0:00Wer riestert, der rostet. Zeit, Vorsorge neu zu denken.
0:03Mit dem neuen Scalable Altersvorsorge Depot wächst nicht nur dein eigenes Geld bis zu deiner Rente.
0:09Du holst dir obendrauf jedes Jahr bis zu 540 Euro Förderung vom Staat.
0:13Jetzt für das Scalable Altersvorsorge Depot voranmelden. Kapitalanlagen bergen Risiken.
0:17Welcome back to the Dynasty Points Rookie Report. I am Ryan Heath.
0:21I'm here with Jakob Sanderson. And guys, it's been four weeks of the NFL season.
0:27It is October 6th when we are recording this.
0:30I don't know about you guys. I'm starting to crave pumpkin spice lattes as long time thinking about thinking readers and Dynasty
0:38Points listeners will understand what I'm getting at here.
0:41It's time for us to kind of reset some of our expectations on these rookies now that we are getting into October.
0:48Jacob and I did a show before the season at the beginning of September that was called what to expect from the 2026 rookie class.
0:57We laid out some predictions, some expectations of what we would see from each rookie over the first month of the season.
1:05Today, we're going to revisit most of those and see what we can do in terms of what we would see from
1:13each rookie over the first month of the season.
1:16Of kind of evaluating these players against what we initially thought if we really need to change any of our views on some of these players.
1:25So I'm excited to get into this. How are you doing today, Jacob?
1:30I'm doing good, man. Pumped to be here. And yeah, week four, always a very fun time to do a check-in quarter of the way through the season.
1:40I know that's kind of like the break-even point between what's more predictive for the current season in terms of like preseason ADP and year-to-date production.
1:49So it's always a really fun week for content.
1:52Super excited to talk about some of the rookies with you.
1:56I also have to do a rookie roundup piece kind of value in the first four weeks that I'll have out later this week for the Athletics.
2:06So kind of a nice chance to hear your perspective before I have to get to writing that tomorrow.
2:12Awesome. Yeah, very much looking forward to reading that people should go check that out as well once that releases.
2:19Yeah, let's get right into it. So in that initial show, I had laid out some questions about each rookie kind of putting them into categories.
2:29And I want to evaluate all of them based on what we thought coming into the year.
2:35So there were four players where my only question was, how good does this player look and how well is he producing in weeks one through four?
2:44Where the expectation coming into the year was these players should get on the field play pretty early.
2:51There shouldn't be role concerns. We're going to get an immediate look at kind of what they can do on the field.
2:58That hasn't been the case for Fernando Mendoza. We can kind of skip past him, obviously, other than just to say that the Raiders offense has looked great.
3:08Kubiak seems to be the real the real deal.
3:12So yeah, while Mendoza, it may be later in the season when we finally see him start.
3:18I do think just long term things are looking good there in terms of the situation, but into the other three guys
3:25that have actually played a good amount of football so far.
3:29I want to start with Carnell Tate. Jakob, why don't you start off with your Carnell Tate thoughts on what we've seen from him through a month?
3:39Yeah, so I thought that it started off kind of like not bad.
3:43Actually, I would say it even started off better than I thought.
3:48And that he was already kind of out of the gates, even with or ahead of Waddell Robinson.
3:54I thought we might have to deal with a couple weeks of him being behind some Waddell Robinson PPR spam.
4:01I think the most disappointing thing, though, for Carnell Tate, especially early on, was just any hope that we would have had
4:09that Cam Ward was going to take a major step in year two.
4:13That kind of went out the window as soon as we saw Cam Ward come out and play.
4:20What's been really encouraging the last two weeks in particular has been Carnell Tate just completely dominating volume for this team.
4:27And actually, in this last week, finally, really posting a very, very startable fantasy performance at 23.5 PPR points this week, even
4:35despite Cam Ward continuing to look not all that good.
4:39In the last couple of weeks, just to put into perspective the degree to which Carnell Tate is dominating volume here, he's
4:46up to 15 catches for nearly 200 yards. Cam Ward has only completed 34 passes for, I believe, about 400 yards.
4:54So, Carnell Tate's almost half of the total receiving yardage.
4:57He's getting over a third of the reception volume.
5:01He's really making the most of a pretty crappy situation.
5:04I'm not quite ready to go this far yet because I thought he was an inferior prospect to this player, and we've
5:12really only seen like one true mega alpha week.
5:15But I would say it's tracking towards viewing his rookie season as a Teddero McMillan-esque rookie season, especially after the impressive week four.
5:23Yeah, Teddero McMillan was the exact comparison that I made over on the main YouTube channel with Scott Barrett the other day.
5:31I do think that, as you said, we're tracking toward the volume.
5:35The per route target earning could just look amazing for Tate by the end of this year.
5:41And even if that only amounts to like a low-end wide receiver two fantasy season as a rookie, kind of similar to
5:49what Teddero McMillan put up in 2025, I think we're going to go into the offseason feeling very good about Carnell Tate.
5:57He's going to be viewed as this kind of potential cornerstone dynasty asset that is only waiting for a quarterback to be
6:05dropped in his lap, or I guess in T-Max case for Bryce Young to take a step forward.
6:11I'm not holding my breath on that for Cam Ward.
6:15But yeah, I think archetype wise, we have kind of learned with Tate that he is not just the per target efficiency
6:22freak that he was at Ohio State, where he was, of course, taking a backseat to Jeremiah Smith.
6:29He has a 36% first read target share through the first four weeks of this year.
6:34That ranks third best among all rookies since 2021 through an initial four weeks.
6:39It's behind only Malik Neighbors and Pukanakua, ahead of Drake London, Zay Flowers, Jamar Chase, some really, really elite rookie seasons out of elite dynasty assets.
6:49So yeah, arrows pointing up on Carnell Tate. We discussed, I think on a previous show that post the Jordan Tyson injury,
6:56he was just clearly the rookie wide receiver one in this class in my rankings and your rankings, I believe.
7:03I don't feel any differently about that. Yeah, awesome stuff with Carnell Tate.
7:08Moving over to a player where it's not all awesome stuff is Jadarian Price.
7:13He was another one of these guys where I said, I want to be very reactive to what we see early in
7:21the season because he's going to have this audition for a very short period of time before Zach Charbonnet comes back to
7:29threaten high value touches again, at least in the short term.
