Dynasty Points artwork

Week 6 Rookie Rankings & Risers: Who Is The Real Deal?

STACKED extracted the fantasy-relevant player signal from this podcast and kept the full transcript here for context.

52 min
Duration
Estimated from transcript
Oct 21, 2026
Published
Wed, October 21, 2026
42
Player insights
28
Players mentioned
Topics
Omar Cooper Jr.Jameson WilliamsKenyon SadiqMason TaylorAntonio WilliamsGarrett WilsonMichael PittmanAdonai MitchellAntonio BrownDenzel BostonDeshaun WatsonDeVonta SmithDK MetcalfElijah Sarratt
Player analysis

Player insights

42

Adonai Mitchell

NegativeRole8:00

Mitchell has been sidelined with a hand injury for an extended period; despite showing good separation scores and air yards in limited action (one game and a half), his catch rate is inconsistent; even upon return, Cooper is expected to be projected higher and continue to outproduce him.

Insight page

Antonio Brown

NegativeValue47:12

Cooper prefers Jameson Williams over Antonio Brown, suggesting Brown is overpriced relative to Williams despite Brown's recent two-game stretch with a touchdown game and 100-yard game in Week 5.

Insight page

Antonio Williams

PositiveRole34:30

With Terry McLaurin out for the season, Antonio Williams inherits a significant opportunity as the Commanders' primary slot/outside receiver. In Week 6 relief work, Williams ran one more route than Stefan Diggs and led the team in route share post-injury; over the full season with Jaden Daniels starting, he's at 1.8 yards per route run—just behind Diggs and ahead of McLaurin—with identical average separation to McLaurin. Cooper views this as Williams's audition for the Commanders' long-term receiver room, especially given Diggs's age (30+) and McLaurin's uncertain recovery from major lower-body injury.

Insight page
PositiveBreakout36:27

Cooper ranks Williams behind both Jaylen Barks Cooper and Jeremy Bernard on prospect profile alone, but credits him with 'the most clearly potentially advantageous long-term situation of anyone we've talked about so far.' Williams has shown explosiveness in relief (including a called-back touchdown in the London game) and is positioned as the long-term receiver for Jaden Daniels, who Cooper expects to remain with the Commanders, making this season a critical audition for the franchise's receiver plans going forward.

Insight page

Denzel Boston

PositiveBreakout33:18

Cooper was initially too low on Denzel Boston and now views him as an absolute monster and star-caliber player. Boston's prospect profile and on-field performance have been super impressive this year. Cooper prefers Boston over Jeremy Bernard in dynasty trades and notes that Boston's upside is further enhanced by the Browns' quarterback situation; even with Deshaun Watson's current struggles, Boston looks elite, and would look even better with a competent quarterback like Case Keenum.

Insight page

Deshaun Watson

NegativeMatchup33:48

Cooper describes Deshaun Watson as super washed, implying that the Browns quarterback situation is a drag on receiver production. This context is used to explain why Denzel Boston looks elite despite playing with Watson, and would look even better with a different quarterback like Case Keenum.

Insight page

DeVonta Smith

PositiveValue12:42

In a one-for-one trade against Omar Cooper, speakers prefer to hold Devonta Smith; the trade is viewed as a wash on both value and production sides, with no clear gain for either party. Smith's established role and consistency make him the safer hold despite Cooper's upside.

Insight page

DK Metcalf

NegativeRole26:42

DK Metcalf is mentioned in context of Aaron Rodgers' target distribution; the implication is that Rodgers is not relying on Metcalf for short-area targets, instead consolidating those targets to Jeremy Bernard.

Insight page

Elijah Sarratt

NegativeProjection23:45

Cooper ranks Elijah Surratt higher than he should every season, using him as a comparable analytical-profile player to Alman Ross St. Brown; however, the broader context is that analytics-based prospecting has almost no relationship to success once you get deep into day three of the draft, with only rare exceptions.

Insight page

Garrett Wilson

NegativeUsage0:49

Garrett Wilson ran the most routes on the Jets in Week 6, with Omar Cooper running fewer routes than only Wilson, indicating Wilson's continued role as the team's primary receiver.

Insight page
NegativeMatchup6:20

Garrett Wilson is getting shattered by Christian Gonzalez in coverage, which may explain why the Jets are targeting the number two receiver (Omar Cooper) more heavily.

Insight page

Isaiah Williams

NegativeRole9:54

Williams is featured in the Jets' 11-personnel sets alongside Mason Taylor and Tim Patrick, part of the coaching staff's rotation strategy.

Insight page

Jameson Williams

NegativeRole23:58

Jamison Williams is characterized as a downfield, super explosive, very flashy type of receiver on his offense, used as a contrast to Jeremy Bernard's profile of consistent short-area targets.

Insight page
NegativeProjection30:06

Cooper notes that Jameson Williams holds disproportionate power over the dynasty community, with recurring annual debates about whether he'll outscore Amin Ross and Sam Brown despite not being a historic target earner; the community's fascination with Williams is driven by 'style points' rather than target-earning fundamentals, a pattern Cooper observes repeats yearly.

Insight page
PositiveRole47:12

Cooper emphasizes Williams is startable every week in one of the league's best offenses that drops back frequently and concentrates targets among four players; he's capable of major spike weeks but will be frustrating in others due to inconsistent target share. Williams is not priced to require becoming something other than what he's been—a talented route-runner without consistent alpha target volume. If Amon-Ra St. Brown, Laporta, or Gibbs get hurt, he becomes a top-20 wide receiver.

Insight page
NegativeProjection48:00

Cooper does not expect Williams to transition into a target-dominant alpha overnight; the hype around him often tries to make him something he's not. His pricing this year does not require him to become something other than what he's been, unlike last year when he was overpriced relative to his actual role.

Insight page

Jarvis Landry

PositiveProjection29:42

Landry is cited as a comp for Jeremy Bernard's upside trajectory—a five-foot-11, 202-pound shifty underneath player with downfield questions who became 'super good for fantasy football' through target volume; Cooper notes Landry wasn't a 'sexy, super exciting type player' but delivered consistent fantasy value, suggesting Bernard could follow a similar path.

Insight page

Jayden Daniels

PositiveRole36:27

Cooper expresses confidence that Jaden Daniels will remain with the Commanders long-term, making him a stable quarterback anchor for the receiver room's future. This stability supports the long-term value of receivers like Antonio Williams who will operate in Daniels's system.

Insight page

Jaylen Warren

PositiveRole13:48

Warren's role has deteriorated; he was immediately put back into rotation with Rico Daddle despite inefficiency, and coaches have moved Jaylen Mitchell ahead of him in the target pecking order. This coaching decision limits Warren's upside and makes him an unattractive trade target compared to Omar Cooper.

Insight page

Kenneth Gainwell

PositiveRole9:08

Gainwell had an incredible breakout game against Detroit but saw his role diminished immediately upon Mason Taylor's return; the Jets shifted to 11-personnel with Tim Patrick and Isaiah Williams, benching the dynamic rookie back 65% of the time, exemplifying the Jets' inconsistent offensive approach.

