0:00Week 6 has wrapped up and we have some players to talk about today.
0:05Three standout performances from this last week of action.
0:08We need to talk about one player returning, one player potentially getting an even bigger opportunity, and another player that might not give his job back.
0:17It's the Week 6 Rookie Report. This is Dynasty Points and it starts right now.
0:22Hello everybody, welcome back to Dynasty Points and the Rookie Report for Week 6.
0:27We had some really great performances this week and it's time to talk about them.
0:33It was one of my favorite times of the week.
0:36Obviously if you're new here, welcome in. If you're coming back, welcome back.
0:41And as always, if you enjoy content like this, you can hit the like and the subscribe button.
0:47It goes a long way. Let us know also in the comments what you want us to talk about in terms of the week.
0:55This 2026 rookie class next week. And we'll put it on our watch list.
1:00Ryan, where do you want to kick off this week on the Rookie Report?
1:05So this week, Thomas Tipple, we have three rookie wide receivers that are getting a lot of buzz in redraft circles, a
1:13lot of buzz, very rightfully so, in Dynasty circles as well.
1:17So I want to talk about all three of them.
1:20I think it makes sense to go in order of where they were selected in rookie drafts and then maybe at the
1:28end we can discuss and debate who we think is going to ultimately have the best season if that differs from how
1:36we would value them going forward in Dynasty. I think these are three players that are really tricky and interesting to try
1:43to re-rank, re-sort, and get right right now. I want to start with Omar Cooper.
1:49Cooper, for those who don't remember, back in week one, ran literally one route, caught a 30-yard pass, and instantly got injured.
1:56I missed the next four games, came back in week six, and right away he was just in a full-time role running fewer routes than only Garrett Wilson.
2:06And he played awesome. He is now only 25 receiving yards behind Kenyon Sadiq for second place on the team, despite only
2:14running 28 routes, which is both a hilariously sad Jets stat and also a kind of cool Omar Cooper stat for someone
2:21that has barely been on the field this year.
2:25He's up at 4.75 yards per hour run. And most interestingly to me, and I think the piece that I feel best
2:32about in terms of projecting his near-term future, is you'll remember coming into the rookie draft season, I think commonly we all
2:40kind of agreed, yeah, it's tricky for Omar Cooper and Kenyon Sadiq because probably only one of them can succeed in the
2:48short term in terms of being an athletic, run-after-catch type of player from the slot in the short area.
2:54Which one's it going to be, basically? It's going to be hard for it to be both of them.
3:01Sadiq had his little mini breakout a few weeks ago without Mason Taylor, but in week six with Cooper healthy, with Mason
3:09Taylor also back in healthy, and with Sadiq playing, Sadiq was in a part-time role, only a 30% route share.
3:16Cooper was absolutely going off. The Jets played a ton more 11 personnel, which obviously helped Cooper get on the field more as well.
3:24He was in the slot two-thirds of the time.
3:27So I think for me, looking forward, I'm willing to kind of place my chip on Cooper, at least for the rest
3:35of this season, and say, it looks like this is how the Jets want to operate with a tight end by committee,
3:43and at least right now with Omar Cooper as a full-time receiver.
3:47I don't know. Jakob Sanderson, am I being too reactionary to the thing that we just saw?
3:53Because, of course, we were very excited about Sadiq a couple of weeks ago, but I think legitimately that there is some
4:00signal here that now that all these guys are healthy, it's Cooper in the full-time role, it's him balling out.
4:07I think that's somewhat predictive. Yeah, I think it's at least right for the rest of this season.
4:14With Kenny and Sadiq, that Detroit game will continue to weigh heavily in my mind for the rest of the season and
4:21the offseason as we look forward to the rest of his career.
4:26I do think he has the type of profile, he has the physicality, he has the youth, the frame, to where I
4:33would not be surprised if he is able to eventually transition himself out of this kind of flex tight end role to
4:41an every down tight end in the future. If, you know, I were the Jets, like especially when they haven't had Cooper
4:49and Mitchell both on the field together, I don't really understand their desire to play.
4:54The Isaiah Williamses and the Tim Patricks ahead of Kenny and Sadiq effectively, but that's just kind of what teams have a
5:02tendency to do sometimes in ways that frustrate us and, in my opinion, themselves.
5:07All that being said, like the projection for the near term with Cooper is way cleaner.
5:12Like Mason Taylor is a pretty reasonable inline tight end.
5:16They clearly don't have an intention of force feeding Kenny and Sadiq.
5:20And Cooper was, I think, a underrated and high quality prospect who was really talked down on for a bunch of nonsense
5:28reasons during the preseason when we hadn't even gotten the chance to see him actually go out there and play real NFL games.
5:36And we've only seen about five quarters of it, but it looks awesome.
5:40So, I mean, I'm curious to see kind of where the market is at on Omar Cooper this week.
5:47Like, you know, we're going to talk about another exciting rookie wide receiver pretty soon.
5:52Cooper is a lot more exciting to me of the two of them, I think.
5:57Cooper was a legitimately high quality prospect who I thought was like a late round one, early round two tweener type.
6:05I thought he had a lot of upside, especially on his profile, kind of a boom-bust prospect because the per route metrics
6:12were really strong, even though he didn't necessarily have a very large sample size of producing early in his career on full routes.
6:20It's only been one game, and like maybe this could be a function of, you know, Garrett Wilson's getting shattered by Christian
6:28Gonzalez, and so you want to target the number two receiver.
