Source + player page
Mattek Fantasy Football fantasy football takes on Jonathan Taylor
Every source-backed video insight STACKED has extracted from Mattek Fantasy Football about Jonathan Taylor.
42
Insights
20
Positive
13
Negative
Insight ledger
All Mattek Fantasy Football insights about Jonathan Taylor
NegativeProjectionNov 13, 2026
Drake May notes that Jonathan Taylor "can absolutely shove this week" against the Dolphins, who are "absolutely pathetic." Taylor could have 28 rushes, 200 yards, and three touchdowns given his talent level. However, May cautions that the floor is "so low in these situations" because the Indianapolis Colts are a bad team with no talented offensive players. This mirrors the Tyler Warren situation—high ceiling but low floor due to team dysfunction.NegativeProjectionNov 6, 2026
Ranked 19th by the source, who is the lowest on Taylor among analysts. Taylor presents a binary outcome: either a top-five running back (22 rushes, 130 yards, 2 TDs) or nearly unplayable. Trade rumors are heavy—Adam Schefter, Rapsheet, Jeremy Fowler, and James Palmer have all reported teams trying to acquire him, and prediction markets heavily favor him being traded. Recent workload has been limited (18 rushes, then 8 rushes; the 18 was his second-fewest of the season), which concerns the source about his pace to get normal volume. The Cowboys matchup offers some upside (they gave up 36 points to Tyler Algier and a career game to Bucky Irving), but the source is conflicted and uncertain whether to move him up. The source notes significant ambiguity around Taylor's usage and would welcome an Adam Schefter Sunday morning tweet confirming the Colts plan to give Taylor a real farewell with as many touches as he can handle in his final game for Indianapolis.NegativeProjectionNov 4, 2026
Ranked RB 10 rest of season; likely trade candidate; if traded, will face playbook learning curve and potential game-or-two of reduced production; if not traded, remains on one of the worst teams in the NFL; Denver trade scenario is ideal but complicated by existing backfield depth (Jonah Coleman, JK Dobbins, Tyler Bedet, R.J. Harvey); Sean Payton's history of timesharing elite backs (e.g., Alvin Kamara) suggests Taylor may not receive full workload even in Denver; Taylor's lack of elite receiving production further limits upside.NegativeDepth ChartNov 3, 2026
The overwhelming favorite to be traded before the deadline, with Denver Broncos and New York Giants reported as interested teams. Antonio Williams personally expects Taylor will not remain an Indianapolis Colt after the trade deadline, making his fantasy value highly uncertain and dependent on trade destination.NegativeRoleNov 2, 2026
Taylor handled only 4 targets and 8 carries in what the source characterizes as likely his final game as an Indianapolis Colt. The source expresses confusion about why Taylor played at all, suggesting he may be traded before the deadline.PositiveMatchupOct 31, 2026
R.J. Harvey identified five potential trade landing spots for Jonathan Taylor, ranked by fit. Cincinnati Bengals top the list with a Super Bowl-quality offense and improved defense but no ground game efficiency, making Taylor a high-impact fit. Minnesota Vikings (6-0) rank second with fewer than 10 offensive touchdowns and desperate need for rushing game juice, positioning Taylor as a high-volume option. Green Bay Packers rank third with the lowest team rushing yards since 1943 in the NFL, creating elite volume opportunity in a high-powered offense. Denver Broncos rank fourth, where Taylor would operate as the lead back with R.J. Harvey and Jonathan Coleman in reserve roles, backed by a great offensive line to pile up fantasy numbers. Seattle Seahawks rank fifth and least favorable—Harvey questions the logic of trading for Taylor after the Seahawks let Kenneth Walker walk and used a first-round pick on Judarian Price, suggesting organizational misalignment and reduced opportunity.NegativeMatchupOct 30, 2026
Ranked 16th for Week 8 but faces insanely tough matchup against Jacksonville, which has the best EPA per rush defense in the NFL. Snap share and touches were reduced last week (71% snaps, 18 rushes). Additional concerns include Colts losing an offensive lineman and Daniel Jones being a bottom-five quarterback in EPA per play. Trade rumors to Vikings are heating up, though source estimates less than 50% probability. Despite these headwinds, source implies Taylor is a must-start: "I don't think you have any choice here."NegativeDepth ChartOct 27, 2026
Ranked in A tier but faces uncertainty due to potential trade deadline movement. The source estimates 15-25% probability Taylor is traded before the deadline, with possible destinations including Minnesota Vikings, Seattle Seahawks, or remaining with Indianapolis Colts. If traded to a team with better offensive situation, Taylor could land in a significantly improved scenario.NegativeDepth ChartOct 27, 2026
