all of these guards where they were not.
33:52So I'm willing to give the benefit of the doubt to him over these guards.
33:57But even just like the individual, like how well are you blocking guys individually?
34:02Tyler's been fine. JPJ's been terrible. Like, all that size and he just doesn't have any knockback power whatsoever.
34:08The vertical displacement is just non-existent. Rodgers has been awful in pass protection.
34:12Burford's just there. So I feel like there's nothing that Linderbaum individually can do here when only one third of their interior
34:20offensive line is playable at this point. So maybe they're going to be active at the trade deadline for a guard.
34:26Good luck finding one because every team needs a guard.
34:30But like you can even see it in the run concept percentages.
34:34Clint Kubiak's a wide zone guy. Why? They're 23rd in wide zone carries per game because they can't do it because their guards can't do it.
34:42Linderbaum can do it just fine. Nobody else can.
34:45They're sixth in inside zone and seventh in power counter pin and bolt because that's the only thing their guards can.
34:52Well, they can't even really do that, but like they definitely can't do wide zone.
34:57So it just feels like they have to be this, you know, less lateral run game, more north-south run game because of
35:04the limitations of the personnel, not the strengths of the personnel.
35:08So to me, I'm putting this as a didn't work without it really being Linderbaum's fault.
35:13It's just they didn't do enough this offseason to fix the entire interior offensive line.
35:18One guy was not going to rectify this by himself.
35:21Yeah, it's tough when you have a problem on both sides as a center.
35:26I've seen it before. Good to great centers who have been good to great throughout their career, and they end up in
35:33a situation either through attrition or injury or changing teams or whatever it is, and they end up with problems on both sides.
35:41It's kind of a two-way go. Damned if you do, damned if you don't, and you end up trying to do one and a half jobs.
35:49But the problem is it's one and a half jobs to the right and one and a half jobs to the left, depending on the play.
35:58Can be up to three jobs on pass protection, right?
36:01And that's just too many jobs for anybody, even great players.
36:05And what you have is these breakdowns in communication, in technique, in whatever else.
36:09And I'll say it, the Raiders' sort of interior knockback, or what I was hoping, expecting the Raiders to be able to
36:16get done in terms of interior knockback on runs this year, has been disappointing.
36:21I was patient through the first couple games. I saw a couple times when I thought, hey, they're getting after it, especially in the first two games.
36:30And I thought, hey, all right, they're getting it solved.
36:33It just fell off the table. And the problem is, like you said, if you have a very good run blocking guard,
36:40maybe if you had a mobile quarterback, you could do that.
36:44You could just say, hey, sometimes he's going to let quick pressure into the backfield.
36:49You're going to have to dodge him, Kirk. Whoops.
36:52Nope. You can't do that. So you have to, again, keep your quarterback upright and pick the guy that is more stable in pass protection.
37:00And if he's a liability in the run game, so be it.
37:04It's more important to keep your passer upright. And it has been like running into a wall for the past two or three weeks.
37:12I will say I don't think Ashton's completely healthy.
37:15There was some discussion about that. He worked out on the field.
37:19They say he's going to play. He doesn't really look right.
37:22I would be leaning more on Mike Washington because he is healthy.
37:26He's a rookie, but he's healthy. But again, if the offensive line's not opening holes and moving people, you're not going to have a great run game.
37:35The running back is going to be struggling for his life, no matter who it is, every single carry.
37:41And that's really where the Raiders have ended up.
37:44So I'm with you. It's stabilized the center position, but that does not stabilize the entire offensive line.
37:50So my high profile move that has not worked out or a dud so far.
37:55And again, this is so far. I'm going to skip all the injury related ones because that's injury and it's fickle.
38:02Like A.J. Brown hasn't been great so far. He's been hurt the entire time.
38:07Miles Garrett got hurt almost immediately. Doesn't mean Miles Garrett's not going to come roaring back in the second half of the season.
38:14He totally could. Been on the field a bunch.
38:17Got paid a bunch of money. Definitely starter level.
38:20Was expected to come in and start under a new but defensive-minded head coach.
38:25And it's Alante Taylor, the corner for Tennessee. So he signed for three years and $60 million.
38:30About $20 million a year. Definite starter money. They are lining him up outside and saying, go be one of our guys.
38:38He hasn't done that yet. He's been targeted 24 times this season.
