Dynasty Points artwork

Dynasty Startup Draft Strategy: 10 Tips to Win in 2026

STACKED extracted the fantasy-relevant player signal from this podcast and kept the full transcript here for context.

41 min
Duration
Estimated from transcript
Jul 1, 2026
Published
Wed, July 1, 2026
30
Player insights
16
Players mentioned
Topics
Christian McCaffreyChuba HubbardCourtland SuttonDrake LondonGarrett WilsonJahan DotsonJalen CokerJalen NailorMatthew GoldenNico CollinsRashod BatemanRhamondre StevensonTee HigginsTetairoa McMillan
Player analysis

Player insights

30

Ashton Jeanty

PositiveRole16:56

Jakob Sanderson identifies Ashton Jeanty as a tier-defining early running back in dynasty startup drafts; drafting early running backs outside of Jeanty, B.J. Robinson, and Jameer Gibbs in the first five or six rounds signals a year-one contending strategy, positioning Jeanty as a premium contending asset.

Insight page

Christian McCaffrey

NegativeProjection23:42

Jakob Sanderson references McCaffrey as an aging asset in dynasty startup strategy, suggesting that younger players should be acquired to provide value after McCaffrey's window of contention closes; this is part of a broader discussion about roster construction and managing the lifespan of elite players in dynasty leagues.

Insight page
PositiveRole33:22

Jakob Sanderson uses Christian McCaffrey as a concrete example of a high-scoring contending asset that immediately shifts draft dynamics in a startup. Tapping McCaffrey signals a year-one contention path and forces other managers to adjust their strategy accordingly. Sanderson cautions against over-committing to contention by taking too many aging stars like McCaffrey, noting that once you've secured top-tier contenders, diminishing returns set in and additional contending assets become less valuable than preserving future draft capital.

Insight page

Chuba Hubbard

PositiveValue30:00

Jakob Sanderson recommends Chuba Hubbard as a boring but valuable alternative to young unproven running backs in dynasty startup bench construction; Hubbard is the type of established player that a contending team might trade a future second for later in the season, making him a more tradeable asset than young players without clear upside paths.

Insight page
PositiveValue30:48

Jakob Sanderson recommends Chuba Hubbard as a boring veteran alternative to young unproven dynasty assets in startup bench construction. Hubbard is the type of older player that contending teams might trade for mid-season (e.g., for a future second), making him more valuable than young WRs like Jalen Coker who lack realistic upside scenarios. Sanderson groups him with Cortland Sutton as a preferred bench fill strategy over speculative youth.

Insight page

Courtland Sutton

PositiveValue30:00

Jakob Sanderson recommends Cortland Sutton as a boring but valuable alternative to young unproven wide receivers in dynasty startup bench construction; Sutton is the type of established player that a contending team might trade a future second for later in the season, making him a more tradeable asset than young players without clear upside paths.

Insight page
PositiveValue30:48

Jakob Sanderson recommends Cortland Sutton as a boring veteran alternative to young unproven dynasty assets in startup bench construction. Sutton is the type of older player that contending teams might trade for mid-season (e.g., for a future second), making him more valuable than young WRs like Jalen Coker who lack realistic upside scenarios. Sanderson groups him with Chuba Hubbard as a preferred bench fill strategy over speculative youth.

Insight page

Drake London

PositiveSleeper18:45

Jakob Sanderson cites Drake London as a historical example of a productive struggle asset in dynasty; London was priced up due to long-term talent indicators but did not immediately convert peripherals into fantasy points, making him a valuable acquisition for tanking teams willing to wait for future production.

Insight page
PositiveProjection30:45

Jakob Sanderson cites Drake London as a historical comparison for players with elite long-term talent but near-term production uncertainty; London exemplifies the productive struggle asset category where dynasty ADP prices in future value despite current-year production concerns.

Insight page

Garrett Wilson

PositiveSleeper18:30

Jakob Sanderson cites Garrett Wilson as a historical example of a productive struggle asset in dynasty; Wilson was priced up due to long-term talent indicators but did not immediately convert peripherals into fantasy points, making him a valuable acquisition for tanking teams willing to wait for future production.

Insight page
PositiveProjection30:40

Jakob Sanderson cites Garrett Wilson as a historical comparison for players with elite long-term talent but near-term production uncertainty; Wilson exemplifies the productive struggle asset category where dynasty ADP prices in future value despite current-year production concerns.

Insight page

Jahan Dotson

NegativeBust32:07

Jakob Sanderson cites Jahan Dotson as a cautionary example of a year-three wide receiver who received significant roster value in dynasty startups but whose theoretical upside slowly dissolved into nothing; Dotson exemplifies the trap of investing in young players without realistic value paths.

Insight page
NegativeBust32:07

Jakob Sanderson cites Jahan Dotson as a historical cautionary example of a year-3 wide receiver with theoretical upside that failed to deliver dynasty value. Dotson represents the trap of spending roster value on young players with multiple narrative paths to success who ultimately dissolve into nothing. Sanderson groups him with Rashad Bateman as examples to avoid repeating when evaluating similar bets on players like Jalen Coker.

Insight page

Jalen Coker

NegativeBust29:08

Jakob Sanderson warns against drafting Jalen Coker in dynasty startup bench spots despite acknowledging he is a fun player; Coker is on a rough offense and is clearly behind established alpha Tedaroa McMillan, making it very hard to create a realistic fantasy upside scenario where he becomes a wide receiver two or better; Sanderson explicitly states Coker is not a good bet for gaining future value on a tanking dynasty team's bench.