Insight page

Kenyon Sadiq

PositiveRole3:00

Sadiq had a mini breakout a few weeks ago without Mason Taylor, but in Week 6 with both Cooper and Taylor healthy, Sadiq was relegated to a part-time role with only a 30% route share. This represents a significant drop from his earlier usage and suggests that with the full Jets receiving corps healthy, Sadiq's role has diminished compared to Cooper's full-time slot role.

Insight page
NegativeValue30:34

Sadiq was acquired alongside Jeremy Bernard and two third-round picks in exchange for Woody Marks, Basil Tootin, and a 2027 fourth-round pick; Cooper frames this as an interesting trade structure where Bernard's side represents better value.

Insight page
PositiveValue30:54

Cooper and co-host prefer Kenyan Sadiq paired with Jeremy Bernard over Basial Tootin in dynasty trades, valuing the diversification of two players rather than betting on a single prospect. The pairing provides two bites at the apple and is viewed as preferable even without either player having significantly higher upside than Tootin individually.

Insight page

Luther Burden

NegativeRole28:11

Cooper draws a game-style comparison between Jeremy Bernard and Luther Burden, noting both are rugged players with great after-the-catch ability and questions about consistency downfield, but both function as very good short-area targets; the comparison suggests similar fantasy usage profiles despite different prospect profiles.

Insight page

Mason Taylor

NegativeRole3:00

Mason Taylor returned to health in Week 6 alongside Omar Cooper. With both players healthy and back in the lineup, the Jets shifted to more 11 personnel packages, which benefited Cooper's slot role while Sadiq's usage decreased to 30% route share.

Insight page
NegativeRole5:07

Mason Taylor is a pretty reasonable inline tight end option for the Jets; the projection for the near term with Cooper is way cleaner, and the Jets clearly don't have an intention of force-feeding Kenny and Sadiq, making Taylor a more straightforward role.

Insight page
NegativeRole9:54

Taylor's return from injury prompted the Jets to shift offensive personnel and reduce Gainwell's role; the team prioritized 11-personnel sets featuring Taylor alongside Tim Patrick and Isaiah Williams.

Insight page

Michael Pittman

PositiveProjection26:28

Michael Pittman Jr. is described as 'washed' heading into the season; Cooper notes that while he was previously bullish on a 'target spamming Michael Pittman season,' that take has spiritually moved to Jeremy Bernard, who now consolidates the short-area targets that Aaron Rodgers is desperate to throw to someone.

Insight page
NegativeRole28:55

Pittman is cited as a comparison for Jeremy Bernard's profile; Cooper uses the Pittman comp 'simply because it's just the feeling I get from the community itself,' suggesting it reflects market perception of Bernard rather than a perfect game-style match.

Insight page

Omar Cooper Jr.

PositiveRole0:49

Cooper returned in Week 6 after missing four games with injury and immediately entered a full-time role, running fewer routes than only Garrett Wilson on the Jets. Despite only 28 routes run, he's 25 receiving yards behind Kenyon Sadiq for second on the team with 4.75 yards per route run. With Mason Taylor also healthy, Sadiq dropped to a 30% route share while Cooper operated in the slot two-thirds of the time, suggesting the Jets prefer Cooper as their full-time slot receiver in 11 personnel packages.

Insight page
PositiveBreakout3:43

Cooper has earned the full-time receiver role and is performing efficiently; Cooper was a legitimately high-quality prospect (late round one, early round two tweener) with strong per-route metrics who was talked down on during preseason. After five quarters of play, he looks awesome to the eye test and has been very efficient. Cooper was ranked highest among rookie receivers discussed by the source before the season, including situation, and remains the highest-ranked rookie receiver of the three discussed. The source sees difference-making upside and believes Cooper could develop into more than a fantasy WR3 at some point in his career; there's a chance he could be a total superstar.

Insight page
PositiveBreakout7:20

Cooper has shown difference-making upside to develop into more than a fantasy WR3 at some point in his career; Cooper is favored over Adonai Mitchell in terms of long-term potential and is expected to be projected higher than Mitchell even when Mitchell returns from injury, based on demonstrated talent and production.

Insight page
NegativeRole7:20

Cooper's role with the Jets is subject to coaching volatility under Aaron Glenn and Frank Reich; even if Adonai Mitchell returns from hand injury, Cooper is expected to maintain at least as much playing time and continue to outproduce him, though short-term route share could dip to 62% if the Jets prioritize Mitchell and other personnel in 12-personnel sets.

Insight page
PositiveValue12:36

Cooper's trade market is frothy; speakers prefer the Cooper side in a trade against Devonta Smith in a 27-two deal, and would take Cooper in a two-for-one against Jalen Warren and Travis Etienne. However, production upside is capped by Jets offense volatility and Christian Gonzalez coverage; even strong performance may yield hit-and-miss weekly fantasy output, limiting helium potential for dramatic value escalation.

Insight page

Reggie Virgil

NegativeUsage50:30

Virgil is the most requested player for the Dynasty Points rookie report but has shown minimal production through Week 6, warranting a watch-list approach rather than immediate coverage.

Insight page

Sam Brown

NegativeProjection30:06

Brown is part of an annual dynasty community debate where Jameson Williams is expected to outscore him despite Williams not being a historic target earner; the comparison highlights how style points and upside narratives can overshadow target-volume fundamentals in community perception.

Insight page

Stefon Diggs

NegativeRole35:54

Stefan Diggs ran one fewer route than Antonio Williams in Week 6 and is not expected to be with the Commanders long-term; Cooper notes Diggs is over 30 years old and unlikely to remain with the team beyond the near future, positioning him as a short-term asset in the Commanders' receiver rotation.

Insight page

Terry McLaurin

NegativeInjury35:03

Terry McLaurin was announced out for the season with a major lower-body injury just 30 minutes before the episode recording. Cooper expresses uncertainty about McLaurin's career trajectory post-injury and whether he will remain relevant at his age upon return, creating significant uncertainty for his dynasty value.

Insight page

Tim Patrick

NegativeRole9:54

Patrick is part of the Jets' 11-personnel rotation, used in blocking responsibilities and 12-personnel sets as the coaching staff rotates personnel.

Insight page

Travis Etienne

NegativeValue13:48

In a trade package with Omar Cooper against Jalen Warren, speakers prefer the Etienne-Cooper side, though Etienne himself receives minimal discussion. The trade preference is driven primarily by Cooper's value and Warren's role concerns rather than Etienne-specific upside.

Insight page

Will Levis

NegativeRole11:28

Will Levis could potentially find his way into the rotation at quarterback if the Jets season spirals further, adding another layer of quarterback uncertainty for Jets pass-catchers. This scenario must be factored into evaluations of Jets receivers.

Insight page

Woody Marks

NegativeValue30:41

Marks was traded alongside Basil Tootin and a 2027 fourth-round pick for Jeremy Bernard, Kenyan Sadiq, and two third-round picks; Cooper notes this is an interesting trade structure but suggests Bernard's side represents better value in the current market.