7:32And it's very important what Jadarian Price does to open the season.
7:37And I would say personally that I thought he was solid as a runner.
7:42There was a lot to like in terms of his efficiency on the ground.
7:47He looked explosive, certainly at times. But of course, he's had some obvious fumbling issues, some obvious issues with his role where
7:54the Seahawks were not willing to give him many of the high value touches at the goal line, giving a lot of
8:02those to Emmanuel Wilson, giving a lot of the routes to George Holani.
8:07So that wasn't great. And now Price is on IR for at least the next three games.
8:13He went on to the IR list before week four and had to watch Emmanuel Wilson put up a huge score in effectively a Belcal role.
8:22So extremely tilting for any Jadarian Price redraft or dynasty managers to watch that happen.
8:27And now Zach Charbonnet, because of the IR return designation rules, has to be active by week seven if he's going to return at all this year.
8:37So very likely he will be active in week six or week seven.
8:41By the time Price returns, Charbonnet is probably also in this backfield.
8:46So, Jacob, I want to pose it back to you.
8:49What have you taken from this Jadarian Price audition that we got through really just the first three weeks?
8:56And are you shifting your outlook on him longer term as a dynasty asset based on it?
9:02Yeah, it's a terrible run out for him for seasonal.
9:06You know, you're hoping to get that. The hope was basically he's got this window of time before Charbonnet comes back to establish himself.
9:14I was particularly bearish. I still am particularly bearish on the quality of play we're going to see from Zach Charbonnet coming off the ACL in this timeline.
9:24And so the hope was Price would have kind of dusted those veterans and asserted himself in a lead role and then
9:32maintain that through the rest of the season. Clearly, that's not going to happen.
9:37I'm not 100% sure when he'll be back. You mentioned he's eligible to return in three weeks.
9:43I thought that the quote from Mike McDonald, you can read into this whatever or nothing.
9:48Like no one's really heard any specifics on what this injury is other than chest.
9:54But I thought it was pretty ominous the way that he was quoted.
9:58It wasn't like we're putting him on IR. He's going to get healthy.
10:03We can't wait to get him back. It was basically like went on a long tangent about our injuries aren't anyone's fault.
10:11And this happens in football. And, you know, we love Jadarian, whatever.
10:15And I think the way that he finished the phrase, I had bolded it in the hitchhiker's guy today, was effectively we
10:23look like he's going to be huge for us or something when he gets back, whenever that is.
10:29Which like I feel like the like what's unsaid there is like whenever that is, meaning like this year, next year.
10:36Like I don't know. Again, nobody even knows what this injury is other than chest.
10:42So maybe like we just won't see him again at all this year.
10:46I'm not sure. Best case for him would be that he does come back like week eight or nine.
10:53Has maybe a couple of weeks to establish himself back up to speed.
10:58And then you get this kind of their buys week 11.
11:02So you'd get a post buy period where maybe it's him versus Charbonnet in more of a mono-mono battle as they're back from both of these injuries.
11:11Like I would definitely favor Price in that battle.
11:14I think he's a substantially better rusher. Whether he would steal the high value touches, probably a little bit less likely.
11:22But I would be bullish on him showing enough to kind of pay off what you could probably get him for right now.
11:30If that happens, I just don't even know if we're going to see him this year.
11:36So my inclination is to be a buyer. I think a lot of people are writing him off as a bust, which I think is pretty premature.
11:45If you actually look at the data on when he's got the ball in his hands, I still think there's been a lot more good than bad.
11:55Like the fumble obviously is a killer. But he has been efficient when he's actually had the ball in his hands.
12:02He's still top 7 in both missed tackles 4 yards after contact per attempt.
12:07Like I think he is a quality rusher. Way better rusher in my opinion than anyone else in this team when healthy.
12:15It's just like I don't really know if I want to buy low now under the assumption that he's going to be back in week 9.
12:24When I think it's actually a little bit murkier and maybe you could buy even lower later.
12:30I'd like to know a little bit more about what's going on with this injury.
12:35I don't know if we're going to learn ever, but I'd love to know more.
12:41I guess my only pushback or like the alternative perspective I would offer is my biggest kind of concern on price coming
12:49in as a prospect was not his skill as a runner or his explosiveness.
12:53All of those things I kind of figured he would do pretty well.
12:58And he has done those things pretty well. Really it was this guy has never shown an ability to win or maintain
13:06a bell cow workload with all of the high value touches that we care about for fantasy.
13:12I'm a little scared with price that even if as you say he gets into kind of a post by competition with Charbonnet looks much better.
13:21That sounds plausible to me. I just would worry that kind of year after year in his career we're doing this dance
13:29where we're never quite sure if he's going to fully consolidate a backfield.
13:33If he ever does, it would probably be great for fantasy, but I just am not.
13:39I've not been convinced in any sense on that kind of question I had on him coming out like Bucky Irving might
13:47be an example or somebody to compare him to there where it's like, yeah, he's a really good running back.
13:54He's a great rusher, but consistently we are in this world where he's losing the touches we care the most about for fantasy.
14:02I just worry about that for price again. Kind of I had wondered if he might just immediately overcome that because of
14:10this early season runway in this situation he had been drafted into, but that didn't happen.
14:16So I'm probably a little lower. I think I agree it doesn't really make sense to sell right now as sentiment is
14:23at its lowest and he is not currently on the football field making big plays like that.
14:29That will happen again in the future and that's probably would be the time to consider selling off of that idea.
14:37I mean, you may be right. You're probably right.
14:40Like I didn't sound like I love this guy as a prospect coming out in Dynasty.
14:46I just I don't know. I just see a lot of people piling on to this guy right now and like labeling
14:53him a bust when I just think it's way premature.
14:57And so like, I don't know. I'd be curious like if you can get him for like decidedly under around one pick in value.
15:06And like, yeah, I definitely agree. Nothing. This has not gone well, but like have these three games that an injury like
15:13meaningfully shifted his range of outcomes negatively? Like not for me.
15:17Like I would value him pretty similarly to how I valued him on rookie draft day at least.
15:24And so if I could get him for substantially under that, I'm pretty into doing that.
15:29All right. Moving on to the last guy who we had said before the season, we want to see the immediate role, the immediate production immediately.