Insight page
NegativeBust29:12

Jakob Sanderson explicitly identifies Jalen Coker as a roster clogger trap in dynasty startup drafts, particularly for non-contending teams filling bench spots in rounds 8+. Despite acknowledging Coker as a fun player, Sanderson argues he lacks a realistic fantasy upside scenario because he plays on a rough offense and is clearly behind established alpha Tedaroa McMillan; the difficulty in creating a WR2-or-better outcome makes him a poor bench asset compared to boring veterans who contenders might trade for mid-season.

Insight page

Jalen Nailor

NegativeBust29:08

Jakob Sanderson groups Jalen Naylor with year-two and year-three wide receivers who lack encouraging per-route data and should be avoided in dynasty startup bench construction; these players are enticing because they're young but lack a realistic value upside scenario, making them roster cloggers that should be skipped in favor of more established players or pure rookies.

Insight page
NegativeBust29:16

Jakob Sanderson names Jalen Naylor as a young WR under 25-26 years old to avoid in dynasty startup bench construction; grouped with Coker as a roster clogger trap despite offseason buzz, Naylor lacks the per-route data or clear path to meaningful fantasy production that would justify roster space on a non-contending team.

Insight page

Malik Nabers

PositiveValue30:00

Jakob Sanderson highlights Nabers as a prime example of a productive struggle/tanking asset for dynasty startups; despite likely starting slow and potentially missing week one due to injury/production concerns, Sanderson recommends drafting him in the middle of round two as a significant discount on elite talent for teams pursuing a year-one tank strategy.

Insight page

Matthew Golden

NegativeBust30:00

Jakob Sanderson includes Matthew Golden in a group of year-two and year-three wide receivers who lack encouraging per-route data and should be avoided in dynasty startup bench construction; these players appear enticing as young dynasty assets but lack a realistic value upside scenario.

Insight page
NegativeBust30:27

Jakob Sanderson identifies Matthew Golden as an example of a year 2-3 wide receiver without encouraging per-route data to avoid in dynasty startup bench construction; Golden falls into the roster clogger category of young players who seem enticing but lack a realistic upside scenario and should be passed over for boring veterans or rookies.

Insight page

Nico Collins

PositiveProjection20:02

Thomas Tipple references Nico Collins as an example of a player whose scoring potential is so high that drafting him immediately shifts a startup draft's dynamics and team-building path toward contention; Collins is positioned as a player whose point-scoring ceiling forces strategic recalibration.

Insight page
PositiveRole33:22

Jakob Sanderson uses Nico Collins as a concrete example of a high-scoring contending asset that immediately shifts draft dynamics in a startup. Tapping Collins signals a year-one contention path and forces other managers to adjust their strategy accordingly.

Insight page

Rashod Bateman

NegativeBust32:07

Jakob Sanderson cites Rashad Bateman as a historical cautionary example of a year-3 wide receiver with theoretical upside that failed to deliver dynasty value. Bateman represents the trap of spending roster value on young players with multiple narrative paths to success who ultimately dissolve into nothing. Sanderson groups him with Jahan Dotson as examples to avoid repeating when evaluating similar bets on players like Jalen Coker.

Insight page
NegativeBust32:07

Jakob Sanderson cites Rashad Bateman as a cautionary example of a year-three wide receiver who received significant roster value in dynasty startups but whose theoretical upside slowly dissolved into nothing; Bateman exemplifies the trap of investing in young players without realistic value paths.

Insight page

Rhamondre Stevenson

PositiveValue33:00

Jakob Sanderson notes that Rhamondre Stevenson continuously gets pushed down and farther down on dynasty boards, but ends up being a value for those who can see it; Stevenson exemplifies a player where there is a realistic path to value if you can navigate the narrative street required to get him to where you need him to be.

Insight page
PositiveValue33:00

Jakob Sanderson cites Rhamondre Stevenson as an example of a narrative-dependent asset that gets continuously pushed down dynasty boards but can provide value for managers who can see past the narrative. Stevenson's value is dependent on understanding the narrative path to his upside, making him a contrarian value pick for those willing to bet against board consensus. Sanderson groups him with Rashad White as examples of undervalued assets.

Insight page

Tee Higgins

NegativeRole18:18

Jakob Sanderson references Tee Higgins (referred to as 'Tedaroa McMillan' in transcript, likely a transcription error for a similar player discussion) as an example of a productive struggle asset where peripherals are strong but the timeline for converting those into fantasy points is unclear due to environment concerns; positioned as a longer-term value play for tanking teams despite near-term production uncertainty.

Insight page
NegativeProjection30:26

Jakob Sanderson uses Tee Higgins (referenced as Tedaroa McMillan in the transcript) as an example of a player with strong peripheral indicators but unclear near-term production timeline; fits the productive struggle/tanking asset profile where long-term talent is evident but actual fantasy points may not materialize in year one due to environment/role uncertainty.

Insight page

Tetairoa McMillan

PositiveProjection30:00

Jakob Sanderson cites Tedaroa McMillan as an example of a player with strong peripheral indicators but unclear near-term production timeline; McMillan fits the productive struggle/tanking asset profile where long-term talent is evident but actual fantasy points may not materialize in year one due to environment/role uncertainty. McMillan is the established alpha wide receiver on his offense ahead of Jalen Coker.