6:32But the fact he was up for it, the fact he's been so efficient, the fact he looks so great to the
6:40eye test, I mean, there's some chance that we just saw the first five quarters of like a total superstar.
6:47Who knows? You know? So, I think I'm definitely pretty interested in buying high on Cooper.
6:52Yeah, I would generally agree. I guess we can just kind of spoil it right now, at least for myself as well.
7:00Yeah, Omar Cooper was the receiver that we are going to talk about today, that I had ranked highest before the season
7:08as a prospect, including his situation and all of that in rookie drafts.
7:12And he remains the rookie receiver of the three that we're going to talk about today, that I am the highest on.
7:20I don't think he's much better than a coin flip to outscore Jeremy Bernard over the rest of the season, just because
7:28of some environmental stuff that we're going to talk about with the Steelers.
7:32But I do think in terms of difference making upside, is this player going to develop into more than a fantasy wide
7:40receiver three at some point in his career? I would easily take Cooper there.
7:45So, yeah, Tom, why don't you bring us through any of these interesting trades that you have going on here?
7:52As you're scrolling through, I guess the only other kind of nitpick that people might have on Cooper and that we'll see
8:00if this is affecting his trade price is Adonai Mitchell has been out for just as long as he has.
8:07He looked good in like a game and a half and had a decent role in terms of commanding air yards down the field.
8:15But ultimately, that doesn't really factor too much into my calculation on Cooper.
8:19Adonai Mitchell, like we call him the ass god here at Fantasy Points, but contained within that nickname is the fact that, hey, he does separate.
8:29He has good average separation scores. He always gets air yards.
8:32But how often does he actually catch the ball?
8:36That's hit or miss. That's up or down. The guy had the glove on his hand is going to be rehabbing and coming back from a hand injury.
8:45I don't know. I think even if the Jets get him back, I would not be at all shocked to see Cooper
8:53continue to play at least as much as he does and continue to outproduce him.
8:58That would be my base expectation. Like the first week that Mitchell comes back, I'm going to be sitting in our projections
9:06meeting and telling Chris Wecht that Cooper needs to be projected higher than Ady Mitchell.
9:11That's how I would see it. But yeah, we can look at some of these trades and I agree with that optimism.
9:19But I would I would brace yourself for short term annoyance with the New York Jets.
9:25You know, this is this is a coaching staff led by Aaron Glenn, who doesn't even know when he's going to get
9:32the ball out of half and when he isn't.
9:35And Frank Reich, who, you know, is a bit of a dinosaur.
9:40So, like, I don't know that this is a team that you can consistently rely on to skate where the puck is going.
9:48As we just saw with Kenny and Sadiq, like he has this incredible breakout game against the Detroit Lions.
9:54And then as soon as they get Mason Taylor back, you know, they couldn't be more excited to play a bunch of
10:0211 personnel with Tim Patrick and Isaiah Williams and put their dynamic rookie back on the sidelines 65% of the time.
10:09That's just kind of like what the Jets are as an organization.
10:14So do I think it's a possibility that Omar Cooper just keeps ascending and ascending and ascending from here?
10:20Definitely. Absolutely. I guess what I would say is that if there is short term aggravation and we instead are forced to
10:28watch Omar Cooper run 62% of the routes because they want to run 80 Mitchell on every single route and they need
10:36to make sure Tim Patrick is out there to rotate into 12 personnel sets for blocking responsibilities or whatever goofy BS we see.
10:44Like, just don't forget that Omar Cooper has shown himself to be a very good player in the meantime and that ultimately talent finds a way.
10:53Um, and specifically, I don't think we have to worry about Aaron Glenn or Frank Wright going into 2027.
10:59So I'm kind of just treating these New York Jets players, be it Cooper, be it Sadiq, be it kind of all
11:07whoever these guys is like, what can you show me about your upside so that we can try to take that into how we view you in 2027?
11:17Yeah, you obviously want consistent production. It just, you have to look at the environment and don't forget, there's a real chance.
11:25It's Kay Klubnick finds his way into the starting rotation.
11:28Even Will Levis potentially finding his way into the rotation at quarterback if the Jets season spirals further than it is.
11:35And that's something you're going to have to take into account.
11:39You're going to see that posted a lot. Uh, so you really have to, like Jacob said, kind of be prepared for
11:47the, the muckiness that is to come with the New York Jets.
11:51Um, you look at some of the trades and it kind of reflects from today.
11:56We're recording this on October 20th, uh, Jameson Williams and a third and there's Omar Cooper in a 27, two.
12:03Yeah. These are some frothy Omar Cooper prices actually, which is a little surprising to me.
12:09I mean, I would definitely take the Cooper in a second side there pretty easily.
12:14Yeah. I think you're, I don't, uh, Smith one is interesting.
12:18Yeah. Yeah. On a re on not a contender.
12:21I'd definitely take Cooper in the two. I like value vacuum.
12:25I think I prefer. Yeah. The Cooper side. Yeah.
12:28The it's the Devonta Smith for Omar Cooper that, that is kind of eyebrow raising to me.
12:34Yeah. That's an interesting one. I mean, that's like the classic trade that's going to look really silly in a month, but
12:42I don't know a hundred percent which side. I mean, I think I'd probably just stick with Devonta because the one thing
12:50about Cooper is almost no matter how good Omar Cooper is like Chris Gary Wilson is one of the best receivers.
12:57The league is not going to be shattered by Christian Gonzalez every week.
13:02And he does play on the jets. So even if Cooper is really good, it's not like we can just expect him
13:09to, you know, put up 20 fantasy points every week.