15:38How good does he look? It was Casey Concepcion.
15:42We can lump Denzel Boston into this as well, because it's been a similar run out for both of them where they
15:49are both full time players, which has been awesome.
15:53It was like a one week kind of stint for Concepcion where he was playing less than Jerry Judy that flipped very quickly.
16:01Both of these guys are taught to on the Browns in route participation.
16:05For Concepcion specifically, the target earning is very strong.
16:09He has a team high 22% target per outrun, a 30% first read target share, both leading the team partially because of
16:16a very heavy kind of underneath design target role.
16:20But due to that, the efficiency hasn't really been there yet for Concepcion over the full season, just 1.24 yards per outrun.
16:27Denzel Boston up at 2.39 yards per outrun. Of course, that's spiked somewhat by a few big plays, but he's looked very
16:35good on those handful of big plays. So I'll pitch it to you here as well.
16:41Jacob, how are you viewing kind of both of these Browns rookies?
16:45Are you flipping them? We both had Concepcion well ahead of Boston before the season.
16:50Has your mind changed on that at all? And just generally, what are your vibes here?
16:56I think they're both total stubs. I guess like my feeling is that Casey is probably a little bit underrated right now.
17:04And he is like still my preferred player. And I don't know if that's even the consensus anymore.
17:10I would still weight him. I still weight the prospect profile pretty heavily.
17:15Four weeks into the season, he was the better prospect.
17:18I think he has just gotten kind of more unlucky on the efficiency stats.
17:23Like I've watched all of his targets. I don't feel as though, with the exception of maybe one or two, that he
17:31is the author of his own poor per target efficiency.
17:35A lot of it is just him being used in some of the lower area role.
17:40And then when he has been used downfield, Watson's either missing him or just turning him down on in breakers and such.
17:48I still like that he has the gadget stuff to kind of supplement his floor.
17:53He still has the higher targets per run. And they're both running a ton of routes.
17:59So it's not like Concepcion's getting route limited for Jerry Judy or anything.
18:04They've gone ahead and done the right thing and just iced Jerry Judy completely in favor of these two rookie studs.
18:11So I guess between the two, I'm probably like more interested in buying KC.
18:16But that's not any shade to Boston. It's just that because he's really maxed out his efficiency early on, I think people
18:24are quite appropriately excited about him and chasing that production a little bit.
18:28So, I mean, I'm excited about both these guys.
18:32They were both prospects that I had ranked ahead of their ADP in rookie drafts.
18:37They're both prospects that I have ranked ahead of meaningfully where I ranked them at the time of rookie drafts.
18:44So I think that the answer can definitely be both.
18:47Ideally, they get a quarterback solution that's a long-term quarterback solution next offseason.
18:52And then we can get really excited about both of them.
18:56But yeah, I think these are the dudes. I think that the more interesting question is like both of these guys hitting
19:04to me has meaningfully changed how I view Harold Fannin.
19:07I don't know if that's the same for you or not, but that's probably the biggest negative shift with the Browns.
19:15For these guys, it's a lot of positivity. Yeah, I'd agree.
19:19Fannin's target earning has come down kind of commensurate with these two breaking out.
19:24The fact that it happened so early in their careers is not necessarily a great sign in terms of Fannin being anywhere
19:31close to a 1A or a 1B target on this offense.
19:35We talk often in fantasy about how it's very hard to be a good fantasy tight end if you aren't the first
19:43or second option on your offense just because of how target distributions work, how NFL offenses are structured in terms of first reads.
19:51So yeah, I would echo pretty much everything you just said.
19:55Very excited about Concepcion and Boston. I agree. Concepcion right now is probably the more gettable one relative to my sentiments.
20:03Let's move over into a different category. Before the season, we had kind of put all of these rookies in the bucket
20:10of I just want to see how much they get on the field and how healthy they are early in the season.
20:18For all of them coming into the year, I think we had a prior assumption that they may not play full time
20:26immediately, whether because of injury, whether because of other players on the depth chart ahead of them.
20:32We wanted to give all of these players a little bit of grace early in the season is kind of the TLDR of it.
20:40With that said, Jeremiah Love has had quite the week, I would say.
20:45Goes from close to an every down bell cow workload in week three, losing only two minute drills and obvious third downs in that game.
20:54Into week four, where he gets out snaps by Tyler Algier.
20:58Algier again runs more routes and love hardly plays in the second half.
21:02There's been a lot of back and forth this week and a lot of, I guess, discoveries or like reading the tea
21:10leaves in terms of all of the quotes we've had come out from Lafleur, from Love himself on why he didn't play
21:18as much in week four as he did in week three.
21:22I'll let you kind of give your interpretation on that, Jacob.
21:26But I would the only thing I wrote on the show sheet is it's the longest year of Jeremiah Love's life.
21:33And that's really just the kind of yeah, just kind of the vibe right now and where the sentiment is at.
21:41So talk to me about love and how you're viewing him as a dynasty asset in the like now that we're in the thick of all this.
21:50Well, this longest year of his life quote has gotten like not just misconstrued.
21:55It's gotten directly oppositely construed by a lot of people.
21:59Like if you read the full quote, I saw people that were aggregating it, framing it as though Jeremiah Love was like
22:06complaining about his usage and saying like, oh man, it's going to be a long year like on these stupid Cardinals.
22:14Like that's that is not how he was saying it at all.
22:18Like he was he was saying it quite literally in the context of there are a lot more games in the NFL than in college.
22:27It will be the longest year of my life.
22:30And, you know, he was dealing with the ankle sprain preseason and then he was dealing with it seemed I mean him
22:38and LaFleur have been very vague about it. But like if you watch the game, I tweeted out a clip earlier, very
22:46obvious that he sustained some form of injury, I think in the second quarter and then retweaked it in the fourth quarter.
22:54But at the very least in the fourth quarter during this game.
22:58And, you know, he's talking about trying to manage his health to get through the year.
23:03That's the context of the quote. I don't know.
23:07Like this is a dynasty show, so I'm glad I'm not really I'm not anywhere near as tilted about this stuff in redraft as most people are.
23:16And like I should be I had like a freaking sweet lineup in the spy that got entirely tanked because of Jeremiah Love.