Insight page
PositiveRole30:00

Jakob Sanderson identifies Tedaroa McMillan as an established alpha wide receiver, using him as the reason why Jalen Coker (who is behind McMillan on the same offense) is a poor dynasty bench asset; McMillan's established role and alpha status make him the clear target on his offense.

Insight page
Full transcript

Episode Transcript

379
0:00Meditieren, Yoga, Joggen, nichts entspannt mich! Echt? Mich entspannt meine Steuer total!
0:04Steuer? Wie Finanzamt? Die Steuererklärung? Ja, ich hab ganz locker über 1000 Euro Zugriff bekommen.
0:10Hast du geheime Connections oder Excel-Superkräfte? Nö, nur die Wieso-Steuer-App.
0:13Wow! Und das ist einfach? Klar, die macht fast alles automatisch.
0:17Ich fühl mich plötzlich so... entspannt! Hol dir dein Geld zurück!
0:21Abgabefrist 31. Juli. Was?! Schaffst du ganz entspannt mit Wieso-Steuer?
0:25Ach, ach ja. Easy Shoppen mit PayPal. Geht jetzt auch im Laden.
0:29Ob Späti oder Club, mit PayPal bezahlst du auch im Real Life.
0:33Einfach und sicher. Und in Restaurants und Bars gibt's sogar noch 5% Cashback, wenn du mit PayPal zahlst.
0:40Tab dir mehr mit PayPal. Alle Infos auf paypal.de 5% Cashback nur auf Einkäufe vor Ort in Restaurants und Bars in Deutschland bei kontaktloser Zahlung mit PayPal.
0:50Gültig vom 2. Juni bis 19. Juli 2026 für die ersten 850.000 berechtigten Kunden.
0:55Maximal 15 Euro Cashback pro Konto. Es gelten Bedingungen auf paypal.de.
0:594, 5, 8, 9, 8, 9, nee, 0, 1, 0, 1, 4, ach...
1:03Schluss mit dem ewigen Abtippen von Kartennummern. Dank Visa Click to Pay.
1:08Ohne 16-stellige Kartennummern einzugeben, Passwörter nachzuschlagen oder extra Apps herunterladen zu müssen.
1:12So kommst du beim Online-Shoppen direkt ans Ziel. Mach Online Bezahlen einfach, schnell, sicher.
1:17Mit Visa Click to Pay. Einfach beim nächsten Checkout auswählen.
1:21The most important thing when doing a startup is getting it right.
1:25Right off the bat, we have 10 tips for you to execute a near-perfect startup draft.
1:31Lock in with us. It's Dynasty Points and it starts right now.
1:35Hello, everybody. Welcome back. Thanks for joining us on Dynasty Points.
1:39Thomas Tipple here with Jakob Sanderson and Ryan Heath.
1:42Again, a little bit different video today. We have 10 tips from us to you for having a better Dynasty startup draft.
1:50The last thing you want to do is go into a startup draft cold, especially if you're new to the game, and learn things the hard way.
2:00We've done it. We're going to help you avoid it here with this episode.
2:05I want to kick things off right away, but before we go, leave a comment below when you're done watching this video.
2:13And let us know what you've learned when doing startups and what tips we might have missed for the next time we record a tips video.
2:22And of course, liking and subscribing helps us in more ways than we can count.
2:27I want to send this right away over to Jacob with your first tip for everybody.
2:33We have three categories. We're kicking this off with preparing for the draft.
2:38Yeah, this is a key one for me, and it's mapping out the tiers.
2:43And the tiers are going to be different depending on your settings, which we're going to get into a little bit later,
2:51depending on how many teams are in it and all of that.
2:55But I go through, I look at my rankings, and I try to note where the big cutoffs are in overall value and in each position.
3:04This is especially important if you're doing any sort of derby.
3:08There's a lot of startups that allow you to have a say in what your draft position is.
3:15And so trying to figure out what you think are the spots you want to be in or the spots you want to avoid is very important.
3:25And regardless, I think being proactive about where you expect the hotspots to be and where you expect the dropoffs to be
3:32at given positions, even in the third, fourth, fifth, sixth round, is hugely important because when that teardrop is about to hit, everyone can feel it.
3:42And it's really, really hard to make value trades.
3:45If there's a run on quarterback or wide receiver or running back or any position, you can start to sense in these
3:53startups that everyone is trying to trade up and nobody is trying to trade down.
3:58But if you have a plan beforehand where you know where these teardrops are going to hit, and in the first round,
4:06you make a little move up or a little move down, and you tack on that move in round four or round
4:14five that you think is going to position you ahead of a big teardrop, you can get that before everyone else is
4:22caught on that this is going to be an important area of the draft.
4:27So map out your rankings, take a look at the ADP, figure out the areas that you think you want to be
4:35drafting in more or less, depending on where you see value, and then try to work trades early in the draft to position you into those areas.
4:45I think a big part that a lot of fantasy managers are a little stubborn with too is finding more than one source for your ADP information.
4:54Do not find one and just stick to that.
4:58Broaden your horizon. There are a lot of other tools too that other managers might get a little snarky about.
5:05Say Keep Trade Cut, for example, is a great way to use rankings, compare them, and set yourself up with your own base tiers like Jacob just mentioned.
5:15Let's hear from Ryan. Yeah, so my biggest tip before a startup draft is you want to just consider who invited me to this draft.
5:24Based on that information, who am I likely drafting against?
5:28I don't just mean literally the person if you know them in real life.
5:33I'm more mean in terms of are they likely consuming Dynasty fantasy football content?
5:38What might that content be? If this is a co-worker that invites you and you're playing against a bunch of your co-workers,
5:46maybe the likelihood there is lower or at least that there will be a few people in the league that might listen
5:53to a couple different sources of content. Is this like a fantasy points listener league or is it just a league tied to a specific content site?
6:03With that in mind, yeah, it might be okay.
6:06The takes of this site or just this universe of people might be, yeah, more so affecting the ADP, affecting the valuations of different players.
6:15Is this a league that was started on Twitter?
6:19We always joke about the Twitter wide receiver boys.
6:22Is our wide receiver valuations going to be inflated?