13:13Like it's, it's still going to be, I think hit and miss production wise for the rest of this season.
13:20And so I don't, I don't know that like Cooper has the capacity to all of a sudden you blink and you
13:27miss it and he's worth three ones. Like, I don't know that that level of helium is there.
13:34So I don't feel the urgency to trade Devonta Smith away to go and get him right now, but I, I could totally see how that works out.
13:44Yeah. Yeah. I would agree. Yeah. The one to one position thing just feels like an, I know ball situation.
13:51And it's not one that I really, I don't think you were losing.
13:55You're not gaining a lot in the value side.
13:58You're not gaining a lot in the production side doing this deal one for one.
14:04So no, this is a, this is a big Devonta Smith for me.
14:08Um, here are two from yesterday that I wanted to look at.
14:12We have the Travis HN and Cooper for Jalen Warren, which I would take the HN and Cooper side pretty easily.
14:20I would as well. Yeah. Give me the Cooper side here.
14:23Let's see. HN for Warren. Yeah. I'll go. I mean, I don't really care about Travis.
14:29I think I'd go with Cooper over. I mean, yeah, I think I'd go Cooper over Warren.
14:35Yeah. The Warren, maybe that would have changed if they didn't just immediately put Warren back in rotation with a super inefficient Rico daddle for no reason.
14:44I mean, this is, I mean, we talked before, I mean, or we were just talking last time about like, you know,
14:52surely they wouldn't just go back to putting 80 Mitchell ahead of Cooper in the target pecking order.
14:58It's like, like sometimes coaches will do the darndest things.
15:02And like, I don't really care that much when they do the darndest things to a rookie, because like what will determine
15:10the course of Omar Cooper's career is not whether he out routes or out targets 80 Mitchell in like a random week, eight game during his rookie season.
15:19But like when you're looking at Jalen Warren, you know, his, his value equation is really based on what can you do for me right now.
15:29And, um, annoyingly what he can do for you right now is, is have a like 55% opportunity share next to Rico daddle.
15:37Yeah. Extremely frustrating stuff. Um, yeah, I, I was afraid and it, it happened.
15:42Uh, but yeah, some of these other, these other two deals to me are clear wins for the Cooper side as well.
15:49Um, I think if I had a double Omar Cooper or a 27 second, I would just take Cooper pretty easily.
15:57What about the high lemon one? Cause I find that interesting.
16:00That this is where I think I'm. Yeah. I think it's an interesting deal.
16:05So I think I'm willing to go Cooper at this point, which is maybe crazy, but I had an interesting debate.
16:13That's where I am with some very active and sharp dynasty players in a group chat the other day about, uh, lemon
16:20versus Bernard, who we're going to talk about in a second.
16:24Um, and kind of like, how do you wait?
16:27The prospect profile, the draft capital versus the immediate production.
16:31Um, I think I'm like a slight lemon there still.
16:34Um, but on this one, I would go Cooper.
16:38I think that the prospect profile gap between lemon and Cooper is not that high.
16:43Um, the situation is like strikingly similar, like actually crazy similar between what the jets and the Eagles did.
16:49You know, they, they each have a stud wide receiver one in the prime of their career.
16:55Uh, they both wear green. They drafted, um, a wide receiver and a tight end who don't make a ton of sense together longterm.
17:04They each have like an ask God wide receiver that sometimes doesn't have hands playing as wide receiver two with wicks and 80 Mitchell.
17:12It's really similar. Um, I, I think that lemon was the better prospect, but like, again, not by that wide of a margin.
17:20So I'll probably just go with the guy who's playing better right now.
17:25And I'll go with Cooper, especially in similar situation.
17:28Yeah, that's exactly how I would think of it.
17:31It's both of these were while, while I had lemon, like a tier ahead as a prospect, it was not like that big of a gap.
17:40Like he, I think lemon was my rookie wide receiver three.
17:44Uh, Cooper was my rookie wide receiver five. Like, I don't know.
17:48Yeah. Yeah. The league didn't seem to view them super differently.
17:52Uh, yeah. I, I think even, yeah. The draft cap literally one game nine spots.
17:57Yeah. Even literally one game of evidence for Cooper versus six, not very good games of evidence for lemon, I think is enough to flip that for me.
18:07Yeah. Yeah. I, um, I'd also say the big thing with like Cooper and I keep teasing that we're going to get
18:15to Bernard and we will, but, um, like from a prospect profile perspective.
18:19At the risk of like breaking what I think is a pretty good heuristic, which is to not separate floor and median
18:27projections from ceiling projections of prospects as much as possible.
18:31I'm just going to do that anyways. Um, but I, I caveat it with it was saying it's a bad idea.
18:38So you could choose to listen to me less now that I've caveated it.
18:43Um, like Cooper, I felt like the flaws in his profile were largely floor-based flaws and median outcome based flaws.
18:50Like I, I love the per route profile. I thought that the movement skills were really special.
18:56What I thought were the major holes in his profile were a lack of early production and just like a lack of
19:03early route volume in his first three seasons. But I didn't feel like this was a guy who had like major talent based limitations.
19:12I felt like this was a guy who, you know, either he could hit a massive ceiling or it's like, it never really comes together for him.
19:21And you look back on the college profile and you're like, well, there were signs there all along.
19:28Um, with Bernard, I mean, the whole book on him was professional wide receiver, like going to be a starter in the league for a long time.