The Colts are actively seeking to trade Taylor as part of a massive rebuild and are starting over from scratch. The source reports that Schefter and other insiders have confirmed the Colts are taking calls and would like to trade Taylor; the source estimates they would accept a second-round pick plus a good day-three pick, or a first-round pick overall. Taylor's imminent departure directly threatens his fantasy value and playing time.NegativeRoleOct 26, 2026
Jonathan Taylor had 18 carries in the Colts game, but the source believes the Colts are actively shopping him and would trade him for a first-round pick as part of a rebuild. Seth McGawan's 11 carries on 20 of 61 snaps is being positioned as an audition to signal to the league that the Colts are open to trading Taylor.NegativeMatchupOct 24, 2026
Ranked #8 running back for Week 7 but faces a terrible matchup against the Minnesota Vikings, who have the most stingy run defense in the NFL.NegativeMatchupOct 22, 2026
Ranked 15th in week 7 flex rankings. The source characterizes this as a nightmare matchup with the Colts facing a 17-point team total and the Vikings being the best run defense in the NFL, with only Jacksonville close to them in yards per play allowed: 'Man, this is a nightmare spot. 17 and 12 point team total. The Vikings have been the best run defense in the NFL.'PositiveProjectionOct 21, 2026
Jonathan Taylor is ranked A-tier in rest-of-season rankings and is averaging over 19 points per game, per Mattek Fantasy Football's top 100 rest-of-season rankings.PositiveProjectionOct 16, 2026
Ranked fifth among running backs for Week 6; tier-one caliber player with no debate.NegativeProjectionOct 13, 2026
Ranked 10th in rest-of-season rankings. Taylor has been inconsistent due to poor quarterback play, scoring 9 points against Houston and 11 against Pittsburgh. The source notes he is very touchdown-dependent, but emphasizes that touchdown dependency is not necessarily a weakness since touchdowns are the primary driver of fantasy football value.NegativeUsageOct 9, 2026
Despite losing some drives to Seth McGowan and playing only 71% of snaps last week, Taylor remains an A-tier start due to his consistent touchdown production.PositiveUsageSep 24, 2026
Despite a difficult matchup against the Texans, Mattek advises starting Jonathan Taylor because of his high volume, 27 PPR points per game, goal-line role, and increased passing game involvement.PositiveValueSep 18, 2026
Mattek Fantasy Football prefers Jonathan Taylor over the package of Jeremiah Love and Chris Avery, using the philosophy of preferring one premium asset over multiple lower-tier pieces; Taylor is ranked ahead of Love in the trade evaluation.PositiveProjectionSep 17, 2026
Ranked #10 overall flex player against Kansas City Chiefs.NegativeProjectionSep 10, 2026
Jonathan Taylor was selected 1.05 overall in this championship draft, establishing him as the fifth overall pick in this draft room. Jonathan Taylor was selected fifth overall in this high-stakes $500,000 grand prize fantasy draft, reflecting elite tier ranking and draft capital allocation.PositiveProjectionSep 9, 2026
Ranked in S tier for Week 1 flex starts; the source projects all S-tier players to finish top 15 PPR points this week.NegativeRoleSep 6, 2026
Rostered in the source's Kansas City home league as a running back option.PositiveValueAug 28, 2026
The source considers a Jonathan Taylor and Kenneth Walker III starting duo to be a beautiful and elite way to begin a fantasy draft. While the source notes Taylor was considered a potential trade candidate following the draft, the initial outlook remains highly optimistic.PositiveProjectionAug 18, 2026
The source highlights Jonathan Taylor as a high-upside RB1 candidate, citing his historical pace of 27 points per game through week 10 of his previous season as evidence of his elite ceiling.NegativeRoleAug 14, 2026
Classified as an anchor running back with a projected 64% carry share in his offense.PositiveValueAug 7, 2026
Multiple elite players drafted ahead of him in this league, including Anthony Gentry at nine, which the speaker views as a draft error. Speaker would not take Chase Brown over Jonathan Taylor, suggesting Taylor should be ranked higher than his current draft position in this format.PositiveInjuryJul 2, 2026
Has missed 18% of his career games with injury, which could create opportunity for DJ Giddens in the Colts backfield.PositiveValueJul 1, 2026
Taylor is mentioned as a potential first-round pick the analyst might not prioritize in best ball formats, though he values running backs from the left side of the board in redraft.NegativeUsageMay 29, 2026