6:25Our running back valuations going to be deflated? Because this league is very much in like the Dynasty Twitter bubble.
6:32These are just things that I want to be thinking about anytime someone invites me to a league.
6:39When Jacob invites me to a league, I'm like, all right, I'm probably playing against a bunch of thinking about thinking subscribers.
6:47I should keep that in mind in terms of when like very Jacob coded guys are going to go.
6:53So yeah, I think that goes for any league that involves a content creator or just in general, any league that involves one of your friends.
7:03If there's a specific creator that they've mentioned before that you know they listen to, it's good to just keep in mind
7:11what are the macro, what's the view on Dynasty Fantasy Football that these people might subscribe to based on any information you might have?
7:19You don't want to get deep into a draft or deep into a league and not know that you're going to get,
7:27well, Jacob has him ranked in X. So you want to know ahead of time like Ryan mentioned.
7:34And before you do any of that, the most important part is checking your settings before you get started, before you even
7:42pay your money, before you draft, take the time to actually read through bylaws, scoring settings, whether there's voting rules or what
7:50a veto process might be, which don't have those.
7:53You think you know now, but you don't. Too many people jump into drafts assuming the league is set up a certain
8:01way, especially when someone tells them, yeah, it's pretty standard.
8:04Then all of a sudden you realize there are five point bonuses for 40 yard plays or half point per carry or
8:12some setting you had no idea even existed. And it's not just scoring.
8:17You have to be aware of what can be changed by league vote.
8:22You might join a league thinking the settings are locked in.
8:26You don't have to worry about it in the future, only to have half of them voted on and changed before the season even gets going.
8:35At that point, that may not be a league for you.
8:39It's definitely not the league that you signed up for.
8:42Be smart with your money. I think it's important to realize that dynasty is still an investment.
8:49It's something that we should be taking care of and thinking about because people play with what they can at times.
8:56And you want to make sure the league is still right for you when the draft kicks off.
9:03You don't want to also go into a draft avoiding, say the quarterback position and not realizing that it's a six point passing touchdown lead.
9:12Or if you know it's a yards per carry league, you would need to know how to adjust your rankings and tiers
9:19like Jacob mentioned to adjust to the quarterbacks, adjust to the, well, whoever the new Debo Samuel is this year.
9:27Be ready and be prepared. And you can only do that by knowing the settings thoroughly.
9:32Settings, bylaws, and everything else required to start a dynasty league has to be done right at the beginning.
9:39And don't let anyone tell you that when the league's settings start changing, it's not okay to leave.
9:46You join the league with expectations. Play the league that you're comfortable in playing with and check those settings before getting things kicked off.
9:54Now that we have the intro to dynasty startups and kind of what to be prepared for, let's move into some general
10:02drafting tips because everybody drafts a little bit differently.
10:05And that's important to think about. Jacob, what do you want people to think about when they go into a startup draft?
10:13Yeah, that's a very good question. I think a key thing that I see people make mistakes of in both directions, and
10:21I'm going to try to thread the middle here, is I'm going to say, don't draft for your week one roster, but do understand your specific league economy.
10:31And so here's what I mean by that. When I say don't draft for your league economy, or when I say don't
10:39draft for your week one roster, what I mean is you're compiling assets and value in a startup draft.
10:46You can always make trades later. And so I would not ever feel in a startup draft that you have to take
10:54a specific position in a specific round because you're filling holes across your starting lineup.
10:59That's especially the case if you're drafting in June.
11:03You're going to have two months to do trades before your year even starts.
11:08And so if you see that there's clearly a value on a certain player that you have a full tier at everyone
11:16else, go ahead and take them and figure out some of the roster holes later.
11:21My caveat to that though, and this is where I say I understand your league economy, is that I will occasionally see some drafters get stubborn about this.
11:31Maybe you're a drafter that values quarterbacks much higher than the rest of your league or devalues running backs more than the rest of your league.
11:40If you want to play into that, that's fine.
11:44But you might need to then be in a mindset of, hey, I'm going to tank for a full year because I'm
11:52going to exploit what I think is a longer term value.
11:56You can't just expect that if you're not taking any quarterbacks because you think everyone's taking them too highly or you're taking
12:03six starting quarterbacks because you think everyone's valuing them too lowly that all of a sudden, a month later, everyone else in
12:11your league is going to completely change their mind and realize that you are right all along.
12:17You have to realize that if what you're doing is something exploitative, if you think everyone else is wrong and valuing a
12:25certain position, then you're still going to have to make trades within that economy.
12:30So basically what I would say is don't worry too much about taking advantage of your starting lineup.
12:37But if you think everybody else is wrong on a given position, be prepared to have to defend that bet for a
12:45very long time because I don't think everyone is just going to immediately go and trade back with you a week later because you hoarded all the quarterbacks.
12:55That leads me to my next point. And I couldn't have said it any better to kick off than you just did.
13:03Understanding the value is important because if you're going in and drafting those six quarterbacks thinking you can trade for them later,
13:11I have to tell you, do not just draft to trade later.
13:15When you're drafting, you have to prepare for 11 other people with completely different opinions, strategies, and values.