19:37You know, what is the high level outcome? Now, a lot of times people say that kind of thing about a player
19:45and then they just get it dead wrong. Right.
19:48It's like, um, we, we place artificial ceilings on guys.
19:51Uh, Amon Rossi Brown is like the patron saint of artificial ceilings where we say, okay, well, this guy got to this
19:59level, but he was always going to get to this level and he's not going to get to the next one.
20:06It's not, this is not right every time, but Bernard kind of hitting immediately.
20:11But then not ascending to superstardom would not be inconsistent with the way that he was profiled coming out.
20:18And so I'm probably more inclined to like buy super high end outcomes on Cooper than I am on, on Bernard.
20:25Yeah. I think I'd agree with that. Uh, and it's not just from like a skillset standpoint, which I think that that
20:33is legitimately part of it is like what these two do on the field where Cooper is much more like the insanely
20:41explosive, exciting athlete, pleasing to the eye, like that type of stuff.
20:45And Bernard as a prospect was much more like he'll get it done.
20:50He's got the lowest drop rate of any wide receiver in the class.
20:54Like all, all of that type of professional wide receiver stuff was where Bernard really shined.
21:00Uh, but I mean, it's also just in peak production of their, of their profile, right?
21:05For Bernard, a lot of the things that we liked about him was, well, his production isn't really elite, but he that's, it's easily explainable.
21:14Like he was competing with all of these NFL level wide receivers at every step of his college journey.
21:21So you can tell the story. It's like understandable why he didn't fully pop on the field or have like a massive,
21:28uh, season by yards per team pass attempt or however you want to measure it.
21:34Right. Uh, he was just always solid. And I, I'd agree.
21:37I think that's kind of what I'd expect from that prospect just to transition into Bernard now, uh, if you put him
21:45on a Steelers offense, that is top five and pass rate over expectation with no Michael Pittman, uh, with Roman Wilson on IR now.
21:54And you just gave him a full-time role next to DK Metcalf, who is for my money, the last couple of seasons
22:01is one of the more like overrated wide receivers in the league in terms of how much does he actually earn targets
22:09and how much will he actually crowd other players out of volume?
22:13Uh, if you put Bernard in that spot or the, or that like prospect profile in that spot, it makes sense to
22:21me that he would put up some strong numbers.
22:24On a 5.3 average depth of target and have the same number of targets as DK Metcalf in his three games without
22:32Michael Pittman like that, that makes a ton of sense to me.
22:36So yeah, while it's good for Bernard and I think I'm just willing to just say, okay, this guy's going to have like Jacoby Myers, his career now.
22:46Uh, I, I just don't know how much I'm willing to buy into the idea that it gets better than that.
22:53But I, yeah, to Jacob's point, maybe that's foolish.
22:56Um, we did say it about Alman Ross St.
22:59Brown. I would say that Alman Ross St. Brown's prospect profile in hindsight was much stronger than Jeremy Bernard's.
23:06I mean, I would say I had him ranked way higher.
23:10I like moved him down obviously when he went in round four, but Alman, Alman Ross St.
23:16Brown is like one of the only cases of the.
23:19He might be the only case of like the analytical darling wide receiver who surprisingly falls to day three.
23:26Um, but then is actually really good. You usually like that guy stinks.
23:31Usually, usually it's Elijah Surratt where it's like, oh, like actually usually the Ravens draft them.
23:36Cause it was also Tylan Wallace. Um, so, uh, it's, it's like, usually it's like, there's, you know, the, the analytical profile looks strong.
23:45We're waiting on the draft capital. The NFL decides, no, this guy stinks.
23:49And they're like, right about that specific profile, like 95% of the time, there's almost no relationship between, um, analytics based prospecting and, uh, success.
23:58Once you get deep into day three, but, uh, Alman Ross St.
24:02Brown is, is the, uh, like the one exception to the hat for sure.
24:07Yeah. And he's the, he's the one that makes me continue to rank Elijah Surratt's of the world much higher than I should every single season.
24:16Yep. Yeah. I think I'm just more into players that have this don't score fun points, uh, um, kind of moniker around them.
24:24Like he's not the downfield, super explosive, very flashy, say Jamison Williams type on that offense.
24:30A lot like Omar Cooper's a lot more deep balls.
24:33At least we haven't seen him get used that way yet.
24:37Me there's just, these guys are really valuable weekend and week out.
24:41If they're getting this kind of consistent usage on teams, I was the Michael Pittman guy on this show for multiple years.
24:49He was not very fun, not very exciting, but still a consistent producer when relied upon.
24:55So I think if we're seeing nine targets last week, 12 targets this week, granted some of that was overtime.
25:02You look at some of the data just up there on the screen.
25:06Speaking of Michael Pittman Jr. And the three games without him, we have just seen a reliance on him.
25:13That as a rookie, almost regardless of profile to me, makes me raise my eyebrows and take a deeper look at it.
25:20If he can consistently earn these targets, then I think, I think he's going to be worth paying for as a very
25:28much useful player in your fantasy lineup. Even though he, again, he doesn't get the sexy points.
25:34He's not the, the hot button, super, you know, explosive, hyper efficient type player that a lot of fantasy players fall in love with.
25:42I'm more than happy than getting somebody like Jeremy Bernard to sit in my flex spots week in and week out.
25:50I'm curious when we get to the trades because my, my inclination would be that like, I probably am not rushing to buy crazy high.
25:59Like I'm not. Me either. I would be surprised if this is a person that I'm ranking in my top 15 dynasty wide receivers one day.
