0:00This is Fantasy Football Today from CBS Sports. What a play!
0:03Can you believe this? He's had no idea. It's time to dominate your fantasy league.
0:08Off to the races! And he stays at his feet!
0:11He's just gonna go the distance! Now here's some combination of Adam, Dave, Jamie and Heath.
0:17Welcome to Monday's show. It is July 13th and it is Tiers Week!
0:21Yes! Quarterback, running back, wide receiver and tight end Tiers and then hopefully a mailbag for you on Friday.
0:27Adam Azer, Jamie Eisenberg and Heath Cummings. We've all been kind of away for a little while.
0:32I want to thank Dave for doing a great job on the Thursday podcast, the live mock draft.
0:38That was great stuff. Heath, welcome back! Hey, it's great to be here.
0:42I was a little disappointed because I thought when you said it was Tiers Week, Jamie and I were just gonna take turns trying to make you cry.
0:51But no, tears are very, very important. Well, how about we all try to make Dan cry on Friday?
0:57By the way, so sometime between now and the end of the month is Dave's 50th birthday.
1:02Everybody just from now until the end of the month start wishing Dave a happy birthday on Twitter, X, whatever it is.
1:09Just send him happy birthday. He won't make it to 50 if you do that.
1:14No, just keep sending it every day. He's gonna be so mad.
1:18Don't do that. Anyway, Dave and Heath and Jamie have their...
1:21It might help you get in the leftover leagues.
1:24So do it. No! You're just evil, man. The happy birthday Dave League.
1:28Okay, so anyway, we'll go through the tiers. We have a few news items for you.
1:33And let's talk generally about tiers. Heath, why should we use tiers?
1:37What can fantasy managers get out of this? Fanagy managers.
1:40Fanagy managers. We need Dan on to get after you for mispronouncing that.
1:45No, I think a lot of times when we rank players, the difference between two and six may not be very big.
1:52And then the difference between six and seven is enormous.
1:55And so tiers help you to see what players within the rankings are kind of grouped together.
2:00And then the best way you can use them is look at the players that you have in the same tier, see what their ADP is.
2:08We're going to talk about that a lot when we get to my tier three quarterbacks.
2:13Because there's a wide range in terms of where these guys are being drafted.
2:18And so you can find somebody with a similar floor, similar upside, similar projection.
2:22But three rounds later, that's how you win fantasy leagues.
2:26Jamie, do you prefer tiers to rankings? I don't know if I have a preference.
2:30I mean, it's obviously somewhat of the same thing.
2:33You know, I think Heath said it appropriately, defined it appropriately.
2:37It's, you know, I'm never going to be like, oh, if I didn't get a player in that tier, I'm screwed.
2:43Or I can't still find, you know, a player that I like in the next tier that is close.
2:49So, like, when Heath said the difference between, you know, six and seven, for example, or seven and eight, you know, in
2:56your rankings, could definitely be a tier drop off.
2:59But clearly they're close enough where you should still feel comfortable drafting that player.
3:04So, if I'm really looking at, like, a draft metric, it wouldn't be tiers or rankings.
3:09It would probably be ADP. Okay. Speaking specifically, by the way, comment from the chat here from Wisco Disco.
3:15Just sent Dave a happy birthday on Twitter. How quickly do I get blocked?
3:19Do you think he's going to know if he starts getting spammed with happy birthdays, like, every day between now and the other one?
3:27He's going to figure it out immediately. You think he'll actually go back and watch to see if I said it or one of us said it?
3:35Or, like, he'll have to. He'll know who it was, Jamie.
3:39He'll know. Does Josh Allen belong in his own tier, Heath?
3:42Yep. Jamie? Yeah. Why? I think his track record, his still ability to perform at a high level, and then also factoring
3:49in when he's going to get drafted, where he's going to get drafted, I think it's pretty clear he's the number one quarterback.
3:57So consistent. I would love to see just stats from weeks one through 17, because the last two years he's been, you
4:04know, one play in week 18, kind of dragged us per game down a little bit.
4:09But it's six years in a row of him being one of the best quarterbacks in fantasy.
4:14It's incredible. You know, if you just go to, like, his game log and just go, like, weeks one through 17 and
4:21take out week 18, you could – I believe it's called Azerstattingham?
4:25No, so I can do that, obviously. I don't need any help to do that.
4:30But I think he's been no worse than third in points per game for six straight seasons if you remove week 18, just weeks one through 17.
4:38I would love to know if any quarterback has ever done that before.
4:43And maybe AI can help me with that. But I feel like it might be the best six-game – six seasons.
4:49If for no other reason he's been healthy, hasn't missed a game.
4:53Maybe the best – I don't think there's any chance you could guess who was number one.
4:58The year before – Try to guess, Adam. Who's number one?
5:02It was QB1 through week 17. Wasn't Stafford? No.
5:05He was third the year before through week 17.
5:08Yeah. He's definitely been – Well, I think he's been top three every year.
5:12But, yeah, let me know. But I think there's a chance that Josh Allen has had the most consistent six-year stretch in fantasy history.
5:20Just throw it out there. It's possible. I don't know.
5:23All right. Which tier represents the beginning of the backup quarterbacks in fantasy?
5:27Four. Tier four for Heath is Shuck, Stafford, Bo Nix, Jordan Love, and Patrick Mahomes.
5:32Those are great options, but not top 12 quarterbacks.
5:35Tier four for Jamie would be a little – I think for Jamie, it's tier five or six.
5:40Yeah, because tier four for Jamie is Lawrence, Dart, and Caleb.
5:44So Jamie's got more tiers than Heath. Tier six for you, that's Malik Willis, Tyler Shuck, Baker Mayfield, Jordan Love.
5:50Yep. I would be fine starting anybody in tier five still.
5:54Tier five for Jamie is Stafford, Purdy, Mahomes. That's similar to tier six for – or tier four for Heath, although not Purdy.
6:01Purdy's in tier three. Also, you just said the name of the guy that I'm going to be higher on that I actually have in tier three.
6:10But Brock Purdy. He was number one? He was QB one through week seven.
6:14He only played eight games, but he was QB one through week 17.
6:18Oh, wow. All right. The rest of tier – what was it?
6:22Five for Jamie was Stafford, Purdy, Mahomes, Kyler, Murray, Bo Nix, Jared Goff.
6:26He'd be fine with that. Oh, Johnny, you can't out me like that.
6:30Come on. Oh, yeah, Johnny. Jamie, don't worry about it.
6:33It's pretty transparent. Which tier do you draft from the most?
6:37Three. For me, it would be tier four. All right.
6:40Tier three for Heath. Sorry, tier three. Excuse me.
6:43Tier three for both of you. For Heath, that's Purdy, Goff, Dart, Lawrence, Herbert, Caleb Williams.
6:48And for Jamie, that's Jaden Daniels, Jalen Hurts, Herbert, and Prescott.
6:52So that, to me, says, Jamie, you go earlier on quarterback than Heath.
6:56No. It's where I typically look for – the three quarterbacks that I'll probably draft the most of this year will be Herbert, Prescott, and Trevor Lawrence.
7:04Herbert, Prescott, Lawrence. Okay. And Heath, yeah, I guess kind of similarly, do you find yourself drafting a particular quarterback or quarterbacks?
7:11I just wrote my – and it'll be published to the site today, but I just wrote my sleepers article.
7:18And at current ADP, I just don't think I'll take a quarterback in the first nine rounds because Brock Purdy's in round
7:2511 and Jared Goff's in round 12. And they're both tier three quarterbacks for me that pretty much always finish in the top ten.
7:32Do you feel that way in four-point per-passing touchdown leagues?
7:35Because we center most of our content on six-point.
7:38In four-point, I'll probably draft Jalen Hurts because he is the guy from – and again, he's in tier two for me.
7:45My tiers – it's going to be weird talking about my tiers versus Jamie's because I think I've got more players in tier two.
7:53But Hurts a lot of times falls to round eight.
7:56And his value relative to the other quarterbacks goes up in four-point per-passed touchdown leagues.
8:01And so Hurts would be the guy I would draft more often in that format.
8:06I think we're going to be big Purdy fans on this show.
8:09In the last three seasons, he's – I won't go through four-point versus six-point because it's been pretty similar.
8:15But he's been per game sixth, eleventh, and fourth.
8:18And I think about that with Caleb Williams who right now is QB six in ADP going 72nd overall.
8:24Caleb Williams is QB six. Brock Purdy on Fantasy Pros is QB 11 going 98th overall.
8:29Brock Purdy has finished as a top six quarterback per game in two of the last three seasons.
8:35And he's going – what did I say Caleb was going?
8:39Caleb is – I know QB six, but he's 72nd.
8:42Brock Purdy is 98th. So you can wait two rounds and get a guy who's already performed like we're hoping Caleb Williams has performed.