13:21No two drafts are ever the same. That's why ADP looks different everywhere.
13:26And the biggest thing to remember is that your value is not always their value.
13:32We are not all playing the same game. You might think you're making a smart move by loading up on a certain
13:39position because the quote value keeps falling to you.
13:43Maybe you take a third, even fourth quarterback early.
13:46Ugh, not me. And on paper, that value looks good.
13:50That player is just too good to pass up.
13:53And then when you turn around and try to trade that quarterback for what you believe he's worth and the rest of
14:01the league just shrugs, that's because from their perspective, if they wanted that player at that value, they could have just taken them themselves.
14:09That's where people get trapped, playing the value game.
14:13It can be a great strategy, but only if you understand the room.
14:17If you misread the league and misread who you're playing against, you can end up with a roster full of players you
14:25drafted to flip only to realize no one's interested in paying your price.
14:30And that is a cold, lonely tag to have slapped on your chest at the start of any league.
14:37Trades are not guaranteed, so draft players you're willing to live with, not just players you assume are going to want later.
14:45It's most often the person who thinks they're the smartest one in the room that gets left behind by an evolving draft economy.
14:53And you do not want to be that smartest person in the room.
14:57So my biggest tip during a draft is going to be a little bit separate from what these two just talked about.
15:05My biggest thing is, as you're making every pick, or before you make every pick, you should consider your path.
15:13What is your year one goal in this startup?
15:16And which side of the spectrum is every pick that you make pushing you toward?
15:21Just to kind of lay out the two possibilities, you can be a contender in year one.
15:27Self-explanatory enough, you're trying to win the league in year one.
15:31Or you can be a year one tanking type of build, a productive struggle, as some people call it, right?
15:38Where you are saying, okay, in year one, I'm not going to be competing, but I am making value bets across the
15:46board to put myself into a position to be a really strong contender one year from now, right?
15:53So after our next rookie draft, I'm going to push the chips in then.
15:58I think both are viable. I think you can succeed at doing either strategy, but you need to understand that every pick
16:06you make, depending on what type of player or asset you're picking up, is pushing your team more toward one end or the other.
16:14And I do think you want to, by the end of the draft at least, have a really good idea of what path you're on.
16:23I don't think you want to have a weird mix of contending assets and productive struggle or tanking value assets, because then
16:31you are not really in a good position to do either.
16:35I think you really ideally want to maximize kind of for one path or the other.
16:41Just to give like some concrete examples here, the types of picks that are going to push you more into a contending
16:49zone are going to be early running backs, especially I'd say outside of exactly B.
16:54John Robinson, Jameer Gibbs, Ashton Jinty. If you're drafting a running back anywhere within those first five or six rounds, that's a
17:02little bit of you saying, okay, I'm going to go score points.
17:07I'm going to try to win in year one because running back, yeah, just running back value is less stable from year to year in general.
17:16The time horizon is not as long. So that's one lever you can kind of pull.
17:22Another lever you can pull is just filling out a lineup for week one and just generally drafting older players that are
17:30priced more so downwardly compared to the amount of points they're going to score, right?
17:35Contending assets, older players that are going to score a lot of points.
17:40On the other end, productive struggle assets, tanking assets.
17:43These, of course, would be future draft picks that you can acquire in trade.
17:48That's something you should be trying to do if you are going the productive struggle route.
17:54Injured players or players with near-term production concerns, but longer-term like high-end talent indicators.
17:59Malik Neighbors is a really good example of that this year where, yeah, he's probably going to start slow, may not be
18:07on the field week one, but as we've talked about on a few of our different recent episodes, it could be a
18:14really good value for a tanking team this year to draft him in the middle of round two of a startup.
18:22That's like a pretty big discount on an elite talent.
18:26Somebody like a Tedaroa McMillan would fall into this camp for me where, yes, the peripherals are really amazing, but it's not
18:34super clear when those are going to turn into actual fantasy points based on his environment, right?
18:40I think Garrett Wilson was in this category for a lot of his career.
18:45Drake London was in this category for a lot of his career.
18:49In Dynasty, these assets are priced up because people, I think, correctly understand, yeah, there's some long-term stability here.
18:56This is a talented player that will score fantasy points at some undetermined point in the future, but it won't necessarily be this year.
19:04It can be really helpful to compare Dynasty and redraft ADP to kind of spot some of these guys.
19:11So yeah, just to review, with every pick you make, you want to understand, is this a contending pick or is this
19:19more of a year one tanking productive struggle type of pick?
19:23I think it's okay to pivot during a startup if you have the opportunity to pull a big trade that you're getting
19:31good value on that is letting you pivot from one path to the other, but you always just want to be aware of what your current path is.
19:41So yeah, that's my biggest thing. Just understand every asset is either going to be priced for this year or for future
19:49years and try to acquire those as efficiently as possible to serve your team's goal.
19:54Right. If you're doing your startup draft, it doesn't matter if you go super young in the first two rounds, as soon
20:02as you tap a player like Nico Collins or Christian McCaffrey because you just know they're going to score too many points,