23:24If I played Kyron Williams over Jeremiah Love, I would have won like $15,000 on Sunday.
23:30So I should be as tilted as anybody, but I just I don't know.
23:35Like we're one week away from him getting this amazing workload and looking great.
23:40And like every week he looks great. Even in this game, he starts out, gets the first six carries of the game.
23:48Like the plan was clearly to feed him again going in.
23:52That's 43 yards on the six carries. We saw him win in several different ways.
23:57Hand runs where he won with quickness to the edge.
24:00We saw where he was able to read flow and cut back with patience.
24:05We saw him win with physicality. We saw the spin move like everything we wanted to see out of Jeremiah Love.
24:13We're seeing the injury stuff is pretty annoying and it's going to be annoying on a week to week basis.
24:20But dynasty big picture, I think like, you know, really all you want to see is, OK, does this guy look like
24:28the superstar I drafted at the 101? And I think clearly the answer to that is yes.
24:34And he's going to be a starter for you this year.
24:38And he's going to be an absolute superstar for you in the future as long as he's able to stay healthy.
24:45I have very little doubt that like this is a guy who are going to be drafting in round one of redraft
24:53leagues for several years of his career. Third overall pick, super prospect, looks great.
24:58I don't think anyone in dynasty actually is that worried, but they shouldn't be.
25:03Yeah, I was incredibly tilted about Jeremiah Love. I jammed him in DFS as well this past week.
25:09I guess that that's the tax we pay for being so into the dynasty format.
25:14Maybe we overplay some of these rookies in their rookie seasons in those spots.
25:19But yeah, I would largely agree with what you just said for dynasty purposes.
25:24Just imagine if Love's week three was his week four, like if the two games had just been sequenced differently, the entire
25:32conversation would be fully like the opposite. Yeah, of what it currently is.
25:37And exactly. It could literally be the same thing in week five where it flips back instantly.
25:43So, yeah, just the fact that Love had even one game in the month of September where he was already up to
25:51a every down bell cow workload is great. That's all I could have possibly asked for for him as a dynasty asset.
25:58And yeah, I'd agree. My guess is people are overreacting in redraft.
26:03I still think he's like close to a borderline RB one for the rest of this season as well.
26:09Definitely. But yeah, we can move over into some of the other rookies.
26:14Makai Lemon was also in this category for us.
26:17We wanted to know how much he would get on the field early.
26:22The specific question that I had posed last time was, will he be playing in two receiver sets by week four?
26:29The answer to that was no. Even with Devontae Smith out, he ran only one route from two receiver sets this past week.
26:37I will say, though, maybe that whole debate in the offseason was over done or overthought because the Eagles are actually just playing a bunch of 11 personnel.
26:47Makai Lemon's route participation rate over the full season is completely fine.
26:51It's at 80 percent. So him being slot only turned out to not be the problem right now.
26:58The problem I would say we have is the per route data.
27:02The target earning has not really been there for Makai Lemon, at least to this point.
27:08Just a 13 percent target per outrun rate over an initial four games among all rookie wide receivers since 2021.
27:15He ranks bottom seven in yards per outrun on an absolutely disgusting list of names where the only fantasy relevant players on
27:23it to this day are Jackson Smith and Jigbus.
27:26So we can cope with that guy, of course.
27:29And Adonai Mitchell, it's Arian Smith, Diami Brown, Jalen Lane, Jalen Polk, Jonathan Mingo that he's kind of surrounded by in terms
27:37of immediate first four weeks efficiency coming into the league.
27:40So I would say that's not super exciting to me or particularly encouraging.
27:45But for me, I would zoom out a little bit, look at the prospect profile, say this was a prospect we really liked.
27:53I would add that, yeah, the only other really round one wide receiver that had this slow of a start was JSN.
28:01So maybe that's just an unfair comparison to even make that I just said 30 seconds ago.
28:07So he has at least a little bit of a runway theoretically here to assert himself in an offense that has not
28:15looked super great so far through four games. I don't know.
28:18I'll throw it over to you, Jacob. I'm really particularly interested in your Makai Lemon take.
28:24Yeah, I had I'm pretty darn sure when we did the show, I said that I had virtually no expectations for him early in the season.
28:33And so I'm not that worried about how the season has started.
28:38I agree he ran more routes actually than I thought he would.
28:42And the slot only stuff has been less limiting than I expected.
28:46I think part of that is Dallas Goddard suffered an injury and Eli Stowers was put on fake IR.
28:53So they've been basically just running 11 personnel constantly.
28:56That being said, like he's been used in a really weird way.
29:00He's been used in this gadget role, which hasn't worked at all.
29:05I don't even really think that's his game. Um, I guess they don't really have anyone on the team who's an obvious short area target.
29:13They don't throw a Saquon Barkley for some reason.
29:17He's also been hurt. That's not really Smith's game.
29:20That's not really Wicks' game. So I kind of get it.
29:24Um, he's also been used in the slot and running in breakers.
29:28And, um, you know, there's a lot of, a lot of hope from people that Jalen Hurts would succeed more on in breakers.
29:36Um, don't think so. Um, you know, Eagles fans and Jalen Hurts believers are, are currently, I think, blaming the fifth different
29:44OC for, for not taking advantage of what Jalen Hurts does well.
29:48There's a lot of, it's not all on Jalen Hurts.
29:52Um, it's a lot on Jalen Hurts. This guy's not good.
29:55Not good at playing quarterback. He's not a good fit for 2026 NFL.
30:00Um, so I don't expect that Makai Lemon is going to have a ton of success playing with Jalen Hurts the way that he's currently playing at least.
30:10Um, especially when the other receivers on the team are used more and better situated to the, like, few areas of the
30:18field that Jalen Hurts could consistently deliver accurate football.
30:21So, um, I continue to have very low expectations for him.
30:25I hated this landing spot. Um, but I think that you had to kind of bake in the grossness of this landing
30:33spot into his cost and that it would likely be a very slow start for him.
30:38And so he'll, he'll remain someone that I'm bullish on in Dynasty.
30:43Probably even if he does nothing the entire year, honestly.
30:46Um, it seems like it's more frequent these days than it used to be that some of these breakouts get a little bit delayed over time.
30:55And so I think that you have to have lower expectations for a lot of rookies, especially if they are going into somewhat murky situations.