38:41He's allowed 21 receptions. That's not good enough at any level.
38:45He's allowed 215 yards, which is the most for any Tennessee defender.
38:49And an NFL passer rating against. Now remember, as a corner, you want that number to be wee.
38:55You want that number to be small. Not large like you do with Jeremiah Smith.
39:00It is 117.9 when you throw the ball at Alante Taylor.
39:03I'm sorry. If you are bringing that guy in to be a starter, I don't care about new system.
39:10I don't care about new coach. He's a good player.
39:13He was a good player in New Orleans. He got starter money.
39:17He's been bad this year. He has been the weak link in that defense.
39:22And don't think that every offensive coordinator coming to town doesn't see that.
39:26Right? They know. Like, hey, if we need something, we're going to Alante Taylor's side.
39:31Because 21 out of 24 times, the other teams have gotten it.
39:35We can probably get ours too. And until he can bow up or he gets replaced, which I don't know that Tennessee
39:42can afford that either roster-wise or money-wise, this is going to continue to happen.
39:46And it's kind of like the offensive lines. The secondary is very much the same thing.
39:52If you have one defender that just flat out is not able to cover, that's where teams are going to go.
39:59And they're not going to stop until you fix it through scheme or blitz or anything else.
40:04Make the coverage into the or make the rush into the coverage.
40:08Whatever you need to do. But if you paid a guy $60 million, you weren't expecting to have to do that because of him.
40:16As far as pickups that actually have worked out, and I would say worked out even better than I thought they would.
40:23Like, I was a fan of the Boya Mafia contract just more so because of the way it was structured.
40:30I thought it was a really team-friendly deal. It was more front-loaded over the first two years.
40:35And I was like, hey, for where the edge market's at, at $50 million, it's a front-loaded deal for not a lot of money.
40:43He was a solid contributor in Seattle. I liked the contract.
40:47He didn't play like this in Seattle. This is the best he's ever looked.
40:51He is seventh in pressures among edges. He is fifth in pressure percentage right behind Will Anderson.
40:57His average getoff is 0.79 seconds. That is ninth fastest in the NFL among all edges.
41:02That is also why he is fourth in quick pressures, which are pressures that happen under two and a half seconds.
41:09He has 12 of those so far this year.
41:12So what is that? Two and a half to three per game where he's getting the quarterback in under two and a
41:19half seconds, which basically just ends the play if you're winning that quickly.
41:24He doesn't get chipped or doubled that much because Dexter Lawrence exists.
41:28I imagine that number might go up by the end of the season because right now Will Anderson's getting chipped and doubled
41:35at like a 30% rate, which is absurd that he still has that high of a pressure percentage.
41:41But I mean, the fact that he is that productive when left alone, that's what they're paying him to do is win your one-on-ones.
41:49He is winning his one-on-ones there. I'm not saying the Cincy defense is perfect.
41:53Obviously, they have flaws, but like one of the main things this team had to fix was their pass rush.
42:00They have done that this year easily at a higher rate than we expected.
42:04And we were defenders of Boye Maffei coming out.
42:07We liked his athleticism, his projection to if he hits his ceiling.
42:11And like you said, he did some nice things in Seattle.
42:15He was a very solid rotational piece. He set the edge pretty well.
42:19You saw the burst occasionally, but the consistency wasn't there.
42:22And he's landed with the Bengals defense and the consistency is happening.
42:26And sometimes you see this with a change of scenery.
42:30We look at guys like Javon Dexter, who very well could have been on this list, got traded to Atlanta and has,
42:37I'm not going to say morphed because he was always good, but he hit a system and a coordinator that understands his strengths.
42:44And he's been one of the best pass rush and defensive tackles in the entire league.
42:50So didn't do that in Chicago. You saw good play.
42:53You saw flashes promise. It's kind of same thing with Maffei.
42:57He goes to the Bengals and he's tearing it up.
43:00My choice is also an edge for an underrated move.
43:03That's been great so far. Cameron Thomas, the edge for Atlanta.
43:07Now I liked Cameron Thomas a lot, but in my wildest dreams, even in my rosiest pre-draft evaluations.
43:13And again, I really liked his tape. I didn't think he could be as good as he's been through five games with Atlanta.
43:20He's ninth in total pressures in the league with 22.
43:23He has 10 quarterback hits. So pressures again, sacks, hurries and hits.