20:10you've immediately and completely shifted the dynamics of your draft and understanding what that means for you will go a long way,
20:18especially if you're not drafting Christian McCaffrey because you know someone else in your league is going to love him more than you do now.
20:27So keeping all those things together in your mind is super important for a successful and true dynasty in every sense of the word.
20:36Now we've prepped you going in and we've given some of our tips on what to do when the draft really kicks
20:44off, but how do you structure your draft and think about structuring your team?
20:49This is usually something that takes multiple reps to get right and it is a constantly evolving conversation.
20:55The strategies from 10 years ago don't necessarily work as well today.
21:00Everyone's caught on to being tradeback demons and nobody wants to make a draft pick it feels like in the fourth round.
21:07So what do you do? How do you structure your draft?
21:11Jacob, what advice do you want to give people for setting up their structure in a better way?
21:18My take would be to be mindful of diminishing returns.
21:21So this is specifically, especially on contenders, but what I often see is Ryan just talked about it, choosing your path.
21:29I think that's very important. But I often see people take this to too far of an extreme where I see a
21:37team basically decide, you know, it's round one and they take B.
21:41John Robinson. So they're taking a running back. Round two, they come back and they take Christian McCaffrey.
21:48It's like, okay, I started running back, running back.
21:51One of them is old. So I'm now a contender and every single move that I make for the rest of the
21:59startup draft has to be now consistent with this path that I've chosen to an extreme degree to the point that I
22:07see teams saying, well, hey, I'm a contender. So that means now my 27 first, my 28 first, they're on the block.
22:15I can't consider any rookies or young players for the rest of the startup draft.
22:20And you end up seeing this team that has gone way too far than necessary in one direction where they have picked
22:2812 players in the first nine rounds because they're trading future picks and they're trading up and all of them are 28 or above.
22:37And you just don't need to do that. I talk all the time on this show and about my, on my sub
22:45stack about how your goal is to maximize the value of your team over time.
22:50And you're never going to do that if you're throwing away years of contention.
22:55That's the case if you're leaving yourself in a perpetual rebuild.
22:59That's also the case if you go all in on a really short window and then leave yourself with nothing at the end of it.
23:08Once you're already one of the best projecting teams in the league, each additional point is just not worth that much to you.
23:16No matter how hard you try, you can truly never build an unbeatable team in year one.
23:22So if you've already taken a Bijon and you've already taken a McCaffrey, maybe you've already traded away that first year's first.
23:30You probably have already done enough to boost yourself to the top of the rankings for this year.
23:37I would focus on the rest of the draft of just taking the best values available.
23:42If that means taking a few younger players who can actually be valuable assets for you after your Christian McCaffrey ages out, I think that's wise.
23:52If that means keeping some of your future picks, I think that's extremely wise.
23:57So you don't need your fourth player on the bench to be a 13 point per game starter.
24:03It would be a lot more valuable for that asset to instead be some picks so that you're not as far in
24:11the hole when your window of contention is up.
24:14I like that you mentioned trading your pick because I want to lean into that a little bit.
24:21I think you should be careful trading your draft picks in a startup, especially if you are not an experienced drafter.
24:28And I'll kind of tell you why. Before you start moving picks, you want to make sure you have as much information as possible in a startup draft.
24:39Your picks are your most valuable currency. Why? Everybody wants them for different reasons.
24:44Everyone assumes that they know what to do with them better than you do.
24:49They don't trust you as a manager, so they want to take advantage of that and sell your pick back to you
24:56at double the cost when that, oh no, I've made a mistake moment finally hits.
25:02But they give you flexibility. They give you options and they allow you to just adjust to how the draft unfolds.
25:09You can look like a contender after the first four rounds of your draft and by the time the draft is over,
25:17that same roster might be staring at a 103 in next year's rookie draft because things change fast.
25:24Players' values shift. Injuries happen. Role changes. A lot can happen before the season even kicks off.
25:30And don't even get me started on drafting based on the strength of schedule because we do not know enough at this point to do that.
25:39That's why giving away your most valuable asset way too early can really limit what you're able to do later.
25:46Now, of course, there are situations where a deal is simply too good to pass up.
25:52Jacob briefly touched on that in his point here, but that happens.
25:57But walking into a startup with the mindset of I'm just going to trade all my picks for players is not something I would recommend for most drafters.
26:07And that's especially true if you're not a hyperactive manager.
26:10Sometimes you're just not the trade guy when the league starts.
26:14Sometimes it just you don't have that chemistry with the league mates and not having your most important piece of ammunition is going to limit you.
26:23If you are not able to constantly be working trade markets, look, our close friend Tom Lee is the master of sending
26:3147 trades in every league on like every Wednesday when the end season.
26:36If you can't do that, if you are not hyperactive on trade markets, constantly checking values and staying ahead of the league
26:44curve, you can box yourself into a roster that looks good in the moment but gives you very little room to maneuver down the road.
26:53So value your picks. Be patient. Use them as leverage when necessary but do not be in a rush to just give
27:01them away because, well, the Rams do it. This is a very, very different game.
27:06I actually hate that quote. I hate the F them picks quote because it immediately leaked into Dynasty Leagues and I can