31:04So, um, I, I remain pretty bullish on my Kyle Lemon long-term.
31:08I, I don't know how bullish I am on him over the course of the season.
31:14Largely, I just don't know what fixes. Like I, the hope, if it was going to be a fix for him, the
31:22hope was it would be a pretty immediate fix where Jalen Hurts would look a lot better, a lot more comfortable throwing
31:30to more areas of the field under this offensive coordinator than he did under Kevin Petulo.
31:35And, um, I think Hurts is actually playing worse than he's maybe ever played, um, right now so far this season.
31:43That's a good point on Hurts. That, that was such a big part of the offseason debate around the Eagles was, will
31:51he be able to throw to the middle of the field on the end breakers?
31:56Can he actually do it? Turns out, yeah, that was foolish optimism from, from myself, from a lot of people around the industry.
32:04I would largely agree with what you just laid out.
32:08I think you gotta continue taking the long view with Lemon.
32:11Moving over to Jordan Tyson. Of course, we don't know anything about him in terms of his performance on the field.
32:19There were multiple reports this week that Tyson is not expected to immediately come off of IR in week five.
32:26More likely they are targeting a week seven or a week nine return, which is after their buy.
32:32They play an international game in week seven. I think that was basically what we had laid out in the preseason or
32:40what your prediction was on that, Jacob. We discussed Tyson in previous weeks about how he and anybody could smash in this
32:48cheat code Saints offense for printing fantasy production and targets to wide receivers in comeback mode.
32:54I mean, anything to add there or are we just kind of still waiting to see?
32:59Yeah, I think that it's the some good and some bad from kind of what's going on in this absence.
33:06The good is that the offense looks like it's just going to continue generating league high rates of dropbacks.
33:13After saying I thought that they wouldn't be able to sustain 43 pass attempts per game.
33:19They went on through 48 last week. Their defense is a total disaster.
33:23They play really fast. Their run game is a total disaster.
33:27I don't I still don't actually think they're going to average 44 pass attempts per game this season, but they will probably
33:35lead the NFL in pass attempts per game. I guess the so that's a big upside.
33:41There's gonna be a ton of there's gonna be a very big pie for him to walk back into.
33:47The downside would be that both Jawan Johnson and especially Devon Vele, I think, have really impressed.
33:53So I don't know that it's going to be like quite as simple as Tyson walks in and from day one that he plays.
34:02He's the number two target. I think that it's going to be a little bit murkier than it probably would have been
34:10if Tyson was just ready to rock from week one.
34:13But like long term, I think it's fine. I guess that the probably the big thing that you'd have to decide on
34:21for like how bullish it's been long term over the first four weeks.
34:26It's just what do you make of Tyler Shock opinions really vary.
34:30I'm probably on the lower end of how impressed I've been by Tyler Shock through the first four weeks, like from a
34:38real life perspective and from a could this guy sustain multiple pass catchers outside of this kind of crazy situation.
34:45But some people are huge fans of Tyler Shock.
34:48And I think it is like difficult to be overly critical of him for sure when he's constantly being forced into obvious
34:56drop back situations over and over and over and over again.
35:00And I want to give him some grace for that.
35:03So I think overall, like some good, some bad for the short term.
35:08And I think where you land on shock probably informs how you feel about him for the long term.
35:14Yeah, Shuck is very, very hard for me to evaluate for the reasons you just mentioned watching that primetime game.
35:22I was I kept thinking this looks like he's playing a video game, sort of like this is just a video game
35:29offense where everybody knows he's dropping back on every single play after the opening drive effectively.
35:35And he kind of makes it work and he does force it downfield and it works a decent amount of the time,
35:43more than it would for probably a lot of quarterbacks in the league thrust into a situation like that.
35:49So, yeah, I don't know. I think I'm probably a little more positive on shock, but I hear you in terms of
35:57if this were like an average kind of situation and defensive and offensive setup would.
36:03The fantasy production support be as high, obviously not.
36:06So, yeah, it's tough there. But I remain bullish on Tyson, even in redraft.
36:11Like I think Makai Lemon is droppable in redraft leagues.
36:14If any redraft people are listening to this podcast, Tyson, I can.
36:19I'd want to give him another shot without Smith this week.
36:22OK, fair. I would more say, like, if you if you have to, like by weeks, he's.
36:28I don't know. I would rather have. I am struggling to think of a player I'd rather have.
36:35Like if I have to pick up and start like Mike Gesicki because I don't have a tight end this week, I
36:43would be OK with dropping Makai Lemon for that.
36:46Something along those lines. I think I think Lemon like this.
36:50This is like it's not an hour never week for Dynasty.
36:54It's it's almost an hour never week for redraft.
36:57It's it's going to be an incredible situation this week for him.
37:01I'm going to I mean, I'll just go ahead.
37:04Like I unless it's like ownership. I haven't looked at ownership.
37:08I haven't looked at prices. I haven't looked at everything.
37:12Anything. I can't imagine he's not going to be a big part of my DFS stands this week in a game against
37:19the Jaguars without their top two running backs. They're going to have a crazy high pass rate.
37:25I'm guessing that I'm guessing that we're going to see something from Lemon this week.
37:31And I think he's kind of startable. But I don't know.
37:35We'll we'll see. I get your point for sure.
37:38If it doesn't happen this week, I don't think it's happening much in twenty twenty six.
37:43You won't have a better spot. Yeah. Well, enjoy playing showdown in the London game this week because he's not on the main slate.
37:52Oh, really? You're going to get. I haven't looked at anything.
37:56That stinks. Oh, yeah. I'm so excited for that spot.
37:59Subject yourself to showdown for for an international game.
38:03Sounds like a captain lineups. OK, you know what?
38:06At least it gets facial toot and off the main slate.
38:10So I don't have to deal with his 44 yard touchdowns being called back.
38:15Oh, my God. That dude, I was not that this is the subject of this show.
38:20But yeah, I had a very, very tilting Sunday from it was from an everything perspective.
38:26But it was incredibly assaulting DFS day for me.
38:29I had my top lineup in the spy, which ended up like still very easily cashing.
38:35And I had a winning day. But like my I played Burrow with T Higgins skinny and I had Zay and I had Nico and I had strange.