Insight page
Full transcript

Episode Transcript

517
0:00Week 6 has wrapped up and we have some players to talk about today.
0:05Three standout performances from this last week of action.
0:08We need to talk about one player returning, one player potentially getting an even bigger opportunity, and another player that might not give his job back.
0:17It's the Week 6 Rookie Report. This is Dynasty Points and it starts right now.
0:22Hello everybody, welcome back to Dynasty Points and the Rookie Report for Week 6.
0:27We had some really great performances this week and it's time to talk about them.
0:33It was one of my favorite times of the week.
0:36Obviously if you're new here, welcome in. If you're coming back, welcome back.
0:41And as always, if you enjoy content like this, you can hit the like and the subscribe button.
0:47It goes a long way. Let us know also in the comments what you want us to talk about in terms of the week.
0:55This 2026 rookie class next week. And we'll put it on our watch list.
1:00Ryan, where do you want to kick off this week on the Rookie Report?
1:05So this week, Thomas Tipple, we have three rookie wide receivers that are getting a lot of buzz in redraft circles, a
1:13lot of buzz, very rightfully so, in Dynasty circles as well.
1:17So I want to talk about all three of them.
1:20I think it makes sense to go in order of where they were selected in rookie drafts and then maybe at the
1:28end we can discuss and debate who we think is going to ultimately have the best season if that differs from how
1:36we would value them going forward in Dynasty. I think these are three players that are really tricky and interesting to try
1:43to re-rank, re-sort, and get right right now. I want to start with Omar Cooper.
1:49Cooper, for those who don't remember, back in week one, ran literally one route, caught a 30-yard pass, and instantly got injured.
1:56I missed the next four games, came back in week six, and right away he was just in a full-time role running fewer routes than only Garrett Wilson.
2:06And he played awesome. He is now only 25 receiving yards behind Kenyon Sadiq for second place on the team, despite only
2:14running 28 routes, which is both a hilariously sad Jets stat and also a kind of cool Omar Cooper stat for someone
2:21that has barely been on the field this year.
2:25He's up at 4.75 yards per hour run. And most interestingly to me, and I think the piece that I feel best
2:32about in terms of projecting his near-term future, is you'll remember coming into the rookie draft season, I think commonly we all
2:40kind of agreed, yeah, it's tricky for Omar Cooper and Kenyon Sadiq because probably only one of them can succeed in the
2:48short term in terms of being an athletic, run-after-catch type of player from the slot in the short area.
2:54Which one's it going to be, basically? It's going to be hard for it to be both of them.
3:01Sadiq had his little mini breakout a few weeks ago without Mason Taylor, but in week six with Cooper healthy, with Mason
3:09Taylor also back in healthy, and with Sadiq playing, Sadiq was in a part-time role, only a 30% route share.
3:16Cooper was absolutely going off. The Jets played a ton more 11 personnel, which obviously helped Cooper get on the field more as well.
3:24He was in the slot two-thirds of the time.
3:27So I think for me, looking forward, I'm willing to kind of place my chip on Cooper, at least for the rest
3:35of this season, and say, it looks like this is how the Jets want to operate with a tight end by committee,
3:43and at least right now with Omar Cooper as a full-time receiver.
3:47I don't know. Jakob Sanderson, am I being too reactionary to the thing that we just saw?
3:53Because, of course, we were very excited about Sadiq a couple of weeks ago, but I think legitimately that there is some
4:00signal here that now that all these guys are healthy, it's Cooper in the full-time role, it's him balling out.
4:07I think that's somewhat predictive. Yeah, I think it's at least right for the rest of this season.
4:14With Kenny and Sadiq, that Detroit game will continue to weigh heavily in my mind for the rest of the season and
4:21the offseason as we look forward to the rest of his career.
4:26I do think he has the type of profile, he has the physicality, he has the youth, the frame, to where I
4:33would not be surprised if he is able to eventually transition himself out of this kind of flex tight end role to
4:41an every down tight end in the future. If, you know, I were the Jets, like especially when they haven't had Cooper
4:49and Mitchell both on the field together, I don't really understand their desire to play.
4:54The Isaiah Williamses and the Tim Patricks ahead of Kenny and Sadiq effectively, but that's just kind of what teams have a
5:02tendency to do sometimes in ways that frustrate us and, in my opinion, themselves.
5:07All that being said, like the projection for the near term with Cooper is way cleaner.
5:12Like Mason Taylor is a pretty reasonable inline tight end.
5:16They clearly don't have an intention of force feeding Kenny and Sadiq.
5:20And Cooper was, I think, a underrated and high quality prospect who was really talked down on for a bunch of nonsense
5:28reasons during the preseason when we hadn't even gotten the chance to see him actually go out there and play real NFL games.
5:36And we've only seen about five quarters of it, but it looks awesome.
5:40So, I mean, I'm curious to see kind of where the market is at on Omar Cooper this week.
5:47Like, you know, we're going to talk about another exciting rookie wide receiver pretty soon.
5:52Cooper is a lot more exciting to me of the two of them, I think.
5:57Cooper was a legitimately high quality prospect who I thought was like a late round one, early round two tweener type.
6:05I thought he had a lot of upside, especially on his profile, kind of a boom-bust prospect because the per route metrics
6:12were really strong, even though he didn't necessarily have a very large sample size of producing early in his career on full routes.
6:20It's only been one game, and like maybe this could be a function of, you know, Garrett Wilson's getting shattered by Christian
6:28Gonzalez, and so you want to target the number two receiver.
6:32But the fact he was up for it, the fact he's been so efficient, the fact he looks so great to the
6:40eye test, I mean, there's some chance that we just saw the first five quarters of like a total superstar.
6:47Who knows? You know? So, I think I'm definitely pretty interested in buying high on Cooper.
6:52Yeah, I would generally agree. I guess we can just kind of spoil it right now, at least for myself as well.
7:00Yeah, Omar Cooper was the receiver that we are going to talk about today, that I had ranked highest before the season
7:08as a prospect, including his situation and all of that in rookie drafts.
7:12And he remains the rookie receiver of the three that we're going to talk about today, that I am the highest on.
7:20I don't think he's much better than a coin flip to outscore Jeremy Bernard over the rest of the season, just because
7:28of some environmental stuff that we're going to talk about with the Steelers.
7:32But I do think in terms of difference making upside, is this player going to develop into more than a fantasy wide
7:40receiver three at some point in his career? I would easily take Cooper there.
7:45So, yeah, Tom, why don't you bring us through any of these interesting trades that you have going on here?
7:52As you're scrolling through, I guess the only other kind of nitpick that people might have on Cooper and that we'll see
8:00if this is affecting his trade price is Adonai Mitchell has been out for just as long as he has.
8:07He looked good in like a game and a half and had a decent role in terms of commanding air yards down the field.
8:15But ultimately, that doesn't really factor too much into my calculation on Cooper.
8:19Adonai Mitchell, like we call him the ass god here at Fantasy Points, but contained within that nickname is the fact that, hey, he does separate.
8:29He has good average separation scores. He always gets air yards.
8:32But how often does he actually catch the ball?
8:36That's hit or miss. That's up or down. The guy had the glove on his hand is going to be rehabbing and coming back from a hand injury.