8:49I'm not saying I like Purdy better than Caleb, but you see what I'm getting at there.
8:55And then is there a tier that you usually avoid in drafts?
8:59One? One and two. Yeah. I get it with avoiding Josh Allen, but I don't want to necessarily avoid – and I
9:06love Josh Allen, but we just – you know, he's just going to go too high for us.
9:11Don't think I want to avoid tier two. Like tier two for Heath is Lamar, Drake, May, Jaden Daniels, Burrow, Hurts, Prescott.
9:18For Jamie, it's just Jackson, May, and Burrow with Daniels, Hurts, Prescott, and Herbert in tier three.
9:24But I don't want to miss out on – I mean, I guess I could say it's easier to make that –
9:31to say that with Heath's tier because it is basically tiers two and three for Jamie.
9:36It's just tier two for Heath. But, man, like those guys could be – some of those guys could approach 28 to 30 points per game, Jamie.
9:44So I don't want to – I don't think we have that in Purdy and Goff, et cetera.
9:50I don't want to just miss out. I don't think you should be like out of your way avoiding them unless they're just being drafted way too soon.
9:59Like, you know, you're going to get to that round three through five range where I think most of these guys will hopefully go.
10:07You know, Josh Allen starting that and then these guys coming off the board in rounds four and five, maybe the end of round three for Lamar Jackson.
10:16But I – it's always going to be the same thing that we'll say, you know, and I think probably to a man.
10:23And it's just if you don't like the players that are on the board at running back, wide receiver, tight end, it's
10:30easy to pivot to the quarterback because, like you said, there's 25-plus point potential for these guys in these tiers.
10:36And, yes, Jared Goff could do that. Brock Purdy could do that.
10:40The guys that we're hoping take that step forward, Caleb Williams, Jackson Dart, Trevor Lawrence on a consistent basis, you know, those guys can clearly do that.
10:49We've seen them do that at times. But it's a matter of, you know, does the upside of an Emeka, a Buka,
10:56a Quinshawn Judkins, you know, whatever player that we're expecting to be, you know, Luther Burden, the next breakout guys versus those
11:03quarterbacks and then hopefully pivoting to, let's say, a Christian Watson later or a Basial Tootin later.
11:08You know, you get the point. You know, somebody later and still getting those quarterbacks.
11:13Like, it's always when the quarterback is drafted and you're like, oh, I wish I would have waited.
11:18At least that was my feeling if I take a quarterback early.
11:22And then when I take a step back and I look at the broad picture of how I draft them, like, you
11:29know, having that guy is a pretty good, it makes you feel a little bit better because just know you're getting those guaranteed points.
11:37Okay. I mean, I kind of feel like he's a 24 to 5 fantasy point per game ceiling, which is awesome.
11:44And honestly, he can easily hit it. But fine.
11:46Did you say Daniels? I did. Yeah. Okay. Yeah.
11:49But if we're talking about like guys who can get to 28, whoever it is, maybe there's four guys, maybe there's six guys.
11:57You just take the guy who goes last. That's how you play the tiers game.
12:01All right. So more on those guys in a little bit.
12:05FFT Dynasty, Heath, give me a promo. Oh, we have three shows this week.
12:09We'll have our regular Tuesday show, our regular Friday show.
12:13And I believe we will have a Wednesday afternoon show as well.
12:16Tune in on Tuesday morning. I'll tell you for sure.
12:19We're going to talk about some of the training camp guys and the guys that are going to see their value change before anybody plays real football games.
12:28And then I think we also need to probably do a couple of mock drafts, just get those refreshed for where the
12:35current value is in terms of FFT listeners. And Beyond the Box Score, also one that you want to check out.
12:42It has its own YouTube channel. Search for Beyond the Box Score.
12:46I'll be on today. I'll be on today also.
12:49Yeah. Different times. Yeah. Well, the thing is, we can't – like we don't do three-hour shows.
12:54So it takes three of us to put together one Jacob Gibbs and Dan Schneier episode.
12:59Yeah. I might only be on for like a half hour.
13:03That's what I told him to. Yeah. I'm talking about Trey McBride.
13:07What are you talking about today? Zay Flowers. Oh, nice.
13:10Okay. I love that. I mean, this is really cool, right?
13:13So it might just be a half hour on Trey McBride.
13:17And it might just be a half hour on Zay Flowers.
13:20And I'm sure that we'll talk about other players within those episodes.
13:24But deep dives for the diehard fan. I think I just came up with the slogan for Beyond the Box Score.
13:31Also want to promote that Dan and I went to the FSGA conference, which for us was the Fantasy Sports and Gaming Association conference.
13:38But Dan probably wishes he had been at the Florida State Golf Association conference because that's all he does is golf.
13:45In fact, he almost made me drive by myself instead of picking him up halfway because he wanted to golf on Friday.
13:52Anyway, we both – Wait, wait, wait, wait. You guys had a plan for you to pick him up and he decided to go golfing beforehand?
14:00No. One hour before I was about to leave, he called me and said, I got to do something on Friday.
14:07It might just make more sense for me to take my own car.
14:11Can you drive by yourself? And he kept kind of not wanting to admit it.
14:16I was like, Dan, just say golf. I know you want to go golfing, right?
14:21So he's like, okay, it's golf. It's golf. But we ended up sticking to the plan.
14:26Anyway, that was before the week even started. We each – he did that.
14:30We each have what we're calling a list of grievances.
14:33We're going to have an airing of grievances on our upcoming mailbag to talk about the horrible things that both of us
14:40did for the two days of FSGA. So it should be fun.
14:44It'll be a Festivus episode hopefully on Friday. Okay.
14:47We'll take a break and come back with some news and notes.
14:51John Breach of CBSSports.com has two ways to spice up NFL overtime, and we'll talk more about the quarterback tiers.
14:57We'll be right back. We are supported by Ring.
15:00Know your home is safe when you're away this summer.
15:03With Ring, it's protected. There's nothing worse than worrying about your house when you should be relaxing on vacation.
15:09Luckily, Ring Battery Doorbell lets you keep track of deliveries at the door so your packages will be there for you when you get back.
15:17If you want to check in on what's happening in the yard, you can zoom in to catch every detail with clear
15:24retinal 2K video on Outdoor Cam Plus. For total peace of mind, you can also know if unexpected motion is detected and
15:31arm your security system from anywhere right in the Ring app with Ring Alarm.
15:36Subscription required. I know for me, I've been traveling a lot this summer for baseball tournaments and just to know that my packages are safe.
15:44And if anybody tries to come close to them, I could just talk to my Ring camera and say, bye bye, buddy.
15:51These are mine. So having Ring is definitely great for your peace of mind when you're traveling.
15:56Travel without worries this summer knowing your home is safe.
15:59With Ring, it's protected. Shop cameras, doorbells, and more right now at ring.com.
16:03Enjoying the World Cup? If you want proper analysis, honest opinions, and plenty of laughs along the way, give The Rest is Football a listen.
16:11Gary Lineker, Alan Shear, and Micah Richards break down the biggest games, the standout moments, and everything happening on and off the
16:18pitch with brilliant guests joining them throughout the tournament.
16:21Whether you've followed football your whole life or you're just getting into it, they'll help you make sense of the drama, the
16:28tactics, the joy, and the heartbreak of the World Cup.
16:31Listen to The Rest is Football wherever you get your podcasts.
16:35Also, Dan and I played tennis on Friday. Who won?
16:38Who do you think? Dan. You would have led with it if you won.
16:42What's going on with my phone? Will you be quiet?
16:45Dan won 6-4. Ooh. Yeah. How's the injury? I'm okay.
16:49You know, it's the day after. It's usually rough.
16:52But Dan didn't play well. And he still did 6-4.
16:55So you would have won the second set? Because we know Dan's stamina is lacking.
16:59Listen, just wait until you hear his excuse. Just wait.
17:03I mean, it's like unbelievable. All right. Daniel Jones is medically cleared to do everything, according to The Athletic.
17:09So he'll be full go going into camp. I just drafted him in the Scott Fish Bowl, which is a super flex league, as my third quarterback.
17:17If you like Daniel Jones, you might be alone this year.
17:21Not a lot of people seem very high on Daniel Jones, although this kind of report could change that.
17:27But right now he's quarterback 25 in average draft position.
17:30Stay on the Colts. They want to reduce Jonathan Taylor's workload.
17:33I think if you were going to make a list of running backs most likely to lead the NFL in carries, would he be first or second?
17:42Top three. Yeah, he'd be up there. But they want to take some work away.
17:47What did you say? First. First, yeah. They want to take some work away.
17:51Just, you know, keep him fresh. No big deal.
17:54Travis Hunter. It's always interesting to hear that. And then we get to games and we never see it.