26:08Um, but I, I definitely don't think that it's like a sell high spot.
26:13I think like probably where I might be looking at Bernard as a guy I actually recommend selling might be, we'll see
26:20what his price heads up being, what his rest of the season ends up being, what might be the off season.
26:28Um, where I think if, if he is like kind of priced in accordance with his typical production and being a year
26:35or two player, it might get a little too frothy for me based on the longer term profile.
26:42But in terms of what, uh, I expect for the rest of the season, I mean, he's in a fantastic spot rest of the season.
26:50I, I, I know Tom, you were, uh, pumped about kind of like one more target spamming Michael Pittman season coming into
26:58the year and like Pittman unfortunately is washed, but I think that your take spiritually lives on through Jeremy Bernard, where he
27:06now gets to kind of consolidate a bunch of these short area targets, uh, that Aaron Rogers is desperate to throw to someone.
27:14And it isn't really DK Metcalf bag. So like the other thing about Bernard that I, I think he gets a bad
27:22rap on is like, he's, he's so often discussed as this like boring snoring Jeremy Bernard player.
27:28Like Ryan brought up Jacoby Myers, Tom brought up Michael Pittman.
27:31I mean, like, I definitely think the limitations in terms of the downfield production are real in his profile, but I do think he's a pretty special mover.
27:41Like I just remember, Oh, you know, before I was even getting into the like prospecting weeds, um, like watching the third
27:49Saturday of October last year and like multiple times, I was like, who's five on Alabama.
27:54Like we can't tackle this fricking guy. And it was Jeremy Bernard.
27:59And like, I won't even lie. Like I didn't know that much about him as a draft prospect at the time, but
28:06I was just consistently like kind of blown away by his movement ability.
28:11And he's been used as a really good threat.
28:14Um, like there, there's like a world where like the analytical prospects are profiles on these guys are polar opposites.
28:21But if I wanted to be, um, like a certain type of fantasy analyst and do the HR meme for, you know,
28:29one guy versus the other guy, like there's some similarities in the games of like Jeremy Bernard and Luther burden in terms
28:36of, uh, like rugged, great after the catch. Um, some questions about consistency downfield, but like very good short area targets.
28:44I don't, there, there's some like sexiness to Bernard's game from a, uh, uh, ball at hand perspective that I think doesn't
28:52get totally captured in like the Jacoby Myers comparisons.
28:55Um, even if maybe it didn't necessarily come through always statistically either.
28:59I, I do think he moves very well with the ball.
29:03And I think he's been used in that way, very effectively with the Steelers.
29:08So I have, I use the Michael Pittman Jr.
29:11One, uh, just simply because it's just the feeling I get from the community itself.
29:16I had, yeah, no, it's, it's, it's how he's talking about it.
29:20You're totally right. Yeah. So his upside to me, again, a lot of this ends up becoming situational.
29:27We, we know what's happening with Rogers and retiring, but does the pass rate stay, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera.
29:34Uh, I could see a certain five foot 11, 202 pound wide receiver from LSU who was a very shifty underneath type
29:42player that had question marks deep downfield. It's Jarvis Landry.
29:45And again, you say a name like that, and it's not like a sexy, super exciting type player, but he was super good for fantasy football.
29:54You can even get into Deontay Johnson type players who weren't great downfield, but they were target earners that scored you a
30:02ton of fantasy points that ended up being very valuable in dynasty.
30:06Even if the longevity wasn't there for them because they're not of the superstar mold.
30:11And I feel like those types of players are consistently underrated.
30:15Cause again, it's not the sexy points that we are in love with.
30:20Right. It's why Jameson Williams holds such power over the dynasty community and why every year we have the conversations is this year.
30:28He's going to outscore Amin Ross, same Brown, even though he's just not a historic target earner.
30:34And we do it every single year, not us, but the very small section of the community does every year.
30:41And I feel like it's the, it's the style points that get you there.
30:46But if you do look at the trades themselves, the buy thing, I don't think is as real right now because he is popping off.
30:54You look at the first trade from today, Woody marks, Basial tootin and a 27 fourth.
31:00And on the other side, it's Jeremy Bernard, Kenyan Sadiq and two thirds.
31:05That's an interesting trade. Um, I want, I think your better value.
31:09Mark said the fourth and the third, I don't care.
31:12So it's Jeremy and Sadiq for tootin. I'll go with the Jeremy and Sadiq side here.
31:18I love me some Basial tootin, but I think that Jeremy and Sadiq give you two bites at the, at the apple.
31:26And I, I would need to, to be like a clear, like 1.5 ones type player for me to clearly prefer him.
31:33And he's not, he's not quite that for me.
31:36Yeah. I was going to say, I think similarly, like it's Bernard plus Sadiq is just enough to me where it's like,
31:44yeah, I'd, I'd rather spread the bets there. Um, I don't know that either are like, particularly higher upside than tootin, but
31:52I think getting two of them is what I'd prefer.
31:55Yeah. I agree with you guys. It's the 28 one stuff that starts to get me just to, I'll sell, I'll sell there.
32:03I'll take the 28 one. Yup. Yeah. I think that's, yeah, yeah.
32:08I'm definitely like white ones over Bernard. I'm doing that.
32:11Yeah. Uh, the next one I see is Boston for Bernard and a third.
32:16I would definitely take Boston. Like, like I think that Bernard versus lemon one is really interesting because you're, you're like, that's
32:24a big weight of prospect profile versus what I'm seeing with my eyes on the field right now.