8:45I don't know. I think even if the Jets get him back, I would not be at all shocked to see Cooper
8:53continue to play at least as much as he does and continue to outproduce him.
8:58That would be my base expectation. Like the first week that Mitchell comes back, I'm going to be sitting in our projections
9:06meeting and telling Chris Wecht that Cooper needs to be projected higher than Ady Mitchell.
9:11That's how I would see it. But yeah, we can look at some of these trades and I agree with that optimism.
9:19But I would I would brace yourself for short term annoyance with the New York Jets.
9:25You know, this is this is a coaching staff led by Aaron Glenn, who doesn't even know when he's going to get
9:32the ball out of half and when he isn't.
9:35And Frank Reich, who, you know, is a bit of a dinosaur.
9:40So, like, I don't know that this is a team that you can consistently rely on to skate where the puck is going.
9:48As we just saw with Kenny and Sadiq, like he has this incredible breakout game against the Detroit Lions.
9:54And then as soon as they get Mason Taylor back, you know, they couldn't be more excited to play a bunch of
10:0211 personnel with Tim Patrick and Isaiah Williams and put their dynamic rookie back on the sidelines 65% of the time.
10:09That's just kind of like what the Jets are as an organization.
10:14So do I think it's a possibility that Omar Cooper just keeps ascending and ascending and ascending from here?
10:20Definitely. Absolutely. I guess what I would say is that if there is short term aggravation and we instead are forced to
10:28watch Omar Cooper run 62% of the routes because they want to run 80 Mitchell on every single route and they need
10:36to make sure Tim Patrick is out there to rotate into 12 personnel sets for blocking responsibilities or whatever goofy BS we see.
10:44Like, just don't forget that Omar Cooper has shown himself to be a very good player in the meantime and that ultimately talent finds a way.
10:53Um, and specifically, I don't think we have to worry about Aaron Glenn or Frank Wright going into 2027.
10:59So I'm kind of just treating these New York Jets players, be it Cooper, be it Sadiq, be it kind of all
11:07whoever these guys is like, what can you show me about your upside so that we can try to take that into how we view you in 2027?
11:17Yeah, you obviously want consistent production. It just, you have to look at the environment and don't forget, there's a real chance.
11:25It's Kay Klubnick finds his way into the starting rotation.
11:28Even Will Levis potentially finding his way into the rotation at quarterback if the Jets season spirals further than it is.
11:35And that's something you're going to have to take into account.
11:39You're going to see that posted a lot. Uh, so you really have to, like Jacob said, kind of be prepared for
11:47the, the muckiness that is to come with the New York Jets.
11:51Um, you look at some of the trades and it kind of reflects from today.
11:56We're recording this on October 20th, uh, Jameson Williams and a third and there's Omar Cooper in a 27, two.
12:03Yeah. These are some frothy Omar Cooper prices actually, which is a little surprising to me.
12:09I mean, I would definitely take the Cooper in a second side there pretty easily.
12:14Yeah. I think you're, I don't, uh, Smith one is interesting.
12:18Yeah. Yeah. On a re on not a contender.
12:21I'd definitely take Cooper in the two. I like value vacuum.
12:25I think I prefer. Yeah. The Cooper side. Yeah.
12:28The it's the Devonta Smith for Omar Cooper that, that is kind of eyebrow raising to me.
12:34Yeah. That's an interesting one. I mean, that's like the classic trade that's going to look really silly in a month, but
12:42I don't know a hundred percent which side. I mean, I think I'd probably just stick with Devonta because the one thing
12:50about Cooper is almost no matter how good Omar Cooper is like Chris Gary Wilson is one of the best receivers.
12:57The league is not going to be shattered by Christian Gonzalez every week.
13:02And he does play on the jets. So even if Cooper is really good, it's not like we can just expect him
13:09to, you know, put up 20 fantasy points every week.
13:13Like it's, it's still going to be, I think hit and miss production wise for the rest of this season.
13:20And so I don't, I don't know that like Cooper has the capacity to all of a sudden you blink and you
13:27miss it and he's worth three ones. Like, I don't know that that level of helium is there.
13:34So I don't feel the urgency to trade Devonta Smith away to go and get him right now, but I, I could totally see how that works out.
13:44Yeah. Yeah. I would agree. Yeah. The one to one position thing just feels like an, I know ball situation.
13:51And it's not one that I really, I don't think you were losing.
13:55You're not gaining a lot in the value side.
13:58You're not gaining a lot in the production side doing this deal one for one.
14:04So no, this is a, this is a big Devonta Smith for me.
14:08Um, here are two from yesterday that I wanted to look at.
14:12We have the Travis HN and Cooper for Jalen Warren, which I would take the HN and Cooper side pretty easily.
14:20I would as well. Yeah. Give me the Cooper side here.
14:23Let's see. HN for Warren. Yeah. I'll go. I mean, I don't really care about Travis.
14:29I think I'd go with Cooper over. I mean, yeah, I think I'd go Cooper over Warren.
14:35Yeah. The Warren, maybe that would have changed if they didn't just immediately put Warren back in rotation with a super inefficient Rico daddle for no reason.
14:44I mean, this is, I mean, we talked before, I mean, or we were just talking last time about like, you know,
14:52surely they wouldn't just go back to putting 80 Mitchell ahead of Cooper in the target pecking order.
14:58It's like, like sometimes coaches will do the darndest things.
15:02And like, I don't really care that much when they do the darndest things to a rookie, because like what will determine
15:10the course of Omar Cooper's career is not whether he out routes or out targets 80 Mitchell in like a random week, eight game during his rookie season.
15:19But like when you're looking at Jalen Warren, you know, his, his value equation is really based on what can you do for me right now.
15:29And, um, annoyingly what he can do for you right now is, is have a like 55% opportunity share next to Rico daddle.
15:37Yeah. Extremely frustrating stuff. Um, yeah, I, I was afraid and it, it happened.
15:42Uh, but yeah, some of these other, these other two deals to me are clear wins for the Cooper side as well.
15:49Um, I think if I had a double Omar Cooper or a 27 second, I would just take Cooper pretty easily.
15:57What about the high lemon one? Cause I find that interesting.
16:00That this is where I think I'm. Yeah. I think it's an interesting deal.
16:05So I think I'm willing to go Cooper at this point, which is maybe crazy, but I had an interesting debate.
16:13That's where I am with some very active and sharp dynasty players in a group chat the other day about, uh, lemon
16:20versus Bernard, who we're going to talk about in a second.
16:24Um, and kind of like, how do you wait?
16:27The prospect profile, the draft capital versus the immediate production.
16:31Um, I think I'm like a slight lemon there still.
16:34Um, but on this one, I would go Cooper.
16:38I think that the prospect profile gap between lemon and Cooper is not that high.
16:43Um, the situation is like strikingly similar, like actually crazy similar between what the jets and the Eagles did.
16:49You know, they, they each have a stud wide receiver one in the prime of their career.
16:55Uh, they both wear green. They drafted, um, a wide receiver and a tight end who don't make a ton of sense together longterm.
17:04They each have like an ask God wide receiver that sometimes doesn't have hands playing as wide receiver two with wicks and 80 Mitchell.
17:12It's really similar. Um, I, I think that lemon was the better prospect, but like, again, not by that wide of a margin.
17:20So I'll probably just go with the guy who's playing better right now.
17:25And I'll go with Cooper, especially in similar situation.
17:28Yeah, that's exactly how I would think of it.