18:00Exactly. Who's the handcuff in your mind? It's one of the training camp battles.
18:05Yeah. Okay. Travis Hunter will be full go for training camp.
18:08I think you just said Giddens there, Jamie? Yes.
18:11Yeah, I guess if we had to pick one.
18:14But we'll see. And Stefan Diggs says he is the best wide receiver two in the NFL.
18:19And I'm very curious to see where he will end up.
18:23Actually not in the NFL. That's true. That's true.
18:26John Breach wrote a fun article. How many number two receivers would you take ahead of him right now?
18:32The way he was talking was like there's only seven or eight wide receiver ones.
18:36And I think he meant like after the elite guys, he's the best.
18:41Devontae Adams. Yeah. Higgins, Pickens, Adams. Darnell Mooney. Darnell Mooney for sure.
18:44I think at this point, and this will get me crushed probably, but I think at this point I'd probably take Jordan Addison.
18:52No, that's... Oh, I think it's fair. I don't think that's getting crushed.
18:56I think we all think Addison's a pretty good player.
18:59I think Diggs might still be a good player though.
19:02Yeah. He's got a point. He could be a very good wide receiver too.
19:07Yeah, I mean listen, if you're the Dolphins, you certainly should be on the phone seeing if there's a potential fit.
19:13I think if you're the Raiders, it makes some sense for him to go there.
19:18Maybe the Chiefs? I think it is probably... It's good to hear him call himself a wide receiver too.
19:24Yes. Like he kind of might have some concern signing Stefan Diggs that he thinks he deserves 10 targets a game.
19:31Yes. Agreed. All right. So a fun article real quick.
19:34John Breach has two ways to spice up NFL overtime.
19:37Inspired by the World Cup, which truth be told, I don't really care much anymore now that the USA is out, but
19:44this has been an incredible World Cup. Almost every game is super exciting.
19:48It's been great. Top three games in the world still alive.
19:52Yeah, it's really cool. It's really cool. So his two ways to spice up NFL overtime is basically borrow the college rule.
19:59The option number one is to do a two-point conversion shootout at the end of overtime.
20:04They don't have an overtime in... They don't have a 10-minute overtime in college football, but they do eventually in their third
20:11overtime, they go to the two-point conversion shootout. So that's option one.
20:15Heath does not like it, I can see. It's gross.
20:18I don't love it. The second one is a really cool idea.
20:22I'm just going to read what John said. If two NFL teams are still tied after the initial 10-minute overtime period, then
20:29everything would come down to the field goal gamble.
20:31That's right. I knew it had to do with kickers.
20:35Yeah. Of course. I knew it had to do with kickers.
20:38For those of you that don't know, John's dad was a legendary kicker for the Cincinnati Bengals.
20:44Yeah. This is pretty funny in that regard. A kicker would get to decide it.
20:48Let's break down how this would work. If a game is still tied after the initial 10-minute overtime period, there would be another coin toss.
20:56The team that wins the toss gets to choose the distance for a field goal attempt.
21:01The team that loses the coin toss would then decide whether to attempt the kick or have the other team attempt it.
21:08So he gave the example of the Packers-Cowboys, which played the only tie in the NFL this year.
21:14The Packers win the coin toss. They choose a 61-yard field goal.
21:18The Cowboys then say, well, we got Brandon Aubrey.
21:21We're going to kick it. If Aubrey makes it, the Cowboys win.
21:25If Aubrey misses it, the Packers win. I just imagine Breach getting so excited thinking about this kicker scenario.
21:31I think this is a great—first of all, he's not saying do away with overtime.
21:35He's saying no more ties. This is all we do if there's a tie.
21:40I don't agree with the chat here. The chat does not like it.
21:44This is a cool tiebreaker. No. I love it.
21:47I'm with the chat. Why? It's so cool. Is, by the way, the worst rule potential change in the history of sports ever, this NBA free-throw thing?
21:55Oh, you know what? I went to an NBA G League game, and I had no idea what was going on.
22:02I couldn't figure out the free-throw rule. I was like, they only take— They do that in high school summer league already.
22:09I like it. I like it. I don't really.
22:12I'm kind of a purist when it comes to basketball.
22:15I get it. You're trying to make the games—like, it's just dead time, and you're trying to take away that dead time.
22:22Yeah. If you get a two-shot foul or a three-shot foul, you get one shot.
22:27If you make it, you get all of the potential points.
22:30If you miss it, you get none. I think now that the Celtics have Mitchell Robinson, I probably like it.
22:37It's more likely that he makes one free-throw than two.
22:40It's completely unlikely he makes two, but I think the last two minutes, it's regular free-throws.
22:45All right. Cued quarterback tiers. Let's talk about tier one.
22:48Josh Allen for both Jamie and Heath. It's a one-person tier.
22:52Don't have to say much here, except do you think the addition— How about this?
22:56Hypothetically, if they had not traded for DJ Moore, would you still have Josh Allen in his own tier, Jamie?
23:03Yes. Heath? I think I probably would, yeah. I'm a little skeptical that DJ Moore is going to make a huge difference.
23:10So, yeah, I think I probably still would. Am I crazy for saying this?
23:14Josh Allen does not have the most upside at the position.
23:18I think Lamar does. Okay. Yes, sir. Me too.
23:21All right. Let's go to tier two then. Let's bring it.
23:24Tier two for Jamie. I think maybe—is it best to look at tiers two and three for Jamie and just compare to tier two for Heath?
23:32Because for Jamie, tier two is Jackson, May, and Burrow.
23:35And tier three is Daniels, Hurts, Herbert, Prescott. Whereas for Heath, tier two is Jackson, May, Daniels, Burrow, Hurts, Prescott.
23:42So it's only missing Herbert. In other words, if you—unless I'm wrong here—if you combine tiers two and three for Jamie, it's
23:49the same as tier two for Heath, except it includes Justin Herbert, right?
23:53Yep. All right. So, Jamie, is there any reason why you decided to separate Jackson, May, and Burrow from Daniels, Hurts, Herbert, and Prescott?
24:01I think those three are on a little bit of a different level.
24:05Obviously, Lamar, as we just alluded to, most upside probably of anybody at the position, has shown you what he's capable of
24:12when he's healthy, and hopefully that's the case this year.
24:15And maybe the new offense under Declan Doyle allows him to be even better.
24:19So, lots of love about Lamar. Drake May, I think, gets better with the addition of A.J.
24:25Brown. It was pretty special last year. And Joe Burrow, when he's been healthy, has been amazing.
24:30Jayden Daniels, you can make a case, obviously. For me, at least, I would separate Daniels from Hurts and Prescott.
24:36So Daniels was the one I probably struggled with the most, but he's at the top of the next tier.
24:43And I, for the most part, early on, leaned on my projections for putting together the tiers.
24:48And I have these six quarterbacks. Is it six, right?
24:51Yeah. All basically within one point per game in my projections.
24:55I kind of would view this tier as they might be.
24:58Well, really, I would say they might be QB2.
25:01The truth is, we've seen several. Usually, there's one guy that sneaks up and is just a little bit better than Josh Allen.
25:09We're just much more confident that Josh Allen's going to be top three than any of these guys.
25:14Yeah, I think. All right. So Jackson, May, and Burrow, tier two for James.
25:19Yeah, go ahead, go ahead. Like, I think May is kind of the hybrid of the group.
25:24Like, Jackson, Daniels, and Hurts could all have enormous rushing production and still good passing numbers.
25:29And I think Burrow and Dak could throw for 5,000 yards and 40 touchdowns.
25:34And May kind of combines. He's probably not going to rush for quite as much as the three I mentioned in terms of fantasy points.
25:42And he's probably not going to throw for quite as much as Burrow and Hurts and Prescott.
25:47But he's good enough in both. Right. Well said.
25:50And Daniels, you know, I like this stat for Jaden Daniels because he only played four games with 100% of the snaps.
25:57And in those four games, it looked a lot like his 2024 season, except just didn't have any rushing touchdowns.
26:03But, you know, his season was so wonky. Knee and hamstring injuries earlier in the season.
26:08Elbow injury later in the season. So few times did he actually start and finish.
26:13But he did that, I think. Like, I don't know if it was weeks one through four, but it was his first four games.
26:21And I think, like, the perception on Jaden Daniels is kind of weird.
26:25And Ricky in the chat is really upset that we have Jaden Daniels ahead of Caleb Williams.
26:30I do, at least. I'm not sure. I have him in a different tier.
26:35Jamie may have him in the same tier next.
26:38But, like, I think from what we've seen so far, I feel more confident in Jaden Daniels as a rusher than Caleb Williams.
26:45And I feel more confident in Jaden Daniels as a passer than Caleb Williams.
26:49Well, it's not even close as a rusher. Right.