32:30Um, I mean, I, I would prefer to have bought a Bernard rest of season just because I think he's in so
32:38much more of a friendly fantasy role, but like from a zoomed out dynasty perspective, both of these guys have been super impressive this year.
32:46And so that's where I probably would lean on the prospect profile.
32:51And it's not like Bernard is like in a great spot from like a dynasty perspective.
32:56Like he's kind of in a, he's, he's in a really good spot for his skillset in this like weird drop back,
33:04happy Aaron Rogers, get the ball out in under two seconds offense.
33:08Um, and he's, his skillset is super conducive to that.
33:12We have no idea what the Steelers situation is going to be next year.
33:16So it may or may not be favorable. Yeah.
33:20Boston looks like an absolute monster. Like he looks every bit of a star caliber player and I was way too low on him.
33:28I think it looks great. I think any quarterback that isn't on the Browns roster, get Case Keenum in there.
33:35And all of a sudden, uh, David, like, uh, wow.
33:39David Boston. I'm an old man. Uh, dense Boston.
33:42Uh, probably looks even, even better than he is.
33:45Cause yeah. Watson is super washed, but yeah, I'll take, I'll, I'll take the Boston side there for the same reasons.
33:52Yeah. I think the running theme here is if you're getting a first or like a first level player, I'm taking that
34:00over Jeremy Bernard, but I, I'd agree. I said earlier that Cooper and Bernard are like a coin flip to outscore each other.
34:08The rest of the season. I would wait, I would wait the coin flip toward Bernard.
34:14I think he is probably a top 30 wide receiver rest of season.
34:18So like, I get it from that perspective, but I agree.
34:22Like I'd need to see more than that to buy into any hypothetical situation that he could find himself in going into next year.
34:30I would just always rather have the insulation of a first or of, uh, Boston that I think could succeed in a
34:38wider variety, uh, of setups and situations. And, and also with Boston, I think we have a, hopefully a better idea of
34:46what the Browns will look like next year than what the Steelers will.
34:50All right, let's move over to the final rookie wide receiver that we're going to talk about in our trio of the day.
34:58It's Antonio Williams. So Terry McLaurin in Monday night football, uh, left very early.
35:03It was just announced of like 30 minutes before we started recording that McLaurin is out for the season.
35:10Uh, so that very clearly creates a big opportunity for Antonio Williams, who I think as a prospect was discussed in maybe
35:18a similar way to Jeremy Bernard, where he was kind of the higher floor.
35:22This looks like a professional NFL player, uh, guy that can definitely play out, play in the slot and maybe play outside type of player should earn targets.
35:32Uh, had some underrated target competition in his college career, but never really hit the heights of production, uh, that around one profile would have.
35:41And we fast forward into this season and Williams has looked pretty good at times in relief of, uh, Terry McLaurin when
35:49he's missed time so far, he's going to miss the rest of the season.
35:54Uh, he ran one more route than Stefan Diggs did, uh, last night in week six, led the team in route share
36:01after McLaurin got injured, uh, over the full season.
36:04Williams is at 1.8 yards per hour run with Jaden Daniels starting.
36:09That's just behind Stefan Diggs. That's more than Terry McLaurin.
36:12Uh, and notably he and McLaurin have the exact same average separation score this year.
36:17So Williams is playing fairly well for a rookie.
36:21He has shown some explosiveness at times. He had that play called back in the London game.
36:27That would have been a long touchdown a couple of weeks ago, uh, that we may or may not have mentioned on this program.
36:35So I look at this and I say, and I get a little intrigued, right?
36:40Because Jaden, while I don't know in terms of the coaching staff, what the long-term regime and vision is, I think Jaden
36:48Daniels is going to be here for a while.
36:51I don't think Stefan Diggs is going to be here for all that much longer.
36:56He is over well over 30 years old. Terry McLaurin, who knows in terms of whether he has a career after this
37:04or continues to be relevant at his age coming back from a major lower body injury, right?
37:10So this is kind of the Antonio Williams audition, so to speak.
37:14Uh, how he performs the rest of the season is going to determine the commander's plans at wide river, uh, going into next year's draft and beyond, right?
37:24So this is a legitimately tricky one for me.
37:27I had Williams ranked behind both Cooper and Bernard, uh, from a prospect profile standpoint, but I think he has the most
37:35clearly potentially advantageous long-term situation of anyone we've talked about so far.
37:39So I'm curious, Jacob, how you kind of weigh that for Antonio Williams, uh, are you much more impressed or less impressed
37:47by what we've seen from Williams on the field so far?
37:51And how does the situation, if you see it the same way as me, kind of weigh into your evaluation of him
37:58relative to those other two guys that we already discussed?
38:02Yeah, I liked Williams as a prospect, like in a, in a pure vacuum.
38:07Um, I had him tiered the same as Jeremy Bernard.
38:10I'll give respect to the NFL with the draft capital gap between them, um, being at one round and say that Jeremy
38:18was the higher tier prospect based on that. Um, but overall, like I thought that they were pretty similar from a talent perspective.
38:26Um, I think that with the situation elements that you pointed out, like, I, I don't know, that feels like something that
38:34probably is more appealing to other people than it is to me.
38:38I think it's nice in terms of like, if you want to buy in on a player that it presents a potential
38:45window in the off season to suggest like, Hey, this guy has a path to be the wide receiver one.
38:52I guess I just, I have a hard time imagining that Washington's long-term plan is.
38:58Well, Terry McLaurin and Stefan Diggs are really old, so we'll just jettison them and then we'll replace them with nothing.