27:14tell you for the most part if you're an experienced drafter you can spot Norfolk coming before it happens and you do
27:22not want to be in that scenario not as a commissioner and certainly not as one of the other 11 players in the league.
27:31Ryan? So my biggest take on how to actually structure your Dynasty roster is going to be most relevant after round 8, round 9.
27:39Most teams have filled out or are about to finish filling out their starting lineups.
27:45We're kind of getting to that last flex to that first bench spot and onward, right?
27:51So everything I'm about to say is in respect to that part of a startup.
27:56I think the biggest mistake I see people making and that honestly the easiest kind of trap to fall into is taking
28:04the roster cloggers and what I mean by a roster clogger is especially if you are a team that's not a year
28:12one contender it is very easy to still at this later point in Dynasty Drafts look at the player list and mentally
28:20check off or cross out I should say anybody that's above a certain age, right?
28:25Oh, I'm not a contender I'm a future value team I need to keep taking young players and that's how you end up with the roster cloggers.
28:35It's how you end this is going to depend on your specific player takes but there's a certain point in Dynasty Drafts
28:43where the younger players who are not rookies are just bad bets overall, right?
28:48They're either bad bets or they have fairly low value ceiling outcomes even if maybe they're fun and kind of cool players
28:56to think about who could get better one day.
28:59A couple examples of this. I think it's really easy to fall into the trap with wide receivers under the age of 25 or 26.
29:08A Jalen Coker would fall into this for me right now.
29:12A Jalen Naylor, a guy that's been getting some offseason buzz.
29:16I love Jalen Coker. I'm clipping this and I'm bringing this back later when the coke daddy is stunting all over your face.
29:24I love Jalen Coker to be totally clear. Really fun player.
29:28He's been a guy I've been in on at different points over the last couple of seasons.
29:34I have no hate in my heart for Jalen Coker.
29:38But when it comes to I'm filling out my bench with dynasty assets that I want to gain value or to be
29:46worth something in the future, I think the Jalen Cokers of the world are not the bets to be making.
29:53Sometimes you are actually better off taking the older guy who might score some points that a tender might want someday rather
30:01than the Jalen Coker of the world who is on a rough offense, is clearly behind an established alpha in Tedaroa McMillan.
30:09Regardless of how fun a player you think he is, it's very hard to create the fantasy football upside scenario where he's a wide receiver two or better.
30:19I'd say the same about Jalen Naylor. I'd say the same about basically any year two or year three wide receiver that
30:27doesn't have any encouraging like per route data. I'd say this about a Matthew Golden.
30:32There are tons of players that fall into this for me where they seem like enticing dynasty assets because they're young and
30:40maybe they'll break out and maybe something will happen.
30:43But if you specifically cannot make the case for that player, just take the boring guy.
30:49Just take the Cortland Sutton, just take the Chuba Hubbard, like these guys that maybe a contender will want someday because those
30:57are the guys that fall in startups. But we flip the calendar over to September, over to October, over to November that
31:05a contending team might say I'll send a future second to.
31:09And don't get me wrong, I'm not saying just go draft a bunch of veterans on your tanking dynasty team.
31:16You can just draft rookies too. You can just go exclusively rookies and you're making at least more of an asymmetrical upside type of bet.
31:25Even for just because we have less information on rookies, right?
31:29Even the worst rookie profiles can hit in a big way, can gain value quickly.
31:34A running back can fall into a workload at some point in the middle of the season as a rookie and instantly
31:42have dynasty value that you can trade. Those are also good bets to make.
31:47I'm saying really the guys in the middle that seem like young and fun dynasty assets but just don't have the realistic value upside scenario.
31:56Stay away from those guys because it's just a really easy trap to fall into.
32:01Despite you completely besmirching the coke daddy, unfairly, I definitely agree with your take.
32:07Think back to all of the roster value spent on a year three Rashad Bateman or Jahan Dotson over the years and
32:14you just watch these assets that have theoretical upsides slowly dissolve into nothing.
32:19So you're probably right even about the coke daddy but at least we have best ball shares for that.
32:26That's right. Best balls for those players. 100%. For me it comes down to if I have to write four different narratives
32:34as to why a player might sort of could one day get there they're probably not a player for me.
32:41It's something that Jacob you used to talk about all the time on the very old full tilt best ball program the
32:49narrative street that you have to walk down to get a player to where you need them to be for that value to hit.
32:58I mean it's why guys like Reminder Stevenson continuously get pushed down and down farther and farther on boards Rashad White etc
33:05and they end up being a value for those who can see it.
33:10I think that there's a path both ways. The last bit of advice this is the bonus this is number 10 and
33:18we saved the most important for last. Having fun.
33:21You must have fun in the leagues that you are in the leagues that you are joining and something that has not
33:29been discussed enough in this episode is how much you need to be in constant contact with your league mates.
33:36Every league is more fun when you are in the mix.
33:40You are in the chat. You are in DMs talking back and forth.
33:45Discuss the draft. Get to know the people you are playing with.
33:49Now not everybody is a super social person. I know me myself.
33:54I'm a little bit I'm a little bit of a curmudgeon at times.
33:58You know me personally it's not hard to see but at the same time you still want to be able to joke
34:06and have fun and keep things moving in a positive direction.
34:10There's a couple things for that to remember as a responsible dynasty manager.