38:45So like all of that part was like fantastic.
38:48And then all the running backs sucked and they sucked in like tilting ways.
38:53It was Tootin who could have had easily two touchdowns was called back.
38:57Love who has the in-game injury and like lose the touchdown down year before the in-game injury.
39:03And then Braylon Allen, who was like proof that I was clearly correct about the inputs, like that he was going to have this role.
39:12And then they just ran 31 plays. So it was like anyway, really, really gross group of running backs.
39:19Yeah, don't worry. You're going to get to play Braylon Allen with 30% of the field this week as your reward for
39:27being right last week, which is how DFS tends to go.
39:31That's the annoying part about DFS. At least like seven years ago in DFS, if that happened, you would get to play
39:39Braylon Allen again the next week at the same ownership.
39:42But like this week, it's like, oh, you had the correct Braylon Allen read.
39:47Congrats. You got like nine points because they ran 30 plays.
39:51And now X week, everyone's changed their inputs and everyone's a projections bot now.
39:56So you get to play Braylon Allen at 32% ownership instead of like nine or whatever it was.
40:02It's horrible. It's terrible. Terrible game. Speaking of terrible Jets performances with that 30 play game, Kenyon Sadiq, another rookie that was affected by this.
40:11Coming into the season, we had posed it as just how often is Kenyon Sadiq going to get on the field early in the year?
40:20He had dealt with an injury throughout a lot of training camp.
40:24We had noted that that was enough to limit Colston Loveland until the end of his rookie season, as talented as we viewed him.
40:33Kenyon Sadiq has over the past two weeks had, I would say, a very encouraging role.
40:38He has been playing, gone from a 57% route share in week three when, of course, he went for over 100 receiving
40:46yards, made a couple of amazing plays, up to a 67% route share in week four.
40:52Again, that's only out of like 32 plays that the Jets somehow ran.
40:56But that's still encouraging to me. It obviously comes with Mason Taylor being hurt, but Sadiq is even playing in 11 personnel.
41:04He's been at about a 60% snap share on those looks over the past two weeks.
41:10I'd say it's very, very encouraging. We talked about this on, yeah, last week's rookie report, but anything to add on Kenyon
41:18Sadiq from what we saw in week four? Are we just continuing to be very bullish?
41:23Yeah, super bullish. I mean, I know week four stunk.
41:27It stunk for all the Jets. Whatever. Whatever. They ran like 30 plays, like I just said with the Braylon Allen tilt.
41:35It's just kind of a throw out the game thing for the Jets.
41:39I think that overall, again, if you listen back to our preseason show, I think neither of us had very high expectations
41:47for early season Sadiq, given he had the offseason kind of cleanup procedure or whatever it was on the hernia issue, given
41:55he was already a really young, really developmental prospect.
41:58So the fact that we got the week three game that we got was over and above my expectations.
42:05As frustrating as the week four letdown was, it doesn't come anywhere close to dampening the enthusiasm that we got from week three.
42:13So yeah, Arrow is very firmly up on Sadiq compared to where we were at preseason.
42:19Omar Cooper has been on IR since week one.
42:22So not a whole lot to say there. Yeah.
42:25Yeah, I mean, I guess the only thing you'd say is that in the very tiny bit of time that we saw
42:33him, I thought he looked really quite impressive, actually.
42:36And then the only thing that's frustrating is that with Sadiq looking as effective as he is, and we know Garrett Wilson's
42:44a massive alpha, it's just going to be hard for him.
42:48It's going to be hard for both Cooper and Sadiq to be major hits long term.
42:53And so I think it is a negative that we're sort of seeing Sadiq hit the upper end of his range of
43:01outcomes so far, but certainly nothing negative from Cooper himself other than the injury.
43:06Yep. Yep. So yeah, that will be intriguing to watch whenever he returns, how that breaks down for the two of them.
43:14But yeah, I don't think you can really move sentiments on Cooper a ton.
43:19And then we had these two wide receivers that would go in the early second round of every rookie draft.
43:26It was Jeremy Bernard and Antonio Williams. Before the season, both of us were, I would say, optimistic on the idea that
43:34Bernard could be playing a lot early in the season.
43:37And we were very curious whether he would be just playing an 11 personnel.
43:42That hasn't really happened so far. Roman Wilson is up at a 59% route share to Jeremy Bernard's 37% this year.
43:50Bernard barely flipped him in week four usage, 42% to 38% of the routes.
43:54But Bernard's been clearly less productive. He is fifth on the team in targets per outrun behind Metcalf, both of the tight ends.
44:03Roman Wilson himself. I was curious if Roman Wilson would get completely shadow-realmed after that drop he had in week three, as
44:10Aaron Rodgers has been known to do. But he has, at least for now, been kind of a sticky part of this Steelers offense.
44:19And I do think that's maybe worth looking at Bernard as a prospect that I don't know that either of us really saw as very high ceiling.
44:28I think a lot of the hope for him going in the early second of rookie drafts was he could be, he
44:36was one of the better bets to play early.
44:39That hasn't happened. So, yeah, is it fair to panic on Bernard or to lower your estimation of him?
44:46I don't know that anybody's buying Jeremy Bernard or that there's an actionable way to deal with this if he's on your roster.
44:54But, yeah, where are you at on Jeremy Bernard?
44:57He's had some good moments. I mean, he flashed a bit in that Patriots game when Pittman missed.
45:04I think, honestly, their best three wide receiver set would be Metcalf, Bernard, and Wilson.
45:09Pittman's giving them completely nothing at all. I assume they're just going to keep trotting him out there every week to do nothing.
45:17But I just assume he's got that veteran status, I guess, even on a new team.
45:23We'll see. I don't have much of an opinion on Bernard.
45:27He... It's been lower... It's been less involved than I expect, for sure.
45:31I would have thought he would have passed Roman Wilson by now.
45:36But I don't know that I've seen anything so terrible to write him off completely.
45:41I would be surprised if this guy's a star.
45:44I'll say that. I was already pretty surprised. Would I be that surprised if this guy became a wide receiver three?
45:52No. Yeah. Agreed. And then on the opposite side of this coin, going into the season, you and I were more negative
45:59or more skeptical on whether Antonio Williams would see much action early in the year.
46:05The reports out of camp were not super great.