43:27Sacks and hits obviously impact on your quarterback. You're putting them on the ground.
43:32He has 10 quarterback hits. That's tied for third in the NFL.
43:36And he's got three sacks, which is tied for 16th through five games.
43:40This is not a player that moved the needle when Atlanta signed him.
43:44Everybody's like, can't count. Okay. Like, is he, is he going to make the team?
43:49Like, is he, is he going to be like the four third or fourth edge?
43:54Is he going to be on the 53? Is he going to be on the active roster on game day?
44:01He was a, he was an edge fringe type player based on his production before hitting Atlanta.
44:06Nate Ollie, we brought him up in the summer series.
44:10He's the defensive line coach for the Falcons this year.
44:13And he came from your Texans, Houston. Yeah. So guy can coach defensive line.
44:18And we are seeing that because the Atlanta defensive line was thought to be a wasteland.
44:23Their top two pass rushers from last year were out young pass rushers, one with injury, the other due to suspension.
44:30And we didn't think this team's pass rush was going to be that good with them on the field.
44:36We were hoping for maybe mid pack success, which would still be a huge jump from where Atlanta was two seasons ago
44:43when they made the major draft investment to go get them.
44:47So we were hoping they could just kind of hold the fort.
44:51The Atlanta defense is third in pass rushing in the NFL.
44:54Cameron Thomas has been a huge part of that, along with guys like Javon Dexter.
44:59Again, Cam Thomas, for what the current edge market is, is a massive value who has wildly overperformed based on expectations.
45:06And Atlanta's reaping the benefits. Yeah, he signed a one year deal for those of you that didn't keep track of Cam Thomas in the offseason.
45:15One year deal, $1.5 million base salary, including bonuses and everything like that.
45:19His cap hits $3.1 million, which is a grand total of 1% of the Falcons cap to get an edge rusher this productive.
45:27That that might be the best value signing of the offseason, like anywhere.
45:31If you're looking at production for four dollars like that's that's insane.
45:35Coaching matters. And we say it all the time, especially I know a lot of you chafe at our rosiness pre-draft, our positivity, right?
45:43We're always looking at what players might be able to do if they hit their ceiling.
45:48A lot of times it's, you know, I'm not going to say never wrong, often wrong, but also early correct on some players.
45:55They have to find the right fit. Sometimes they do and sometimes they don't.
46:00Right. Some players go through their whole career, might be short, never find the right place to truly unlock the skills they had.
46:08Doesn't mean they weren't skilled players. Means they never found that perfect match of sort of lock and key fit.
46:14Cam Thomas has a couple of stops before this one.
46:17Hasn't really shown out. Ends up in Atlanta. Bam.
46:20First month of the season. He is a literal top 10 pass rusher in the NFL.
46:26He is the source of my copium over the Marvin Jr.
46:29trade because he also spent four years in Arizona doing not a whole lot until he left Arizona.
46:35So I don't know. Maybe the same will happen for Marvin.
46:39I guess we'll see. All right. Speaking of young players that are popping off, young pass rushers that are popping off, we
46:46talked about David Bailey or rather said we would talk about David Bailey last episode.
46:51Let's do it now. We have time. Let's acknowledge that he is now the first player in NFL history.
46:57First pass rusher in NFL history to start his career in his first five games of 25 tackles and five sacks.
47:04A lot of that came in the last game.
47:07Obviously, we had nine pressures, five quick pressures in one game.
47:11Eight of them were in one on one. So he's winning his one on one.
47:15So he had three sacks. His average getoff was point eight four.
47:19And it wasn't just him winning with speed rushes like we saw in college.
47:24Like he won with power. He won inside. He won out like it was all of it.
47:30Right. And, you know, his rematch against Fano, which he saw in college.
47:34He got Fano got lit up in this game for being honest.
47:38But it like he wasn't just beating Fano is beating both of them like he won on both sides.
47:44So great, great day for him. And I think this is the moment that Jets fans are waiting for of like, OK, we got one here.
47:53Right. Because Arvel Reese has had good tape and Caleb Downs had good tape.
47:57Sonny Stiles had good tape. And everybody's like, oh, did the Jets screw up the second overall pick?
48:03After that game. At least the answer isn't definitively yes.
48:06You know, the answer is like, hey, they might have something here.
48:10They might have a real edge rusher that was worth the second overall pick.
48:15Yeah, they might. David Bailey's had some decent flashes so far.
