Dynasty Contenders vs. Rebuilders: The BEST Trades to Make Right Now (Ep. 2262)

Recommended as a gettable super flex option for contenders, particularly if on a non-contending team; Rodgers should be available at a discount compared to Stafford because he only has one year left after this season, making him less valuable long-term but still useful for immediate contention windows.

Bogman considers Rodgers a viable QB2 option in super flex if the acquisition cost is low (e.g., fourth-round pick), making him the cheaper alternative to Stafford. However, there is skepticism about Rodgers' retirement timeline; while he says this is his final year, he made the same claim last year and returned, so his stated intentions are not fully trusted. The assessment is that he 'looks pretty done' and should be assumed to be retiring after this season, but with caveats about his credibility.

Fitz identifies Brock Bowers as one of the elite force-multiplier tight ends—alongside B.J. Robinson, Jameer Gibbs, JSN, and Josh Allen—that a real contender should have as a cornerstone of their title run.

Caleb Douglas is listed among young pass catchers, many of them rookies, who are not producing for their current teams and available as buy-low trade targets for rebuilders seeking to acquire youth at a discount.

Bell hasn't gotten anything straight yet and is cited as an example of a bench player in deep dynasty rosters who isn't contributing to a contender's immediate needs; however, he's specifically highlighted as a young player with room to grow and is used as an example of a lottery ticket that contenders can package with a lower pick (third or fourth round) to acquire veteran depth pieces, giving them two shots at replacing a traded player.

Mentioned as a lottery ticket example in dynasty trade discussions; represents the type of young unproven player that contenders might package with lower draft picks when trading for immediate help.

Chris Bell is listed among young pass catchers not producing for their current teams and available as a buy-low trade target for rebuilders; represents an opportunity to acquire youth at a discount by trading veterans to contending teams.

Fitz identifies Christian McCaffrey (age 30) as a 'useful geezer' with significant 2026 value but limited long-term value; he would trade a late first-round pick to acquire CMC as a contender, expecting his pick to be late given his contending status.

Jeremiah Smith values CMC at a late first-round pick for contenders, with potential to add a late third or young player with minimal 2026 value due to his pass-catching ability and remaining utility in 2026.

Bogman uses CMC as an example of a top-tier asset that rebuilding teams should hold and leverage aggressively in trades. If CMC is a rebuilder's last good player with minimal depth behind him, the rebuilder holds significant leverage and should squeeze maximum value from contenders, aiming to be overpaid rather than fairly compensated. The principle is that bottom-feeder teams should make contenders overpay for premium assets because staying healthy and competitive is difficult.

Bogman notes that David Montgomery has been awful and underperforming, highlighting the importance of having depth at running back; teams counting on Montgomery as RB2, flex, or occasional flex need backup options like Ollie Gordon to survive the season.

Fitz identifies Derrick Henry (age 32) as a 'useful geezer' with significant 2026 value but limited long-term value; he would trade a late first-round pick to acquire Henry as a contender, expecting his pick to be late given his contending status.

Jeremiah Smith identifies Henry as a high-value 2026 target for contenders despite his age (32); recommends trading a late first-round pick to acquire him, noting he still has significant value and hasn't indicated retirement plans, making him worth the premium cost.

Eli Stowers is listed among young tight ends available as buy-low trade targets for rebuilders; represents an opportunity to acquire youth at a discount.

Fitz identifies George Kittle (age 33) as a 'useful geezer' with significant 2026 value but limited long-term value; he is one of six players Fitz specifically targets for contenders seeking short-term production.

Jeremiah Smith values Kittle at a late second-round pick but notes contenders may need to add incentives to grease the deal; Kittle remains an important cog for the 49ers with potential for additional value beyond 2026, though rebuilding teams may be more willing to trade him.

Bob Bogman highlights Kittle's 2024 recovery and performance as evidence that veteran tight ends can outperform expectations; after a torn Achilles and team turnover, Kittle recovered faster than anticipated and led the league in tight end touchdowns, demonstrating durability and value beyond initial projections.

Isaac Tesla is described as just so interesting because of the physical traits; listed among young pass catchers available as buy-low trade targets for rebuilders, suggesting his athletic profile makes him an intriguing prospect despite current lack of production.