26:52As a passer, that's interesting. I think I expect Caleb to take the next step, and a lot of fantasy players in general do.
27:00But there's no reason to expect that Jaden Daniels wouldn't be better, is there?
27:04Yes, there is. His best and maybe only legitimate weapon is 30 years old now.
27:09Okay, so it's weapons. But not like passing ability.
27:12I mean, if he were playing on the Chicago Bears this year, you know.
27:16He might be QB1. Yeah. Right. That's kind of how I'm seeing it.
27:20That's how I approach it. Jamie, your thoughts on Jaden Daniels?
27:24And I'm sorry, let me just say again, first four games when he played 100% of the snaps, he was, Jaden Daniels,
27:31like, as bad as last year was. He was actually the top seven quarterback per game.
27:36And again, that was only four games, but it was with zero, I think, zero rushing touchdowns in those four games.
27:43So, anywho, yeah, no rushing touchdowns. But your thoughts on Daniels?
27:46Well, I think Jaden Daniels' best weapon is himself.
27:49You know, so that's the biggest reason. You know, so what he'll do with his legs, he could easily rush for 1,000 yards.
27:56He was close as a rookie. So, does he have the weapons that Caleb Williams has?
28:01Well, clearly not. But I think the interesting part of Jaden Daniels will be, if they sign Stefan Diggs, if they sign
28:08somebody else, do they get another receiver of significance?
28:11And how high does he then go? I don't think Heath will have him much higher, but maybe he does move him up a spot.
28:19For me, it'll probably just put him in this tier.
28:22I wouldn't take him ahead of Jackson, May, or Burrow.
28:26But it would definitely, you know, bump up his round value.
28:29So, I think Jaden Daniels can still get better.
28:32But at this point, I just think you know what you're getting.
28:36You're getting a very good running quarterback who could throw it as well as anybody.
28:41And if he had better weapons, like Heath said, he might be talking about QB1 or QB2.
28:46Combining what we've talked about already today, man, wouldn't that be the perfect spot for Stefan Diggs?
28:51Yep. I think that's where he wants to go.
28:54I mean, he went to school at Maryland. I think he's training there, you know, so it just makes a lot of
29:01sense, especially after the Brandon Ayuk fiasco, if that was something they were considering.
29:06Like, Diggs may have his off-field issues and, you know, still maybe having to, you know, go through something.
29:12But as a player, as we talked about, you know, for what he accomplished last year, coming off an ACL tear, learning
29:19a new offense, learning a new quarterback, like he really, I think, showed he can still be an asset to a team
29:26and for our purposes can potentially be a number three fantasy receiver if things go right.
29:31I don't think Joe Burrow requires much discussion. We pretty much know who he is, although injuries have really held him back in his career.
29:39But I always do this every year. I look at the games where Burrow, Chase, and Higgins are all healthy, playing, you
29:46know, more than 50% of the snaps or as close to normal snapshare as possible.
29:50And there's been five years, and you look at these sample sizes, and I'm going to tell you how many points per
29:57game Joe Burrow has averaged when Higgins, when he, Higgins, and Chase are all healthy.
30:02So from 2021 on. 23.3 points per game in six point, which is good, not great.
30:0729.1, which is amazing. He was terrible in 2023.
30:10They all were bad. 28.2 in 2024, which would have made him QB two per game, and 25.7 last year, which also
30:17would have made him QB two per game. So in three of the last five seasons, Joe Burrow has been good enough
30:24to be number one or number two per game in six point and anywhere from two to four per game in four
30:31point per passing touchdown leagues when they've all been healthy.
30:34Can we get a number of games that has happened each year?
30:38So it was 14 games, nine games, seven games, 12 games, and five games.
30:43So like, and that's kind of the thing is I think like we've, the chat has mostly been saying like Jaden Daniels health is the concern.
30:51He can't stay healthy. He can't. I don't hear that about Joe Burrow very often.
30:56You're right. And certainly it happens with Higgins. You don't hear that often really?
31:00I think the, I think the Russian quarterbacks give people more anxiety, right?
31:04Like we expect them to get hurt. Not just general public.
31:08I mean, you know, I, I don't know at what point that it became like, oh, it's so, it's so concerning.
31:14You know, maybe it was RG three, you know, after the rookie season he had, and everybody was, you know, petrified afterwards.
31:21But I mean, look, you have to have some concern about it, but I can't, you can't have a realistic injury conversation
31:28and not have Joe Burrow in there. It's just not fair.
31:32Sure. Agreed. All right. So how about Jalen Hurts, Dak Prescott, and Justin Herbert with Hurts and Prescott in this tier two
31:39or three group for both Jamie and Heath and Herbert in there just for Jamie.
31:44So what's the, what's the upside for those guys, Jamie, Herbert Prescott and Hurts?
31:48I mean, Hurts track record is clearly tried and true.
31:51It's just a matter of, you know, to what level you're going to get Jalen Hurts and losing AJ Brown doesn't help.
31:58But I think the group that he has with him, at least from a depth standpoint, is, has the chance to be solid.
32:05You know, so there are questions, you have to have questions about his receiving court, because we've never seen Devontae Smith in this role.
32:13Dallas Goddard has been solid, but he has a tough time staying healthy.
32:17Makai Lemon is a first round rookie, but he's already dealing with an injury.
32:22Marquise Brown, Dante Wicks, you can go on and on just about, you know, the pros and cons of these guys.
32:28But again, Jalen Hurts, if he's going to run, then you're going to get the tush push.
32:34You're going to get the rushing touchdowns. You're going to get, you know, probably 500 plus yards.
32:39And so that keeps him in the conversation to be a top five fantasy quarterback, which is why Keith has him where he does.
32:47And, you know, for just a little bit of a lesser extent, so do I.
32:52Obviously, the one that I think needs to probably have the, you know, you need to be sold on is Justin Herbert.
32:59Right. If you're not paying attention to what's going on this offseason.
33:02And that's the addition of Mike McDaniel. You know, and then you look at what he did last year where he ran
33:09the ball to a level that we haven't seen from over 400 yards rushing.
33:14When he had his tackles healthy or when he had his tackle healthy because he didn't have Rashawn Slater for the entire
33:21season and only had Joe out for six games.
33:24But in the first four games, it looked like first and second year Justin Herbert.
33:28And so for me, if anybody hasn't been paying attention, obviously I'm all in on the chargers this year.
33:34I think Justin Herbert has a chance to get back to that 25 plus point threshold.
33:40If I said that correctly. Um, you know, with the tackles healthy and almost entirely rebuilt interior of his line.
33:46But really it's like, we saw Mike McDaniel get a passing yards leading season from Tua Tunga-Vailoa.
33:51And that's now going from, I don't want to be disrespectful to it, but that's like going from like, uh, Adam, you still have your Volvo?
34:00I never had a Volvo. Volkswagen? What'd you have?
34:02I had a Volkswagen. Now I have a Honda CRV.
34:06Okay. Okay. So like that level of car to like, you know, uh, uh, uh, a much nicer version of it, you
34:13know, like it's like Justin Herbert's is a huge upgrade.
34:16Yeah. We're, we're definitely stepping into the BMW here.
34:19Right. Uh, yeah. We think. Yeah. Well, I didn't, I didn't say like, uh, I didn't say like, uh, I didn't say.
34:26I was thinking like, what's the car that looks really, really awesome.
34:29Like an alien bug thing. The Tesla. That weird, like tank.
34:33Yeah. I know what you're talking about. I think the thing with Herbert is you've seen him be an elite fantasy quarterback
34:40and then it just was broken for a variety of reasons.
34:43His play offensive issues, offensive coaching, all those things for, you know, a three, four year period.
34:49And we've seen flashes of it again. And now the hope would be, at least for me is the coach could be great.
34:56He's been one of the most creative play callers in the league since taking over the Dolphins head coaching spot.
35:03And now he's in with the chargers, all his weapons and hopefully everybody around him stays healthy.
35:08It's a huge question mark, but I'm, I'm hoping that's going to be the case.
35:13My biggest question, I think with Herbert is what is the pass volume in Los Angeles?
35:18Like how, his best season, he threw the ball 672 times, had 5,000 yards passing, 38 touchdowns.
35:23The last two seasons, it's been 504 attempts and 512 attempts.
35:27It's really, really hard to be a difference maker at quarterback.
35:30Now, if you rush for 500 yards, that helps.
35:33Maybe he does that. He almost did that last year.
35:36Maybe he does that again. Right. I don't know where you guys would put Herbert because it is a bit of a
35:43mystery with McDaniel and maybe he wants to throw the ball more now that he's got Herbert.
35:49I've got him 15th in pass attempts, but I haven't, I don't really have a strong lean.
35:54That's why he's kind of in the middle of the pack for me.