17:31It's both of these were while, while I had lemon, like a tier ahead as a prospect, it was not like that big of a gap.
17:40Like he, I think lemon was my rookie wide receiver three.
17:44Uh, Cooper was my rookie wide receiver five. Like, I don't know.
17:48Yeah. Yeah. The league didn't seem to view them super differently.
17:52Uh, yeah. I, I think even, yeah. The draft cap literally one game nine spots.
17:57Yeah. Even literally one game of evidence for Cooper versus six, not very good games of evidence for lemon, I think is enough to flip that for me.
18:07Yeah. Yeah. I, um, I'd also say the big thing with like Cooper and I keep teasing that we're going to get
18:15to Bernard and we will, but, um, like from a prospect profile perspective.
18:19At the risk of like breaking what I think is a pretty good heuristic, which is to not separate floor and median
18:27projections from ceiling projections of prospects as much as possible.
18:31I'm just going to do that anyways. Um, but I, I caveat it with it was saying it's a bad idea.
18:38So you could choose to listen to me less now that I've caveated it.
18:43Um, like Cooper, I felt like the flaws in his profile were largely floor-based flaws and median outcome based flaws.
18:50Like I, I love the per route profile. I thought that the movement skills were really special.
18:56What I thought were the major holes in his profile were a lack of early production and just like a lack of
19:03early route volume in his first three seasons. But I didn't feel like this was a guy who had like major talent based limitations.
19:12I felt like this was a guy who, you know, either he could hit a massive ceiling or it's like, it never really comes together for him.
19:21And you look back on the college profile and you're like, well, there were signs there all along.
19:28Um, with Bernard, I mean, the whole book on him was professional wide receiver, like going to be a starter in the league for a long time.
19:37You know, what is the high level outcome? Now, a lot of times people say that kind of thing about a player
19:45and then they just get it dead wrong. Right.
19:48It's like, um, we, we place artificial ceilings on guys.
19:51Uh, Amon Rossi Brown is like the patron saint of artificial ceilings where we say, okay, well, this guy got to this
19:59level, but he was always going to get to this level and he's not going to get to the next one.
20:06It's not, this is not right every time, but Bernard kind of hitting immediately.
20:11But then not ascending to superstardom would not be inconsistent with the way that he was profiled coming out.
20:18And so I'm probably more inclined to like buy super high end outcomes on Cooper than I am on, on Bernard.
20:25Yeah. I think I'd agree with that. Uh, and it's not just from like a skillset standpoint, which I think that that
20:33is legitimately part of it is like what these two do on the field where Cooper is much more like the insanely
20:41explosive, exciting athlete, pleasing to the eye, like that type of stuff.
20:45And Bernard as a prospect was much more like he'll get it done.
20:50He's got the lowest drop rate of any wide receiver in the class.
20:54Like all, all of that type of professional wide receiver stuff was where Bernard really shined.
21:00Uh, but I mean, it's also just in peak production of their, of their profile, right?
21:05For Bernard, a lot of the things that we liked about him was, well, his production isn't really elite, but he that's, it's easily explainable.
21:14Like he was competing with all of these NFL level wide receivers at every step of his college journey.
21:21So you can tell the story. It's like understandable why he didn't fully pop on the field or have like a massive,
21:28uh, season by yards per team pass attempt or however you want to measure it.
21:34Right. Uh, he was just always solid. And I, I'd agree.
21:37I think that's kind of what I'd expect from that prospect just to transition into Bernard now, uh, if you put him
21:45on a Steelers offense, that is top five and pass rate over expectation with no Michael Pittman, uh, with Roman Wilson on IR now.
21:54And you just gave him a full-time role next to DK Metcalf, who is for my money, the last couple of seasons
22:01is one of the more like overrated wide receivers in the league in terms of how much does he actually earn targets
22:09and how much will he actually crowd other players out of volume?
22:13Uh, if you put Bernard in that spot or the, or that like prospect profile in that spot, it makes sense to
22:21me that he would put up some strong numbers.
22:24On a 5.3 average depth of target and have the same number of targets as DK Metcalf in his three games without
22:32Michael Pittman like that, that makes a ton of sense to me.
22:36So yeah, while it's good for Bernard and I think I'm just willing to just say, okay, this guy's going to have like Jacoby Myers, his career now.
22:46Uh, I, I just don't know how much I'm willing to buy into the idea that it gets better than that.
22:53But I, yeah, to Jacob's point, maybe that's foolish.
22:56Um, we did say it about Alman Ross St.
22:59Brown. I would say that Alman Ross St. Brown's prospect profile in hindsight was much stronger than Jeremy Bernard's.
23:06I mean, I would say I had him ranked way higher.
23:10I like moved him down obviously when he went in round four, but Alman, Alman Ross St.
23:16Brown is like one of the only cases of the.
23:19He might be the only case of like the analytical darling wide receiver who surprisingly falls to day three.
23:26Um, but then is actually really good. You usually like that guy stinks.
23:31Usually, usually it's Elijah Surratt where it's like, oh, like actually usually the Ravens draft them.
23:36Cause it was also Tylan Wallace. Um, so, uh, it's, it's like, usually it's like, there's, you know, the, the analytical profile looks strong.
23:45We're waiting on the draft capital. The NFL decides, no, this guy stinks.
23:49And they're like, right about that specific profile, like 95% of the time, there's almost no relationship between, um, analytics based prospecting and, uh, success.
23:58Once you get deep into day three, but, uh, Alman Ross St.
24:02Brown is, is the, uh, like the one exception to the hat for sure.
24:07Yeah. And he's the, he's the one that makes me continue to rank Elijah Surratt's of the world much higher than I should every single season.
24:16Yep. Yeah. I think I'm just more into players that have this don't score fun points, uh, um, kind of moniker around them.
24:24Like he's not the downfield, super explosive, very flashy, say Jamison Williams type on that offense.
24:30A lot like Omar Cooper's a lot more deep balls.
24:33At least we haven't seen him get used that way yet.
24:37Me there's just, these guys are really valuable weekend and week out.
24:41If they're getting this kind of consistent usage on teams, I was the Michael Pittman guy on this show for multiple years.
24:49He was not very fun, not very exciting, but still a consistent producer when relied upon.
24:55So I think if we're seeing nine targets last week, 12 targets this week, granted some of that was overtime.
25:02You look at some of the data just up there on the screen.
25:06Speaking of Michael Pittman Jr. And the three games without him, we have just seen a reliance on him.
25:13That as a rookie, almost regardless of profile to me, makes me raise my eyebrows and take a deeper look at it.
25:20If he can consistently earn these targets, then I think, I think he's going to be worth paying for as a very
25:28much useful player in your fantasy lineup. Even though he, again, he doesn't get the sexy points.
25:34He's not the, the hot button, super, you know, explosive, hyper efficient type player that a lot of fantasy players fall in love with.
25:42I'm more than happy than getting somebody like Jeremy Bernard to sit in my flex spots week in and week out.
25:50I'm curious when we get to the trades because my, my inclination would be that like, I probably am not rushing to buy crazy high.
25:59Like I'm not. Me either. I would be surprised if this is a person that I'm ranking in my top 15 dynasty wide receivers one day.
26:08Um, but I, I definitely don't think that it's like a sell high spot.