46:08Our vibes at the time were very much that he may not be a factor much at all in the first half of the season.
46:17That hasn't been the case. Antonio Williams has had some great moments.
46:21He's leading the team in yards per outrun right now.
46:25He played a real full-time role in week four with Terry McLaurin out.
46:29Played ahead of Trail on Burks, ahead of Diami Brown.
46:33Was able to command the second most targets on the team behind Stefan Diggs.
46:38Jaden Daniels is expected back in week five. I think this is pretty exciting.
46:43I don't know exactly how it happens, whether it's McLaurin or Diggs missing more time or Williams just continuing to force his way onto the field in 11.
46:53But he's probably one of the bigger risers for me after four weeks.
46:57I'm curious how you see it, Jacob. For sure.
47:00Yeah. Super encouraging. Really encouraging week four game. Obviously, he had to play with our guy, Tzatziki Suvlaki, a quarterback.
47:07So it was tough for him to be able to put up a ton of stats.
47:13He did have an 87-yard touchdown callback on an illegal shift that didn't impact the play.
47:19I think there was also a holding like 50 yards downfield that maybe did impact the play a little bit more.
47:26But either way, I've been really impressed with Antonio Williams.
47:30He's lined up inside. He's lined up outside. He ran, I think it was 74% of the routes or 73% of the routes, depending on last week.
47:39He ran one less route than Stefan Diggs anyway.
47:42He was almost at a team high in routes.
47:46So I think it's super encouraging. I expect some level of continued rotation, but I think that they are starting to understand
47:53that he is one of their best three wide receivers.
47:57And he's made a lot of really impressive plays to me.
48:01So I'm a fan of Antonio Williams. It's, I think, a really great long-term spot where even if he doesn't provide a
48:09ton of startable value this year, he's going to show enough flashes.
48:13And he's already shown a lot of flashes that with two older wide receivers ahead of him that are not that long
48:21for the team, you can really start to dream on a path for him over the short to long term.
48:28And this is a guy who had the type of value that we weren't really requiring more than flashes from in year one.
48:36So I think there's outs to him being startable in seasonal leagues with Jaden Daniels back, especially with Terry McLaurin out.
48:43I wouldn't be surprised if he has a nice week this upcoming week.
48:48And I've definitely seen enough flashes to be locked in in Dynasty.
48:52So yeah, very encouraged by Antonio. Great. Those were the main guys that I wanted to cover.
48:58We had a few other guys we could sort of quick hit on.
49:03I had two more categories in our preseason show.
49:06The first was just kind of a calendar reminder to say, has the Dynasty community forgotten about these players?
49:13Does it make sense to try to go out and buy low?
49:17Maybe because of anything that's happened indirectly with these teams or the players.
49:22The first name on this list was Dijon Stribling.
49:25Not a whole lot else to say on there outside of our discussion that we had after week one.
49:31Unless there's anything else you want to add on Dijon Stribling, Jacob?
49:36No. Is it someone you're looking at? Yeah. We just didn't get enough information, right?
49:41I mean, like, we got to see him play for a quarter and a half.
49:46He, like, ran a bunch of routes. That's good.
49:50Didn't get targeted on any of the routes. That's bad.
49:53It's not, like, so bad that we can be certain he will never get targeted on another route.
49:59It was a quarter and a half. Yeah, I'm guessing your opinion on Dijon Stribling right now probably is pretty tied to
50:07what your opinion was on him as a prospect and how swayed you were by offseason reports.
50:13There's just nothing we've seen this season that would push you much in either direction.
50:19I'm curious to see if he gets back this season and what he does.
50:24Because if we see very little of him for the rest of this season, you know, on a team where the leading
50:31receivers ahead of him are a very old Mike Evans and a very old Deebo Samuel and a very hurt Ricky Pearsall,
50:39I imagine he will be just as big of a topic all of next offseason.
50:44And I guess it would just be nice if we could have, like, a few games of him playing healthy in the
50:52NFL to talk about instead of only having to talk about four months of preseason hype, draft capital, and then another eight
51:00months of offseason conversations about Dijon Stribling. You make such a great point here by even by bringing up Ricky Pearsall as
51:08well, because I just see this playing out for me in the exact same way where I have been very low on
51:16Ricky Pearsall relative to other people at points in his career.
51:19I have been Ricky Pearsall curious at points in his career when people haven't seemed to care or consider like, hey, this
51:27could just be the guy that walks into the number one role for the 49ers.
51:33I know after or as Jawan Jennings was potentially leaving, that was something in my mind.
51:38I would take a similar approach with Dijon Stribling.
51:41I don't feel any particular type of way about how talented he is.
51:46I do feel a particular type of way about how Kyle Shanahan can scheme targets to literally almost whoever he wants.
51:53And if there's ever a 410 and one game from Christian Kirk this year saying that.
51:59Oh, yeah, we are happening. Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah.
52:02So, yeah, if there ever comes a point when that I feel that's not priced into Dijon Stribling, then maybe I'll become a booster or an advocate.
52:12I would imagine that that won't be over the next eight months.
52:16But yeah, we'll have to see. The other player in the has the community forgotten about him category is Eli Stowers.
52:24I have nothing to really say here. Do you, Jacob?
52:27We can move to the next guy. It's been as bad of a start as you could possibly imagine.
52:34Yeah. I'd imagine that's priced in. Yep. And then I think maybe the most interesting name here when this calendar reminder pinged
52:42on my computer today is Ty Simpson. And that's because per Brett Whitefield, our film guy at Fantasy Points, Matt Stafford's arm
52:49looks much worse relative to last year. By the data, he ranks 28th of 32 quarterbacks in accurate throw rate on throws of 20 or more yards downfield.
52:59Right now, he has the highest check down rate that Matthew Stafford has ever had over at least the past five years.
53:07And I would be willing to bet over probably the previous 10 years as well.
53:12I'm not saying Ty Simpson's going to matter this year or anything even approaching that.
53:18I don't think the Rams ever go away from Stafford or anything ridiculous like that.
53:23But in terms of the odds of Stafford retiring next offseason or the Rams moving on or having some other plan, I
53:31think that's higher than I would have guessed it would have been before the season started.
53:36So I do think that's notable for a player like Ty Simpson where there's been no kind of direct news.