35:58Yeah. I think the rushing yards, I mean, you mentioned what he did last year, Jamie, but I don't think we can bank on that.
36:06He had no, no, you know, so maybe 300 rushing yards.
36:10I think he's certainly capable of that. You know, 17.5, 18, he's, he's been around 17 to 18 rushing yards per game.
36:17Most years last year, Herbert was 31 rushing yards per game.
36:20So that'll probably come down. What's the difference between him and Dak Prescott?
36:24For me, it's the ability to just take a step forward where I think Prescott is just going to kind of stay
36:31in the same level where he's been, which has been fantastic.
36:35You know, so I could see Herbert 20 north of 25 points.
36:38I think you said it earlier, like 23, 24 points to me is Dak Prescott.
36:43So I, I guess I probably have to answer since I have them in different tiers.
36:48Um, I, for me, it, like Jamie mentioned the great McDaniel season with Tua and maybe multiple seasons, but he had Tyreek
36:55and Waddle and I am like Dak has CD lamb and George Pickens compared to Lad McConkie who were hopeful breaks out and Quentin Johnston.
37:03Like it's a, it's a pretty big difference in pass catching weapons for me.
37:08And I have a lot more projected passes for Dak than I do for Herbert.
37:12So that's, I think where I'm going to guess probably Dave and I align on this a little bit more is that
37:19I think that Cowboys defense takes a significant step forward.
37:23Yeah. But to the chargers level, the chargers could have one of the best.
37:27No, no, no, no. But there's a difference there.
37:30I think the, if, if it goes as I hope and Harbaugh just says, that's yours, Mike, go do what you want.
37:37And doesn't rain in Mike McDaniel. Like we could see a lot of just fantastic things coming out of the chargers.
37:44Not that the Cowboys aren't going to be great, but I think there's, there's a chance that it's like one of the best offenses in football.
37:52I think the Cowboys, you know, under Dan Quinn, they did have some good defenses, some really good defenses.
37:58And I believe they straight through the ball. I, I meant to come, I meant to do that research and know it for sure.
38:06But I don't think they've never really been like, no, I wouldn't say they've never been run heavy, but I think they've
38:13still had good pass volume even with good defenses.
38:15And then also I looked at, at six teams last year that made pretty big jumps defensively.
38:21It went up at least 10 spots from 2024 to 2025 and points per game allowed.
38:26And then like Carolina threw a lot less, but San Francisco had a higher pass rate.
38:31The Jaguars had a lower pass rate, but a new coach, same with the Patriots.
38:36Uh, the Browns went from first to seventh and pass rate.
38:39The Falcons had a slight increase in pass rate.
38:42So overall, it wasn't exactly conclusive looking at the six teams that had the biggest improvement defensively from 2024 to 2025 and
38:49what it meant for their pass rate. Um, you know, I couldn't, especially because two of them had a new coach, you
38:56know, and you expected Mike Vrabel to be more run heavy.
39:00I don't know if you expected that from Leon Cohen, but okay.
39:03I've got to take a break. So that is the first three tiers basically for Jamie, the first two tiers for Heath.
39:10We'll get into the Brock Purdy's Jackson darts, Trevor Lawrence's Caleb Williams of the world.
39:15When we come back on fantasy football today. This past summer, my wife and I took my parents, our son and our granddaughter on vacation to Tennessee.
39:24We wanted to get out into nature. So we found the perfect cabin on Airbnb where all four generations could stay together.
39:31The amenities really made the trip special. We had our own hot tub with a mountain view, a fire pit for late night s'mores and a full kitchen.
39:40When you're traveling with four generations, eating every meal out gets expensive.
39:43So it was great to make bacon and eggs for breakfast one morning and grill steaks for dinner another night.
39:50Booking a stay like this gives you the flexibility to vacation how you want, where you want with the people who matter most.
39:57But it got me thinking Airbnb isn't just great for finding places to stay.
40:02You can also list your own home when you're away.
40:05It's nice that the same platform I use to book family vacations can also help me earn a little extra money during
40:12high demand weekends without having to up in my daily life.
40:15Honestly, listing my house feels like a smart thing to do because it's just so incredibly practical.
40:21I'm already going to be traveling anyway. So why not earn a little extra money to put toward an upcoming vacation, help
40:28offset the cost of my flights or upgrade my travel gear.
40:31Turns an empty house into an easy opportunity while you enjoy your own time off.
40:36Your home might be worth more than you think.
40:39Find out how much at airbnb.com slash host. All right, on to tier four.
40:43And if Caleb Williams is going to be, you know, in this tier for Jamie, he's in tier three, the kind of
40:50the end of tier three for Heath. He's just no one has him on our, in our site as a top six
40:57quarterback, just to say that, but he is obviously very exciting.
41:01Jamie has Trevor Lawrence, Jackson Dart and Caleb Williams in tier four.
41:04And again, this is kind of like tier three.
41:07Maybe you just go back real quick. If you wouldn't mind a tier three for Heath, because for Jamie, it's Lawrence Dart
41:14and Caleb in tier four, but tier three has all three of those guys for Heath.
41:19As well as Purdy and Goff. Yeah, Purdy and Goff and Herbert.
41:23So look, whether it's tier three, whether it's tier four, we're, you know, in the back, the back part of the top
41:3012 and the beginning of, you know, the outside, I wouldn't call them backups.
41:35They may not be 12th, but you know, they're starting quarterbacks.
41:38They're just not in the first two tiers. So Purdy, Goff, Dart, Lawrence, Caleb Williams.
41:43Am I forgetting anyone? Herbert for Heath, but not for Jamie.
41:46Yeah, I think Jamie, we'd be, we'd be perfectly fine with these guys as our quarterbacks.
41:51What are our expectations for the Purdy, Goff, Dart, Lawrence, Caleb?
41:55I mean, in the case of Purdy and Goff, you have the track record of what they've done and hopefully will continue
42:02to do, you know, so I just don't see the same upside.
42:06And that's probably not fair for Purdy because as Heath alluded to through week 17 from points per game standpoint, he was
42:13great, but he obviously didn't play very many games in the first 11.
42:17For Goff, it's just kind of, can he ever exceed that 21, 22 point threshold?
42:22For me, why I have Lawrence, Dart and Williams ahead of them, and I go back and forth between Dart and Williams.
42:29So, you know, that's kind of a tough one just based on how much the Giants could potentially run the ball.
42:35So I think once we get an official word on Malik Nabors, I'll probably move Williams ahead of Dart.
42:41But in the case of these other guys, you're hoping that they take the step forward.
42:46And if they do take the step forward, and we saw flashes of it, obviously Dart did everything that he accomplished last year without Malik Nabors.
42:55The neighbors got hurt in week four. That was Dart's first dart.
42:59What Dart did as a rusher hopefully will continue.
43:01And then the additions that they made in the passing game, you know, from free agency, rookie, you know, and even just,
43:08you know, just taking a step forward in year two would be the hope.
43:13I think in the case of Caleb Williams and Trevor Lawrence, like, you know, the coaching changes were so important for them
43:20and hopefully will continue to be important for them.
43:23Now, Caleb, you know, can he break through that threshold that's never happened before of being the first 4,000-yard passer?
43:29I mean, he really did it last year, but he didn't.
43:33But can he be that first 4,000-yard passer in Chicago history?
43:36You know, and how far can he get to, you know, on top of that?
43:41For Lawrence is, you know, I'm sure this will be Heath's, you know, point on him is that he's just never done
43:48it consistently over the course of a season. And so does what we saw, did what we see last year, does he
43:55have the potential to do that again? And that's what I'm counting on.
43:59I think Liam Cohen's offense has just been fantastic for the last two quarterbacks that have been in it.
44:05Baker Mayfield in 2024, Trevor Lawrence in 2025. And, you know, you talk about weapons for some of these guys and nitpicking
44:12it, like Jacksonville may not have, like, a true number one, but they have potentially four number twos, you know?
44:18And it's pretty exciting to see what Lawrence did last year and hopefully we get a better Brian Thomas and, you know,
44:25a continuation of Parker Washington and the, you know, parts that they put Travis Hunter in, you know, parts of the game
44:32that they put Travis Hunter in and Jacoby Myers, like it could be really fun.
44:37So that's kind of why I think if you're inclined to wait on quarterback, it just, it's so, it's such a deep
44:44position with so much upside and so many different ways you can go.
44:48Like you're starting to see for Heath, you know, as we get into it a little bit more, like here's where the
44:55number one quarterback is from a year ago and the NFL MVP and Matthew Stafford, who some people just don't think are
45:02going to do it again, which is why he's not ranked higher.
45:06You have Mahomes. If he's healthy, we know what he's capable of and showed it last year, you know, when he was
45:13running again, I don't think that'll be the case, but you know, it can just go on and on.