26:13I think like probably where I might be looking at Bernard as a guy I actually recommend selling might be, we'll see
26:20what his price heads up being, what his rest of the season ends up being, what might be the off season.
26:28Um, where I think if, if he is like kind of priced in accordance with his typical production and being a year
26:35or two player, it might get a little too frothy for me based on the longer term profile.
26:42But in terms of what, uh, I expect for the rest of the season, I mean, he's in a fantastic spot rest of the season.
26:50I, I, I know Tom, you were, uh, pumped about kind of like one more target spamming Michael Pittman season coming into
26:58the year and like Pittman unfortunately is washed, but I think that your take spiritually lives on through Jeremy Bernard, where he
27:06now gets to kind of consolidate a bunch of these short area targets, uh, that Aaron Rogers is desperate to throw to someone.
27:14And it isn't really DK Metcalf bag. So like the other thing about Bernard that I, I think he gets a bad
27:22rap on is like, he's, he's so often discussed as this like boring snoring Jeremy Bernard player.
27:28Like Ryan brought up Jacoby Myers, Tom brought up Michael Pittman.
27:31I mean, like, I definitely think the limitations in terms of the downfield production are real in his profile, but I do think he's a pretty special mover.
27:41Like I just remember, Oh, you know, before I was even getting into the like prospecting weeds, um, like watching the third
27:49Saturday of October last year and like multiple times, I was like, who's five on Alabama.
27:54Like we can't tackle this fricking guy. And it was Jeremy Bernard.
27:59And like, I won't even lie. Like I didn't know that much about him as a draft prospect at the time, but
28:06I was just consistently like kind of blown away by his movement ability.
28:11And he's been used as a really good threat.
28:14Um, like there, there's like a world where like the analytical prospects are profiles on these guys are polar opposites.
28:21But if I wanted to be, um, like a certain type of fantasy analyst and do the HR meme for, you know,
28:29one guy versus the other guy, like there's some similarities in the games of like Jeremy Bernard and Luther burden in terms
28:36of, uh, like rugged, great after the catch. Um, some questions about consistency downfield, but like very good short area targets.
28:44I don't, there, there's some like sexiness to Bernard's game from a, uh, uh, ball at hand perspective that I think doesn't
28:52get totally captured in like the Jacoby Myers comparisons.
28:55Um, even if maybe it didn't necessarily come through always statistically either.
28:59I, I do think he moves very well with the ball.
29:03And I think he's been used in that way, very effectively with the Steelers.
29:08So I have, I use the Michael Pittman Jr.
29:11One, uh, just simply because it's just the feeling I get from the community itself.
29:16I had, yeah, no, it's, it's, it's how he's talking about it.
29:20You're totally right. Yeah. So his upside to me, again, a lot of this ends up becoming situational.
29:27We, we know what's happening with Rogers and retiring, but does the pass rate stay, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera.
29:34Uh, I could see a certain five foot 11, 202 pound wide receiver from LSU who was a very shifty underneath type
29:42player that had question marks deep downfield. It's Jarvis Landry.
29:45And again, you say a name like that, and it's not like a sexy, super exciting type player, but he was super good for fantasy football.
29:54You can even get into Deontay Johnson type players who weren't great downfield, but they were target earners that scored you a
30:02ton of fantasy points that ended up being very valuable in dynasty.
30:06Even if the longevity wasn't there for them because they're not of the superstar mold.
30:11And I feel like those types of players are consistently underrated.
30:15Cause again, it's not the sexy points that we are in love with.
30:20Right. It's why Jameson Williams holds such power over the dynasty community and why every year we have the conversations is this year.
30:28He's going to outscore Amin Ross, same Brown, even though he's just not a historic target earner.
30:34And we do it every single year, not us, but the very small section of the community does every year.
30:41And I feel like it's the, it's the style points that get you there.
30:46But if you do look at the trades themselves, the buy thing, I don't think is as real right now because he is popping off.
30:54You look at the first trade from today, Woody marks, Basial tootin and a 27 fourth.
31:00And on the other side, it's Jeremy Bernard, Kenyan Sadiq and two thirds.
31:05That's an interesting trade. Um, I want, I think your better value.
31:09Mark said the fourth and the third, I don't care.
31:12So it's Jeremy and Sadiq for tootin. I'll go with the Jeremy and Sadiq side here.
31:18I love me some Basial tootin, but I think that Jeremy and Sadiq give you two bites at the, at the apple.
31:26And I, I would need to, to be like a clear, like 1.5 ones type player for me to clearly prefer him.
31:33And he's not, he's not quite that for me.
31:36Yeah. I was going to say, I think similarly, like it's Bernard plus Sadiq is just enough to me where it's like,
31:44yeah, I'd, I'd rather spread the bets there. Um, I don't know that either are like, particularly higher upside than tootin, but
31:52I think getting two of them is what I'd prefer.
31:55Yeah. I agree with you guys. It's the 28 one stuff that starts to get me just to, I'll sell, I'll sell there.
32:03I'll take the 28 one. Yup. Yeah. I think that's, yeah, yeah.
32:08I'm definitely like white ones over Bernard. I'm doing that.
32:11Yeah. Uh, the next one I see is Boston for Bernard and a third.
32:16I would definitely take Boston. Like, like I think that Bernard versus lemon one is really interesting because you're, you're like, that's
32:24a big weight of prospect profile versus what I'm seeing with my eyes on the field right now.
32:30Um, I mean, I, I would prefer to have bought a Bernard rest of season just because I think he's in so
32:38much more of a friendly fantasy role, but like from a zoomed out dynasty perspective, both of these guys have been super impressive this year.
32:46And so that's where I probably would lean on the prospect profile.
32:51And it's not like Bernard is like in a great spot from like a dynasty perspective.
32:56Like he's kind of in a, he's, he's in a really good spot for his skillset in this like weird drop back,
33:04happy Aaron Rogers, get the ball out in under two seconds offense.
33:08Um, and he's, his skillset is super conducive to that.
33:12We have no idea what the Steelers situation is going to be next year.
33:16So it may or may not be favorable. Yeah.
33:20Boston looks like an absolute monster. Like he looks every bit of a star caliber player and I was way too low on him.
33:28I think it looks great. I think any quarterback that isn't on the Browns roster, get Case Keenum in there.
33:35And all of a sudden, uh, David, like, uh, wow.
33:39David Boston. I'm an old man. Uh, dense Boston.
33:42Uh, probably looks even, even better than he is.
33:45Cause yeah. Watson is super washed, but yeah, I'll take, I'll, I'll take the Boston side there for the same reasons.
33:52Yeah. I think the running theme here is if you're getting a first or like a first level player, I'm taking that
34:00over Jeremy Bernard, but I, I'd agree. I said earlier that Cooper and Bernard are like a coin flip to outscore each other.
34:08The rest of the season. I would wait, I would wait the coin flip toward Bernard.
34:14I think he is probably a top 30 wide receiver rest of season.
34:18So like, I get it from that perspective, but I agree.
34:22Like I'd need to see more than that to buy into any hypothetical situation that he could find himself in going into next year.
34:30I would just always rather have the insulation of a first or of, uh, Boston that I think could succeed in a
34:38wider variety, uh, of setups and situations. And, and also with Boston, I think we have a, hopefully a better idea of
34:46what the Browns will look like next year than what the Steelers will.