39:05And then our, our wide receiver one will be Antonio Williams and our wide receiver two will be Traylon Burks.
39:12Like that doesn't seem like the plan that they're going to enact.
39:16Um, I, I expect that they will probably add other players.
39:20Um, and then Antonio Williams will hopefully have a chance to be a full routes player for most of the rest of this year and in year two.
39:30And like, I guess what I would say is that if he can't like, I mean, he's a rookie, so, uh, you
39:38know, I'm not saying like if he can't out, out target, uh, Stefan Diggs, it's over for him or anything like that.
39:45But I guess what I'm saying is I don't anticipate him to have a substantially easier task in year two.
39:52Then you get to run, you know, a full route share and the wide receiver on the other side are Stefan Diggs and Traylon Burks.
40:01Like, I think, I think that's a pretty good situation for him to produce in right now.
40:07Um, and, and I'm excited to see it over the rest of the season.
40:12I've definitely been impressed by what I've seen from him.
40:15Yeah. He had the long touchdown called back for legal motion penalty.
40:20He got the, the pass from Terry McLaurin. That was a little off.
40:24He couldn't quite catch that. Like we're talking about a player that stats could look a lot better, uh, if not for
40:32again, which seems to be a theme this year with how many penalties there are in the league.
40:38Uh, but really to a lot to Jacob's point, he has the path now to establish the role that we're hoping for.
40:46If he doesn't really take control of that, uh, I would probably be looking to, looking to avoid, like, I'm not going
40:54to have like a big year to breakout. Um, conversation if he doesn't kind of cement his legitimate role for the rest of the year.
41:02So I'm interested to really see what happens week seven, week eight, where guys like Bernard and Boston and all these other
41:10guys have really fortified a role for themselves already.
41:13Williams has very much been. We'll say spotty. Like we'll say it's been some ups, some downs, um, like a 12.4% target share.
41:21Like you really want to see that start to climb.
41:25We're talking about guys like Bernard with over 20, right?
41:28And even Cooper playing one game coming back and kind of dominating.
41:32If you would in that, in that game environment, we haven't seen that quite from Williams that it's a lot of, Oh, he was, he was this close.
41:42So I'm going to give him the next two weeks to really, really see if he can quote establish it.
41:49If you would perform really interested in conversations. Yeah, I think it's fair to say that he's shown us significantly less than
41:57Omar Cooper and Jeremy Bernard have so far this year.
42:00Uh, and yeah, as I mentioned, had him behind both as prospects.
42:05Um, I don't know. I will see like what the prices are here in terms of how much I care about the
42:12situational stuff that you can kind of write out for him in the future in terms of.
42:18Does he just claim the number one role? Like he has to be good in order to do that first.
42:25Right. I guess that's always the, it's like the dynasty player putting the cart before the horse to use the oldest metaphor in the book.
42:34Uh, it's kind of what we will sometimes do with these players where it's like, yeah, there's nobody else here and he has a good opportunity to produce.
42:44But that does very clearly come with like a, an even lower value floor where it's like, well, if he doesn't step
42:52up and produce in this situation, then, then what's he going to be to me?
42:57What's he going to be to his NFL team after that?
43:01So that, yeah, something that I'll have in my mind as we look at some of these trades.
43:07Yeah. I mean, you get Cam Scadabo and Antonio Williams or Denzel Boston.
43:11I'm going to go Boston here. That's an easy Boston.
43:15Yeah. You don't think Scadabo is going to really bounce back after Najee Harris got really?
43:21I mean, I think he'll bounce back in the sense of like, I would still bet on him to lead the Giants backfield and points rest of season.
43:30But I don't think he's that good. And I, they're clearly not committed to him in the longterm whatsoever.
43:37I heard the quote where it's like, no one has stepped up in the backfield.
43:42It's like, Oh my God, ruthless. This one I think is funny.
43:46I'm starting to wonder if, if Ryan made this trade is we were talking Noel earlier today before we sat down to
43:54record, but Aaron Rogers, Antonio Williams and a 28 fourth or Jalen Noel.
43:59Antonio Williams. Yeah, I did not. So I did not make this trade, but this comparison popped into my head earlier as
44:06I was writing up Jalen Noel and preparing to talk about Antonio Williams on the show.
44:12So to me, if I'm just looking kind of in a vacuum, I don't think Noel and Williams are like that different
44:20in terms of what they have shown us as players so far.
44:24Of course, Noel got on the field much less in his rookie season than Williams has so far.
44:30But in terms of yards per hour run to date, Noel is just under two.
44:35It seems like the Texans are starting to slightly appreciate his talents.
44:40It is kind of the opposite of the Antonio Williams situation though, where if it were Jalen Noel that was going to
44:47get to run a full-time route share across from only Stefan Diggs and be attached to Jaden Daniels, I might legitimately be
44:55excited or maybe a little more excited than I am with Antonio Williams.
45:00But yeah, this trade where you're also getting Aaron Rodgers, assumedly that's a useful quarterback for the person that's getting him in this deal.
45:08I would take the Aaron Rodgers-Antonio Williams side. Look, I love Jalen Noel.
45:13Someone's got to tell me what the path is to him being like a real fantasy asset and not just a fun meme.
45:21Like I like Jalen Noel. I like him as a player.
45:24I wish he was on a team that I rooted for in real life.
45:29Every single time that they give him the ball, he does things with it.
45:34I mean, it's taken kind of until now for him to even just be trusted to be like the full-time slot receiver.