45:19So if we look at tier three, I mean, I know we're on tier four for Jamie, but it's really mostly tier
45:26three for Heath and I go by these, these players one by one.
45:30And you tell me, uh, should we do upside here or, you know, how likely you are to draft them?
45:36Maybe. Yeah. Draft, draftometer. How likely you are to draft them?
45:40Brock Purdy, zero to 10. Eight. Um, likely to draft, uh, six.
45:44Jared Goff. Nine. Four. Heath, why so much higher on Goff?
45:47Uh, well, and I don't know, maybe fantasy pros ADP is different, but right now in CBS ADP, Jared Goff is 144th in ADP.
45:55So he's at the 1213 turn. So I could draft him as my QB two.
46:00Much different. If I drafted an upside QB one.
46:03Much different on fantasy pros. But I think quarterbacks in general are going earlier.
46:07107. But what, what are Purdy compared to Goff on fantasy pros?
46:11It's pretty close. Purdy is QB 12. I think I said, and Goff is QB 15.
46:16They're about eight picks apart. Yeah. I don't think that's going to like, how high is golf on fantasy pros?
46:22QB 15, 107th overall. Purdy's actually QB 11, 98th overall.
46:25So I think there's got to be some super flex factored in there.
46:30Cause there's not one QB leagues where the 15th QB is being drafted in round nine very often.
46:35Yeah. Typically I, I guess. I think they separate theirs though.
46:39Fantasy pros. So do we, by the way. What I would say is if golf is 15th on fantasy pros, he's 16th on CBS.
46:46So he is a backup quarterback. Well, yes, but, but we agree.
46:50There are more than 12 guys who are worth starting where you could settle for as your, I mean, it's pretty cool.
46:57The QB 15 is Jared golf. I don't know about in a four point per passing touchdown league, although yards count.
47:04And I think that would be his worst finish since he got to Detroit.
47:08Since his first year in Detroit. Let's see. Last four seasons per game.
47:12Yeah, you're absolutely right. 13th, 12th, 8th and 9th in that's well, that's counting up.
47:17That's from 22 to 2025. So last two years, golf's been eighth and ninth per game.
47:22That's six point in four point per passing touchdown leagues.
47:25Golf has been 14th, 14th, 7th and 11th per game.
47:29And I don't know. I'm not, I'm just not really sure I'm going to draft that guy.
47:34If the best he's done is QB seven or eight in the last four years.
47:39Well, what if you draft him as QB 16?
47:42Then yeah, but. So I don't know why we would like, you don't have to draft him earlier than that.
47:48I think if you, if you, if you know, you're going to be, and you have enough depth on your roster.
47:55If you know, you're going to be in on the potential injury guys, Jane Daniels, Joe Burrow, those type of quarterbacks or
48:02the unproven guys of dart or Caleb, or, you know, you want to throw Trevor Lawrence in there, whatever.
48:08Like this is the perfect marriage is Jared golf and one of those guys.
48:12Now, if you really want to wait and say, okay, I really believe in Kyler Murray this year, a Murray golf pairing
48:19late or a shuck pairing, you know, shuck golf pairing, you know, those types of things or a pretty golf pair, you
48:26know, just looking at pretty wasn't healthy last year either.
48:29You know? So there's, there's lots of different ways to go.
48:33Like Jared golf is the perfect guy to say, I'm going to know what I have.
48:38And it's funny. You say if, if you're getting QB seven, you don't want that, but, um, right.
48:44I, I, well, I didn't say that. I know what you meant, but, um, um, if you know what you're getting with
48:51Jared golf, which is at worst, let's say a QB 12 or 13 finish.
48:55Like that'll win you some weeks though with the, if the rest of your roster is doing what it's supposed to.
49:02I'm a huge fan of Jared golf is J is Matthew Stafford, not a better version of Jared golf.
49:08Cause twice in the last five years, Matthew Stafford has been out of this world.
49:13Good. And golf hasn't reached those heights. Stafford's also been worse.
49:16So he's more volatile, but does, does he not have more upside than Jared golf?
49:21I think so. Heath. I mean, it's hard to say he doesn't after what happened last year.
49:26I just don't really believe anything that I just don't really believe that he can do what he did last year again.
49:33So I guess you'd have to say he has a higher upside and he is also much more likely to be dropped.
49:40Cause he was on the waiver wire in leagues.
49:43Yeah. I dropped them. Two of the past four years, probably sometime last year.
49:48I dropped them. Yep. He averaged 26 points per game last year.
49:51He averaged 24 points per game in 2021. And let me just see what golf has, uh, if golf, how many, if
49:58golf has ever reached 24 points per game, I'd be surprised.
50:02Uh, his high, his highest with Detroit is 22.9, 23.1 with the Rams back in 2018.
50:07So that's a little bit of a comparison of the upsides maybe of Stafford versus, but I think golf is like even Jaden Daniels.
50:15We talked about him and his injury concerns. Like he, he is the perfect guy to pair with those guys golf.
50:21Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I think if we're talking about as a backup, it's awesome.
50:26Um, not sure I'd want him as my starter.
50:29Well, I don't know. I shouldn't say that. I, I, he's not for me.
50:33If he's your starter, then you have five running backs and five wide receivers that you took in the first 11 rounds.
50:40Yeah. He's good. He's really good. I, we did a draft on Thursday last week, uh, 10 team half PPR draft.
50:47And for anybody that was, you know, saw the story.
50:50Um, so I drafted for Dave, just using Dave's rankings and completely whiffed on tight end just because whenever it came up,
50:57he didn't have a tight end in his rankings at high.
51:00And, you know, ended up with, I think, um, Dalton Kincaid and Chico Conco were his tight ends.
51:06It's the same thing with quarterback. Like if you just continue to stockpile talent, like he, he just said, you're just, you're drafting great running backs, great receivers.
51:15Just can't pass on those types of players. Like you get to that spot and it's like, oh, I'm stuck with Jared golf.
51:22And then I think if you take golf, then you take another high upside guy.
51:27So then that's where guys like for me, Kyler and Tyler Shuck come into play.
51:32Bo Nix, who's another guy that's getting a little, you know, somewhat disrespected by all of us because he's been a top
51:3910 quarterback each his first two seasons and still has the potential with it.
51:43Hey, you've got another receiver who should make you better, but we're going to rank you lower than you finished the last two years.
51:51Like that's what we do. It's wild. And he's actually a Bo Nix is right.
51:56One pick behind Jared golf on fantasy pros QB 16.
51:59Uh, I just got to hear, right. He's been top 10 or 12 each of the last two years.
52:05Yeah. Bo Nix. It's not always the prettiest. He was actually 13th per game last year.
52:10Sorry, but, but really it does seem like people were pretty down on him and he got right.
52:16Like you said, he got wild. I just got a text message by the way, from Dave Richard.
52:21Uh, he said today isn't my birthday. So he's taking it out on me.
52:26Apparently thanks. You should just say, I know that's what I said.
52:30I said, what do you, what do you mean?
52:32Uh, all right. What a weird thing to say.
52:35So Jackson dart, because anything, well, I think we need to talk about Caleb Williams.
52:40Why you guys are a little, I guess, lower on Caleb than, uh, than the fantasy industry.
52:46It's two things for me and it may change, but as of right now, he is the least accurate passer that we might draft in fantasy football.
52:54He is kind of what people think Jalen hurts is as a passer and stylistically.
52:59I think he plays football the exact opposite way that his coach would like to.
53:04Okay. Jamie, I just think it's a great position.
53:06You know, like again, the one that I struggle with is dart and Caleb, just because we're, we're hoping at this point,
53:13cause I think that's the only thing you can do is you're hoping that Malik neighbors is not going to be on
53:20the public for the first five or six weeks of the season.
53:24And you don't have that because if he has that, and even if it's not the best version of Malik neighbors, it's
53:31still better than what he had last year. You know?
53:34So you give him neighbors, you give him, uh, Darnell Mooney, give him Isaiah likely, you know, you give him, you know,
53:41hopefully, uh, the ability to run, which I think is the biggest part of this because, you know, he got hurt last
53:48year, but, or multiple times last year. But if he does that, like that's a different gear than Caleb Williams has, at least as fantasy quarterback.
53:57So, um, I love Caleb Williams. I don't know if anybody can, can watch him and say, that's not fun to watch.
54:04That's not fun to root for. And, and now maybe we see, I don't know if you get necessarily better as a
54:11group by losing DJ more, but you get more Luther burden.
54:14You get hopefully a full year of Colston Lovellum because didn't really have that animal until the end of the season going into the playoffs.
54:22And he didn't have Romo Doomsday at that time.
54:25So if everybody's healthy, like it could be great and we could be completely wrong.
54:30And the ADP can be exactly right that he is a toxic quarterback.