34:50All right, let's move over to the final rookie wide receiver that we're going to talk about in our trio of the day.
34:58It's Antonio Williams. So Terry McLaurin in Monday night football, uh, left very early.
35:03It was just announced of like 30 minutes before we started recording that McLaurin is out for the season.
35:10Uh, so that very clearly creates a big opportunity for Antonio Williams, who I think as a prospect was discussed in maybe
35:18a similar way to Jeremy Bernard, where he was kind of the higher floor.
35:22This looks like a professional NFL player, uh, guy that can definitely play out, play in the slot and maybe play outside type of player should earn targets.
35:32Uh, had some underrated target competition in his college career, but never really hit the heights of production, uh, that around one profile would have.
35:41And we fast forward into this season and Williams has looked pretty good at times in relief of, uh, Terry McLaurin when
35:49he's missed time so far, he's going to miss the rest of the season.
35:54Uh, he ran one more route than Stefan Diggs did, uh, last night in week six, led the team in route share
36:01after McLaurin got injured, uh, over the full season.
36:04Williams is at 1.8 yards per hour run with Jaden Daniels starting.
36:09That's just behind Stefan Diggs. That's more than Terry McLaurin.
36:12Uh, and notably he and McLaurin have the exact same average separation score this year.
36:17So Williams is playing fairly well for a rookie.
36:21He has shown some explosiveness at times. He had that play called back in the London game.
36:27That would have been a long touchdown a couple of weeks ago, uh, that we may or may not have mentioned on this program.
36:35So I look at this and I say, and I get a little intrigued, right?
36:40Because Jaden, while I don't know in terms of the coaching staff, what the long-term regime and vision is, I think Jaden
36:48Daniels is going to be here for a while.
36:51I don't think Stefan Diggs is going to be here for all that much longer.
36:56He is over well over 30 years old. Terry McLaurin, who knows in terms of whether he has a career after this
37:04or continues to be relevant at his age coming back from a major lower body injury, right?
37:10So this is kind of the Antonio Williams audition, so to speak.
37:14Uh, how he performs the rest of the season is going to determine the commander's plans at wide river, uh, going into next year's draft and beyond, right?
37:24So this is a legitimately tricky one for me.
37:27I had Williams ranked behind both Cooper and Bernard, uh, from a prospect profile standpoint, but I think he has the most
37:35clearly potentially advantageous long-term situation of anyone we've talked about so far.
37:39So I'm curious, Jacob, how you kind of weigh that for Antonio Williams, uh, are you much more impressed or less impressed
37:47by what we've seen from Williams on the field so far?
37:51And how does the situation, if you see it the same way as me, kind of weigh into your evaluation of him
37:58relative to those other two guys that we already discussed?
38:02Yeah, I liked Williams as a prospect, like in a, in a pure vacuum.
38:07Um, I had him tiered the same as Jeremy Bernard.
38:10I'll give respect to the NFL with the draft capital gap between them, um, being at one round and say that Jeremy
38:18was the higher tier prospect based on that. Um, but overall, like I thought that they were pretty similar from a talent perspective.
38:26Um, I think that with the situation elements that you pointed out, like, I, I don't know, that feels like something that
38:34probably is more appealing to other people than it is to me.
38:38I think it's nice in terms of like, if you want to buy in on a player that it presents a potential
38:45window in the off season to suggest like, Hey, this guy has a path to be the wide receiver one.
38:52I guess I just, I have a hard time imagining that Washington's long-term plan is.
38:58Well, Terry McLaurin and Stefan Diggs are really old, so we'll just jettison them and then we'll replace them with nothing.
39:05And then our, our wide receiver one will be Antonio Williams and our wide receiver two will be Traylon Burks.
39:12Like that doesn't seem like the plan that they're going to enact.
39:16Um, I, I expect that they will probably add other players.
39:20Um, and then Antonio Williams will hopefully have a chance to be a full routes player for most of the rest of this year and in year two.
39:30And like, I guess what I would say is that if he can't like, I mean, he's a rookie, so, uh, you
39:38know, I'm not saying like if he can't out, out target, uh, Stefan Diggs, it's over for him or anything like that.
39:45But I guess what I'm saying is I don't anticipate him to have a substantially easier task in year two.
39:52Then you get to run, you know, a full route share and the wide receiver on the other side are Stefan Diggs and Traylon Burks.
40:01Like, I think, I think that's a pretty good situation for him to produce in right now.
40:07Um, and, and I'm excited to see it over the rest of the season.
40:12I've definitely been impressed by what I've seen from him.
40:15Yeah. He had the long touchdown called back for legal motion penalty.
40:20He got the, the pass from Terry McLaurin. That was a little off.
40:24He couldn't quite catch that. Like we're talking about a player that stats could look a lot better, uh, if not for
40:32again, which seems to be a theme this year with how many penalties there are in the league.
40:38Uh, but really to a lot to Jacob's point, he has the path now to establish the role that we're hoping for.
40:46If he doesn't really take control of that, uh, I would probably be looking to, looking to avoid, like, I'm not going
40:54to have like a big year to breakout. Um, conversation if he doesn't kind of cement his legitimate role for the rest of the year.
41:02So I'm interested to really see what happens week seven, week eight, where guys like Bernard and Boston and all these other
41:10guys have really fortified a role for themselves already.
41:13Williams has very much been. We'll say spotty. Like we'll say it's been some ups, some downs, um, like a 12.4% target share.
41:21Like you really want to see that start to climb.
41:25We're talking about guys like Bernard with over 20, right?
41:28And even Cooper playing one game coming back and kind of dominating.
41:32If you would in that, in that game environment, we haven't seen that quite from Williams that it's a lot of, Oh, he was, he was this close.
41:42So I'm going to give him the next two weeks to really, really see if he can quote establish it.
41:49If you would perform really interested in conversations. Yeah, I think it's fair to say that he's shown us significantly less than
41:57Omar Cooper and Jeremy Bernard have so far this year.
42:00Uh, and yeah, as I mentioned, had him behind both as prospects.
42:05Um, I don't know. I will see like what the prices are here in terms of how much I care about the
42:12situational stuff that you can kind of write out for him in the future in terms of.
42:18Does he just claim the number one role? Like he has to be good in order to do that first.
42:25Right. I guess that's always the, it's like the dynasty player putting the cart before the horse to use the oldest metaphor in the book.
42:34Uh, it's kind of what we will sometimes do with these players where it's like, yeah, there's nobody else here and he has a good opportunity to produce.
42:44But that does very clearly come with like a, an even lower value floor where it's like, well, if he doesn't step
42:52up and produce in this situation, then, then what's he going to be to me?
42:57What's he going to be to his NFL team after that?
43:01So that, yeah, something that I'll have in my mind as we look at some of these trades.
43:07Yeah. I mean, you get Cam Scadabo and Antonio Williams or Denzel Boston.
43:11I'm going to go Boston here. That's an easy Boston.
43:15Yeah. You don't think Scadabo is going to really bounce back after Najee Harris got really?
43:21I mean, I think he'll bounce back in the sense of like, I would still bet on him to lead the Giants backfield and points rest of season.
43:30But I don't think he's that good. And I, they're clearly not committed to him in the longterm whatsoever.