48:18He's had some highlight plays. He hasn't had a complete game yet in his rookie season, but it's starting to look like he's truly putting it together.
48:27Cleveland could not block him run or pass. This was a complete game.
48:32They tried pretty much everything. They tried pretty much everyone and they didn't have any success.
48:37So huge effort and hustle all day long. That was really impressive.
48:41Backsiding runs, dragging down the quarterback on, you know, some cleanup sacks, some pure sacks for the game.
48:47Three tackles for loss, like you said. Nine total pressures.
48:50Three total sacks. The coolest thing for me is that five of those total pressures came in true pass at situations, including
48:57two of the sacks, one hit and two of the hurries.
49:01So lined up, designated passing down, you versus me.
49:04And he was winning. And that's quite frankly why you take a guy that high in the draft.
49:10He's starting to look like a player that opposing offenses are going to have to deal with or he's going to wreck your shop.
49:18And I mean, anything you want to do, run at him, run away from him, pass.
49:23He was destroying all of it. Um, you mentioned the power piece, which was awesome for me.
49:28Tremendous speed to power rush versus Fano. You didn't see a lot of that in the tape.
49:34If you want to go look at it, it's in the first quarter at nine, 12 hits him, just puts him on skates.
49:42Now the footing was not great. It's not great for everybody though.
49:45And he pushed him directly back, basically discarded him, grab the quarterback.
49:49We didn't see a ton of that in college.
49:52That's the most exciting thing for me. When we say, Oh, a guy's got to develop a counter move or he's got to be better with power.
50:01He's got to be better with his hands or whatever else.
50:05And then he starts to do that in the pros against top competition.
50:09Fano was my top tackle in this class. He absolutely put him on a sled.
50:14He had a nice speed dip. Now that's more of his college tape versus DeJuan Jones on the other side, the other tackle on third and 30.
50:23Poor DeJuan. He can't get that low. He did.
50:26And to be honest, Bailey didn't get that low either.
50:29He's just so fast that he gave him a slightly, slightly lessened target to hit.
50:34He was under and through, barely slowed him down.
50:37Didn't even really have to bend his rush route that much.
50:41And when you have a guy that is as athletically gifted as David Bailey, and he's that fast, you don't get a decent hand on him.
50:49He is on the quarterback. It was well under two seconds before he got to the quarterback.
50:55Um, just an awesome tape to watch. Like guys contributing in every game.
50:59Like when he's on the field, it's what you want to see in college, quite frankly.
51:04When a guy that is highly touted, you know, potential top draft pick, you don't want to have to know who he is.
51:12You don't have to look his number up. You just want to put the tape on and go, holy crap, that guy's wrecking everything.
51:20That's what this tape looked like in the pros.
51:23Got to be a huge relief to Jets fans to say, you know, barring unforeseen circumstances, injury or something else, this guy
51:30can get it done at a top level in all phases.
51:33He's not just good at one thing and we'll wait, be patient and he'll get good at the other things.
51:40He is good at all the things right now.
51:43And if he can continue to play with this level of effort, just this level of effort, the results will come.
51:50If you're looking at the 2026 draft as a whole, the early returns, right?
51:54Because the narrative going into the draft was, hey, this is a terrible class.
51:59Like there's just not a lot of talent. And even you and I were like, it's not the same as like peak
52:06years, you know, comparing it to sure. 2027, 2011, 2014, 2018, I think.
52:11Was it 2017 or 2018? One of those was like a crazy year.
52:15And so we're like, okay, yeah, it's not that.
52:18And certainly the shelf hit quicker because of NIL kind of thinning out day three.
52:23But, you know, I felt like there was a lot of talent in this draft that was getting undervalued because of the
52:30narrative about how poor this class was in some people's views.
52:34So if David Bailey works out, that's great. The Jets desperately needed that hit at second overall.
52:39But Mancer Delane has flashed. Sonny Stiles has flashed.
52:42Francis Malanoa has looked great at guard so far.
52:45Caleb Downs is Caleb Downs. Venga Ioane. I don't even care what position he's playing.
52:50He's been amazing. He might be the best offensive rookie in the league this year.
52:55I think he is. I would vote for him for rookie of the year right now.
53:00Yeah. 100%. He's been great. Blake Miller's been up and down, but like there's been encouraging signs.
