Source + player page

Hogs Haven fantasy football takes on Athan Kaliakmanis

Every source-backed article insight STACKED has extracted from Hogs Haven about Athan Kaliakmanis.

80
Insights
39
Positive
8
Negative
Insight ledger

All Hogs Haven insights about Athan Kaliakmanis

NegativeProjectionOct 9, 2026
In his first NFL appearance, the seventh-round rookie from Rutgers flashed impressive ability to stretch the field but also made mistakes expected of a late-round rookie QB thrust into action. He completed 15/33 attempts (45.5%, ADOT 14.1 yards) for 186 yards, 1 TD, 1 INT, 1 sack for 9 yards, and ran 3 times for 16 yards (5.3 Y/A). He finished with a 29.4% passing success rate and 20.7 total QBR, which placed him ahead of Sam Darnold (20.4) and Daniel Jones (19.6) in Week 4.
PositiveProjectionOct 7, 2026
In his NFL debut against the Colts, backup QB Athan Kaliakmanis tied C.J. Stroud for the highest average depth of target at 14.1 yards and had six passes of at least 30 yards—the most for any quarterback in a single game so far this season. He completed two of those deep shots: a 48-yarder to Dyami Brown and a 47-yarder to Treylon Burks for his first career touchdown pass. Despite facing only 20% pressure from the Colts defense, Kaliakmanis showed willingness to let the ball fly downfield in the second half. He is expected to serve as the backup stabilizing the room in Week 5 while Jayden Daniels recovers.
PositiveProjectionOct 6, 2026
Athan Kaliakmanis completed 15 of 33 pass attempts for 186 yards and his first career touchdown pass while being sacked once and throwing his first career interception. Given Mariota is likely to miss time and Jayden Daniels isn't guaranteed to be back this week, Kaliakmanis could be in line to start his first career game on Sunday against the Giants. The source highlighted his confidence as the biggest positive takeaway; most young quarterbacks in that situation come in timid and check the ball down, but Kaliakmanis was aggressive and happy to take shots down the field, which gave the Commanders life and a chance at staying in the game.
NegativeProjectionOct 4, 2026
In his emergency Week 4 start against Indianapolis, Kaliakmanis completed 15-of-33 passes for 186 yards, 1 TD, and 1 INT. The source notes he showed moments of brilliance and confidence—including a touchdown pass to Treylon Burks described as 'a thing of beauty'—but also demonstrated operational issues and an inability to sustain drives consistent with limited practice reps and experience. Coach Dan Quinn credited Kaliakmanis for showing 'a lot of confidence and some fearlessness' while noting the team didn't do enough around him.
PositiveProjectionAug 28, 2026
Kaliakmanis has completed 17 of 24 passes for 249 yards, averaging 10.38 yards per attempt with zero interceptions—a rate that would rank among the best in the NFL in the regular season. The source emphasizes that his traits (arm talent, intermediate accuracy, downfield aggressiveness, pocket comfort) reflect genuine quarterback ability rather than preseason noise. His comfort in David Blough's play-action and rollout-heavy scheme, which requires downfield ball placement from unconventional platforms, exceeds Sam Hartman's three-year comfort level in the system.
PositiveProjectionAug 27, 2026
The source says Kaliakmanis has had a meteoric rise from 17th place in offseason rankings to first place heading into the final preseason game. Entering camp, the 7th round pick was realistically battling Sam Hartman for the third-string QB role. Against the Lions, he completed 11/14 (78.6%) for 162 yards at an ADOT of 9.4 yards for a 114.9 passer rating, looking clearly superior to Hartman (81.8% completion on shorter targets, ADOT 5.4 yards). With Hartman in the rearview mirror and Marcus Mariota nursing an MCL sprain, Kaliakmanis could become Jayden Daniels' primary backup on opening day.
NegativeBreakoutAug 26, 2026
Backup quarterback Athan Kaliakmanis has performed so well in the first two preseason games that the Commanders may not be able to risk cutting him to stash him on the practice squad. Against the Lions, he completed 11 of 14 passes for 168 yards with zero touchdowns, zero interceptions, and zero sacks taken. His ability to move calmly within the pocket under pressure, recognize defensive schemes, shorten his drop, and get the ball out quickly has been impressive. As the game progressed, he also began hitting explosive plays down the field beyond just chain-moving plays, demonstrating developing quarterback skills.
PositiveProjectionAug 25, 2026
Rookie QB demonstrated ability to attack the field vertically with 162 passing yards on 11 completions against Detroit; stretching the field on all three levels on boundary and field sides, showing arm velocity and confidence to attack defenses. The source notes his combination of arm talent and willingness to use it raises his stock, and that offensive coordinator David Blough wouldn't be limited in play calling with him under center. Kaliakmanis has an edge over Sam Hartman and could be in line to be Jayden Daniels' backup when Marcus Mariota's time ends in Washington.
PositiveProjectionAug 25, 2026
Backup quarterback building momentum in Commanders QB battle; threw for 162 yards on 11-of-14 passing (78.6% completion) and 'completely avoided any sacks after taking two against Miami the week before.' Source notes he 'can't match Kaliakmanis' raw willingness to mix creativity with arm power' compared to starter Hartman, and 'is quickly endearing himself to those searching for inning-eating Daniels replacements, rapidly raising the stakes on a less-than-obvious roster battle.'
NegativeProjectionAug 24, 2026
7th-round QB nominee for Mason/Brennan Preseason Hype Award; strong preseason performance against Detroit with 79% completion (11-for-14), 162 passing yards, 114.9 passer rating, and 92.4 PFF grade. Showed ability to step up in pocket and push ball downfield with good footwork; limited athleticism noted as ongoing concern but arm talent evident. Extended playing time due to Jayden Daniels limited to 3-play series and Marcus Mariota out with MCL sprain.
PositiveRoleAug 23, 2026
Kaliakmanis is making a strong case to be the third quarterback on the Commanders' initial roster. He looked comfortable running the offense, delivered accurate throws on the move, and maneuvered well in the pocket. He completed 78% of his passes for 162 yards without being sacked in the preseason game. Notably, he demonstrated arm strength to stretch the field—a skill not highlighted in the draft process—with a 55-yard completion to Nick Nash down the sideline and a 30-yard pass to Jaden Bradley. He is competing with Sam Hartman for the final quarterback spot, with the competition expected to continue through the preseason finale.
PositiveProjectionAug 15, 2026
Seventh-round rookie QB Athan Kaliakmanis made a strong case for the Commanders' QB3 job in his preseason debut. He started fast with 33 yards on his first two throws to rookie Antonio Williams (16 yards) and tight end Colson Yankoff (17 yards), followed by a 20+ yard completion to Jacoby Jones. He finished 6-of-10 with 87 passing yards and no touchdowns. His arm strength was evident throughout, showing conviction, athleticism, and a level of comfort that defied his inexperience. The source notes there was far more good than bad in the Day 3 selection from Rutgers, and it would be a big surprise if he didn't find his name on the 53-man roster. With Mariota exiting with a possible non-contact leg injury, Kaliakmanis could potentially stabilize the backup quarterback spot.
PositiveProjectionAug 15, 2026
Backup QB competing for the No. 3 quarterback spot showed slightly more efficiency than Sam Hartman in his preseason action. The Rutgers product completed 6-of-10 passes for 87 yards and flashed serious arm talent while working the ball down the field, including a 16-yard TD pass to rookie Antonio Williams. Both Hartman and Kaliakmanis will see significant preseason time to prove worthy of the No. 3 roster spot, though it remains a pick 'em at this point.