53:44And it can very easily be a player on a contender's taxi squad that they are not getting any points out of right now.
53:52I think that's worth looking into. Do you have anything to add on that, Jacob?
53:57I got nothing on Simpson. Yeah, he's a black box.
54:01He's going to kind of remain that for me.
54:04But I think that he remains a fun piece to target in trades for exactly the reason you said.
54:11He can be kind of the closest thing to a first round pick for some teams that might not have one or might not want to trade one.
54:21All right. And our final category that we had going into the season, the big question that we had about these two
54:28players was simply how good do these players teammates that are ahead of him on the depth chart?
54:35Look, the first name on that list was Nick Singleton.
54:38I'm not sure I have a ton on Titans running backs.
54:42It's kind of been the same where Tony Pollard, I think, is playing decently relative to what the offense is giving him, which is not very much.
54:52Tajay Spears is continually on the injury report as he always kind of seems to be.
54:58I don't know that there's any movement on Singleton.
55:01But for Jonah Coleman, I think there has been serious movement, as we've discussed on this show in the past.
55:08But just to bring it home again and really hit this point that I think is important.
55:14The two questions we had were, does RJ Harvey look like a better runner than last year?
55:20I would say that that's hard to evaluate, given he's only been given 12 carries.
55:25Yeah. But that in itself kind of is an answer to that question, I would say.
55:31And the other question was, does Dobbins still look explosive?
55:34I would say no to that. I am curious to hear your thoughts, Jacob.
55:39But yeah, give me your full Broncos backfield outlook right now.
55:43No. So Dobbins, I think, is a fully unwashed watch for me.
55:47He still looks totally fine if he's just running between the tackles.
55:52He still has the vision, the patience, all of those subtleties, all those skills he still has in spades.
55:58But anytime he's asked to completely shift direction, there's been multiple plays where he tried to make a cut to the outside.
56:06But I was like, oh, this is going to go well.
56:10And then it didn't go well because he just doesn't have the foot speed anymore.
56:15To be able to accomplish that. Even just some jump cuts and stuff.
56:20The suddenness is really reduced for J.K. Dobbins compared to what we're used to seeing.
56:25So I think the stock is way down on Dobbins.
56:29Even though you mentioned he only has 12 carries, I will say that he missed one of the games.
56:36And then he missed parts of another game. And the two games that he played in full were games that basically trailed the whole time.
56:44So there hasn't really been a lot of opportunities for carries.
56:48And he has been playing more or less at an even split on early downs with J.K.
56:54Dobbins this year. Like they typically rotate who starts which drive.
56:58And they typically relieve each other if a drive is successful enough to carry on past a series or two.
57:05That's not how it was last year. Last year was just predominantly Dobbins starting almost every drive.
57:11And Harvey was playing kind of a specific gadget play role.
57:15Like the way I described it in the column today was it's less that they're using Harvey on pass plays and using Dobbins on run plays.
57:24But more that they're just alternating the entirety of what their offense is depending on what running back is in the game.
57:32Like when Dobbins is in the game, it's like we're bringing in our extra tight end and we're going to run the ball.
57:40We're going to establish it. And then as soon as Harvey comes in the game, it's like now we're playing like air raid spread ball.
57:49And it's really incoherent and it's really bizarre. They're not married together.
57:53Anyways, Harvey as he looks as a player, he looks great to me in space.
57:59Like awesome. Like he is doing God's work trying to turn these Bonix checkdowns from two yard plays into seven yard plays.
58:07I mean the contact balance is ridiculous. Some of these, he looks fast, he's explosive, like all that stuff.
58:13He looked mostly like that last year. So it's not like we're seeing a massively different player.
58:19We're just kind of seeing the same really talented but kind of flawed player get better usage.
58:25My guess is that he's going to remain in largely this role because I think a lot of what Dobbins lacks can
58:33be made up for by Jonah Coleman both this year and next.
58:37I guess the big thing for Harvey is, is Bo Nix going to play like this all year?
58:44Like because it's not like, so Harvey's getting some designs, touches and stuff.
58:48A lot of the Harvey, he got 10 catches this week and a lot of them were just Bo Nix taking checkdowns that he shouldn't.
58:57Like there were open receivers down there. Bo Nix is just, Derek Klosson referred it to as performatively going through progressions where
59:05he's just like, oh look, it's over there. Anyway, I'm going to check it down.
59:10It's like, you already decided to check it down.
59:13The guy you looked at was open. You just wanted to check it down.
59:18So there was, anyway, Bo Nix is driving me crazy.
59:22RJ Harvey's leading the team in target share. It's good for RJ Harvey.
59:27He's doing his best to make it good for the Broncos.
59:30He's still not fully succeeding, but he's kind of like the only bright spot of this offense right now.
59:37So I think it's been arrow up, but like, I don't know that it's actually that sustainable into being more than a low end RB2.
59:46Yeah, that's how I've kind of covered and written Harvey up for the past two weeks as well is the usage in
59:54theory is great that he is leading all running backs in target share right now, leading his team in target share.
60:01He's 0.3 receiving yards per game behind Pat Bryant for the team high in receiving yards per game, which is absurd, especially
60:09considering he's averaging like a negative three a dot.
60:12It's just all him trying to do it by himself from behind the line of scrimmage.
60:18But yeah, that is a symptom of a deeply broken offense, or at least of an offense that is is likely not
60:26going to have that much success doing only that.
60:29So it is tough. I'm I'm am of two minds on it.
60:33We could see a play caller change here. I'm not ready to write the book on the Broncos offense.
60:40But yeah, I do think more importantly, Dobbins has left an opening for Coleman to come and make an impact.
60:47I as soon as he comes off of IR.
60:50So that's going to do it on our rookie review here.
60:54This has been very informative. Hopefully all of you found this useful, got a nice expectation reset now that we are into October.
61:02Make sure that if you haven't checked it out, you go watch our live stream from last night where we went over
61:10some of the veterans that we are buying and selling and have stock up and down on after week four.
61:17It was a lot of fun. It will be a lot of fun.
61:22We're about to go do it right now after we finish this.
61:26So stick with us on Dynasty Points and have an amazing rest of your week.
61:31We'll see you next time. Kapitalanlagen bergen Risiken.