The Eagles reduced Daniel Jones' rushing production and goal-line opportunities in 2025 to prioritize Jonathan Taylor's offensive player of the year candidacy, indicating a shift in offensive role allocation.NegativeValueNo date
Ranked 24th overall against the Miami Dolphins by Fernando Mendoza and would rank even lower against any other opponent. Mendoza notes the Indianapolis Colts are arguably worse than the Los Angeles Chargers, with a depleted receiving corps (Laquan Treadwell, Ashton Doulan, Dion Burks), Daniel Jones 'playing the worst football of his career,' and Seth McGawan receiving 30% of backfield touches. Mendoza argues the Colts are a 'zombie football team' with no playoff implications and no incentive to increase Taylor's workload; he would trade Taylor at 75 cents on the dollar. However, he acknowledges Taylor likely cannot be benched in most leagues and could still have a huge game; his expectation is that Taylor and the entire Colts offense 'are probably going to be bad' with a 20.5-point implied team total and the Dolphins set up to 'squeeze the life out of you.'NegativeProjectionNo date
Ranked 11th in rest-of-season running back rankings, but the source acknowledges there is an argument he should be ranked much lower. Described as basically an explosive Elijah Gordon now with no passing game usage on a poor Colts team; last top-10 week at RB was week 6 against Tennessee; only notable game was week 2 vs Kansas City. The source would trade him at 75 cents on the dollar and notes this could easily be a bad ranking; co-the source Zack has him at 34. Injury shutdown risk is elevated given the team's lack of playoff contention.NegativeProjectionNo date
Brutal performance with negative 4.6 expected fantasy points on 13 carries for 21 yards; McGawan played 20 snaps to Taylor's 44. The Colts offense is terrible with a bad offensive line, bad quarterback play, and poor coaching, making Taylor a candidate for trade. Chase Brown wants Taylor owners to get an Adam Schefter notification of a trade to the Vikings, Giants, or anywhere else because the Colts are heading toward Los Angeles Chargers territory where even good fantasy results won't feel good to start.PositiveProjectionNo date
Ranked A tier by Mattek Fantasy Football, indicating strong fantasy projection and matchup quality.PositiveRoleNo date
Jonathan Taylor is the primary red-zone back for the Colts, handling goal-line and red-zone carries alongside Tyler Warren, limiting Josh Downs' touchdown upside in the end zone.PositiveProjectionNo date
A-tier RB1 against Washington Commanders; clear top-tier running back in fantasy football with no concerns.PositiveProjectionNo date
Ranked 9th overall as a clear fantasy starter against the Commanders.PositiveProjectionNo date
Ranked 10th in rest-of-season rankings with 21.2 PPR points per game average; the source notes the Colts' offense has been better than expected and expects Taylor to continue performing well despite non-ideal pass-catching usage.PositiveValueNo date
Jonathan Taylor's availability in the second round last year is cited as an example of the market overreacting to injury concerns.NegativeInjuryNo date
Rico Dael highlights Jonathan Taylor's injury history, noting he has missed at least two games every year of his career until last season, which increases the value of his backup.PositiveProjectionNo date
Ranked #8 overall in McCaffrey's top 100 fantasy football players. McCaffrey considered moving him behind CeeDee Lamb and Justin Jefferson but ultimately kept him at #8. Reports on Daniel Jones's Achilles injury have been quite good. Adding Keenan Allen and playing him instead of Nick Westbrook-Keen is expected to make the Indianapolis Colts marginally better on offense. After week 8 of last season, Taylor was on pace to have the best fantasy football season for any running back since LaDainian Tomlinson, with carries of 29, 32, 14, 31, 23, 34, 37.PositiveValueNo date
Aj Brown took Jonathan Taylor at pick 1.7 as the anchor of his team after calculating that the wall of elite running backs (Gentry, Chase Brown, Walker, Hampton, Barkley) would be unavailable by his turn; Taylor represents the best available running back value at that draft position. Selected as starting running back in week-one lineup.NegativeBustNo date
Jonathan Taylor's first-round ADP is inflated relative to peers like Christian McCaffrey, Amon-Ra St. Brown, and Justin Jefferson. His back-half decline was severe when quarterback play deteriorated (Daniel Jones injured, Philip Rivers). After a 50-point game vs. Atlanta, he had only one more RB1 finish (17 points vs. Jacksonville in week 17). With uncertainty around Daniel Jones's return from Achilles injury and concerns that Shane Steichen's offensive scheme may regress, Taylor is projected closer to 13–17 fantasy points per game rather than his 2025 peak, making him safer to let others draft in round 1.