43:37I heard the quote where it's like, no one has stepped up in the backfield.
43:42It's like, Oh my God, ruthless. This one I think is funny.
43:46I'm starting to wonder if, if Ryan made this trade is we were talking Noel earlier today before we sat down to
43:54record, but Aaron Rogers, Antonio Williams and a 28 fourth or Jalen Noel.
43:59Antonio Williams. Yeah, I did not. So I did not make this trade, but this comparison popped into my head earlier as
44:06I was writing up Jalen Noel and preparing to talk about Antonio Williams on the show.
44:12So to me, if I'm just looking kind of in a vacuum, I don't think Noel and Williams are like that different
44:20in terms of what they have shown us as players so far.
44:24Of course, Noel got on the field much less in his rookie season than Williams has so far.
44:30But in terms of yards per hour run to date, Noel is just under two.
44:35It seems like the Texans are starting to slightly appreciate his talents.
44:40It is kind of the opposite of the Antonio Williams situation though, where if it were Jalen Noel that was going to
44:47get to run a full-time route share across from only Stefan Diggs and be attached to Jaden Daniels, I might legitimately be
44:55excited or maybe a little more excited than I am with Antonio Williams.
45:00But yeah, this trade where you're also getting Aaron Rodgers, assumedly that's a useful quarterback for the person that's getting him in this deal.
45:08I would take the Aaron Rodgers-Antonio Williams side. Look, I love Jalen Noel.
45:13Someone's got to tell me what the path is to him being like a real fantasy asset and not just a fun meme.
45:21Like I like Jalen Noel. I like him as a player.
45:24I wish he was on a team that I rooted for in real life.
45:29Every single time that they give him the ball, he does things with it.
45:34I mean, it's taken kind of until now for him to even just be trusted to be like the full-time slot receiver.
45:42However, I mean, they just traded for Marvin Harrison.
45:45They're going to get Jaden Higgins back next year.
45:48Like they want to play a million tight ends.
45:51The path for him to be like a 80% route rate player is hellacious.
45:56I just, I'd love to see it. Like I would really like to be wrong about that, but I don't, I mean,
46:04the Houston Texans barely played Nico Collins 80% of the routes.
46:08Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. The way, the way I put this is that Noel at best is probably just this generation's Josh Downs
46:16where for years, we're probably going to be like, Hey, he's had like two startable games.
46:21I'm saying at best, we're going to be for years.
46:25Like, Hey, this guy rules, please play him full-time.
46:28And then maybe one day it will happen out of circumstance because they're forced to.
46:33And we're, we'll just get the hammer dropped on us again and find out that he's not actually going to deliver on
46:41the expectations as we found out with Downs this year.
46:44Yeah. That's good to say. You mean when they do play them full-time, but then bringing in a dusty vet, like Keenan
46:52Allen, who saps all the fun and energy out of, out of him.
46:57Oh my God. Yeah. Not, not good. Good. That's so brutal, but we have, um, another Jameson Williams trade with Jameson Williams
47:04and then Antonio Williams and a 27, two. Seems like people are really trying to get out of the Jameson Williams boat.
47:12Um, it's coming off of his best game too in week five.
47:16I guess people are trying to sell that or two good games in a row.
47:21You had the two touchdown game before that. He had the a hundred yard game.
47:27Uh, I would definitely take Jameson Williams over Antonio.
47:30Oh, it was a two. I thought it was a three.
47:34Uh, I'll still take Jameson Williams. I will here too.
47:37Yeah. I'll go with Jamo. I have like Jameson Williams concerns, but I mean, it's still one of the better offenses.
47:44He's going to have, I don't have James. Like, I don't have Jameson Williams concerns because I just think like Jameson Williams is what Jameson Williams is.
47:54He's, he's going to run every route on one of the best offices in the league.
48:00He's a talented player who is capable every week of like having a, a major spike week.
48:05In the weeks that he doesn't, he's going to be frustrating.
48:09He's never going to have like a consistent 25% target share.
48:13He's never been that player. He wasn't even that player in college.
48:17The, the upside is he's in an offense that drops back a gazillion times and only wants to use four players.
48:25So if any of those, like as it stands, he's startable every week.
48:29You just have to live and die with the results kind of on a, on a sequencing basis.
48:36And then if any of Aminra or Laporta or Gibbs get hurt, then he's, he's going to be a top 20 wide receiver.
48:44Like, I don't think that he's priced at a point where that equation is that bad.
48:49It's just that like, there's, there's a lot of hype that kind of want to make, make him something that he's not.
48:57But I also don't think he's actually priced like, you know, like last year he kind of was, but this year he,
49:05his price, I don't feel like has actually applied that.
49:08He needs to become something other than what he's been.
49:12So I'm, I don't have Jamison Williams concerns, but I, I definitely think like, you know, I don't, I don't expect Jamison
49:19Williams to transition into a target dominant alpha overnight.
49:22Yeah. I agree there. We have one more to test the Basial Tootin belief.
49:27Tootin or Williams, a second and a third. Tootin.
49:31Well, I'll, yeah, I'll take the points here with Basial Tootin.
49:34Yeah. I'll take Tootin as well. Um, yeah, I agree.
49:38So that's kind of where we're at with the three wide receivers, kind of a wide price range where Bernard seems to
49:46be the more expensive one, which I guess. Yeah.
49:49Overtime game winning touchdown, massive point game really looks like a legitimate breakout.
49:53I actually couldn't believe when I went and looked at what DK Metcalf did in that same game.
50:00And I just, it's very odd. Like the, the targets, like the pass rate, it's everything in Pittsburgh is weird right now.
50:07Everything. So people are really, um, I don't blame you for selling.
50:11I'll say that trying to capitalize off of that.
50:15So don't, don't blame you with that. That's our three players for this week's rookie report.
50:20Really love being able to dive into these. Look, I know some people on the fantasy points, YouTube channel.
50:27We're really hoping that we would get into Reggie Virgil content.
50:31He is like the most requested player we have to talk about.
50:35I promised everybody we'll put them on the watch list and see what happens this week.
50:41And, uh, the poor sub just, just commented back and said, I guess we're going to have to have a little bit of patience.
50:49Cause, uh, there's a whole lot of nothing from him.
50:52But like I said, if you leave a comment and let us know who you want us to take a look at,
51:00we'll add them to the watch list. See if they make the show.
51:05We have a long stretch to go. This is only week six.
51:09Who knows what happens in the next six weeks here on the rookie report.
51:14You're going to want to stay locked in right here.
51:17So again, hit that like button, hit the subscribe button and join us.
51:22Uh, apparently a lot of people didn't know this, but we still do go live on Tuesday nights.
51:28Uh, those podcasts just are not released the same way that they were before.
51:33You can go and check that out pretty much as soon as we're done recording.
51:38We hit a quick reset and we go over live on the fantasy points dynasty YouTube channel.
51:44But I will say with how much it has been requested, the live will be released in podcast format.
51:51Just a little later. It will come out on Thursday mornings, not Wednesday mornings when the rookie report releases.
51:58So it has been requested. You're going to get it.
52:01Uh, it'll just be an earlier release over on the YouTube page.
52:05Cause we do it live until next time. Remember that clear eyes and full hearts can never lose your best days are always been tilting.

More episodes from Dynasty Points

6