53:06Maxi Hanajor. Oh, this Steelers got one there. This last week, right?
53:10Again, just like Bailey. Some flashes, but like, hey man, you gotta be with a Hanajor.
53:15You gotta be better with your hands, right? You can't just offer up your hands.
53:20They're gonna chop him down. This week, much, much better with his hands.
53:24Weighted, flashed, uses length, uses power, his athleticism. It's like, yeah, that's the tool.
53:29That's how you have to use it to win against NFL pass rushers.
53:33So cool to see. He is rapidly improving. Yeah.
53:36And becoming their right tackle in the future that you and I hoped he could be considering his physical skills.
53:42I think the Browns hit on both the receivers they picked, Casey Conception, and especially Denzel Boston.
53:48He's been awesome. Let's see. Who else am I forgetting?
53:51I think... Dillon. Dillon. Dillon Price has been injured.
53:54Dillon Thieneman. Oh, yeah. Dillon Thieneman. Well, until the Packer game.
53:58Dude. That was his welcome to the NFL moment.
54:01He got bombed. He just bombed in that game.
54:04Well, you look at the first one, like, he is in Christian Watson's chest in the end zone.
54:10Like, it's a great... It's an amazing throw by Love.
54:13Like, it's a crazy throw. If you look at the end zone angle of that throw, for everybody that says, like, oh, Jordan Love's not a good quarterback.
54:22I'm like, buddy, look at the end zone angle of that throw.
54:26The first one in the first quarter to Christian Watson.
54:29And Thieneman... Absurd. Is in his chest at the catch point.
54:33He's got his head down and his shoulder up, but he is literally in Watson's chest.
54:38He is in phase in the end zone. Watson makes a tough, contested catch in the end zone because Christian Watson's great
54:45and the other guys get paid too. But I'm not that upset about Dillon Thieneman on that play.
54:51I know a lot of people are giving him garbage.
54:55I'm like, hey, he was there. It's tough to stay with Christian Watson down the field.
55:00He did that. He was at the catch point and contesting it.
55:04Great play by Love. Awesome play by Watson. Not a bad play by Thieneman.
55:08So overall, this rookie class has been good. I'm not saying it's like immediate superstars all over the place.
55:15Oh, Jacob Rodriguez. Well, okay. Other than bootleg gem Jacob Rodriguez and bootleg gem Grayson Halton.
55:20Other than that. Starting to play. No, it's again.
55:23We had that narrative. This isn't just us. You know, Johnny come lately saying, oh, we think it's good now.
55:29We said at the time, it's not that bad.
55:32And depending on fit, there is talent at all levels of this draft.
55:37Not as much, but not none. And that narrative.
55:40I think that drumbeat started really early. September, October.
55:43People like this is a bad draft. It's a bad draft.
55:46It's a thin draft. There's nothing here. There's nothing here.
55:49And, you know, different position groups. Oh, this is super thin.
55:53There's nobody. I was like, ah. You know, again, we're optimistic.
55:57I don't really ever think that any year. It was lesser than some other years.
56:02But there are a lot of good players. And we're seeing them make contributions very early and often.
56:08Speaking of Bears defenders getting the shit beat out of them.
56:11Oh, yes. Our shot of the week winner this week.
56:14Of course. Of course. I don't think the patrons could resist themselves.
56:18Marshawn Lloyd running over the Bears in quite possibly the most violent touchdown run of the season so far.
56:25So cheers to you, Marshawn Lloyd. That really sucked.
56:28Yeah. He's contributing and they desperately need him to be contributing.
56:31We had all hoped that Jalen Johnson was going to get back to the point where he could get himself in position to make tackles like that.
56:40Actually making the tackle kind of a different thing.
56:43Yeah. Easier said than done for sure. Want to thank all of our patrons who make this show possible every single week.
56:50All of our executive producers on Patreon. Fitzy, Connor, Kelbs, Mike, Owen, Eiken, Stewart, and Major.
56:55Thank you all once again for the support. Thank you to everybody who voted on the poll on Patreon for shot of the week.
57:03Remember, it was a public poll. Always is every single week.
57:07You don't have to be a patron to vote.
57:10We appreciate it if you become one. Thank you to all of our sponsors.
57:14Thank you to Alden, our wonderful editor. And we will see you all very soon.
57:19You're welcome. Thank you. You're welcome. Thank you. Thank you.
57:23So,