Bogman recommends trading J.K. Dobbins for minimal value ('for a song') in rebuilding scenarios. Dobbins currently has a nice role in Denver with Javonte Williams (Coleman) out, but his role is expected to diminish when Coleman returns, making him a short-term asset not worth holding. The underlying concern is job security and role instability rather than immediate performance.

Jadarian Price does not look like he will be very impactful in year one; listed as a running back available for trade by owners willing to part with him, suggesting limited immediate fantasy value despite being a draft pick.

Jordan Tyson is listed among young pass catchers who are not producing for their current teams and could be pried loose in trades by rebuilders targeting veterans; represents a buy-low opportunity for teams willing to trade for underperforming youth.

Fitz identifies Josh Allen as one of the elite force-multiplier quarterbacks—alongside B.J. Robinson, Jameer Gibbs, JSN, and Brock Bowers—that a real contender should have as a cornerstone of their title run.

Kenyon Sadiq is listed among young tight ends available as buy-low trade targets for rebuilders; represents an opportunity to acquire youth at a discount.

Makai Lemon is listed among young pass catchers not producing for their current teams and available as a buy-low trade target for rebuilders; represents an opportunity to acquire youth at a discount by trading veterans to contending teams.

Recommended as a super flex target for contenders; Stafford is signed through two more years and is more valuable and viable in fantasy than Aaron Rodgers; the source prefers spending up for Stafford over trying to get Rodgers cheaply because of the two-year window and superior fantasy production.

Bogman prefers Stafford over Aaron Rodgers for a QB2 in super flex because Stafford has two years of viability remaining, but the preference flips if the cost differential is significant (e.g., second-round pick for Stafford versus fourth-round for Rodgers); in that case, the cheaper asset makes more sense. However, there are concerns about Stafford's durability given serious back questions a year ago and the Rams' sub-.500 record this year, raising the possibility this could be his last year if the team falls short of expectations.

Fitz identifies Mike Evans (age 33) as a 'useful geezer' with significant 2026 value but limited long-term value; he is one of six players Fitz specifically targets for contenders seeking short-term production.

Jeremiah Smith values Evans at a late second-round pick for contenders seeking 2026 value; positioned alongside Adams as a veteran receiver option with limited long-term dynasty value but strong near-term utility.

Used as a cautionary example of a young player traded away by contenders who then breaks out; the source notes that trading away young unproven players like Washington with draft picks can backfire when the player becomes one of the best at their position, though the source acknowledges this risk is worth taking for immediate contention.

Bogman highlights Ollie Gordon as an example of unexpected depth that emerged from nowhere to provide insurance when primary running backs underperform, illustrating the value of having playable bench pieces for contenders.

Cooper is currently injured and cited as an example of a bench player in deep dynasty rosters who isn't contributing to a contender's immediate needs; mentioned as a potential trade piece that a contender could package with a lower pick to acquire veteran help.

O'Marion Hampton is described as a bad fit for the Mike McDaniel offense; the speaker has not given up on him and views it as a good time to buy him for a more useful piece, suggesting he's undervalued and available at a discount due to scheme mismatch rather than talent concerns.

Pearsall is currently injured and cited as an example of a bench player in deep dynasty rosters who isn't contributing to a contender's immediate needs; mentioned as a potential trade piece that a contender could package with a lower pick to acquire veteran help.

Ricky Pearsall is listed among young pass catchers available as buy-low trade targets for rebuilders; his inclusion is noted in context of being hurt, making him a potential acquisition for teams willing to wait for recovery.

RJ Harvey was grabbed off waivers at the end of last season and held value heading into this year despite not performing well this season; illustrates how end-of-season wire pickups can provide trade leverage in dynasty leagues, though his actual production has disappointed.

Terrence Ferguson is listed among young tight ends available as buy-low trade targets for rebuilders; represents an opportunity to acquire youth at a discount.

Fitz identifies Travis Kelce (age 37) as a 'useful geezer' with significant 2026 value but limited long-term value; he is one of six players Fitz specifically targets for contenders seeking short-term production.

Jeremiah Smith values Kelce at a late second-round pick for contenders but notes his retirement seems imminent at age 37, making him the only veteran in the group whose retirement timeline appears totally imminent; still worth acquiring for 2026 contention windows.

Jeremiah Smith recounts trading away McBride for minimal value when McBride was having a red shirt year with the Cardinals; the trade looks bad in hindsight, illustrating the risk of selling low on young players during down years in dynasty.