34:15I'll give them to you here and you guys can let me know if you agree or disagree.
34:21Ways to keep your league fun during the draft.
34:25Do not mention players until they are draft. This is corny.
34:29This is beyond aggravating. You're not creating an arms race for that player.
34:33You're not jacking the price up. You're really just creating avenues for bad faith arguments and it can really stunt relationships and drafts and trades moving forward.
34:43And Ryan we talked about something yesterday when preparing for this show today.
34:48It's the same thing about fake leveraging players and trade negotiations and having people call your bluff.
34:54It can really set a bad tone for people.
34:57Yeah I think when you're in a startup and you're trying to trade down for example and you're in DMs with another
35:05manager who might be trying to trade up. I think it's totally fine to say yeah this is my target at this pick if I don't trade it.
35:15that's totally fine to say. As the manager that is trading up they're often going to appreciate that piece of information and
35:23I think it can lead to more open lines of communication just more willingness to make deals with you.
35:30But the really important thing is that you actually follow up your words with actions.
35:35The moment you start trying to game this and tell different managers different things or try to like fake them out and
35:43say that you're going to draft this player but then not actually do it if they still don't trade up with you.
35:51You've lost all credibility. You are the manager that I do not want to trade with and I have no interest in
35:59engaging in like a lengthy trade negotiation with you because I just know you're kind of here to try to play me
36:07like a chess piece and I'm not really interested in participating in such a thing.
36:12So yeah just try to keep that in mind like we're all humans here.
36:17This is like a game ultimately about how you're communicating and dealing with humans to like work toward a adversarial goal that you have on opposing sides.
36:27But yeah we're like we're still people we still want to feel like we're being treated fairly and having fun and we're
36:35all kind of on the same page in the same realm.
36:39So yeah just don't be like a weirdo sociopath that's trying to treat people as chess pieces.
36:45Yeah I mean that was going to be that was my honorable mention is just like yeah get in the DMs chop it up with people be pleasant.
36:55I can speak from first-hand experience that like there have been people that have been extremely unpleasant towards me that I won't
37:03trade with and I have probably too many times met that unpleasantness with equal unpleasantness and shut off a potential trade partner for myself.
37:11It's something that you know we can all be better at.
37:15But like I've brought up the example in my post before I did like a post a couple years ago called Why
37:23We Trade in Dynasty and I spent like a thousand words talking about Settlers of Catan at the beginning.
37:30And like I this is particularly potent to me because my friend group won't play Settlers of Catan with me.
37:37They're not they don't allow me to play with them because I'm difficult to play with.
37:43I am annoying I pout when I lose and when other people do things that are suboptimal for them that help other
37:51people win I complain about it and I point out why they weren't following proper game theory principles and everyone likes me less.
37:59So like you don't want to be the manager that's similar to me playing Catan being like Tom you fucking moron why would you give Ryan a wheat?
38:09You know nobody wants that. I just imagine playing Civilization with you two just imagine Yeah I mean like one time I've
38:17played a lot of Civ in my life. Civ 5 specifically started the C6 lovers out there.
38:23But and one time I was like going to win but I was I guess annoying people and so everybody decided to
38:31give Paul a bunch of money so he could buy enough city states to win even though he wasn't a contender in the game just to spite me.
38:41And it was deeply aggravating and I still haven't forgotten about it.
38:46I threw a massive temper tantrum and I stand by that.
38:50I have a dynasty related situation where I remember very early a couple of guys we played with were very mad at
38:57a few other players in the league and I definitely got a layup soft serve ice cream style trade given to me
39:05and the quote after was go in the league and as a manager I'm absolutely going to take that but you also
39:13don't want to create that kind of environment. So remember and I say this in the send-off all the time remember that
39:21there are people on the other side of that screen that are also trying to enjoy themselves and have a great time
39:29because this game changed my life this game changed our lives here you don't know what it's going to do for you
39:37in the future new friends lifelong who knows but dynasty is fun we should continue to have fun while playing and leagues
39:45well they should always be fun even even if they are very competitive maybe not quite as as Jacob is in Civ
39:53but well that's a story for another day. Thanks for joining us today and remember to leave a comment let us know
40:01what we forgot let us know what you've learned so we can be better drafters in the future and continue to provide better and better content for you.
40:11That's what we're here for. Keep in mind the lives return next week first five for five of the season.
40:18I'm so excited as your two-time defending champion to be hosting this year's five for five boys start studying because week one is going to be ruthless.
40:28I can't wait gonna be excited to see Lucas back as well.
40:32Remember he's so excited and so sad we've seen some comments.
40:36You're our five for five host this year right?
40:39That's right. You won so you're our host this year.
40:43I'm glad you were listening as I was speaking in the in the outro just now that was very Scott Barrett of
40:51you but yes as your two-time defending back to back champion I will be hosting so as I said get studying Lucas
40:59is back we're back we're live it's Tuesday nights at 6 Eastern you're not going to want to miss it.
41:06Remember that clear eyes and full hearts can never lose and that your best days are not only spent drafting but they're always spent tilting.
41:15We'll see you guys next time.

More episodes from Dynasty Points

6