45:42However, I mean, they just traded for Marvin Harrison.
45:45They're going to get Jaden Higgins back next year.
45:48Like they want to play a million tight ends.
45:51The path for him to be like a 80% route rate player is hellacious.
45:56I just, I'd love to see it. Like I would really like to be wrong about that, but I don't, I mean,
46:04the Houston Texans barely played Nico Collins 80% of the routes.
46:08Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. The way, the way I put this is that Noel at best is probably just this generation's Josh Downs
46:16where for years, we're probably going to be like, Hey, he's had like two startable games.
46:21I'm saying at best, we're going to be for years.
46:25Like, Hey, this guy rules, please play him full-time.
46:28And then maybe one day it will happen out of circumstance because they're forced to.
46:33And we're, we'll just get the hammer dropped on us again and find out that he's not actually going to deliver on
46:41the expectations as we found out with Downs this year.
46:44Yeah. That's good to say. You mean when they do play them full-time, but then bringing in a dusty vet, like Keenan
46:52Allen, who saps all the fun and energy out of, out of him.
46:57Oh my God. Yeah. Not, not good. Good. That's so brutal, but we have, um, another Jameson Williams trade with Jameson Williams
47:04and then Antonio Williams and a 27, two. Seems like people are really trying to get out of the Jameson Williams boat.
47:12Um, it's coming off of his best game too in week five.
47:16I guess people are trying to sell that or two good games in a row.
47:21You had the two touchdown game before that. He had the a hundred yard game.
47:27Uh, I would definitely take Jameson Williams over Antonio.
47:30Oh, it was a two. I thought it was a three.
47:34Uh, I'll still take Jameson Williams. I will here too.
47:37Yeah. I'll go with Jamo. I have like Jameson Williams concerns, but I mean, it's still one of the better offenses.
47:44He's going to have, I don't have James. Like, I don't have Jameson Williams concerns because I just think like Jameson Williams is what Jameson Williams is.
47:54He's, he's going to run every route on one of the best offices in the league.
48:00He's a talented player who is capable every week of like having a, a major spike week.
48:05In the weeks that he doesn't, he's going to be frustrating.
48:09He's never going to have like a consistent 25% target share.
48:13He's never been that player. He wasn't even that player in college.
48:17The, the upside is he's in an offense that drops back a gazillion times and only wants to use four players.
48:25So if any of those, like as it stands, he's startable every week.
48:29You just have to live and die with the results kind of on a, on a sequencing basis.
48:36And then if any of Aminra or Laporta or Gibbs get hurt, then he's, he's going to be a top 20 wide receiver.
48:44Like, I don't think that he's priced at a point where that equation is that bad.
48:49It's just that like, there's, there's a lot of hype that kind of want to make, make him something that he's not.
48:57But I also don't think he's actually priced like, you know, like last year he kind of was, but this year he,
49:05his price, I don't feel like has actually applied that.
49:08He needs to become something other than what he's been.
49:12So I'm, I don't have Jamison Williams concerns, but I, I definitely think like, you know, I don't, I don't expect Jamison
49:19Williams to transition into a target dominant alpha overnight.
49:22Yeah. I agree there. We have one more to test the Basial Tootin belief.
49:27Tootin or Williams, a second and a third. Tootin.
49:31Well, I'll, yeah, I'll take the points here with Basial Tootin.
49:34Yeah. I'll take Tootin as well. Um, yeah, I agree.
49:38So that's kind of where we're at with the three wide receivers, kind of a wide price range where Bernard seems to
49:46be the more expensive one, which I guess. Yeah.
49:49Overtime game winning touchdown, massive point game really looks like a legitimate breakout.
49:53I actually couldn't believe when I went and looked at what DK Metcalf did in that same game.
50:00And I just, it's very odd. Like the, the targets, like the pass rate, it's everything in Pittsburgh is weird right now.
50:07Everything. So people are really, um, I don't blame you for selling.
50:11I'll say that trying to capitalize off of that.
50:15So don't, don't blame you with that. That's our three players for this week's rookie report.
50:20Really love being able to dive into these. Look, I know some people on the fantasy points, YouTube channel.
50:27We're really hoping that we would get into Reggie Virgil content.
50:31He is like the most requested player we have to talk about.
50:35I promised everybody we'll put them on the watch list and see what happens this week.
50:41And, uh, the poor sub just, just commented back and said, I guess we're going to have to have a little bit of patience.
50:49Cause, uh, there's a whole lot of nothing from him.
50:52But like I said, if you leave a comment and let us know who you want us to take a look at,
51:00we'll add them to the watch list. See if they make the show.
51:05We have a long stretch to go. This is only week six.
51:09Who knows what happens in the next six weeks here on the rookie report.
51:14You're going to want to stay locked in right here.
51:17So again, hit that like button, hit the subscribe button and join us.
51:22Uh, apparently a lot of people didn't know this, but we still do go live on Tuesday nights.
51:28Uh, those podcasts just are not released the same way that they were before.
51:33You can go and check that out pretty much as soon as we're done recording.
51:38We hit a quick reset and we go over live on the fantasy points dynasty YouTube channel.
51:44But I will say with how much it has been requested, the live will be released in podcast format.
51:51Just a little later. It will come out on Thursday mornings, not Wednesday mornings when the rookie report releases.
51:58So it has been requested. You're going to get it.
52:01Uh, it'll just be an earlier release over on the YouTube page.
52:05Cause we do it live until next time. Remember that clear eyes and full hearts can never lose your best days are always been tilting.