54:34But, um, I just don't want to overvalue Caleb Williams.
54:37The same thing with Jackson Dart. Like both those guys to me can be amazing.
54:42And you could also see a little bit of a step back just based on how things may or may not change.
54:49And the, the bears, you know, look, we'll see if their run game continues to be as impressive.
54:55If not, then I think more is on Caleb, which I think will help.
54:59Um, and in the case of, of, uh, the offensive line too, like, you know, there's a little bit of a change
55:06going on there, which I hope will still be as productive for the bears.
55:10Man, Caleb versus Dart is such an easy call for me.
55:14It's just so clearly Caleb Williams. Dart has one advantage over him and it's potentially it's rushing totals and rushing.
55:20I thought it was throwing the ball where he wants to.
55:24I understand that criticism of Caleb. Like it's obviously there's no arguing against it.
55:28He completed less than 60% of his passes. It's a joke, but he also makes some plays that are so unbelievable that
55:35just from a fantasy points perspective, it makes up for it.
55:39Right. He's got least chunk plays. Um, but he's just such a better player than Jackson Dart.
55:44I think at this point, and it's really Ben Johnson and all those weapons versus Matt Nagy and the lack of weapons.
55:51Uh, but Dart was better as a starter than Caleb last year, right?
55:55Probably it's, it's hard to say, you know, believe it or not, Jackson Dart only had one top five finish in 12
56:02starts in six point per passing touchdown leagues in four point for passing touchdown leagues.
56:07He had like four or something, uh, which I think in four point, he was definitely better than Caleb in six point.
56:14Caleb was 10th per game. Dart had that game with zero points against the Vikings.
56:19So I don't know. I think it was a little closer than, than we might think.
56:24Is it that easy for you? If Malik is healthy?
56:27Yes. Um, Ricky in the chat says this guy is obsessed with completion percentage.
56:31I'm not sure if he was talking about you or me, but I just wanted to say that when I was talking
56:38about accuracy, I was not necessarily talking about completion percentage so much as all of the advanced metrics that we have that
56:45measure on target throws and bad throws. Yes, Jamie.
56:48Thank you, Heath. I think he's probably referring to you, but the completion percentage is so bad for Caleb Williams that you just can't ignore it.
56:57But I think I've, I've just been on Twitter and there are a lot of really smart people in the industry.
57:03And just one of the things I keep seeing is how good Ben Johnson offenses are, um, how, how smart he is and what he does differently.
57:12And it's just like, Jamie, you're, you're in on the chargers because of McDaniel just in this particular comparison, bears versus giants.
57:19I mean, it's such a no brainer for me to favor the guy on the bears.
57:24I mean, look, every, everything logically says Caleb Williams should be better because he is the prospect.
57:29He is the better, he has the better weapons.
57:32He has the better coach. And, you know, again, depending on what sample sizes you want to use, when everybody was healthy
57:39for the bears, he was better than what Jackson dart was, but Jackson dart didn't have his best weapon and got better weapons.
57:46If you give him neighbors again, whatever version of it, it's still to me better than what he had last year.
57:53No, no disrespect to Wanda Robinson. Um, Isaiah likely is a huge upgrade.
57:57You know, Darnell Mooney, I think is a big addition.
58:00And so yes, Matt Nagy may not be great.
58:03Uh, but I think Jackson darts rushing ability from a fantasy perspective, you got to give that a big boost for him over Caleb Williams.
58:11Dave kids, Dave is. So why are strangers wishing me a happy 50th?
58:15That's strange. Why, why am I dealing with this?
58:18Why would, how, how would I know? Dave, this is not fair.
58:22I said, they like you question mark. All right.
58:25Listen, I've done a pretty bad job here of navigating this show.
58:29Uh, so we have a lot of quarterbacks remaining to talk about here.
58:33So let's just talk about the next group. And, uh, for, for Heath, it's Tyler Shuck and, and Matthew Stafford, Bo Nix, Jordan Love and Patrick Mahomes.
58:41Tyler Shuck, Matthew Stafford, Bo Nix, uh, Jordan Love and Patrick Mahomes.
58:45And we're 17 quarterbacks deep for Heath at this point.
58:48A similar tier for Jamie would be Stafford, Purdy Mahomes, Kyler, Nix and Goff.
58:53It's actually fairly different there, but, uh, that's tier five for Jamie versus tier four for Heath.
58:58Uh, but good quarterbacks. Heath, you want to take us through your, uh, tier four Shuck, Stafford, Nix, Love, Mahomes.
59:05Yeah, I think these are the high end QB twos that nobody will be surprised if half of them finish as like QB 10 through 12.
59:13I don't, I do think there's some touchdown regression coming for, for Matthew Stafford.
59:17I'm a little concerned. I, I kind of feel even more so about the way about Bo Nix that I do Caleb Williams.
59:25Like he just hasn't played quarterback as well as his fantasy production suggests.
59:29Um, Mahomes sticks out like a sore thumb here.
59:32And if he's 100% to start camp, I'll probably move him up a little bit, but I'm a little worried that the
59:39addition of Kenneth Walker means they throw less and Mahomes coming off of an injury means he runs less.
59:45And that's a pretty bad combination for fantasy football purposes.
59:48I actually think there's, I mean, you could argue that I think there's three guys in this tier that could be awesome.
59:55I'm not going to say top, whatever, but Stafford Nix and Mahomes.
59:59I mean, Love has been awesome in terms of efficiency.
60:02He just had like, if green Bay just decides to throw the ball a normal amount, he could be awesome.
60:08Just about to say that. Yeah. He's played great.
60:11You're absolutely right. That's why I'm a little surprised you have Shuck in here.
60:16Shuck was really good last year for a rookie and not just for a rookie, but I'm a little surprised you have
60:22him with Stafford Nix, Love and Mahomes. I, the way like we've given all the, uh, the shine to Mike McDaniel and Ben Johnson and they're awesome.
60:31And for fantasy football purposes, so is Kellen Moore, especially for passing games.
60:35Kellen Moore's very awesome. Um, and if Chris Olave and Jordan Tyson are both healthy, Tyler Shuck might have one of the
60:42best wide receiver duos in the NFL. All right.
60:45How about we take a look at Jamie's tier five?
60:48Cause it's similar. So just, just, just for, uh, for Shuck, um, he averaged, I think it was around, or I don't
60:55remember what exactly what it was is his 20 points.
60:58I gotta tell you a second, but Kellen Moore as a play caller from a points per game perspective, his quarterbacks, the
61:05worst year he's gotten was a 21 point per game season.
61:09Wow. Now granted that's Dak Prescott, Jalen hurts and Justin Herbert.
61:12So is Tyler Shuck on that level? We'll find out.
61:16Is he, I don't think he was the coordinator for Hertz best season.
61:20Dan and I had a fight about that, but he, he was the coordinator for Herbert's best season.
61:25He was the, no, he wasn't the coordinator for Herbert's best season.
61:29Herbert's best season was his first two years. He only had Herbert for one year.
61:34Um, he was Hertz coordinator for the super bowl year.
61:37So obviously from a team standpoint, and he had some pretty great seasons with Dak.
61:42I love it. Tyler Shuck scored 19.1 or more fantasy points in six straight games to end the season.
61:48And, uh, he only had seven touchdown passes in those six games, but he was very good down the stretch three of his last five games.
61:56He was over 33 yards rushing. So if he can do that a little bit more, that's going to make him pretty special too.
62:04And that was a pretty big surprise to me anyway, but it was a big part of his game.
62:10Chuck was on pace from in his nine starts.
62:13He was on pace for 329 rushing yards and six rushing touchdowns.
62:17And I don't know how to look at that.
62:19Cause I think that, that surprised me. Like I said, I didn't think he had that in him.
62:25If he's really that kind of a rusher, then wow, that's a huge deal.
62:30But if he's not that kind of a rusher, then maybe that's where we see regression.
62:35Uh, Jamie's tier five is Stafford, Purdy, Mahomes, Kyler, Bo Nix, and Jared Goff.
62:39So having Kyler in this mix, whereas Heath has Kyler in a, in a tier with Malik Willis and Baker Mayfield.
62:46So I guess Jamie, I'd say you're showing a little more confidence in Kyler Murray, grouping him with Stafford, Purdy, Mahomes, Nix,
62:53and Goff, as opposed to Jamie grouping Kyler with Malik Willis and Baker Mayfield.
62:57As opposed to Heath doing that. Sorry. Yeah. I, I, you know, I, I go back to Kevin O'Connell and the weapons
63:04that Kyler Murray now has, this is the best group he's ever played with, you know, in terms of complete talent, you know?
63:12So, I mean, on paper, you know, having young Trey McBride with an old DeAndre Hopkins or, you know, young Marvin Harrison
63:19and unproven Michael Wilson with Trey McBride, like, you know, you could sort of look at it a billion different ways, but
63:26I think Justin Jefferson, Jordan Addison, Jawan Jennings, and TJ Hawkinson.
63:29In this offense should hopefully allow Kyler Murray to, you know, play at a very high level.
63:34And if he's healthy and hopefully motivated to get another big deal, because he's, you know, down to his, you know, this
63:41is, I don't know if his last shot, but this is certainly his last, you know, maybe big opportunity to, you know,
63:48be a surefire starter in this league. So I'm just banking on the upside here.
63:53So, you know, if, if you're talking about floor, Bo Nix, Jared Goff certainly have, much safer floors ceiling though.
64:00I think Kyler Murray can get to that 22, 23, 24 point per game range.
64:04Yeah. Yeah. I had Kyler Malik and Mayfield in the same tier because I think they might all three be awesome and they might all three be terrible.
64:13Murray Willis and Mayfield. Yes. This is the, they could be awesome.
64:17They could be just absolutely terrible. I love that.
64:20I love that. Mayfield was off to a really good start last year.
64:24Then he had some injuries and a Buka got injured and Mike Evans got injured and this and that.
64:30Um, and then, but it's not just last year for Mayfield.
64:34Like he has the, like just an insanely wide range of outcomes throughout his career.
64:38All right. Let's get to the next tiers. Then tier six for Heath is to a Stroud, Daniel Jones, Sam Darnold and Cam Ward.
64:46Tier six for Jamie is a, is kind of like tier five ish for Heath Malik Willis, Tyler Shuck, Baker Mayfield and Jordan love.
64:54So I'm just gonna ask a quick Baker Mayfield question here.
64:57Uh, would you guys be comfortable if he was your starting quarterback?
65:01No, not right now. No, but maybe you don't have to do it, but you know, if you were in like a
65:0814 team league, I don't think it's the worst thing.
65:11I think throw Daniel Jones in that equation too.
65:14Right. It's not that hard to see him being awesome again.
65:17He was awesome last year in the same offense.
65:20Right. Do you feel that way or no? No, that's a different offense though.
65:25I'd feel more that way if he had done it for longer, different offense.
65:29Cause it doesn't have pit man. Oh, I'm sorry.
65:32You said Daniel Jones. I thought you meant to make me.
65:36No, no. Um, all right. So, so Malik Willis, Tyler Shuck, Baker Mayfield, Jordan love.
65:40That's a tier for, for Jamie. We get to the kind of deeper guys.
65:45Heath's tier six is to a Stroud, Daniel Jones, Sam Darnold and Cam Ward.
65:49There's also guys like Jacoby Brissett. We could talk about Bryce Young, Aaron Rogers, but for Heath, it's to a Stroud, Daniel Jones, Sam Darnold and Cam Ward.
65:58It had to be something about these five quarterbacks that made them stand out from the Bryce Young's and Geno Smith's and
66:05Aaron Rogers of the world to a Stroud, Daniel Jones, Sam Darnold, Cam Ward.
66:10Yeah, I think. And two is probably the one that stands out the way I'm going to classify this, but I'm pretty
66:17optimistic about him and Stefanski's system with the weapons that he has.
66:20I think he can do the thing that Stefanski wants quarterbacks to do, which is take three steps back and deliver it to somebody who's open.
66:29And he has guys who will be open. So I would say these five quarterbacks, I think they're definitely QB twos.
66:35I wouldn't be surprised if I'm too low on one or two of them.
66:40But mostly it's just I think these five guys are going to start all year and they don't make me want to throw up in my mouth.
66:48And everybody below them does. Okay. Jamie, your thoughts on this last group to a Stroud, Daniel Jones, Darnold and Cam Ward?
66:55I think, you know, these are super flex options.
66:58These are, you know, this is I don't really see like, oh, these are the type of quarterbacks I want to pair
67:05with somebody else because I think there's upset. I think maybe Cam Ward has that.
67:10You know, I'm so annoyed with CJ Stroud's career arc at this point.
67:14It's just very frustrating to see what he did as a rookie and then, you know, just completely falling off every year, almost every year afterwards.
67:22And they continue to give him weapons and hopefully maybe tank Dell being back if he's healthy.
67:28And Jaden Higgins taking a step forward to help Nico Collins makes the best CJ Stroud that we have.
67:34But it just feels like I don't know if it's the system or just whatever it is.
67:39It's just not working for him. But look, Daniel Jones was great last year when healthy.
67:44And, you know, you read the report that he's all systems go.
67:48So that could certainly be the case. Sam Donald really has one weapon at this point that you feel comfortable with.
67:55Cam Ward's really the one that kind of stands out here.
67:58If he can take a leap because of Carnell Tate and Wondell Robinson and Brian Dable's offense, like he did look really
68:05good by comparison to the start of the season in the last four games.
68:10And I hope that guy shows up again. What we have on the screen here is Cam Ward's ranking among 70 rookie quarterbacks since 2000.
68:1870 guys who were passer rating qualified and where Cam Ward ranked.
68:2155th in EPA per expected points added per drop back.
68:2552nd in success rate. 59th in yards per attempt.
68:2750th in touchdown rate. Not bad in completion rate.
68:3031st. Very good. 7th in interception rate. Although I watched tape of him against the Saints and he threw almost through four interceptions in the fourth quarter.
68:39I like the way Thomas put it in the U colors there in the bottom.
68:44Oh, cool. Really? That was nice. But what I would point out about his EPA per drop back, his success rate and his yards per attempt.
68:52They were all 52nd or worse out of 70 rookies since 2000.
68:56Is that for most of it, there's only one quarterback that ranked below him as a rookie that ended up being any good.
69:03Josh Allen? Josh Allen. And so now we have the Brian Dable thing.
69:07Dable's, you know, Titans coordinator now. And that's the guy that helped Josh Allen get his career going.
69:13But most of the guys who had a worse rookie season than Cam Ward, I mean, almost like Bryce Young is the best case scenario.
69:21So it's a little alarming. I think drops were a big part of it.
69:25The offense should be a lot better. But just pointing out he had a really bad rookie.
69:31I would think that like also there were a few stats that Caleb Williams was probably in the neighborhood with him on this as a rookie.
69:39Oh, yes. Completion rate. But not the. OK, I'll tell you.
69:42I'll go right now. Cam Ward. So in EPA, no good quarterback was worse than him.
69:48In success rate. It's not just worse. Like if you're in the neighborhood.
69:52Yeah. I don't know that anyone was really in the neighborhood either.
69:55Success rate. Only Josh Allen was worse in terms of being good.
69:59Yards per attempt. Derek Carr was worse. Touchdown rate.
70:02Carson Wentz, Nick Foles and Trevor Lawrence were worse.
70:05Big play rate. Many quarterbacks. That's not even an important stat.
70:09Many good quarterbacks were bad at big play rate as rookies.
70:12Caleb, I'm not quite sure. Caleb, off target rate.
70:15I didn't have that on here because it's a relatively new stat.
70:19Not every quarterback since 2000 even like has a recorded off target rate.
70:23But Caleb Williams was worse. Josh Allen was worse.
70:26Cam Ward had a bad rookie year. He's got a hell of an arm though.
70:30He can make some phenomenal plays. He was the number one pick.
70:34Don't give up on him. He could be a guy that bucks the trend.
70:39All right. That's it for today's show. Thank you so much for watching and listening.
70:43We will talk to you next time. Tomorrow it's running back tears.
70:47And Dan Schneier is already stirring things up in the chat.
70:51Making fun of me for not loving what Dan called the greatest cheesesteak in the world.
70:56That is literally what he said. And I think the Greek restaurant down the street from me makes a better cheesesteak than what I had.
71:04Here we go. We'll talk to you tomorrow on Fantasy Football Tonight.
71:08Podcasts. Let's talk about Viore clothing. I love these clothes.
71:11I love the versatility. That's what really stands out.
71:14When I went to the website, the first thing I saw was the tennis shop.
71:18So of course I got some tennis shirts from Viore and they're great to play in.
71:24But also I could just wear them around the house or out to lunch.
71:28Again, versatility. That's what you're going to get from Viore clothes.
71:31Whether it's shorts, shirts, hoodies, men's clothing, women's clothing, whatever.
71:35How about the Viore core shorts? People love these.
71:37Ideal for fitness, running, and training. But also stylish and comfortable enough to wear all day.
71:43Make sure you check out the core shorts. Viore is an investment in your happiness.
71:47Some of the most comfortable and versatile clothing on the planet.
71:51For our listeners, they're offering 20% off your first purchase at viore.com slash fantasy football.
71:56That's V-U-O-R-I dot com slash fantasy football. Exclusions apply.
71:58Visit the website for full terms and conditions.